Physical review. E

Predictability in a hydrodynamic pilot-wave system: Resolution of walker tunneling

Loïc Tadrist, Tristan Gilet, Peter Schlagheck, John W. M. Bush

Published Jul 9, 2020• 31 citations

Abstract

A walker is a macroscopic coupling of a droplet and a capillary wave field that exhibits several quantumlike properties. In 2009, Eddi et al. [Phys. Rev. Lett. 102, 240401 (2009)PRLTAO0031-900710.1103/PhysRevLett.102.240401] showed that walkers may cross a submerged barrier in an unpredictable manner and named this behavior "unpredictable walker tunneling." In quantum mechanics, tunneling is one of the simplest arrangements where similar unpredictability occurs. In this paper, we investigate how unpredictability can be unveiled for walkers through an experimental study of walker tunneling with precision. We refine both time and position measurements to take into account the fast bouncing dynamics of the system. Tunneling is shown to be unpredictable until a distance of 2.6 mm from the barrier center, where we observe the separation of reflected and transmitted trajectories in the position-velocity phase-space. The unpredictability is unlikely to be attributable to either uncertainty in the initial conditions or to the noise in the experiment. It is more likely due to changes in the drop's vertical dynamics arising when it interacts with the barrier. We compare this macroscopic system to a tunneling quantum particle that is subjected to repeated measurements of its position and momentum. We show that, despite the different theoretical treatments of these two disparate systems, similar patterns emerge in the position-velocity phase space.

DOI: 10.1103/physreve.102.013104

Related papers

Tunneling of walking oil drops

Mogens T. Levinsen

Walkers are oil drops surfing on a vibrated oil surface and driven by their self-generated capillary waves. Since some of the first measurements on walkers seemingly showed quantum-like behavior, walkers have been considered a model system for a hydrodynamic pilot-wave system. An early experiment showed that the passage of the walker over a submerged barrier resulted in what was coined "unpredictable walker tunneling" in analogy with quantum tunneling. Together with the double slit experiment, tunneling is one of the fundamental phenomena that show the probabilistic nature of quantum mechanics. A later experiment that refined the measurement of position and timing of the walker narrowed the region where transmission changed from 0 to 1 by a factor 10 but still found "unpredictable tunneling." However, at a certain small distance close to the rim of the barrier, predictability sets in, and separation between reflected and transmitted trajectories is observed. After careful analysis of identified noise sources, the authors find that neither noise nor insufficient knowledge of initial conditions alone could explain the unpredictability. They therefore conclude that it is more likely due to changes in the drop's vertical dynamics arising when it interacts with the barrier. They also analyzed a quantum particle impinging on a barrier by step-wise collapsing the wave function and showed a similar behavior for this. Here we revisit the "tunneling" of walkers. Enforcing a stringent control of temperature in all aspects of the experiment results in the observation of a much sharper transition, much like that of a classical system, reducing the unpredictability by another factor of 10. Apart from varying the velocity of the walker by changing the drop size, we varied it by changing the amplitude of the drive. We furthermore found that a micron-size change in fluid height changes transmission from 0 to 1. The observed sharpness of the transition suggests that in a noise-free environment the transition would be truly abrupt, at least in the regions of phase-space for the drop that have been investigated so far.

Physical review. ENov 12, 20250 citations

Tunneling with a hydrodynamic pilot-wave model

André Nachbin, Paul A. Milewski, John W. M. Bush

2009)] presented experimental results demonstrating the unpredictable tunneling of a classical wave-particle association as may arise when a droplet walking across the surface of a vibrating fluid bath approaches a submerged barrier.We here present a theoretical model that captures the influence of bottom topography on this wave-particle association and so enables us to investigate its interaction with barriers.The coupled wave-droplet dynamics results in unpredictable tunneling events.As reported in the experiments by Eddi et al. and as is the case in quantum tunneling [Gamow, Nature (London) 122, 805 (1928)], the predicted tunneling probability decreases exponentially with increasing barrier width.In the parameter regimes examined, tunneling between two cavities suggests an underlying stationary ergodic process for the droplet's position.

Physical Review FluidsMar 30, 201768 citations

Unpredictable Tunneling of a Classical Wave-Particle Association

Antonin Eddi, Emmanuel Fort, Frédéric Moisy +1 more

A droplet bouncing on a vibrated bath becomes a "walker" moving at constant velocity on the interface when it couples to the surface wave it generates. Here the motion of a walker is investigated when it collides with barriers of various thicknesses. Surprisingly, it undergoes a form of tunneling: the reflection or transmission of a given incident walker is unpredictable. However, the crossing probability decreases exponentially with increasing barrier width. This shows that this wave-particle association has a nonlocality sufficient to generate a quantumlike tunneling at a macroscopic scale.

Physical Review LettersJun 16, 2009203 citations

Hydrodynamic quantum analogs

John W. M. Bush, Anand U. Oza

The walking droplet system discovered by Yves Couder and Emmanuel Fort presents an example of a vibrating particle self-propelling through a resonant interaction with its own wave field. It provides a means of visualizing a particle as an excitation of a field, a common notion in quantum field theory. Moreover, it represents the first macroscopic realization of a form of dynamics proposed for quantum particles by Louis de Broglie in the 1920s. The fact that this hydrodynamic pilot-wave system exhibits many features typically associated with the microscopic, quantum realm raises a number of intriguing questions. At a minimum, it extends the range of classical systems to include quantum-like statistics in a number of settings. A more optimistic stance is that it suggests the manner in which quantum mechanics might be completed through a theoretical description of particle trajectories. We here review the experimental studies of the walker system, and the hierarchy of theoretical models developed to rationalize its behavior. Particular attention is given to enumerating the dynamical mechanisms responsible for the emergence of robust, structured statistical behavior. Another focus is demonstrating how the temporal nonlocality of the droplet dynamics, as results from the persistence of its pilot wave field, may give rise to behavior that appears to be spatially nonlocal. Finally, we describe recent explorations of a generalized theoretical framework that provides a mathematical bridge between the hydrodynamic pilot-wave system and various realist models of quantum dynamics.

Reports on Progress in PhysicsOct 16, 2020130 citations

Transition Orbits of Walking Droplets

Joshua Parker

It was recently discovered that millimeter-sized droplets bouncing on the surface of an oscillating bath of the same fluid can couple with the surface waves it produces and begin walking across the fluid bath. These walkers have been shown to behave similarly to quantum particles; a few examples include single-particle diffraction, tunneling, and quantized orbits. Such behavior occurs because the drop and surface waves depend on each other to exist, making this the first and only known macroscopic pilot-wave system. In this paper, the quantized orbits between two identical drops are explored. By sending a perturbation to a pair of orbiting walkers, the orbit can be disrupted and transition to a new orbit. The numerical results of such transitions are analyzed and discussed.

Jan 1, 20150 citations

One-dimensional pilot-wave dynamics of walking droplets

S.J.H. Koerhuis

Pilot-wave dynamics of walking droplets is a field in hydrodynamics that has been studied extensively for its interesting features previously thought to be found only in quantum mechanics. The walking droplets in combination with their pilot-wave form a spatially delocalized entity called a walker, wherefrom quantum-like features arise. \n\nThe behavior and dynamics of the droplet have been described theoretically, where the walker moves in a two-dimensional (plane) bath. We start the theoretical development of an analogous one-dimensional version of this theory that describes the walker's behavior in an one-dimensional (long and narrow) bath. We set up the model basis for the equation of motion of the vertically bouncing droplet by looking at a quasi-static droplet in our one-dimensional system. \n\nOur goal is to develop a theory that eventually describes and rationalizes the dynamics and statistical behavior of a walker in our one-dimensional setting. We predict that the simplification to an one-dimensional setting will make the theory behind the behavior of the walker system more understandable. Hence, the theory, which is the basis for explaining the emerging quantum-like features, will eventually shed some light on what is and what is not fundamental to quantum mechanics.\n\nSpecifically, the surface- and potential energy of a quasi-static droplet are calculated and expressed in an harmonic decomposition of the droplet's shape. The expansion coefficients that arise in the harmonic decomposition are calculated by performing an averaging method on the potential energy and minimizing the total energy of a droplet resting on a rigid surface. The expansion coefficients are shown to accurately describe the droplet's shape for a range of Bond numbers (a dimensionless number representing the relative magnitude of gravity to surface tension per unit area), where the range depends on the contact area that the droplet makes with the underlying surface. These results can be used to further develop the one-dimensional walker theory.

Jan 1, 20200 citations