Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

European Journal of Physics

Time evolution in quantum systems: a closer look at student understanding

Gina Passante, Benjamin P. Schermerhorn, Steven J. Pollock, Homeyra R. Sadaghiani

Published Nov 18, 2019• 15 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Abstract Time evolution of quantum systems has been shown to be one of the most difficult components of a typical undergraduate quantum mechanics course. In this work, we examine the current literature, and then take a closer look at the process that students use to determine how the quantum state of a spin-1/2 particle evolves with time. We divide the process of writing a time-dependent state into five elements and use these to both directly probe student understanding and guide our coding of student responses. We focus on three elements of this process, including knowledge of the Hamiltonian, the energy eigenstates and eigenvalues, and what basis should be used when writing the state as a function of time using the phase e − i E n t / ℏ . Analysis of four exam questions given at three institutions suggests that knowledge of the energy eigenbasis and its importance for time evolution may be a weak point in student understanding.

DOI
10.1088/1361-6404/ab58bf

Related papers

Questioning with university students on stationarity, time evolution and connection between sets of eigenstates in quantum mechanics

Giacomo Zuccarini, Marisa Michelini, Alberto Stefanel

Conceptual change from a classical to a quantum perspective is a challenging task for students. Basic concepts such as state and time evolution, already posing problematic issues in classical physics, require a different interpretation because of the redefinition of the concept of state, inextricably linked to fundamental features of new system behavior such as incompatibility between observables. Within an empirical research aimed at investigating connections between conceptual aspects and formalism emerging from student reasoning, we designed questionnaire items to explore how student describe time evolution of states, how they identify stationary states and how they use related concepts of eigenstate of an observable and incompatibility between observables in this process. Data gathering instruments were developed through a case study to collect student points of view on the relevant issue. For each aspect, at least two items were designed in order to cross-examine from different perspectives. Data analysis was organized following qualitative research methodology. The questionnaire was administered to a small group of students together with follow-up interviews. The study shows that most students link energy eigenstates to stationary states, but inverse implication doesn’t emerge with the same strength. The relation between energy eigenstates and those of different observables is clearly stated only when a commutator expression is identified by students. Energy eigenstates and their linear combinations are related to time invariance and time evolution in quantum mechanics in familiar-abstract context of infinite well, while uncertainties emerge in the crucial situation of scattering. Students answer as expected to questions concerning familiar tasks and contexts, but this doesn’t correspond to conceptual understanding of crucial elements under investigation. There is a need to build competence on critical reasoning.

•Jan 1, 2014•0 citations

Examining student ideas about energy measurements on quantum states across undergraduate and graduate levels

Gina Passante, Paul J. Emigh, Peter S. Shaffer

This paper is part of the Focused Collection on Upper Division Physics Courses.]Energy measurements play a fundamental role in the theory of quantum mechanics, yet there is evidence that the underlying concepts are difficult for many students, even after all undergraduate instruction.We present results from an investigation into student ability to determine the possible energies that can be measured for a given wave function and Hamiltonian, to determine the probabilities of each energy measurement and how they depend on time, and to recognize how a measurement of energy affects the state.By analyzing student responses to open-ended questions, we identify five broad, interrelated sets of conceptual and reasoning difficulties related to energy measurements.Data are drawn from sophomore-, junior-, and graduate-level quantum mechanics courses.Particular attention is paid to incorrect ideas that persist across all levels.

Physical Review Special Topics - Physics Education Research•Sep 23, 2015•65 citations

Investigating Student Difficulties with Time dependence of Expectation Values in Quantum Mechanics

Emily Marshman, Chandralekha Singh

Quantum mechanics is challenging even for advanced undergraduate and graduate students.In the Schrödinger representation, the wave function evolves in time according to the time dependent Schrödinger equation.The time dependence of the wave function gives rise to time dependence of the expectation value of observables.We have been exploring the difficulties that advanced undergraduate and graduate students have with time dependence of expectation values in quantum mechanics.We have developed and administered conceptual free response and multiplechoice questions to students to investigate these difficulties.We also interviewed 23 students individually using a thinkaloud protocol to obtain a better understanding of the rationale behind students' written responses.We find that many students struggle with time dependence of expectation values of observables.We discuss some findings.

arXiv:1510.01299•Physics Education Research Conference (PERC)•Feb 1, 2014•19 citations

Exploring student ideas on change of basis in quantum mechanics

Giaco Corsiglia, Benjamin P. Schermerhorn, Homeyra R. Sadaghiani +3 more

A common task when problem solving in quantum mechanics, including in a spins-first curriculum, involves changing the basis of a given state.Our research in undergraduate quantum mechanics courses at three institutions explores student thinking about basis, basis expansion coefficients, and change of basis in the context of spin-½ systems.Our investigation is based on conceptual and computational written questions as well as student reasoning interviews.We identify student ideas about whether and how changing basis affects the state, examine how students perceive notation as indicative of choice of basis, explore students' interpretations of the structure and meaning of a basis expansion, and identify the range of methods students employ when changing basis.For instance, we find a recurring idea that changing basis alters the physical system, and observe that some students chose to relabel the ket representing a quantum state vector after changing basis.Together, these results paint a broad, qualitative picture of a variety of ways that students grapple with basis and change of basis, with potential implications for instruction.

Physical Review Physics Education Research•Jun 6, 2022•19 citations

Introducing the concepts of energy and dynamics in quantum mechanics by engaging students in theoretical modeling

Giacomo Zuccarini, Maria Bondani

Abstract In the last decades, empirical investigations have shown the existence of deep and persistent difficulties with teaching/learning the time independent Schrödinger equation and time evolution. At the same time, research has provided evidence in favor of engaging students in modeling activities to help them improve their understanding. However, there is a lack of model-based curriculum materials for teaching the concepts of energy and dynamics in quantum mechanics. To illustrate how modeling could be included in the learning of these topics, we outline an educational proposal in the context of a spins-first approach. As a starting point to introduce the energy concept for atoms and particles, the learning path leverages student knowledge of the Bohr model. The energy level structure of a hydrogen atom with transitions accompanied by the absorption or emission of a photon provides an intuitive basis for activating the modeling of energy, that is organized around the analysis of contrasting cases on the possible results of spin flip transitions in a magnetic field. In this process, students are guided to build a mathematical representation of energy and to investigate its nature up to a derivation of the energy eigenvalue equation. The learning path allows students to compare and contrast the semi-classical Bohr model with the quantum model, as a support to help them build a consistent understanding of the latter. A different set of contrasting cases on the possible results of spin measurements after different amounts of time in the field is used to activate a qualitative modeling process on time evolution, which is then quantitatively examined by analyzing graphs of the state tomography, guiding students to explore the basic features of quantum dynamics up to a derivation of the Schrödinger equation.

European Journal of Physics•Jul 20, 2026•0 citations

Student understanding of quantum mechanics

Chandralekha Singh

We investigate the difficulties of advanced undergraduate students toward the end of a full year upper-level quantum mechanics course with concepts related to quantum measurements and time development. Our analysis is based upon a test administered to 89 students from six universities and interviews with 9 students. Strikingly, most students shared the same difficulties despite variations in background, teaching styles, and textbooks. Concepts related to stationary states, eigenstates, and time dependence of expectation values were found to be particularly difficult. An analysis of written tests and interviews suggests that widespread misconceptions originate from an inability to discriminate between related concepts and a tendency to overgeneralize.

American Journal of Physics•Aug 1, 2001•239 citations
Abstract Time evolution of quantum systems has been shown to be one of the most difficult components of a typical undergraduate quantum mechanics course. In this work, we examine the current literature, and then take a closer look at the process that students use to determine how the quantum state of a spin-1/2 particle evolves with time. We divide the process of writing a time-dependent state into five elements and use these to both directly probe student understanding and guide our coding of student responses. We focus on three elements of this process, including knowledge of the Hamiltonian, the energy eigenstates and eigenvalues, and what basis should be used when writing the state as a function of time using the phase e − i E n t / ℏ . Analysis of four exam questions given at three institutions suggests that knowledge of the energy eigenbasis and its importance for time evolution may be a weak point in student understanding.
Conceptual change from a classical to a quantum perspective is a challenging task for students. Basic concepts such as state and time evolution, already posing problematic issues in classical physics, require a different interpretation because of the redefinition of the concept of state, inextricably linked to fundamental features of new system behavior such as incompatibility between observables. Within an empirical research aimed at investigating connections between conceptual aspects and formalism emerging from student reasoning, we designed questionnaire items to explore how student describe time evolution of states, how they identify stationary states and how they use related concepts of eigenstate of an observable and incompatibility between observables in this process. Data gathering instruments were developed through a case study to collect student points of view on the relevant issue. For each aspect, at least two items were designed in order to cross-examine from different perspectives. Data analysis was organized following qualitative research methodology. The questionnaire was administered to a small group of students together with follow-up interviews. The study shows that most students link energy eigenstates to stationary states, but inverse implication doesn’t emerge with the same strength. The relation between energy eigenstates and those of different observables is clearly stated only when a commutator expression is identified by students. Energy eigenstates and their linear combinations are related to time invariance and time evolution in quantum mechanics in familiar-abstract context of infinite well, while uncertainties emerge in the crucial situation of scattering. Students answer as expected to questions concerning familiar tasks and contexts, but this doesn’t correspond to conceptual understanding of crucial elements under investigation. There is a need to build competence on critical reasoning.
This paper is part of the Focused Collection on Upper Division Physics Courses.]Energy measurements play a fundamental role in the theory of quantum mechanics, yet there is evidence that the underlying concepts are difficult for many students, even after all undergraduate instruction.We present results from an investigation into student ability to determine the possible energies that can be measured for a given wave function and Hamiltonian, to determine the probabilities of each energy measurement and how they depend on time, and to recognize how a measurement of energy affects the state.By analyzing student responses to open-ended questions, we identify five broad, interrelated sets of conceptual and reasoning difficulties related to energy measurements.Data are drawn from sophomore-, junior-, and graduate-level quantum mechanics courses.Particular attention is paid to incorrect ideas that persist across all levels.
Quantum mechanics is challenging even for advanced undergraduate and graduate students.In the Schrödinger representation, the wave function evolves in time according to the time dependent Schrödinger equation.The time dependence of the wave function gives rise to time dependence of the expectation value of observables.We have been exploring the difficulties that advanced undergraduate and graduate students have with time dependence of expectation values in quantum mechanics.We have developed and administered conceptual free response and multiplechoice questions to students to investigate these difficulties.We also interviewed 23 students individually using a thinkaloud protocol to obtain a better understanding of the rationale behind students' written responses.We find that many students struggle with time dependence of expectation values of observables.We discuss some findings.
A common task when problem solving in quantum mechanics, including in a spins-first curriculum, involves changing the basis of a given state.Our research in undergraduate quantum mechanics courses at three institutions explores student thinking about basis, basis expansion coefficients, and change of basis in the context of spin-½ systems.Our investigation is based on conceptual and computational written questions as well as student reasoning interviews.We identify student ideas about whether and how changing basis affects the state, examine how students perceive notation as indicative of choice of basis, explore students' interpretations of the structure and meaning of a basis expansion, and identify the range of methods students employ when changing basis.For instance, we find a recurring idea that changing basis alters the physical system, and observe that some students chose to relabel the ket representing a quantum state vector after changing basis.Together, these results paint a broad, qualitative picture of a variety of ways that students grapple with basis and change of basis, with potential implications for instruction.
Abstract In the last decades, empirical investigations have shown the existence of deep and persistent difficulties with teaching/learning the time independent Schrödinger equation and time evolution. At the same time, research has provided evidence in favor of engaging students in modeling activities to help them improve their understanding. However, there is a lack of model-based curriculum materials for teaching the concepts of energy and dynamics in quantum mechanics. To illustrate how modeling could be included in the learning of these topics, we outline an educational proposal in the context of a spins-first approach. As a starting point to introduce the energy concept for atoms and particles, the learning path leverages student knowledge of the Bohr model. The energy level structure of a hydrogen atom with transitions accompanied by the absorption or emission of a photon provides an intuitive basis for activating the modeling of energy, that is organized around the analysis of contrasting cases on the possible results of spin flip transitions in a magnetic field. In this process, students are guided to build a mathematical representation of energy and to investigate its nature up to a derivation of the energy eigenvalue equation. The learning path allows students to compare and contrast the semi-classical Bohr model with the quantum model, as a support to help them build a consistent understanding of the latter. A different set of contrasting cases on the possible results of spin measurements after different amounts of time in the field is used to activate a qualitative modeling process on time evolution, which is then quantitatively examined by analyzing graphs of the state tomography, guiding students to explore the basic features of quantum dynamics up to a derivation of the Schrödinger equation.
We investigate the difficulties of advanced undergraduate students toward the end of a full year upper-level quantum mechanics course with concepts related to quantum measurements and time development. Our analysis is based upon a test administered to 89 students from six universities and interviews with 9 students. Strikingly, most students shared the same difficulties despite variations in background, teaching styles, and textbooks. Concepts related to stationary states, eigenstates, and time dependence of expectation values were found to be particularly difficult. An analysis of written tests and interviews suggests that widespread misconceptions originate from an inability to discriminate between related concepts and a tendency to overgeneralize.