Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physics Essays

Time for another paradox

S. Baune

Published Nov 21, 2009• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

We consider the detection of a superluminal signal. We show that there exists a particular inertial frame in which the superluminal signal is not uniquely localizable and that it is detected everywhere at the same instant within the inertial frame. This leads to a novel paradox to which we attribute the relativity of simultaneity.
DOI
10.4006/1.3227030

Related papers

Would Superluminal Influences Violate the Principle of Relativity?

Kent A. Peacock

It continues to be alleged that superluminal influences of any sort would be inconsistent with special relativity for the following three reasons: (i) they would imply the existence of a ‘distinguished’ frame; (ii) they would allow the detection of absolute motion; and (iii) they would violate the relativity of simultaneity. This paper shows that the first two objections rest upon very elementary misunderstandings of Minkowski geometry and on lingering Newtonian intuitions about instantaneity. The third objection has a basis, but rather than invalidating the notion of faster-than-light influences it points the way to more general conceptions of simultaneity that could allow for quantum nonlocality in a natural way.

arXiv:1301.0307•Lato Sensu Revue de la Société de philosophie des sciences•Jul 1, 2014•7 citations

Relativistic Non-Localization: An Ignored Reality

Gajendra Singh Solanki

Relativistic non-localization enables a moving particle such as a photon to exist at different positions in different frames at an instant and gives rise to an experimentally distinguished physics of relativity. A photon exists in a relativistic non-localized superstate until it is encountered by a detector which results in the collapse of the superstate so as to preserve the lightspeed across frames because the motion state of the detector affects the position of detection. But the current relativity inadvertently assumes the photons to be relativistically localized and invents the relativity of simultaneity. The relativistic non-localization, which is the nonlocality across frames, remained hidden so far under the mathematical elegance of Lorentz transform but is readily revealed by the real domain transform.

•Feb 1, 2021•2 citations

Superluminal quantum reference frames

Amrapali Sen, Matthias Salzger, Łukasz Rudnicki

Abstract Particles cannot travel faster than the speed of light, nor can information. Nonetheless, this assumption has been frequently questioned over the years. This includes radical proposals like tachyons that can be observed in particle accelerators to more subtle ideas like studying superluminal causation to find classical explanations for quantum correlations. Most recently, it has been argued (Dragan and Ekert 2020 New J. Phys. 22 033038) that in a world with superluminal observers local determinism is impossible, linking the two pillars of physics-quantum theory and relativity-suggesting that the latter serves as the foundation for the former. Motivated by this approach, in this work, we extend the framework of quantum reference frames to incorporate superluminal Lorentz transformations. We apply this conceptual result to examine an apparent paradox where particles acquire negative energies after undergoing a superluminal Lorentz boost and propose a resolution within our framework. A consequence of this resolution is that different observers no longer agree whether a particle is incoming or outgoing or in a superposition of the two. We further find a similar apparent paradox for the entropy and/or temperature under superluminal Lorentz boosts and resolve it in an analogous fashion. Finally, we discuss Bell experiments under superluminal quantum reference frame transformations, showing that the involved probabilities still remain conserved. By applying the toolbox of quantum reference frames, we start charting an unexplored territory of superpositions between sub-and-superluminal quantum observers which gives rise to new conceptual questions.

arXiv:2506.11787•New Journal of Physics•Apr 1, 2026•2 citations

The impossibility of one-way superluminal signaling in the framework of modern Physics

Moses Fayngold

This is a response to the note criticizing my paper A New Paradox in Superluminal Signaling. The criticism is based, among other things, on arbitrarily postulated statement about invarience of direction of superluminal information transfer. The analysis presented in my response shows the absence of any grounds for such statement and confirms my original proof of the impossibility of one-way superluminal signaling. The analysis also unveils many other inconsistencies in the discussed note and shows that all its criticism is unsubstantiated. Key words: superluminal signaling, tachyons, the information flow

arXiv:2203.12394•Feb 26, 2022•1 citation

Exploring Ultra Lightspeed Communication using Relativistic Non Localization

Gajendra Singh Solanki

This paper, the tenth in the series of ‘Rudiments of relativity revisited’, explores superluminal communication based on relativistic non-localization of new relativity. The new relativity preserves the lightspeed like the current one but also digs deeper into the mechanism behind this constancy. The relativistic non-localization as a superstate is one of the explanations: a photon exists in a superstate of relativistic non-localization, which collapses on detection such that the lightspeed is preserved in the frame of detection. Is it possible to trick this mechanism for the light to supersede its own speed using one or more cross-frame interruptions meant to collapse its superstate in one frame and relaying another burst of light to be detected in another? The two subsequently relayed light-bursts individually preserve lightspeed in their respective frames of detection, but the net result of the two cross-frame flights can be fast or slow travel in a vacuum. Various caveats, assumptions, and experiments to explore supra or infra luminal communication under new relativity are discussed.

•Jan 1, 2021•0 citations

Another Comment on ``Quantum Entanglement and Nonexistence of Superluminal Signals''

Vladimir S. Mashkevich

We argue that the claim given in quant-ph/9801014 remains untenable in the revised version. The fallacy in the proof is a misinterpretation of the no-cloning and teleportation theorems, which do not involve time and reference frames.

arXiv:quant-ph/9803027•Mar 12, 1998•0 citations
It continues to be alleged that superluminal influences of any sort would be inconsistent with special relativity for the following three reasons: (i) they would imply the existence of a ‘distinguished’ frame; (ii) they would allow the detection of absolute motion; and (iii) they would violate the relativity of simultaneity. This paper shows that the first two objections rest upon very elementary misunderstandings of Minkowski geometry and on lingering Newtonian intuitions about instantaneity. The third objection has a basis, but rather than invalidating the notion of faster-than-light influences it points the way to more general conceptions of simultaneity that could allow for quantum nonlocality in a natural way.
Relativistic non-localization enables a moving particle such as a photon to exist at different positions in different frames at an instant and gives rise to an experimentally distinguished physics of relativity. A photon exists in a relativistic non-localized superstate until it is encountered by a detector which results in the collapse of the superstate so as to preserve the lightspeed across frames because the motion state of the detector affects the position of detection. But the current relativity inadvertently assumes the photons to be relativistically localized and invents the relativity of simultaneity. The relativistic non-localization, which is the nonlocality across frames, remained hidden so far under the mathematical elegance of Lorentz transform but is readily revealed by the real domain transform.
Abstract Particles cannot travel faster than the speed of light, nor can information. Nonetheless, this assumption has been frequently questioned over the years. This includes radical proposals like tachyons that can be observed in particle accelerators to more subtle ideas like studying superluminal causation to find classical explanations for quantum correlations. Most recently, it has been argued (Dragan and Ekert 2020 New J. Phys. 22 033038) that in a world with superluminal observers local determinism is impossible, linking the two pillars of physics-quantum theory and relativity-suggesting that the latter serves as the foundation for the former. Motivated by this approach, in this work, we extend the framework of quantum reference frames to incorporate superluminal Lorentz transformations. We apply this conceptual result to examine an apparent paradox where particles acquire negative energies after undergoing a superluminal Lorentz boost and propose a resolution within our framework. A consequence of this resolution is that different observers no longer agree whether a particle is incoming or outgoing or in a superposition of the two. We further find a similar apparent paradox for the entropy and/or temperature under superluminal Lorentz boosts and resolve it in an analogous fashion. Finally, we discuss Bell experiments under superluminal quantum reference frame transformations, showing that the involved probabilities still remain conserved. By applying the toolbox of quantum reference frames, we start charting an unexplored territory of superpositions between sub-and-superluminal quantum observers which gives rise to new conceptual questions.
This is a response to the note criticizing my paper A New Paradox in Superluminal Signaling. The criticism is based, among other things, on arbitrarily postulated statement about invarience of direction of superluminal information transfer. The analysis presented in my response shows the absence of any grounds for such statement and confirms my original proof of the impossibility of one-way superluminal signaling. The analysis also unveils many other inconsistencies in the discussed note and shows that all its criticism is unsubstantiated. Key words: superluminal signaling, tachyons, the information flow
This paper, the tenth in the series of ‘Rudiments of relativity revisited’, explores superluminal communication based on relativistic non-localization of new relativity. The new relativity preserves the lightspeed like the current one but also digs deeper into the mechanism behind this constancy. The relativistic non-localization as a superstate is one of the explanations: a photon exists in a superstate of relativistic non-localization, which collapses on detection such that the lightspeed is preserved in the frame of detection. Is it possible to trick this mechanism for the light to supersede its own speed using one or more cross-frame interruptions meant to collapse its superstate in one frame and relaying another burst of light to be detected in another? The two subsequently relayed light-bursts individually preserve lightspeed in their respective frames of detection, but the net result of the two cross-frame flights can be fast or slow travel in a vacuum. Various caveats, assumptions, and experiments to explore supra or infra luminal communication under new relativity are discussed.