On the Security of the Free-XOR Technique.

Seung Geol Choi, Jonathan I. Katz, Ranjit Kumaresan, Hong-Sheng Zhou

Published Jan 1, 2011• 1 citation

Abstract

Yao’s garbled-circuit approach enables constant-round secure two-party computation for any boolean circuit. In Yao’s original construction, each gate in the circuit requires the parties to perform a constant number of encryptions/decryptions, and to send/receive a constant number of ciphertexts. Kolesnikov and Schneider (ICALP 2008) proposed an improvement that allows XOR gates in the circuit to be evaluated “for free”, i.e., incurring no cryptographic operations and zero communication. Their “free-XOR ” technique has proven very popular, and has been shown to improve performance of garbled-circuit protocols by up to a factor of 4. Kolesnikov and Schneider proved security of their approach in the random oracle model, and claimed that (an unspecified variant of) correlation robustness would suffice; this claim has been repeated in subsequent work, and similar ideas have since been used (with the same claim about correlation robustness) in other contexts. We show that, in fact, the free-XOR technique cannot be proven secure based on correlation robustness alone: somewhat surprisingly, some form of circular security is also required. We propose an appropriate notion of security for hash functions capturing the necessary requirements, and prove security of the free-XOR approach when instantiated with any hash function satisfying our definition. Our results do not impact the security of the free-XOR technique in practice, or imply an error in the free-XOR work, but instead pin down the assumptions needed to prove security.

Related papers

Fast Garbling of Circuits Under Standard Assumptions.

Shay Gueron, Yehuda Lindell, Ariel Nof +1 more

Protocols for secure computation enable mutually distrustful parties to jointly compute on their private inputs without revealing anything but the result. Over recent years, secure com-putation has become practical and considerable effort has been made to make it more and more efficient. A highly important tool in the design of two-party protocols is Yao’s garbled circuit construction (Yao 1986), and multiple optimizations on this primitive have led to performance improvements of orders of magnitude over the last years. However, many of these improvements come at the price of making very strong assumptions on the underlying cryptographic primitives being used (e.g., that AES is secure for related keys, that it is circular secure, and even that it behaves like a random permutation when keyed with a public fixed key). The justification behind making these strong assumptions has been that otherwise it is not possible to achieve fast garbling and thus fast secure computation. In this paper, we take a step back and examine whether it is really the case that such strong assumptions are needed. We provide new methods for garbling that are secure solely under the assumption that the primitive used (e.g., AES) is a pseudorandom function. Our results show that in many cases, the penalty incurred is not significant, and so a more conservative approach to the assumptions being used can be adopted.

Jan 1, 20150 citations

Fast Garbling of Circuits Under Standard Assumptions

Shay Gueron, Yehuda Lindell, Ariel Nof +1 more

Protocols for secure computation enable mutually distrustful parties to jointly compute on their private inputs without revealing anything but the result. Over recent years, secure computation has become practical and considerable effort has been made to make it more and more efficient. A highly important tool in the design of two-party protocols is Yao's garbled circuit construction (Yao 1986), and multiple optimizations on this primitive have led to performance improvements of orders of magnitude over the last years. However, many of these improvements come at the price of making very strong assumptions on the underlying cryptographic primitives being used (e.g., that AES is secure for related keys, that it is circular secure, and even that it behaves like a random permutation when keyed with a public fixed key). The justification behind making these strong assumptions has been that otherwise it is not possible to achieve fast garbling and thus fast secure computation. In this paper, we take a step back and examine whether it is really the case that such strong assumptions are needed. We provide new methods for garbling that are secure solely under the assumption that the primitive used (e.g., AES) is a pseudorandom function. Our results show that in many cases, the penalty incurred is not significant, and so a more conservative approach to the assumptions being used can be adopted.

ACM SIGSAC Conference on Computer and Communications Security (CCS)Oct 6, 201571 citations

The Use of Circuit Evaluation Techniques for Secure Computation

Oleg Selajev

Secure two-party computation problem is about two parties that want to compute some function of their private inputs in a way that other party won’t learn it. We describe a general way to perform secure two-party computation of a function specified as a boolean circuit, which was proposed by A.A. Yao in 1982. This method is named Yao garbled circuit evaluation and is secure against semi-honest adversaries. We present a new efficient protocol for secure two-party computation Circus, that is secure against malicious adversary in consistency model. Consistency model implies that either both parties will receive correct output and persist privacy of their inputs or a honest party will know, that is was cheated and that adversary potentially have learnt 1 bit of other party’s input value. We specify all necessary sub-protocols and their security requirements and prove security of Circus in malicious environment.

Jan 1, 20111 citation

A New Approach to Practical Active-Secure Two-Party Computation

Jesper Buus Nielsen, Peter Sebastian Nordholt, Claudio Orlandi +1 more

We propose a new approach to practical two-party computation secure against an active adversary. All prior practical protocols were based on Yao's garbled circuits. We use an OT-based approach and get efficiency via OT extension in the random oracle model. To get a practical protocol we introduce a number of novel techniques for relating the outputs and inputs of OTs in a larger construction. We also report on an implementation of this approach, that shows that our protocol is more efficient than any previous one: For big enough circuits, we can evaluate more than 20000 Boolean gates per second. As an example, evaluating one oblivious AES encryption (~34000 gates) takes 64 seconds, but when repeating the task 27 times it only takes less than 3 seconds per instance.

arXiv:1202.3052Feb 14, 201226 citations

Faster Secure Two-Party Computation Using Garbled Circuits

Yan Huang, David Evans, Jonathan I. Katz +1 more

Secure two-party computation enables two parties to evaluate a function cooperatively without revealing to either party anything beyond the function's output. The garbled-circuit technique, a generic approach to secure two-party computation for semi-honest participants, was developed by Yao in the 1980s, but has been viewed as being of limited practical significance due to its inefficiency. We demonstrate several techniques for improving the running time and memory requirements of the garbled-circuit technique, resulting in an implementation of generic secure two-party computation that is significantly faster than any previously reported while also scaling to arbitrarily large circuits. We validate our approach by demonstrating secure computation of circuits with over 109 gates at a rate of roughly 10 microseconds per garbled gate, and showing order-of-magnitude improvements over the best previous privacy-preserving protocols for computing Hamming distance, Levenshtein distance, Smith-Waterman genome alignment, and AES.

USENIX Security SymposiumJan 1, 2011566 citations

Zero-Knowledge Using Garbled Circuits: How To Prove Non-Algebraic Statements Efficiently.

Marek Jawurek, Florian Kerschbaum, Claudio Orlandi

Zero-knowledge protocols are one of the fundamental concepts in modern cryptography and have countless applications. However, after more than 30 years from their introduction, there are only very few languages (essentially those with a group structure) for which we can construct zero-knowledge protocols that are efficient enough to be used in practice. In this paper we address the problem of how to construct efficient zero-knowledge protocols for generic languages and we propose a protocol based on Yao’s garbled circuit technique. The motivation for our work is that in many cryptographic applications it is useful to be able to prove efficiently statements of the form e.g., “I know x s.t. y = SHA-256(x)” for a common input y (or other “unstructured” languages), but no efficient protocols for this task are currently known. It is clear that zero-knowledge is a subset of secure two-party computation (i.e., any protocol for generic secure computation can be used to do zero-knowledge). The main contribution of this paper is to construct an efficient protocol for the special case of secure two-party computation where only one party has input (like in the zero-knowledge case). The protocol achieves active security and is essentially only twice as slow as the passive secure version of Yao’s garbled circuit protocol. This is a great improvement with respect to the cut-n-choose technique to make Yao’s protocol actively secure, where the complexity grows linearly with the security parameter.

Jan 1, 201311 citations