A dilute gas Bose-Einstein condensate (BEC) near a Feshbach resonance offers a system that can be tuned from the well-understood regime of weak interactions to the complex regime of strong interactions. Strong interactions play a central role in the phenomena of superfluidity in liquid He, and theoretical treatments for this regime have existed since the 1950’s. However, these theories have not been experimentally tested as superfluid He offers no similar mechanism with which to tune the interactions. In dilute gas condensates near a Feshbach resonance, where interactions can be tuned, strong interactions have proven difficult to study due to the condensate’s metastable nature with respect to the formation of weakly bound molecules. In this thesis, I introduce an experimental system and novel probes of the gas that have been specifically designed to study strongly interacting BECs. I present Bragg spectroscopy measurements that have accessed this regime, as well as proof-of-principle experiments using photon-counting for Bragg spectroscopy at low-momentum. Finally, I show preliminary data using contact spectroscopy, which is a method that could lead to the first measurements of the predicted interaction energies for a dilute Bose gas of atoms in the strongly interacting regime.
The work described in this thesis can be divided into two parts. The first part is concerned with the production of degenerate Fermi gases and Bose-Fermi mixtures. The second part of the thesis describes studies of strongly interacting spin-mixtures of ultracold fermions. We have cooled a magnetically trapped spin-polarized 6Li Fermi gas into quantum degeneracy by sympathetic cooling with bosonic 23Na. In order to do this, we have converted our previously developed apparatus for Bose-Einstein condensation of 23Na into a two-species cooling facility. We have produced 6Li samples with up to 7 × 107 atoms at temperatures below 0.5TF , and up to 3× 107 atoms at temperatures as low as 0.05TF . Further, we have also produced stable quantum degenerate mixtures of 23Na and 6Li, with several million atoms of each species. In a second set of experiments, we have studied strongly interacting spin-mixtures of 6Li. The strength of interactions was resonantly controlled by applying a magnetic field and tuning to “Feshbach resonances”, which occur when the total energy of the colliding particles coincides with the energy of a bound molecular state. These studies are relevant for the continuing quest for a superfluid transition in a Fermi gas. By studying the inelastic decay of the cloud, we have experimentally identified two Feshbach resonances for the inter-state interactions of the two lowest ground states of 6Li. Most importantly, we found that the lifetime of the strongly interacting system is long enough to observe a superfluid transition in the future. The effects of the coherent collisions in 6Li spin-mixtures were studied using radiofrequency (RF) spectroscopy. We demonstrated the absence of mean field “clock shifts” in a two-state mixture of fermions, and have introduced a three-level method to observe the interaction energy shifts. In the strongly interacting regime, near a Feshbach resonance, we have observed universal behavior of the interaction energy, independent of the value of the scattering length. Finally, we have theoretically studied the effects of Pauli blocking during a free expansion of a degenerate Fermi gas. We have concluded that a strongly interacting normal gas will undergo a hydrodynamic expansion even at zero temperature, due to inefficiency of the Pauli suppression of collisions. Therefore, the already observed hydrodynamic expansion cannot be conclusively interpreted as a signature of superfluidity. Thesis Supervisor: Wolfgang Ketterle Title: John D. MacArthur Professor of Physics
The year 2015 marks the 20th anniversary of the achievement of Bose–Einstein condensation (BEC) in atomic vapors. Atomic BEC, realized by Eric Cornell, Carl Wieman and Wolfgang Ketterle in 1995, commenced an exciting wave to explore quantum few- and many-body physics. Different from solid state matter and helium superfluids, atomic condensates in the gas phase come with drastically lower densities and temperatures, which place the systems in a unique regime where the atomic interactions are simple and precisely known. Furthermore, the condensates are typically weakly interacting: the interaction length scale of few nanometers is much shorter than the interatomic separation of hundreds of nanometers. Thus many early experimental observations can be well understood based on mean-field theory. One celebrated model is the Gross-Pitaevskii equation which provides a precise and quantitative description of weakly interacting Bose condensates [1]. Opportunities to extend cold atom research beyond the weak interaction regime emerged in the early 2000s. Several experimental schemes were developed to prepare atoms in the strong correlation and interaction regimes. One approach is loading atoms into an optical lattice, the interference pattern of laser beams. The lattice potential enhances the interactions of localized atoms and quenches their kinetic energy. A variety of lattice configurations are realized that promise novel quantum phases of ultracold atoms. Another route to strong interaction is based on Feshbach resonance, typically induced by magnetically shifting a molecular state near the scattering continuum of atoms. The resonant coupling between scattering atoms and the molecular state leads to a divergence of the atomic interaction length scale. Exactly on Feshbach resonance, the collision cross section reaches the quantum mechanical limit, and the system becomes strongly hydrodynamic with mean-free path as short as interparticle separation. Fascinating observations in the strong coupling regime soon followed: prominent examples include the superfluid-Mott insulator transition in optical lattices [2], resonantly interacting Fermi gases in the BEC–BCS (Bardeen–Cooper–Schieffer superfluid) crossover [3] and Efimov three-body states [4], and they lead to tremendous research interest into novel quantum states and quantum dynamics. One of the key motivations in these explorations is to uncover new, universal principles that underpin the physics of strongly correlated quantum systems. A well-studied universal behavior in many-body physics manifests in the critical phenomena near a continuous phase transition. Near the critical point, the system develops a diverging correlation length, which suppresses the dependence on other microscopic length scales. The systems are thus scale invariant and can be universally characterized by a few critical exponents. In cold atoms, divergence of correlation lengthes has been observed near the superfluid phase transition [5,6], as well as the superfluid-Mott insulator quantum phase transition in optical lattices. In the lattice experiments, scale invariance can be tested based on the equation of state measurements [7]. These works complement the transport measurements in condensed matter experiments. Has a new class of universal physics been discovered in atomic quantum gases? Yes, it turns out that a special class of strongly interacting quantum gas with ‘intrinsic’ scaling symmetry emerges near a Feshbach resonance [8]. Near the resonance, the scattering length scale diverges a → ∞ [9], unimaginable in classical systems, and the interaction length reaches the maximum value allowed by quantum mechanics as 1/k, called the ‘unitarity limit’ and k is the momentum of the scattering state. A famous example is the strongly interacting Fermi gas in the BEC–BCS crossover regime, where the resonant interactions lead to strong pairing and and universal hydrodynamic behavior. An exciting development in the study of the BEC–BCS crossover focuses on the Fermi gas exactly on Feshbach resonance. Here the system, also called a ‘unitary Fermi gas’, is the most complex and strongly correlated. The resonant interaction, however, implies a special scaling symmetry of the system. To understand the symmetry, we consider a scale transformation: x → Λx that stretches the coordinates of all atoms by a factor of Λ, and thus reduces the atomic density n by a factor of Λ3 in a 3D gas and the kinetic energy Ek ∝ −∇2 by Λ2. One can see that both kinetic energy Ek and interaction energy in the unitarity limit na → n/k are reduced by the same factor Λ2. The system is thus hypothesized to be invariant under the scale transformation [8]. Remarkably, similar scaling symmetry also holds for 2D quantum gas with a constant coupling g = const. [10]. Here stretching the size of the 2D gas by a factor of Λ also reduces both the kinetic Ek and interaction energy gσ by Λ2, where σ is the 2D density. Since the scaling symmetry in these systems comes directly from the form of the interactions, intrinsic scale invariance is robust at all temperatures T and chemical potentials μ and does not rely on the proximity to a phase transition. The scaling symmetry suggests that the only independent variables are the ratios of the length scales or the equivalent energy scales. In a grand canonical ensemble, the independent ratio can be chosen as μ/kBT. This realization greatly simplifies theoretical description as well as the experimental characterization of the system. Theoretically, a new set of universal thermodynamic relations are expected to be insensitive to the microscopic details; experimentally, measurements are expected to collapse into universal functions that only depend on μ/kBT. Measurements on unitary Fermi gas and the 2D Bose gas are consistent with the scaling hypothesis, shown in Fig. 1(a) and (b). Remarkable quantitative agreement between measurements and calculations has greatly advanced our understanding of the ‘unitary Fermi gas’ and 2D atomic gas. Ultracold atomic gases which are intrinsically scale invariant: (a) unitary Fermi gas, (b) 2D Bose gas and (c) unitary Bose gas. The scaling symmetry suggests that thermodynamic observables only depend on the ratio of chemical potential and thermal energy |
μ~=μ/kBT|. In (a), thermodynamic pressure of a unitary Fermi gas is compared with calculations and other measurements. Figure courtesy of M. Zwierlein [11]. In (b), the collapse of the density measurement at various temperatures (inset) confirms the scaling symmetry. Figure adopted from [12]. Panel (c) shows the three-body loss spectrum in a 6Li133Cs mixture. The geometric progression of the Efimov resonance positions at B = B1, B2 and B3 toward the Feshbach resonance at B0 results from the discrete scaling symmetry of Efimov physics. Figure adopted from [13]. We may expect the same scaling symmetry for a resonantly interacting Bose gas. Here, however, the scaling symmetry is more subtle because of the presence of three-body physics. Predicted by Vitaly Efimov in the context of nuclear physics [14], an infinite number of three-body bound states exist for resonantly interacting bosons and their energies follow a discrete scaling law, breaking the otherwise continuous scaling symmetry. Identical fermions do not form such three-body states due to Pauli's exclusion principle. Theoretically the three-body bound states are supported by the ‘Efimov potential’ V(R)∝ − 1/R2, where R is the characteristic length scale of the three interacting atoms. While the Efimov potential does not break the continuous scaling symmetry, the presence of discrete three-body states does break the symmetry. An alternative picture based on renormalization group limited cycles [15] also explains the discrete scaling symmetry of the system, a scenario that rarely happens in electronic systems. Experimentally, Efimov states have been observed in cold gases of alkali atoms, as well as in helium-4. The geometric scaling symmetry of Efimov states is reported in a recent experiment, shown in Fig. 1(c). The same discrete scaling symmetry is expected for unitary quantum gas of bosons, which, if confirmed, will establish a unique and fascinating class of strongly interacting quantum systems. While in this article, we focus on atoms in optical lattices and unitary atomic gases as primary examples of universal physics that have been actively investigated, efforts in many new research frontiers have shown promising prospects to uncover new universal physics in the strongly correlated and interacting systems. Non-equilibrium dynamics is one of the hottest directions. Ultracold atoms are particularly suited for the study of quantum dynamics due to their slow evolution time scales of miniseconds to seconds. Dynamics near a quantum phase transition and the thermalization of isolated quantum systems are two research topics with many unanswered questions. Cold atom experiments may provide new universal insights that go beyond current theoretical framework. Another exciting direction is quantum many-body systems with long range or very strong interactions. Examples include trapped ions, and condensates of exotic atoms with huge magnetic dipole moments, polar molecules, as well as those with Rydberg excitations. These systems possess various long range interactions. Novel universal dynamics, for example, propagation of information and entanglement, are predicted to depend solely on the asymptotic form of the interaction and the dimension of the systems. The author thanks Yijun Wang for discussion and careful reading of the article. This work was supported by National Science Foundation (PHY-0747907) and Army Research Office-Multiple University Research Initiative (W911NF-14-1-0003).
This thesis presents experiments probing physics in the crossover between Bose-Einstein condensation (BEC) and BCS superconductivity using an ultracold gas of atomic fermions. Scattering resonances in these ultracold gases (known as Feshbach resonances) provide the unique ability to tune the fermion-fermion interactions. The work presented here pioneered the use of fermionic Feshbach resonances as a highly controllable and tunable system ideal for studying the cusp of the BCS-BEC crossover problem. Here pairs of fermionic atoms have some properties of diatomic molecules and some properties of Cooper pairs. I present studies of a normal Fermi gas at a Feshbach resonance and the work required to cool the gas to temperatures where superfluidity in the crossover is predicted. These studies culminated in our observation of a phase transition at the cusp of the BCS-BEC crossover through condensation of fermionic atom pairs. I also discuss subsequent work that confirmed the crossover nature of the pairs in these condensates.
Ultracold atomic gases with tunable interactions offer an ideal platform for studying interacting quantum matter. While the few- and many-body physics are generally complex and intractable, the problem can be greatly simplified in an atomic gas by a controlled separation of relevant length and energy scales. Precise control of experimental parameters, via Feshbach resonances, optical potentials and radio-frequency radiation, enables deterministic measurements of few-body physics, including universal physics and the Efimov effect. In this thesis, I present our recent studies on precisely measuring two- and three-body physics in an ultracold Bose gas. I begin by describing our new apparatus used for generating and studying ultracold 39K gas samples. Then, I focus on our precision spectroscopy of Feshbach dimer binding energies, spanning three orders of magnitude and with sub-kilohertz resolution. These measurements enable us to locate a Feshbach resonance and determine scattering length values with unprecedented accuracy. Finally, I present our precise measurements locating an exotic three-body state, specifically the Efimov ground state. We find that the trimer state location significantly deviates from the value predicted by van der Waals universality. Due to small experimental and systematic uncertainties, our measurement is the strongest evidence of departure from the universal value and is the first observed deviation near a Feshbach resonance of intermediate strength.
This thesis summarizes our study on the properties of ultracold Fermions near a Feshbach resonance. The Feshbach resonance allows for a continuous tuning of the interaction strength between the atoms. With this tunability, many properties predicted for the BCS-BEC crossover region in solids can be shown to exist in this ultracold Fermi gas. With the highly controllable parameters and the clean environment in the experiments, the study of the Bardeen-Cooper-Schrieffer (BCS) to Bose-Einstein Condensation (BEC) crossover in ultracold Fermions provides valuable insights to the strongly interacting crossover region, which has never been achieved before in solids. We first examine the properties of 6 Li and 40 K gases. We find that in the unitary region the properties of the system do not depend on the atom species: outside the unitary region, the properties of the system do depend on the scattering properties of the different atom species. We study the dynamics of the ultracold Fermions in the crossover region in response to the variations in the external magnetic field. We find that the response depends on the time scale and the amplitude of the variations; which is in qualitative agreement with the experimental observations. We derive a set of dynamic mean-field equations for a Fermi gas in an arbitrary potential trap near a wide Feshbach resonance. The equations are more general than the local density approximation (LDA), and less demanding computationally as the Bogoliubov-de-Gennes (BdG) equation. We then analyze the solubility of the equations, as well as solve a simplified version of the equations for illustration and for self-consistency check on the assumptions made during the derivation. We systematically study the possible phases for a trapped Fermi gas with population imbalance near a Feshbach resonance. Our results agree qualitatively well with the recent experimental results, and predict the existence of two exotic non-BCS superfluid phases for the strongly interacting gas with population unbalance: the Breached Pair (BP) phase and the Fulde-Ferrell-Larkin-Ovchinnikov (FFLO) phase. Finally, to guide the experimental efforts in the search of new quantum phases, we propose a detection scheme for the possible exotic phases.