Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Quantum Chaos, Operator Growth, and Holography

Alexandre Streicher

Published Jan 1, 2019• 0 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

The exact role of the internal degrees of freedom (a.k.a. d.o.f.) in holography is not well-understood. Thus, in this thesis, we study a toy model of holography without space: the Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev (SYK) Model. This 0+1 theory of all possible 4-body interactions of N fermion "flavors"/"colors" features a low energy limit reproducing aspects of 1+1 Jackiw-Teitelboim gravity. First, we show that the inherent discreteness of the quantum spectrum results in universal late-time behavior due to eigenvalue repulsion. We then note that the theory's four-point functions probe the phenomenon of operator growth, where an internal d.o.f. goes on to epidemically evolve into larger products of internal d.o.f.s. In this manner where small operators smoothly grow into superpositions of increasing products of operators, we observe a sort of "size" locality, which is intimately tied with the notion of a conformal primary "descending" along its descendants. In fact, we find that the underlying structure of the SYK epidemic limits to that of a probe particle falling into a $AdS_2$ black hole. In other words, similar to how nearest neighbor interactions lead to dynamics on a flat space background, we demonstrate that many internal interactions lead to dynamics on a higher dimensional geometry.

Related papers

Complexity growth of operators in the SYK model and in JT gravity

Shao-Kai Jian, Brian G. Swingle, Zhuo-Yu Xian

Abstract The concepts of operator size and computational complexity play important roles in the study of quantum chaos and holographic duality because they help characterize the structure of time-evolving Heisenberg operators. It is particularly important to understand how these microscopically defined measures of complexity are related to notions of complexity defined in terms of a dual holographic geometry, such as complexity-volume (CV) duality. Here we study partially entangled thermal states in the Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev (SYK) model and their dual description in terms of operators inserted in the interior of a black hole in Jackiw-Teitelboim (JT) gravity. We compare a microscopic definition of complexity in the SYK model known as K-complexity to calculations using CV duality in JT gravity and find that both quantities show an exponential-to-linear growth behavior. We also calculate the growth of operator size under time evolution and find connections between size and complexity. While the notion of operator size saturates at the scrambling time, our study suggests that complexity, which is well defined in both quantum systems and gravity theories, can serve as a useful measure of operator evolution at both early and late times.

arXiv:2008.12274•Journal of High Energy Physics•Mar 1, 2021•116 citations

Quantum chaos and holographic tensor models

Chethan Krishnan, Sambuddha Sanyal, P. N. Bala Subramanian

A class of tensor models were recently outlined as potentially calculable examples of holography: their perturbative large-N behavior is similar to the Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev (SYK) model, but they are fully quantum mechanical (in the sense that there is no quenched disorder averaging). These facts make them intriguing tentative models for quantum black holes. In this note, we explicitly diagonalize the simplest non-trivial Gurau-Witten tensor model and study its spectral and late-time properties. We find parallels to (a single sample of) SYK where some of these features were recently attributed to random matrix behavior and quantum chaos. In particular, the spectral form factor exhibits a dip-ramp-plateau structure after a running time average, in qualitative agreement with SYK. But we also observe that even though the spectrum has a unique ground state, it has a huge (quasi-?)degeneracy of intermediate energy states, not seen in SYK. If one ignores the delta function due to the degeneracies however, there is level repulsion in the unfolded spacing distribution hinting chaos. Furthermore, there are gaps in the spectrum. The system also has a spectral mirror symmetry which we trace back to the presence of a unitary operator with which the Hamiltonian anticommutes. We use it to argue that to the extent that the model exhibits random matrix behavior, it is controlled not by the Dyson ensembles, but by the BDI (chiral orthogonal) class in the Altland-Zirnbauer classification.

arXiv:1612.06330•Journal of High Energy Physics•Mar 1, 2017•133 citations

Large N Fields and Holography

Animik Ghosh

We study (nearly) AdS/CFT holography within the context of the Sachdev-Ye- Kitaev (SYK) model. We present a systematic procedure to extract the dynamics of the low energy Schwarzian mode in SYK type models with a single energy scale J and emergent reparametrization symmetry in the infrared within the framework of perturbation theory. We develop a systematic approach using Feynman diagrams in bilocal theory to obtain a formal expression for the enhanced and O(1) corrections to the bilocal propagator and apply this general technique to large q SYK. We show that the Schwarzian theory describes a sector of a general class of two dimensional CFTs using conformal bootstrap techniques. We also provide a gravitational interpretation of this fact by showing that the dynamics in the near horizon throat of a specific class of BTZ black holes is described very well by Jackiw-Teitelboim (JT) gravity which gives rise to the Schwarzian action. We study the highly nontrivial conformal matter spectrum of the SYK model at arbitrary q. We provide a three dimensional bulk interpretation and carry out Kaluza-Klein (KK) reduction to reproduce the SYK spectrum and more significantly, the conformal bilocal propagator. We provide an interpretation of the two dimensional dual spacetime of the conformal sector of the SYK model using techniques from bilocal holography. We present a resolution of a conundrum about the signature of the dual spacetime using nonlocal integral transformations.

•Aug 4, 2020•0 citations

Quantum chaos and holographic tensor models

Chethan Krishnan, Sambuddha Sanyal, Subramanian, Bala P N

A class of tensor models were recently outlined as potentially calculable examples of holography: their perturbative large-N behavior is similar to the Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev (SYK) model, but they are fully quantum mechanical (in the sense that there is no quenched disorder averaging). These facts make them intriguing tentative models for quantum black holes. In this note, we explicitly diagonalize the simplest non-trivial Gurau-Witten tensor model and study its spectral and late-time properties. We find parallels to (a single sample of) SYK where some of these features were recently attributed to random matrix behavior and quantum chaos. In particular, the spectral form factor exhibits a dip-ramp plateau structure after a running time average, in qualitative agreement with SYK. But we also observe that even though the spectrum has a unique ground state, it has a huge (quasi-?)degeneracy of intermediate energy states, not seen in SYK. If one ignores the delta function due to the degeneracies however, there is level repulsion in the unfolded spacing distribution hinting chaos. Furthermore, there are gaps in the spectrum. The system also has a spectral mirror symmetry which we trace back to the presence of a unitary operator with which the Hamiltonian anticommutes. We use it to argue that to the extent that the model exhibits random matrix behavior, it is controlled not by the Dyson ensembles, but by the BDI (chiral orthogonal) class in the Altland-Zirnbauer classification.

•Jan 1, 2017•94 citations

Quantum chaos in the sparse SYK model

Patrick Orman, Hrant Gharibyan, John P. Preskill

A bstract The Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev (SYK) model is a system of N Majorana fermions with random interactions and strongly chaotic dynamics, which at low energy admits a holographically dual description as two-dimensional Jackiw-Teitelboim gravity. Hence the SYK model provides a toy model of quantum gravity that might be feasible to simulate with near-term quantum hardware. Motivated by the goal of reducing the resources needed for such a simulation, we study a sparsified version of the SYK model, in which interaction terms are deleted with probability 1 −p . Specifically, we compute numerically the spectral form factor (SFF, the Fourier transform of the Hamiltonian’s eigenvalue pair correlation function) and the nearest-neighbor eigenvalue gap ratio r (characterizing the distribution of gaps between consecutive eigenvalues). We find that when p is greater than a transition value p 1 , which scales as 1/ N 3 , both the SFF and r match the values attained by the full unsparsified model and with expectations from random matrix theory (RMT). But for p < p 1 , deviations from unsparsified SYK and RMT occur, indicating a breakdown of holography in the highly sparsified regime. Below an even smaller value p 2 , which also scales as 1/ N 3 , even the spacing of consecutive eigenvalues differs from RMT values, signaling a complete breakdown of spectral rigidity. Our results cast doubt on the holographic interpretation of very highly sparsified SYK models obtained via machine learning using teleportation infidelity as a loss function.

arXiv:2403.13884•Journal of High Energy Physics•Feb 26, 2025•21 citations

Conformality of 1/N corrections in Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev-like models

Stéphane Dartois, Harold Erbin, Swapnamay Mondal

The Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev (SYK) model is a quantum-mechanical model of $N$ Majorana fermions which displays a number of appealing features---solvability in the strong coupling regime, near-conformal invariance and maximal chaos---which make it a suitable model for black holes in the context of the $\mathrm{AdS}/\mathrm{CFT}$ holography. In this paper, we show for the colored SYK model and several of its tensor model cousins that the next-to-leading order in the large-$N$ expansion preserves the conformal invariance of the two-point function in the strong-coupling regime, up to the contribution of the pseudo-Goldstone bosons due to the explicit breaking of the symmetry which are already seen in the leading-order four-point function. We also comment on the composite field approach for computing correlation functions in colored tensor models.

arXiv:1706.00412•Physical review. D/Physical review. D.•Dec 6, 2019•23 citations
The exact role of the internal degrees of freedom (a.k.a. d.o.f.) in holography is not well-understood. Thus, in this thesis, we study a toy model of holography without space: the Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev (SYK) Model. This 0+1 theory of all possible 4-body interactions of N fermion "flavors"/"colors" features a low energy limit reproducing aspects of 1+1 Jackiw-Teitelboim gravity. First, we show that the inherent discreteness of the quantum spectrum results in universal late-time behavior due to eigenvalue repulsion. We then note that the theory's four-point functions probe the phenomenon of operator growth, where an internal d.o.f. goes on to epidemically evolve into larger products of internal d.o.f.s. In this manner where small operators smoothly grow into superpositions of increasing products of operators, we observe a sort of "size" locality, which is intimately tied with the notion of a conformal primary "descending" along its descendants. In fact, we find that the underlying structure of the SYK epidemic limits to that of a probe particle falling into a AdS2AdS_2AdS2​ black hole. In other words, similar to how nearest neighbor interactions lead to dynamics on a flat space background, we demonstrate that many internal interactions lead to dynamics on a higher dimensional geometry.
Abstract The concepts of operator size and computational complexity play important roles in the study of quantum chaos and holographic duality because they help characterize the structure of time-evolving Heisenberg operators. It is particularly important to understand how these microscopically defined measures of complexity are related to notions of complexity defined in terms of a dual holographic geometry, such as complexity-volume (CV) duality. Here we study partially entangled thermal states in the Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev (SYK) model and their dual description in terms of operators inserted in the interior of a black hole in Jackiw-Teitelboim (JT) gravity. We compare a microscopic definition of complexity in the SYK model known as K-complexity to calculations using CV duality in JT gravity and find that both quantities show an exponential-to-linear growth behavior. We also calculate the growth of operator size under time evolution and find connections between size and complexity. While the notion of operator size saturates at the scrambling time, our study suggests that complexity, which is well defined in both quantum systems and gravity theories, can serve as a useful measure of operator evolution at both early and late times.
A class of tensor models were recently outlined as potentially calculable examples of holography: their perturbative large-N behavior is similar to the Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev (SYK) model, but they are fully quantum mechanical (in the sense that there is no quenched disorder averaging). These facts make them intriguing tentative models for quantum black holes. In this note, we explicitly diagonalize the simplest non-trivial Gurau-Witten tensor model and study its spectral and late-time properties. We find parallels to (a single sample of) SYK where some of these features were recently attributed to random matrix behavior and quantum chaos. In particular, the spectral form factor exhibits a dip-ramp-plateau structure after a running time average, in qualitative agreement with SYK. But we also observe that even though the spectrum has a unique ground state, it has a huge (quasi-?)degeneracy of intermediate energy states, not seen in SYK. If one ignores the delta function due to the degeneracies however, there is level repulsion in the unfolded spacing distribution hinting chaos. Furthermore, there are gaps in the spectrum. The system also has a spectral mirror symmetry which we trace back to the presence of a unitary operator with which the Hamiltonian anticommutes. We use it to argue that to the extent that the model exhibits random matrix behavior, it is controlled not by the Dyson ensembles, but by the BDI (chiral orthogonal) class in the Altland-Zirnbauer classification.
We study (nearly) AdS/CFT holography within the context of the Sachdev-Ye- Kitaev (SYK) model. We present a systematic procedure to extract the dynamics of the low energy Schwarzian mode in SYK type models with a single energy scale J and emergent reparametrization symmetry in the infrared within the framework of perturbation theory. We develop a systematic approach using Feynman diagrams in bilocal theory to obtain a formal expression for the enhanced and O(1) corrections to the bilocal propagator and apply this general technique to large q SYK. We show that the Schwarzian theory describes a sector of a general class of two dimensional CFTs using conformal bootstrap techniques. We also provide a gravitational interpretation of this fact by showing that the dynamics in the near horizon throat of a specific class of BTZ black holes is described very well by Jackiw-Teitelboim (JT) gravity which gives rise to the Schwarzian action. We study the highly nontrivial conformal matter spectrum of the SYK model at arbitrary q. We provide a three dimensional bulk interpretation and carry out Kaluza-Klein (KK) reduction to reproduce the SYK spectrum and more significantly, the conformal bilocal propagator. We provide an interpretation of the two dimensional dual spacetime of the conformal sector of the SYK model using techniques from bilocal holography. We present a resolution of a conundrum about the signature of the dual spacetime using nonlocal integral transformations.
A class of tensor models were recently outlined as potentially calculable examples of holography: their perturbative large-N behavior is similar to the Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev (SYK) model, but they are fully quantum mechanical (in the sense that there is no quenched disorder averaging). These facts make them intriguing tentative models for quantum black holes. In this note, we explicitly diagonalize the simplest non-trivial Gurau-Witten tensor model and study its spectral and late-time properties. We find parallels to (a single sample of) SYK where some of these features were recently attributed to random matrix behavior and quantum chaos. In particular, the spectral form factor exhibits a dip-ramp plateau structure after a running time average, in qualitative agreement with SYK. But we also observe that even though the spectrum has a unique ground state, it has a huge (quasi-?)degeneracy of intermediate energy states, not seen in SYK. If one ignores the delta function due to the degeneracies however, there is level repulsion in the unfolded spacing distribution hinting chaos. Furthermore, there are gaps in the spectrum. The system also has a spectral mirror symmetry which we trace back to the presence of a unitary operator with which the Hamiltonian anticommutes. We use it to argue that to the extent that the model exhibits random matrix behavior, it is controlled not by the Dyson ensembles, but by the BDI (chiral orthogonal) class in the Altland-Zirnbauer classification.
A bstract The Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev (SYK) model is a system of N Majorana fermions with random interactions and strongly chaotic dynamics, which at low energy admits a holographically dual description as two-dimensional Jackiw-Teitelboim gravity. Hence the SYK model provides a toy model of quantum gravity that might be feasible to simulate with near-term quantum hardware. Motivated by the goal of reducing the resources needed for such a simulation, we study a sparsified version of the SYK model, in which interaction terms are deleted with probability 1 −p . Specifically, we compute numerically the spectral form factor (SFF, the Fourier transform of the Hamiltonian’s eigenvalue pair correlation function) and the nearest-neighbor eigenvalue gap ratio r (characterizing the distribution of gaps between consecutive eigenvalues). We find that when p is greater than a transition value p 1 , which scales as 1/ N 3 , both the SFF and r match the values attained by the full unsparsified model and with expectations from random matrix theory (RMT). But for p < p 1 , deviations from unsparsified SYK and RMT occur, indicating a breakdown of holography in the highly sparsified regime. Below an even smaller value p 2 , which also scales as 1/ N 3 , even the spacing of consecutive eigenvalues differs from RMT values, signaling a complete breakdown of spectral rigidity. Our results cast doubt on the holographic interpretation of very highly sparsified SYK models obtained via machine learning using teleportation infidelity as a loss function.
The Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev (SYK) model is a quantum-mechanical model of NNN Majorana fermions which displays a number of appealing features---solvability in the strong coupling regime, near-conformal invariance and maximal chaos---which make it a suitable model for black holes in the context of the AdS/CFT\mathrm{AdS}/\mathrm{CFT}AdS/CFT holography. In this paper, we show for the colored SYK model and several of its tensor model cousins that the next-to-leading order in the large-NNN expansion preserves the conformal invariance of the two-point function in the strong-coupling regime, up to the contribution of the pseudo-Goldstone bosons due to the explicit breaking of the symmetry which are already seen in the leading-order four-point function. We also comment on the composite field approach for computing correlation functions in colored tensor models.