Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

European Journal of Physics

Tunneling times in a taut string

Diosdado Villegas, Francisco Antonio Horta-Rangel, Tamé González, Israel Quirós, Rolando Pérez-Álvarez, Fernando de León‐Pérez

Published Mar 25, 2020• 3 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Abstract The mathematical analogy of classical and matter waves can help to teach the elusive subject of tunneling times in undergraduate physics courses. The tunneling of mechanical energy through a taut string is revisited in this paper in order to study tunneling times for this classical system. General properties of the group delay, the dwell time and the interference time are described. Moreover, we explain how to build string arrays with piecewise constitutive parameters that behave like quantum mechanical heterostructures with alternating well and barrier layers. The paradoxical Hartman effect is also analyzed.

DOI
10.1088/1361-6404/ab8362

Related papers

Delay Time and the Hartman Effect in Quantum Tunneling

Herbert G. Winful

A general relation between the group delay and the dwell time is derived for quantum tunneling. It is shown that the group delay is equal to the dwell time plus a self-interference delay. The Hartman effect in quantum tunneling is explained on the basis of saturation of the integrated probability density (or number of particles) under the barrier.

Physical Review Letters•Dec 23, 2003•234 citations

Delay time and the Hartman effect in double-barrier tunneling

Natalia M. Litchinitser, John R. Valenzuela, Herbert G. Winful

A relation between the phase time and the dwell time in double-barrier tunneling is investigated under the resonant and the off-resonant conditions. The role and physical meaning of the self-interference delay is discussed. The Hartman effect is examined in double-barrier geometry and a physical explanation for the phenomenon is developed.

Frontiers in Optics•Jan 1, 2004•0 citations

On the generalized Hartman effect and transmission time for a particle tunneling through two identical rectangular potential barriers

Nikolay Leonidovich Chuprikov

We develop a new quantum-mechanical approach to scattering a particle on a one-dimensional (1D) system of two identical rectangular potential barriers, which implies modelling the dynamics of its subprocesses -- transmission and reflection -- at all stages of scattering. On its basis we define, for each subprocess, the dwell time as well as the local (exact) and asymptotic (extrapolated) group times. Our concept of the asymptotic transmission group time confirms the validity of the Wigner phase time in the opaque limit, as well as the existence of the usual and generalized Hartman effects predicted on its basis. On the energy scale, this concept is valid everywhere in the high energy region as well as in the low energy region, excepting resonance points and their neighborhoods. On the contrary, the Buttiker dwell time is valid, as the transmission time, just only at the resonance points. Our concept of the transmission dwell time predicts monotonous growth of the tunneling time when the distance between the opaque barriers increases. By our approach only this time scale yields the true time spent, on average, by transmitted particles in the region occupied by the system. We explain why the asymptotic and local transmission group times cannot play this role and why the concept of {\it transmission group} velocity lies beyond the scope of special relativity. And else, all the transmission times admit only indirect measurements. Hence the unambiguous interpretation of all tunneling-time experiments is impossible when the transmission dynamics at all stages of scattering is unknown.

arXiv:1005.1323•May 8, 2010•1 citation

Some important aspects of the tunneling phenomenon through quantum structures

E. Polatdemir

Tunneling phenomenon is one of the wondrous events that take place particularly in quantum mechanics and it has no counterpart in classical physics. We focus on its two important implications : tunneling time and tunneling probability. There has been no consensus on tunneling times among the tunneling time community for last seven decades. So far, most of the attempts to calculate tunneling times have apparently been centered on a simple rectangular barrier example. We implement the tunneling times with the most widely accepted approach, which is using physical Larmor clock, into a nonsymmetrical barrier and a double barrier. It results in different and unique insights into the usual understanding of tunneling time. Three characteristics tunneling time expressions are thoroughly studied in these quantum structures. The difference between dwell time and phase-delay time is once again approved. The unique characteristics of the phase-delay time, which was thought to be exactly similar to dwell time when we assign higher energies to the particles, is also revealed in the nonsymmetrical barrier that it should actually be regarded as a distinct feature from the dwell time. The singularity of reflection time in rectangular barrier is no longer valid in nonsymmetrical barrier. The finiteness of reflection time fairly shows that different quantum structures might bear some taboo breaking results. Since a double barrier involves much more complicated features and calculations, the calculation of tunneling times under this barrier is praiseworthy. The dwell time is the most crucial, troublesome and distinctive tunneling time element to look into for a double barrier. Besides the dwell and phase-delay time, we also calculate the three characteristic times as well as the reflection time for a double barrier. Another area that we study within the context of tunneling phenomenon is the tunneling probability. Recently, there has been ground shaking attempts in modifying the conventional WKB formulae. We follow one of the modified versions of WKB formulae in order to be able to calculate the tunneling probability through different quantum structures where conventional WKB formulae fail. These generalized WKB connection formulae are applied to some complex quantum potentials by seeking aid from the Green's function and the path integral approach. One of the biggest problems in quantum mechanics (visualization) is partially overcome through implementing the method of diagrammatic representations that make the life easier in understanding the events happening in the quantum world when we attempt to calculate the transmission and reflection probabilities. This part therefore has a pedagogical sense too in terms of interpreting the results in a diagrammatic way with the help of the path integral approach.

•Jan 1, 2002•0 citations

On Times and Speeds of Time-Dependent Quantum and Electromagnetic Tunneling

М. В. Давидович

Abstract This is a review of studies of quantum tunneling, which is described by the one-dimensional Schrödinger equation, and electromagnetic tunneling, where “superluminal” velocities and times of tunneling are considered. Integral and integrodifferential equations have been presented to describe tunneling. According to these equations, superluminal motion is impossible. The paradoxical Hartman effect has been discussed and explained. It has been shown that the velocity of passage of a particle in a beam through a barrier in the case of steady-state and time-dependent quantum tunneling is equal to the velocity of its incidence on the barrier and quasiphotons inside any layer of matter carry the energy always at a subluminal velocity. However, the tunneling time of a single particle or a photon is meaningless.

Journal of Experimental and Theoretical Physics•Jan 1, 2020•12 citations

Quantum Tunneling Times and the Hartman Effect in Polymer Quantization

Siriburana, Thanakorn

This research aims to study the behavior of quantum tunneling within the framework of polymer quantization, where spacetime has a discrete structure with a fundamental length $\mu_0$. From the Hamiltonian difference equation, we obtained analytical wave functions in each region of the potential barrier and numerically calculated the transmission coefficient and Wigner time delay $\tau_w$ for comparison with standard quantum mechanics. The calculation results show that when the particle energy is lower than the potential barrier $E < W_0$, the tunneling time $\tau_w(n)$ increases rapidly within the narrow barrier and saturates when the width is sufficiently large, confirming that the Hartman effect phenomenon persists even when the spacetime structure is discontinuous. The value of $\mu_0$ affects the saturation time but does not change the qualitative nature of this behavior. In the case of $E > W_0$, the time increases continuously with width, which is consistent with standard quantum mechanics. This result suggests that the semi-classical properties of potential barrier penetration, particularly the Hartman effect, are stable against modifications to spacetime structure and provide important insights into understanding the behavior of quantum systems within a framework inspired by Loop Quantum Gravity (LQG).

•Dec 2, 2025•0 citations
Abstract The mathematical analogy of classical and matter waves can help to teach the elusive subject of tunneling times in undergraduate physics courses. The tunneling of mechanical energy through a taut string is revisited in this paper in order to study tunneling times for this classical system. General properties of the group delay, the dwell time and the interference time are described. Moreover, we explain how to build string arrays with piecewise constitutive parameters that behave like quantum mechanical heterostructures with alternating well and barrier layers. The paradoxical Hartman effect is also analyzed.
We develop a new quantum-mechanical approach to scattering a particle on a one-dimensional (1D) system of two identical rectangular potential barriers, which implies modelling the dynamics of its subprocesses -- transmission and reflection -- at all stages of scattering. On its basis we define, for each subprocess, the dwell time as well as the local (exact) and asymptotic (extrapolated) group times. Our concept of the asymptotic transmission group time confirms the validity of the Wigner phase time in the opaque limit, as well as the existence of the usual and generalized Hartman effects predicted on its basis. On the energy scale, this concept is valid everywhere in the high energy region as well as in the low energy region, excepting resonance points and their neighborhoods. On the contrary, the Buttiker dwell time is valid, as the transmission time, just only at the resonance points. Our concept of the transmission dwell time predicts monotonous growth of the tunneling time when the distance between the opaque barriers increases. By our approach only this time scale yields the true time spent, on average, by transmitted particles in the region occupied by the system. We explain why the asymptotic and local transmission group times cannot play this role and why the concept of {\it transmission group} velocity lies beyond the scope of special relativity. And else, all the transmission times admit only indirect measurements. Hence the unambiguous interpretation of all tunneling-time experiments is impossible when the transmission dynamics at all stages of scattering is unknown.
Tunneling phenomenon is one of the wondrous events that take place particularly in quantum mechanics and it has no counterpart in classical physics. We focus on its two important implications : tunneling time and tunneling probability. There has been no consensus on tunneling times among the tunneling time community for last seven decades. So far, most of the attempts to calculate tunneling times have apparently been centered on a simple rectangular barrier example. We implement the tunneling times with the most widely accepted approach, which is using physical Larmor clock, into a nonsymmetrical barrier and a double barrier. It results in different and unique insights into the usual understanding of tunneling time. Three characteristics tunneling time expressions are thoroughly studied in these quantum structures. The difference between dwell time and phase-delay time is once again approved. The unique characteristics of the phase-delay time, which was thought to be exactly similar to dwell time when we assign higher energies to the particles, is also revealed in the nonsymmetrical barrier that it should actually be regarded as a distinct feature from the dwell time. The singularity of reflection time in rectangular barrier is no longer valid in nonsymmetrical barrier. The finiteness of reflection time fairly shows that different quantum structures might bear some taboo breaking results. Since a double barrier involves much more complicated features and calculations, the calculation of tunneling times under this barrier is praiseworthy. The dwell time is the most crucial, troublesome and distinctive tunneling time element to look into for a double barrier. Besides the dwell and phase-delay time, we also calculate the three characteristic times as well as the reflection time for a double barrier. Another area that we study within the context of tunneling phenomenon is the tunneling probability. Recently, there has been ground shaking attempts in modifying the conventional WKB formulae. We follow one of the modified versions of WKB formulae in order to be able to calculate the tunneling probability through different quantum structures where conventional WKB formulae fail. These generalized WKB connection formulae are applied to some complex quantum potentials by seeking aid from the Green's function and the path integral approach. One of the biggest problems in quantum mechanics (visualization) is partially overcome through implementing the method of diagrammatic representations that make the life easier in understanding the events happening in the quantum world when we attempt to calculate the transmission and reflection probabilities. This part therefore has a pedagogical sense too in terms of interpreting the results in a diagrammatic way with the help of the path integral approach.
Abstract This is a review of studies of quantum tunneling, which is described by the one-dimensional Schrödinger equation, and electromagnetic tunneling, where “superluminal” velocities and times of tunneling are considered. Integral and integrodifferential equations have been presented to describe tunneling. According to these equations, superluminal motion is impossible. The paradoxical Hartman effect has been discussed and explained. It has been shown that the velocity of passage of a particle in a beam through a barrier in the case of steady-state and time-dependent quantum tunneling is equal to the velocity of its incidence on the barrier and quasiphotons inside any layer of matter carry the energy always at a subluminal velocity. However, the tunneling time of a single particle or a photon is meaningless.
This research aims to study the behavior of quantum tunneling within the framework of polymer quantization, where spacetime has a discrete structure with a fundamental length μ0\mu_0μ0​. From the Hamiltonian difference equation, we obtained analytical wave functions in each region of the potential barrier and numerically calculated the transmission coefficient and Wigner time delay τw\tau_wτw​ for comparison with standard quantum mechanics. The calculation results show that when the particle energy is lower than the potential barrier E<W0E < W_0E<W0​, the tunneling time τw(n)\tau_w(n)τw​(n) increases rapidly within the narrow barrier and saturates when the width is sufficiently large, confirming that the Hartman effect phenomenon persists even when the spacetime structure is discontinuous. The value of μ0\mu_0μ0​ affects the saturation time but does not change the qualitative nature of this behavior. In the case of E>W0E > W_0E>W0​, the time increases continuously with width, which is consistent with standard quantum mechanics. This result suggests that the semi-classical properties of potential barrier penetration, particularly the Hartman effect, are stable against modifications to spacetime structure and provide important insights into understanding the behavior of quantum systems within a framework inspired by Loop Quantum Gravity (LQG).