In quantum mechanics, the theory of quantum transitions is grounded on the convergence of a series of time-dependent perturbation theory. In nuclear and atomic physics, this series converges because the dynamics of quantum transitions (quantum jumps) are absent by definition. In molecular and chemical physics, on the contrary, the dynamics of "quantum" transitions, being determined by the joint motion of a light electron (or electrons) and very heavy nuclei, are present by definition, and the series of time-dependent perturbation theory becomes singular. An exception is the dynamic problem for stationary states in the Born-Oppenheimer adiabatic approximation, when the electronic subsystem turns out to be "off" from the general dynamic process and therefore is not dynamically full-fledged: it only forms an electric potential in which the nuclei oscillate. Removing the aforementioned singularity can be accomplished in two ways. The first method was consisted of introducing an additional postulate in the form of the Franck-Condon principle into molecular quantum mechanics, in which the adiabatic approximation is used. The second method was proposed by the author and consisted of damping the singular dynamics of the joint motion of an electron and nuclei in the intermediate (transient) state of molecular "quantum" transitions by introducing chaos. This chaos arises only during molecular quantum transitions and is called dozy chaos. Formally, the damping is carried out by replacing an infinitely small imaginary addition in the spectral representation of the complete Green's function of the system with its finite quantity. The damping chaos (dozy chaos) leads to the continuity of the energy spectrum in the molecular transient state, which is a sign of classical mechanics. Meanwhile, the initial and final states of the molecule obey quantum mechanics in the adiabatic approximation. Molecular quantum mechanics, which takes into account the chaotic dynamics of the transient state of molecular "quantum" transitions, can be called quantum-classical (dozy-chaos) mechanics. The efficacy of the damping for the aforementioned singularity was previously shown by dozy-chaos mechanics of elementary electron transfers in condensed matter, which is the simplest case of dozy-chaos mechanics, and its applications to a whole number of problems, especially to the optical spectra in polymethine dyes and their aggregates. This paper provides a regular exposition of this dozy-chaos (quantum-classical) mechanics of the elementary electron transfers. The main results of its applications presented in the introduction are also described.
In quantum mechanics, the theory of quantum transitions is grounded on the convergence of a series of time-dependent perturbation theory. In nuclear and atomic physics, this series converges because the dynamics of quantum transitions (quantum jumps) are absent by definition. In molecular and chemical physics, on the contrary, the dynamics of "quantum" transitions, being determined by the joint motion of a light electron (or electrons) and very heavy nuclei, are present by definition, and the series of time-dependent perturbation theory becomes singular. An exception is the dynamic problem for stationary states in the Born-Oppenheimer adiabatic approximation, when the electronic subsystem turns out to be "off" from the general dynamic process and therefore is not dynamically full-fledged: it only forms an electric potential in which the nuclei oscillate. Removing the aforementioned singularity can be accomplished in two ways. The first method was consisted of introducing an additional postulate in the form of the Franck-Condon principle into molecular quantum mechanics, in which the adiabatic approximation is used. The second method was proposed by the author and consisted of damping the singular dynamics of the joint motion of an electron and nuclei in the intermediate (transient) state of molecular "quantum" transitions by introducing chaos. This chaos arises only during molecular quantum transitions and is called dozy chaos. Formally, the damping is carried out by replacing an infinitely small imaginary addition in the spectral representation of the complete Green's function of the system with its finite quantity. The damping chaos (dozy chaos) leads to the continuity of the energy spectrum in the molecular transient state, which is a sign of classical mechanics. Meanwhile, the initial and final states of the molecule obey quantum mechanics in the adiabatic approximation. Molecular quantum mechanics, which takes into account the chaotic dynamics of the transient state of molecular "quantum" transitions, can be called quantum-classical (dozy-chaos) mechanics. The efficacy of the damping for the aforementioned singularity was previously shown by dozy-chaos mechanics of elementary electron transfers in condensed matter, which is the simplest case of dozy-chaos mechanics, and its applications to a whole number of problems, especially to the optical spectra in polymethine dyes and their aggregates. This paper provides a regular exposition of this dozy-chaos (quantum-classical) mechanics of the elementary electron transfers. The main results of its applications presented in the introduction are also described.
Quantum–classical mechanics and the Franck–Condon principle related to quantum mechanics are discussed as two alternative theoretical approaches to molecular optical spectroscopy. The statement of the problem is connected with the singularity of quantum mechanics in describing the joint motion of electrons and nuclei in the transient state of “quantum” transitions. This singularity can be eliminated by introducing chaos into the transient state. Quantum mechanics itself, supplemented by chaos (dozy chaos), is called quantum–classical mechanics. Using the simplest example of quantum transitions, it is shown that the results of quantum–classical mechanics in the case of strong dozy chaos correspond to the physical picture based on quantum mechanics and the Franck–Condon principle. The same chaos can be strong for small molecules in standard molecular spectroscopy and simultaneously weak in the photochemistry and nanophotonics of large molecules, where quantum mechanics no longer works. To describe the chaotic dynamics of the transient state, it is necessary to apply quantum–classical mechanics. Thus, the erroneous Franck–Condon physical picture of molecular “quantum” transitions is workable from a practical point of view as long as we are dealing with sufficiently small molecules, just as the erroneous geocentric picture of the world was workable until we went out into outer space.
Introduction We now move to considering the dynamics of a system of nuclei and electrons. Of course, both electrons and nuclei are subject to the laws of quantum mechanics, but since nuclei are 2000 to 200,000 times heavier than electrons, we expect that classical mechanics will be a much better approximation for the motion of nuclei than for the motion of electrons. This means that we expect a level of approximation to be valid, where some of the degrees of freedom (d.o.f.) of a system behave essentially classically and others behave essentially quantum-mechanically. The system then is of a mixed quantum/classical nature. Most often the quantum subsystem consists of system of electrons in a dynamical field of classical nuclei, but the quantum subsystem may also be a selection of generalized nuclear coordinates (e.g., corresponding to high-frequency vibrations) while other generalized coordinates are supposed to behave classically, or describe the motion of a proton in a classical environment. So, in this chapter we consider the dynamics of a quantum system in a non-stationary potential. In Section 5.2 we consider the time-dependent potential as externally given, without taking notice of the fact that the sources of the time-dependent potential are moving nuclei, which are quantum particles themselves, feeling the interaction with the quantum d.o.f. Thus we consider the time evolution of the quantum system, which now involves mixing-in of excited states, but we completely ignore the back reaction of the quantum system onto the d.o.f. that cause the time-dependent potential, i.e., the moving nuclei.
Bohm theory is a formulation of Quantum Mechanics that characterises the state of a quantum system according to both the wave function, as in the conventional formulation, and the coordinates (positions) of all the particles that evolve in time drawing quantum continuous trajectories. Furthermore, a statistical ensemble of all the possible trajectories, raising from the impossibility to know the initial position of all the particles, establishes the exact correspondence with the traditional Quantum Mechanics. From a computational point of view, Bohm theory has found many applications in Chemical Physics especially to develop new methodologies for solving the Schrödinger equation and to address semi-classical approximations of Quantum Mechanics. From a theoretical point of view, the most appealing feature of Bohm theory is its capability to supply a conceptual map between the quantum formalism and our representation of what a chemical system is. Chemical systems are composed of molecules, but the same idea of molecule requires a specific arrangement in the space of particles, i.e., the nuclei of the atoms. The statistical description of conventional Quantum Mechanics on the basis of wave function alone is insufficient to establish a clear correspondence with such a picture of molecules. Indeed, chemists employ usually Classical Mechanics in order to overcome this drawback of the standard quantum theory. On the other hand, if the particles position is included in the quantum formalism, as Bohm theory does, the map can be defined in a self-consistent way. In other words, Bohm theory appears to be the suitable quantum framework to represent molecules and their motion. The chemical representation of molecular systems finds a natural correspondence with a single Bohm trajectory, since it is always implicitly assumed that molecular components have specific spatial position independently of our knowledge about it. Consequently, we develop a quantum method whose fundamental assumption is that a single Bohm trajectory, i.e., a quantum molecular trajectory, describes the molecular systems and the molecular motion correctly. First of all, we examine the correspondence between a single Bohm trajectory and the conventional Quantum Mechanics, without using the ensemble of trajectories. We verify that such a correspondence exists through numerical simulations and we prove formally that the statistical properties of a single Bohm trajectory explain the probabilistic description of Quantum Mechanics. Once the consistency of this original approach has been established, we investigate the predicted properties. For instance, we take into account the constants of motion (such as the energy) corresponding to the time evolution of the coordinates and the behaviour of simple chemical systems, e.g., the vibrational motion of single molecules interacting with a resonant field. In this way, unexpected features of the molecular motion are found. Secondly, we tackle the challenge of describing many components systems (like the chemical systems in ordinary conditions). As a matter of fact, the computation of the Bohm trajectory and of the wave function is extremely demanding. However, the statistical properties of the Bohm trajectory allow the derivation of stochastic theories for examining the dynamics of open quantum systems, i.e., few molecules (or few degrees of freedom) interacting with their environment (the other molecules). One of the developed stochastic methods correlates the dynamics of the reduced density matrix, for the degrees of freedom of interest, to the evolution of the corresponding Bohm coordinates. In other words, the Bohm equation, determining the set of all the particles velocities according to the full wave function, is replaced with a stochastic one that approximates the velocity of a subset of coordinates according to the reduced density matrix. In such a way, the quantum fluctuations induced by the environment are taken into account. The advantage of this method concerns its capability of describing quantum systems, including open quantum systems, in terms of a quantum trajectory. This could allow the understanding of the molecular motion during a spectroscopical experiment. The possibility of investigating reactive systems, such as conformational changes, is particularly interesting. As a matter of fact, chemical reactions can be completely characterised only through the particles motion and we define the suit- able quantum methodology providing a self-consistent description of the molecular motion.
By now the “chaos revolution” has reached nearly every branch of the natural sciences. In fact, chaos is everywhere. To name but a few examples, we talk about chaotic weather patterns, chaotic chemical reactions and the chaotic evolution of insect populations. Atomic and molecular physics are no exceptions. At first glance this is surprising since atoms and molecules are well described by the linear laws of quantum mechanics, while an essential ingredient of chaos is nonlinearity in the dynamic equations. Thus, chaos and atomic physics seem to have little to do with each other. But recently, atomic and molecular physicists have pushed the limits of their experiments to such high quantum numbers that it starts to make sense, in the spirit of Bohr's correspondence principle, to compare the results of atomic physics experiments with the predictions of classical mechanics, which, for the most part, show complexity and chaos. The most striking observation in recent years has been that quantum systems seem to “know” whether their classical counterparts display regular or chaotic motion. This fact can be understood intuitively on the basis of Feynman's version of quantum mechanics. In 1948 Feynman showed that quantum mechanics can be formulated on the basis of classical mechanics with the help of path integrals. Therefore it is expected that the quantum mechanics of an atom or molecule is profoundly influenced, but of course not completely determined, by the qualitative behaviour of its underlying classical mechanics.
Chemical dynamics, in principle, should be understood by solving the time-dependent Schrödinger equation for a molecular system, describing motion of the nuclei and electrons. However, the computational efforts to solve this partial second-order differential equation scales exponentially with the system size, which prevents us from getting exact numerical solutions for systems larger than 4-5 atoms. Thus, approximations simplifying the picture are necessary. The so-called Born-Oppenheimer approximation, separating motion of the electrons and nuclei is the central one: solution to the electronic Schrödinger equation defines the potential energy surface on which the nuclear motion unfolds, and there are standard quantum chemistry software packages for solving the electronic Schrödinger equation. For the nuclear Schrödinger equation, however, there are no widely applicable quantum-mechanical approaches, and most simulations are performed using classical Newtonian mechanics which is often adequate due to large nuclear masses. However, the nuclear quantum effects are significant for chemical processes involving light nuclei at low energies, and including these effects into simulation, even approximately, is highly desirable. In this dissertation, an approximate methodology of including quantum-mechanical effects within the quantum trajectory or the de Broglie-Bohm formulation of the Schrödinger equations is developed. Use of the trajectory framework makes the approach scalable to hundreds of degrees of freedom. The methodology is applied to study high-dimensional systems (solid He4 and others) relevant to chemistry.
The application of modern quantum chemical methods to the simulation of chemical reactions makes it obvious that the Copenhagen picture of quantum mechanics cannot be maintained. In ab-initio molecular dynamics methods, any kind of matter is described by applying the Schrödinger equation to the electronic structure and using classical Newton dynamics for the motion of the atomic nuclei. By lots of calculations on this basis, it has become obvious that this concept is superior to a quantum chemical description of nuclear motion. The nuclei move according to Newton's laws in a perfectly local and deterministic way while the surrounding electronic cloud determines bonding and antibonding interactions between the atoms. The resulting theory is a deterministic formulation of quantum mechanics which is free from paradoxa and is able to explain complex phenomena like photochemistry. An obvious consequence is that molecules like ammonia can have a permanent dipole moment in spectroscopic measurements, while consistent application of traditional quantum mechanics predicts a higher symmetry as is outlined in the paper.