Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Revista Mexicana de Física

Exploring surface waves vortex interaction in deep water: A classical analog of the Quantum Mechanics Aharonov-Bohm effect

Francisco Vivanco, Francisco Melo

Published Nov 1, 2002• 0 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

We present a simple experiment to study the interaction of surface waves with a vertical vortex in the deep water regime. Similarly to what occurs in the Quantum Mechanics Aharonov-Bohm problem for electron interacting with a magnetic potential, the effec

Related papers

Wavefront dislocations in the Aharonov-Bohm effect and its water wave analogue

Michael Berry, R. G. Chambers, M D Large +2 more

We study the wavefronts (i.e. the surfaces of constant phase) of the wave discussed by Aharonov and Bohm, representing a beam of particles with charge q scattered by an impenetrable cylinder of radius R containing magnetic flux Ф. Defining the quantum flux parameter by α = q Ф/ h . we show that for the case R = 0 the wave ψ AB possesses a wavefront dislocation on the flux line, whose strength (i.e. the number of wave crests ending on the dislocation) equals the nearest integer to α . When α passes through half-integer values, the strength changes, by wavefronts unlinking and reconnecting along a nodal surface. In quantum mechanics this phase structure is unobservable, but we devise an analogue where surface waves on water encounter an irrotational ‘bathtub’ vortex; in this case α depends on the frequency of the waves and the circulation of the vortex. Experiments show dislocation structures agreeing with those predicted. ψ AB is an unusual function. in which incident and scattered waves cannot be clearly separated in all asymptotic directions; we discuss its properties using a new asymptotic method.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Jul 23, 2017•1 citation

The Aharonov-Bohm effect in scattering of nonrelativistic electrons by a penetrable magnetic vortex

Yu. A. Sitenko

arXiv:1405.7171•Quantum Studies Mathematics and Foundations•Aug 12, 2014•2 citations

Wavefront dislocations in the Aharonov-Bohm effect and its water wave analogue

Michael Berry, R. G. Chambers, M D Large +2 more

The authors study the wavefronts (i.e. the surfaces of constant phase) of the wave discussed by Aharonov and Bohm, representing a beam of particles with charge q scattered by an impenetrable cylinder of radius R containing magnetic flux Phi . Defining the quantum flux parameter by alpha =q Phi /h, they show that for the case R=0 the wave psi AB possesses a wavefront dislocation on the flux line, whose strength (i.e. the number of wave crests ending on the dislocation) equals the nearest integer to alpha . When alpha passes through half-integer values, the strength changes, by wavefronts unlinking and reconnecting along a nodal surface. In quantum mechanics this phase structure is unobservable, but they devise an analogue where surface waves on water encounter an irrotational 'bathtub' vortex; in this case alpha depends on the frequency of the waves and the circulation of the vortex. Experiments show dislocation structures agreeing with those predicted. psi AB is an unusual function in which incident and scattered waves cannot be clearly separated in all asymptotic directions; they discuss its properties using a new asymptotic method.

European Journal of Physics•Jul 1, 1980•223 citations

The double slit experiment, the Aharonov-Bohm effect, and a new quantum potential theory: Towards a realistic interpretation of quantum mechanics

R. E. L. Mónaco, G. G. Cabrera

Foundations of Physics Letters•Feb 1, 1994•5 citations

Aharonov-Bohm scattering from the hydrodynamical viewpoint

J.-Q. Liang, X. X. Ding

Physics Letters A•Jan 1, 1987•10 citations

Aptly named Aharonov-Bohm effect has classical analogue, long history

Michael Berry

Writing about what is usually termed the Aharonov-Bohm (AB) effect, Peter Sturrock and Timothy Groves argue (Physics Today, April 2010, page 8) that the same physics was discovered a decade earlier 1 1. W. Ehrenberg, R. E. Siday, Proc. Phys. Soc. B 62, 8 (1949). and should rightly be called the Ehrenberg-Siday effect. I agree that Werner Ehrenberg and Raymond Siday deserve recognition for their anticipation of AB. Indeed, in recent talks celebrating the 50th anniversary of AB, I began by describing the unfairly neglected paper by Ehrenberg and Siday. Nevertheless, I have come to a different conclusion from Sturrock and Groves: The expression “Aharonov-Bohm effect” is justified, for two reasons.First, although there is no doubt that the work by Ehrenberg and Siday anticipated how inaccessible magnetic flux can influence electron interference, that was as a curiosity, at the end of a paper whose main emphasis was the Hamiltonian analysis of electron optics. By contrast, Yakir Aharonov and David Bohm emphasized from the start, as an essential and general aspect of quantum mechanics, the physical influence of inaccessible fields that act nonlocally through the vector potential.Second, Ehrenberg and Siday’s semi-classical approximation—essentially applying the Dirac magnetic phase factor to electrons traveling on either side of the flux—implies a wavefunction that is multivalued and therefore not the correct solution of Schrödinger’s equation. The lack of a single-valued wavefunction leaves their prediction open to doubt. By contrast, Aharonov and Bohm derived the exact single-valued solution for waves scattered by a flux line. Recently, it was shown that the Ehrenberg-Siday approximation corresponds to the first terms in a “many-whirls” representation that treats the exact AB wavefunction as a topological sum over paths circling the flux. 2 2. M. V. Berry, J. Phys. A (in press). Attribution of credit is a delicate matter. It tends to excite strong feelings, and I write about it reluctantly. But the Ehrenberg-Siday paper does seem to exemplify the unfortunate phenomenon identified by Alfred North White-head in a 1916 address to the British Association for the Advancement of Science: “Everything of importance has been said before, by someone who did not discover it.”In a companion letter in the April 2010 issue, Alexander Ershkovich correctly points out that the AB effect is present in classical Hamiltonian mechanics, even though remote magnetic fields cannot influence Newtonian trajectories. He advocates a “search for experiments that might prove … a classical analogue of the Aharonov-Bohm effect.” Such an experiment exists already. In the classical physics of waves on a moving medium, the flow velocity acts like the vector potential in quantum mechanics, so the flow vorticity acts like the magnetic field; the analogy is precise. Fine details of the AB wavefunction were observed in ripples on the surface of water swirling irrotationally into a bathtub vortex, 3 3. M. V. Berry, R. G. Chambers, M. D. Large, C. Upstill, J. C. Walmsley, Eur. J. Phys. 1, 154 (1980). whose core is the analogue of inaccessible magnetic flux. REFERENCESSection:ChooseTop of pageREFERENCES <<CITING ARTICLES1. W. Ehrenberg, R. E. Siday, Proc. Phys. Soc. B 62, 8 (1949). Google ScholarCrossref2. M. V. Berry, J. Phys. A (in press). Google Scholar3. M. V. Berry, R. G. Chambers, M. D. Large, C. Upstill, J. C. Walmsley, Eur. J. Phys. 1, 154 (1980). Google ScholarCrossref© 2010 American Institute of Physics.

Physics Today•Jul 30, 2010•13 citations
We study the wavefronts (i.e. the surfaces of constant phase) of the wave discussed by Aharonov and Bohm, representing a beam of particles with charge q scattered by an impenetrable cylinder of radius R containing magnetic flux Ф. Defining the quantum flux parameter by α = q Ф/ h . we show that for the case R = 0 the wave ψ AB possesses a wavefront dislocation on the flux line, whose strength (i.e. the number of wave crests ending on the dislocation) equals the nearest integer to α . When α passes through half-integer values, the strength changes, by wavefronts unlinking and reconnecting along a nodal surface. In quantum mechanics this phase structure is unobservable, but we devise an analogue where surface waves on water encounter an irrotational ‘bathtub’ vortex; in this case α depends on the frequency of the waves and the circulation of the vortex. Experiments show dislocation structures agreeing with those predicted. ψ AB is an unusual function. in which incident and scattered waves cannot be clearly separated in all asymptotic directions; we discuss its properties using a new asymptotic method.
The authors study the wavefronts (i.e. the surfaces of constant phase) of the wave discussed by Aharonov and Bohm, representing a beam of particles with charge q scattered by an impenetrable cylinder of radius R containing magnetic flux Phi . Defining the quantum flux parameter by alpha =q Phi /h, they show that for the case R=0 the wave psi AB possesses a wavefront dislocation on the flux line, whose strength (i.e. the number of wave crests ending on the dislocation) equals the nearest integer to alpha . When alpha passes through half-integer values, the strength changes, by wavefronts unlinking and reconnecting along a nodal surface. In quantum mechanics this phase structure is unobservable, but they devise an analogue where surface waves on water encounter an irrotational 'bathtub' vortex; in this case alpha depends on the frequency of the waves and the circulation of the vortex. Experiments show dislocation structures agreeing with those predicted. psi AB is an unusual function in which incident and scattered waves cannot be clearly separated in all asymptotic directions; they discuss its properties using a new asymptotic method.
Writing about what is usually termed the Aharonov-Bohm (AB) effect, Peter Sturrock and Timothy Groves argue (Physics Today, April 2010, page 8) that the same physics was discovered a decade earlier 1 1. W. Ehrenberg, R. E. Siday, Proc. Phys. Soc. B 62, 8 (1949). and should rightly be called the Ehrenberg-Siday effect. I agree that Werner Ehrenberg and Raymond Siday deserve recognition for their anticipation of AB. Indeed, in recent talks celebrating the 50th anniversary of AB, I began by describing the unfairly neglected paper by Ehrenberg and Siday. Nevertheless, I have come to a different conclusion from Sturrock and Groves: The expression “Aharonov-Bohm effect” is justified, for two reasons.First, although there is no doubt that the work by Ehrenberg and Siday anticipated how inaccessible magnetic flux can influence electron interference, that was as a curiosity, at the end of a paper whose main emphasis was the Hamiltonian analysis of electron optics. By contrast, Yakir Aharonov and David Bohm emphasized from the start, as an essential and general aspect of quantum mechanics, the physical influence of inaccessible fields that act nonlocally through the vector potential.Second, Ehrenberg and Siday’s semi-classical approximation—essentially applying the Dirac magnetic phase factor to electrons traveling on either side of the flux—implies a wavefunction that is multivalued and therefore not the correct solution of Schrödinger’s equation. The lack of a single-valued wavefunction leaves their prediction open to doubt. By contrast, Aharonov and Bohm derived the exact single-valued solution for waves scattered by a flux line. Recently, it was shown that the Ehrenberg-Siday approximation corresponds to the first terms in a “many-whirls” representation that treats the exact AB wavefunction as a topological sum over paths circling the flux. 2 2. M. V. Berry, J. Phys. A (in press). Attribution of credit is a delicate matter. It tends to excite strong feelings, and I write about it reluctantly. But the Ehrenberg-Siday paper does seem to exemplify the unfortunate phenomenon identified by Alfred North White-head in a 1916 address to the British Association for the Advancement of Science: “Everything of importance has been said before, by someone who did not discover it.”In a companion letter in the April 2010 issue, Alexander Ershkovich correctly points out that the AB effect is present in classical Hamiltonian mechanics, even though remote magnetic fields cannot influence Newtonian trajectories. He advocates a “search for experiments that might prove … a classical analogue of the Aharonov-Bohm effect.” Such an experiment exists already. In the classical physics of waves on a moving medium, the flow velocity acts like the vector potential in quantum mechanics, so the flow vorticity acts like the magnetic field; the analogy is precise. Fine details of the AB wavefunction were observed in ripples on the surface of water swirling irrotationally into a bathtub vortex, 3 3. M. V. Berry, R. G. Chambers, M. D. Large, C. Upstill, J. C. Walmsley, Eur. J. Phys. 1, 154 (1980). whose core is the analogue of inaccessible magnetic flux. REFERENCESSection:ChooseTop of pageREFERENCES <<CITING ARTICLES1. W. Ehrenberg, R. E. Siday, Proc. Phys. Soc. B 62, 8 (1949). Google ScholarCrossref2. M. V. Berry, J. Phys. A (in press). Google Scholar3. M. V. Berry, R. G. Chambers, M. D. Large, C. Upstill, J. C. Walmsley, Eur. J. Phys. 1, 154 (1980). Google ScholarCrossref© 2010 American Institute of Physics.