IEEE International Conference on Microwaves, Communications, Antennas and Electronic Systems (COMCAS)

The Quantum Illumination Story : (Invited Paper)

Jeffrey H. Shapiro

Published Nov 1, 2019• 6 citations

Abstract

Superposition and entanglement, the quintessential characteristics of quantum physics, have been shown to provide communication, computation, and sensing capabilities that go beyond what classical physics will permit. It is natural, therefore, to explore their application to radar, despite the fact that decoherence-caused by the loss and noise encountered in radar sensing-destroys these fragile quantum properties. This paper tells the story of “quantum illumination”, an entanglement-based approach to quantum radar, from its inception to its current understanding. Remarkably, despite loss and noise that destroys its initial entanglement, quantum illumination does offer a target-detection performance improvement over a classical radar of the same transmitted energy. A realistic assessment of that improvement's utility, however, shows that its value is severely limited. Nevertheless, the fact that entanglement can be of value on an entanglement-breaking channel-the meta-lesson of the quantum illumination story-should spur continued research on quantum radar.

DOI: 10.1109/comcas44984.2019.8958368

Related papers

The Quantum Illumination Story

Jeffrey H. Shapiro

Quantum Radar! Check out what Wikipedia says about it: it might render stealth aircraft obsolete. Watch YouTube videos that purport to explain all about it. Read press reports in which China claims it field tested one in 2016. But is there any fire underneath all that smoke? This talk will answer that question by telling the story of “quantum illumination”, from its beginnings through recent theoretical and experimental results. Quantum illumination is the only quantum radar concept that has been proven, theoretically, to outperform all classical radars of the same transmitted energy in detecting a weakly-reflecting target that is embedded in strong background noise. It uses a source of quadrature-entangled signal and idler beams to gain its target-detection performance improvement despite loss and noise that destroys the entanglement. A realistic assessment of that improvement's utility, however, shows that its value is severely limited. Nevertheless, the fact that entanglement can be of value on an entanglement-breaking channel — the meta-lesson of the quantum illumination story — should spur continued research on quantum radar.

arXiv:1910.12277IEEE Aerospace and Electronic Systems MagazineApr 1, 2020174 citations

Quantum Radar Through Entanglement‑Based Illumination: A Framework for Enhanced Target Detection

mark harrison, CP Nova

Quantum radar systems leverage entangled photon pairs to detect and identify targets in noisy or cluttered environments with sensitivity beyond classical limits. By transmitting one photon of an entangled pair toward a distant object while retaining its partner locally, the system exploits quantum correlations to improve signal discrimination, reduce noise susceptibility, and enhance detection probability. This paper outlines the physical principles, operational architecture, and performance advantages of entanglement‑based illumination, providing a clear foundation for future quantum‑enhanced sensing technologies.(If you want it shorter, longer, or more formal, tap: shorter paragraph, longer paragraph, more formal)

Sep 18, 20260 citations

Restoring Quantum Superiority of Noisy Quantum Illumination

Wei Wu, Jun‐Hong An

Quantum illumination uses quantum entanglement as a resource to enable higher-resolution detection of low-reflectivity targets than is possible with classical techniques. This revolutionary technology could transform modern radar. However, it is widely believed that the decoherence induced by the ubiquitous quantum noise destroys the superiority of quantum illumination, severely constraining its performance and application in our present noisy intermediate-scale quantum era. Here, we propose a method to restore the quantum superiority of the quantum illumination in the presence of quantum noises. Going beyond the widely used Born-Markov approximation, we discover that the resolution of noisy quantum illumination is highly sensitive to the energy spectrum of the composite system formed by each of the two light modes and its local quantum noise. When a bound state is present in the energy spectrum, the resolution asymptotically approaches its ideal form. Our result establishes a physical principle to preserve the quantum superiority and paves the way for the realization of high-resolution quantum illumination in noisy situations.

arXiv:2510.20378Oct 23, 20250 citations

A Short Communication on Quantum Radar Obstacles and the Failing 'Quantum Illumination' Theoretical Solution

Metin Celalettin, Horace King

Quantum Illumination is the phenomena where defense contractors, scientists, quantum engineers and photonics experts have pondered it as the solution for correction method and for the effects of atmosphere on entanglement, causing atmospheric coupling, bringing the quantum system to its final phase; quantum decoherence.Rather than discard the tactic, large sums of money have been poured into strategies such as improving target detection in an effort to make quantum illumination efforts more efficient, or attempting to achieve quantum illumination using Gaussian states whereby quantum harmonic oscillators adopt states resembling the oscillatory behavior of a classical harmonic oscillator.So far the progress of a deployable quantum radar has not quite been achieved due to this same obstacle, quantum decoherence.This study proposes the solution for developing a military quantum radar whereby quantum decoherence due to quantum illumination to overcome the effects of atmosphere coupling on the quantum radar's quantum entangled photons.

Dec 14, 20180 citations

Progress Toward an All-Microwave Quantum Illumination Radar

Jérôme Bourassa, Christopher M. Wilson

Quantum illumination has been suggested as a way to improve the sensitivity of remote target detection by taking advantage of quantum entanglement between a traveling electromagnetic beam of light interrogating the target, and a second beam kept in the lab. In the microwave domain, superconducting quantum circuit utilizing superconducting Josephson tunnel junctions can be used as quantum-limited amplifiers of faint microwave signals, as well as bright sources of quantum entangled signals. These Josephson parametric amplifiers (JPAs) are poised to become fundamental building block in a future quantum illumination radar operating in the microwave domain. Demonstrating a practical advantage of quantum illumination with ambient temperature signals is, however, challenging. Indeed, current quantum protocols are not practical as they require a complex receiver with stringent phase-matching conditions, which cannot be met in the field. Notably, it is also not currently known how one can transfer faint microwave signals out of cryogenic systems without destroying their fragile entanglement. In this article, we discuss the recent progress and challenges regarding the development of an all-microwave quantum illumination radar using the recently developed and implemented quantum-enhanced noise radar protocol. This quantum illumination protocol is simpler to implement and procures a quantum enhancement over its classical analog. Finally, we discuss different strategies that may resolve the issue of transmitting microwave entanglement under ambient conditions. We, thus, conclude that successful transmission of entangled microwaves can be done in the near future, with possible demonstrations of practical quantum advantage over short distances.

IEEE Aerospace and Electronic Systems MagazineNov 1, 202010 citations

Quantum illumination radar with entangled coherent states

Zhiwei Tao, Yi-Chong Ren, Azezigul Abdukirim +2 more

There has been a great interest in quantum metrology (e.g., quantum interferometric radar) due to its applications in sub-Rayleigh ranging and remote sensing. Despite interferometric radar has received vast amount of attentions over the past two decades, very few researches has been conducted on another type of quantum radar: quantum illumination radar, or more precisely quantum target detection. It is, in general, used to interrogate whether the low-reflectivity target in a noisy thermal bath is existed using quantum light. The entanglement properties of its emitted light source give it a unique detection advantage over the classical radar. Entangled coherent state (ECS), as a class of quantum states with high entanglement robustness in noisy environments, has been widely used in several fields of quantum science such as quantum informatics, quantum metrology . In this paper, we investigate the target detection performance of quantum illumination radar based on three different types of ECS states. We employ the two-mode squeezed vacuum state (TMSV) and the coherent state as benchmarks to compare and analyze the relationship between the entanglement strength of the three types of ECS states and their quantum illumination detection performance. We found that the detection performance of the three ECS states is better than that of the coherent state. However, it is inferior to that of the TMSV state when the target is of low reflectivity. The emitted photon number is much smaller than the background noise (we call this as “good” illumination conditions). On the contrary, quantum illumination radar has no obvious advantage over coherent state radar for target detection under other illumination conditions; further, the detection performance of these three types of ECS states is not evidently related to that of the TMSV state and the coherent state. Finally, we reveal that the target detection performance of quantum illumination for the first two types of ECS states can be determined by their entanglement strength under “good” illumination conditions by adjusting the inter-modal phase of these two ECS states while keeping the emitted photon number constant. Under other illumination conditions, there is no evidence to demonstrate the entanglement strength of ECS states being associated with their target detection performance.

Acta Physica SinicaJan 1, 20214 citations