Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Decision

The cost of asking: How evaluations bias subsequent judgments.

Lee C. White, Emmanuel M. Pothos, Michael Jarrett

Published Jul 27, 2020• 23 citations
Publisher

Abstract

A novel decision bias, called the evaluation bias (EB), was reported by White et al. (2014). In a sequence of two stimuli of opposite affective valence, evaluating the first stimulus leads to a more contrasting evaluation for the second one, compared to when the first stimulus is just observed. The EB is consistent with a long tradition of constructive influences or decision biases in questionnaire judgments. The prediction of the EB was based on the application of a quantum probability model, taking advantage of the unique role of evaluations in quantum probability. In the present work, we develop the quantum model so as to examine whether similar predictions are possible in the context of real questionnaires, where precise control over the relative valence of stimulus pairs is impossible. It is shown that an EB prediction can be extracted and we test this prediction in an organizational opinion survey, administered to a range of organizations across four experiments (total N = 868 and 84 organizations) and with two different languages. In all experiments, there was clear evidence for an EB. We examine the result with the quantum model and Hogarth and Einhorn’s (1992) belief-adjustment model. Both models can broadly capture the empirical findings and so offer promise for providing a formal understanding of constructive influences.

DOI
10.1037/dec0000136

Related papers

Constructive Biases in Clinical Judgment

B. W. Wojciechowski, Bernadetta Izydorczyk, Paweł Błasiak +3 more

With a pair of oppositely valenced stimuli, rating the first one sometimes leads to a more extreme evaluation for the second (e.g., if the second is negatively valenced, rating the first stimulus would lead to a more negative rating for the second). We considered an evaluation bias in the case of clinical diagnosis relating to eating disorders. A population sample which included experienced clinical psychologists and psychiatrists showed partial evidence of an evaluation bias, when judging descriptions of individuals designed to be consistent with eating disorders or not. Quantum probability theory, the probability rules from quantum mechanics without any of the physics, is particularly well-suited to modeling the evaluation bias (and constructive influences generally), because a measurement (or judgment) can change the state of the system. We applied a previous quantum model to the present result, an extension of the model embodying noisy processes, and belief adjustment model. We discuss how model fits inform an examination of rationality in the observed behavior.

Topics in Cognitive Science•Jun 3, 2021•4 citations

An investigation of a quantum probability model for the constructive effect of affective evaluation

Lee C. White, Albert Barqué-Duran, Emmanuel M. Pothos

The idea that choices can have a constructive effect has received a great deal of empirical support. The act of choosing appears to influence subsequent preferences for the options available. Recent research has proposed a cognitive model based on quantum probability (QP), which suggests that whether or not a participant provides an affective evaluation for a positively or negatively valenced stimulus can also be constructive and so, for example, influence the affective evaluation of a second oppositely valenced stimulus. However, there are some outstanding methodological questions in relation to this previous research. This paper reports the results of three experiments designed to resolve these questions. Experiment 1, using a binary response format, provides partial support for the interaction predicted by the QP model; and Experiment 2, which controls for the length of time participants have to respond, fully supports the QP model. Finally, Experiment 3 sought to determine whether the key effect can generalize beyond affective judgements about visual stimuli. Using judgements about the trustworthiness of well-known people, the predictions of the QP model were confirmed. Together, these three experiments provide further support for the QP model of the constructive effect of simple evaluations.

Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society A Mathematical Physical and Engineering Sciences•Nov 30, 2015•17 citations

A quantum probability perspective on the nature of psychological uncertainty

Lee C. White, Emmanuel M. Pothos, Jerome R. Busemeyer

Making a choice between alternatives can influence our subsequent evaluation of the selected option (e.g.Sharot, Velasquez & Dolan, 2010).Thus, in resolving psychological uncertainty, the act of making a judgment itself appears to have a constructive role in subsequent related decisions.This study focuses on emotional ambivalence and the development of affective evaluations over two stages, such that (just) making an intermediate evaluation in the first stage is shown to influence the overall affective evaluation in the second stage.Models based on classical probability theory, which assume that an intermediate evaluation simply reads off an existing internal state, cannot accommodate this result in a natural way.An explanation is offered with a quantum probability model, which, under specific circumstances, requires the measurement of an internal state to have a constructive role.The predictions of the quantum probability model were supported by the empirical results.

Cognitive Science•Jan 1, 2013•6 citations

Evidence for constructive influences from simple evaluations.

Lee C. White, Emmanuel M. Pothos, Michael Jarrett

There have been several demonstrations of constructive influences from choice paradigms, for example, when a decisionmaker has to commit to one of the available options and abandon the rest. In such cases, an expectation of constructiveinfluences, whereby the preference for the chosen option increases, while the preference for the abandoned ones decreases,is perhaps reasonable (e.g., as a way to reduce cognitive dissonance). However, this reasoning is harder to translateto situations such that there is a simple evaluation. We employ an organizational questionnaire to show that a simpleevaluation of an earlier statement can lead to systematic influences on a later one. Our results generalize our understandingfor when constructive influences may occur. We outline a technical framework for predicting this bias (which we labelevaluation bias), based on quantum theory. Quantum theory is an appropriate framework for modelling constructiveinfluences, because the theory involves a fundamental process of state change when a measurement (evaluation) is made.

Cognitive Science•Jan 1, 2019•0 citations

Is there a problem with quantum models of psychological measurements?

Jerome R. Busemeyer, Zheng Wang

This article presents the results of an experiment, called the ABA experiment, designed to test a fundamental prediction of quantum probability theory when applied to human judgments and decisions. The prediction concerns the effect of one measurement on another when the measurements are incompatible (i.e., the answers to the measurements depend on the order of these measurements). After an initial measurement of an opinion on an issue, A, the answer to a second measurement on the same issue A immediately afterwards will certainly be the same as the first. However, according to the uncertainty principle, if a measurement of opinion on issue A is followed by an incompatible measurement on another issue, B, then the answer to a second measurement on issue A will become uncertain. This prediction was tested with 325 participants on a wide range of 12 different set of issues that were previously shown to be incompatible. Contrary to previous claims published in this journal, the empirical findings support the prediction of quantum probability theory applied to human judgments.

PLoS ONE•Nov 8, 2017•27 citations

The Constructive Role of Decisions: Implications from a quantum Approach

Emmanuel M. Pothos

Abstract : The last interim report was submitted Jan. 2015. This grant had two objectives. The first was to explore the nature of constructive influences indecision making. The second concerned understanding decision making in Prisoner's Dilemma. **First objective; constructive judgments. This isthe idea that sometimes making a decision can alter the underlying relevant mental state. Simply put, if a person is uncertain whether e.g. aradar signal represents a threat or not, then being asked to decide (Does this signal represent a threat?) changes the underlying mentalrepresentations. If the person decides that the radar does represent a threat, he/she would perceive it as more threatening, than previously.This is an important idea since it impacts on our understanding of how questions, ratings, other cognitive measurements can actually alter themental states. Part of the motivation for studying this question is our expertise with quantum theory, an innovative mathematical framework forunderstanding cognition, which has to predict that the resolution of any e.g. question alters the mental state in a specific way. Up to the pointof the first report, we had validated the main idea (as outlined in the grant proposal), with two main publications (appr. six distinctexperiments; note, several other outcomes had been produced within this grant). Between the last report and the end of the grant wepursued a mathematically more sophisticated and empirically more ambitious demonstration, which related to the impact of increasing thedensity of intermediate judgments on an eventual determination. We found, as our model predicted, that a higher density of intermediatejudgments slowed down opinion change. We think this finding is important for AFOSR. For example, consider the issue of trust in anautonomous agent: suppose an operator monitors the performance of the agent.

•Dec 1, 2016•0 citations
A novel decision bias, called the evaluation bias (EB), was reported by White et al. (2014). In a sequence of two stimuli of opposite affective valence, evaluating the first stimulus leads to a more contrasting evaluation for the second one, compared to when the first stimulus is just observed. The EB is consistent with a long tradition of constructive influences or decision biases in questionnaire judgments. The prediction of the EB was based on the application of a quantum probability model, taking advantage of the unique role of evaluations in quantum probability. In the present work, we develop the quantum model so as to examine whether similar predictions are possible in the context of real questionnaires, where precise control over the relative valence of stimulus pairs is impossible. It is shown that an EB prediction can be extracted and we test this prediction in an organizational opinion survey, administered to a range of organizations across four experiments (total N = 868 and 84 organizations) and with two different languages. In all experiments, there was clear evidence for an EB. We examine the result with the quantum model and Hogarth and Einhorn’s (1992) belief-adjustment model. Both models can broadly capture the empirical findings and so offer promise for providing a formal understanding of constructive influences.
With a pair of oppositely valenced stimuli, rating the first one sometimes leads to a more extreme evaluation for the second (e.g., if the second is negatively valenced, rating the first stimulus would lead to a more negative rating for the second). We considered an evaluation bias in the case of clinical diagnosis relating to eating disorders. A population sample which included experienced clinical psychologists and psychiatrists showed partial evidence of an evaluation bias, when judging descriptions of individuals designed to be consistent with eating disorders or not. Quantum probability theory, the probability rules from quantum mechanics without any of the physics, is particularly well-suited to modeling the evaluation bias (and constructive influences generally), because a measurement (or judgment) can change the state of the system. We applied a previous quantum model to the present result, an extension of the model embodying noisy processes, and belief adjustment model. We discuss how model fits inform an examination of rationality in the observed behavior.
The idea that choices can have a constructive effect has received a great deal of empirical support. The act of choosing appears to influence subsequent preferences for the options available. Recent research has proposed a cognitive model based on quantum probability (QP), which suggests that whether or not a participant provides an affective evaluation for a positively or negatively valenced stimulus can also be constructive and so, for example, influence the affective evaluation of a second oppositely valenced stimulus. However, there are some outstanding methodological questions in relation to this previous research. This paper reports the results of three experiments designed to resolve these questions. Experiment 1, using a binary response format, provides partial support for the interaction predicted by the QP model; and Experiment 2, which controls for the length of time participants have to respond, fully supports the QP model. Finally, Experiment 3 sought to determine whether the key effect can generalize beyond affective judgements about visual stimuli. Using judgements about the trustworthiness of well-known people, the predictions of the QP model were confirmed. Together, these three experiments provide further support for the QP model of the constructive effect of simple evaluations.
Making a choice between alternatives can influence our subsequent evaluation of the selected option (e.g.Sharot, Velasquez & Dolan, 2010).Thus, in resolving psychological uncertainty, the act of making a judgment itself appears to have a constructive role in subsequent related decisions.This study focuses on emotional ambivalence and the development of affective evaluations over two stages, such that (just) making an intermediate evaluation in the first stage is shown to influence the overall affective evaluation in the second stage.Models based on classical probability theory, which assume that an intermediate evaluation simply reads off an existing internal state, cannot accommodate this result in a natural way.An explanation is offered with a quantum probability model, which, under specific circumstances, requires the measurement of an internal state to have a constructive role.The predictions of the quantum probability model were supported by the empirical results.
There have been several demonstrations of constructive influences from choice paradigms, for example, when a decisionmaker has to commit to one of the available options and abandon the rest. In such cases, an expectation of constructiveinfluences, whereby the preference for the chosen option increases, while the preference for the abandoned ones decreases,is perhaps reasonable (e.g., as a way to reduce cognitive dissonance). However, this reasoning is harder to translateto situations such that there is a simple evaluation. We employ an organizational questionnaire to show that a simpleevaluation of an earlier statement can lead to systematic influences on a later one. Our results generalize our understandingfor when constructive influences may occur. We outline a technical framework for predicting this bias (which we labelevaluation bias), based on quantum theory. Quantum theory is an appropriate framework for modelling constructiveinfluences, because the theory involves a fundamental process of state change when a measurement (evaluation) is made.
This article presents the results of an experiment, called the ABA experiment, designed to test a fundamental prediction of quantum probability theory when applied to human judgments and decisions. The prediction concerns the effect of one measurement on another when the measurements are incompatible (i.e., the answers to the measurements depend on the order of these measurements). After an initial measurement of an opinion on an issue, A, the answer to a second measurement on the same issue A immediately afterwards will certainly be the same as the first. However, according to the uncertainty principle, if a measurement of opinion on issue A is followed by an incompatible measurement on another issue, B, then the answer to a second measurement on issue A will become uncertain. This prediction was tested with 325 participants on a wide range of 12 different set of issues that were previously shown to be incompatible. Contrary to previous claims published in this journal, the empirical findings support the prediction of quantum probability theory applied to human judgments.
Abstract : The last interim report was submitted Jan. 2015. This grant had two objectives. The first was to explore the nature of constructive influences indecision making. The second concerned understanding decision making in Prisoner's Dilemma. **First objective; constructive judgments. This isthe idea that sometimes making a decision can alter the underlying relevant mental state. Simply put, if a person is uncertain whether e.g. aradar signal represents a threat or not, then being asked to decide (Does this signal represent a threat?) changes the underlying mentalrepresentations. If the person decides that the radar does represent a threat, he/she would perceive it as more threatening, than previously.This is an important idea since it impacts on our understanding of how questions, ratings, other cognitive measurements can actually alter themental states. Part of the motivation for studying this question is our expertise with quantum theory, an innovative mathematical framework forunderstanding cognition, which has to predict that the resolution of any e.g. question alters the mental state in a specific way. Up to the pointof the first report, we had validated the main idea (as outlined in the grant proposal), with two main publications (appr. six distinctexperiments; note, several other outcomes had been produced within this grant). Between the last report and the end of the grant wepursued a mathematically more sophisticated and empirically more ambitious demonstration, which related to the impact of increasing thedensity of intermediate judgments on an eventual determination. We found, as our model predicted, that a higher density of intermediatejudgments slowed down opinion change. We think this finding is important for AFOSR. For example, consider the issue of trust in anautonomous agent: suppose an operator monitors the performance of the agent.