Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Aspects of Unitarity in Black Holephysics

Arpit Das, Supervisor Prof. Narayan Banerjee

Published Apr 1, 2018• 0 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

We have investigated issues concerned with unitarity in some spherically symmetric (1+3) dimensional inhomogeneous models. To be specific, we focused on the dynamics of a spherical collapsing infinitesimally thin shell whose exterior in the neutral case is described by the Schwarzschild metric and in the charged case, by the Reissner-Nordstrom metric. We adopted the Wheeler-deWitt formalism for our study which gave rise to the Functional Schrodinger method. To address the unitarity issues, we computed the density matrix for the total outgoing radiation in all the cases we investigated. We further computed the probability density plus the probability current for the concerned wavefunctions and showed that they all satisfy the continuity equation which in the Schrodinger picture implies unitarity. The density matrix approach was previously done in some detail regarding the Schwarzschild case and these models were shown to obey unitary evolution. However, the authors therein had to resort to some numerical simulations for their end results and plots. On the contrary, probability conservation which we demonstrate in this work is purely analytic in nature. Furthermore, we improve upon the previous works of and show that there density matrix approach can also be done analytically. Additionally, checking unitarity by probability conservation is a novelty of our work.

Related papers

Nonlinear Generalisation of Quantum Mechanics

Alireza Jamali

According to our current understanding of quantum mechanics, a `measurement' violates unitarity. In other words as the act of measurement `resets' the probabilities described by the Schrödinger equation, in the very `moment' of the collapse of the wavefunction, conservation of probability does not hold. To make progress in our understanding of the measurement problem it is thus expected that one must encompass in a single equation both otherwise mutually-exclusive processes of measurement and unitary evolution. In this light, turning to the continuity equation, we realize the possibility that if we allow for existence of sources and sinks in the `fluid of probability' we get closer to such a theory by arriving at nonlinear generalizations of Schrödinger and Klein-Gordon equations. The generalized equations derived are then shown to satisfy all conditions that are expected from a proper generalization: simplification to their linear counterparts by a well-defined dynamical condition, and Galilean and Lorentz invariance.

•Jul 1, 2022•1 citation

NON-UNITARY AND UNITARY TRANSITIONS IN GENERALIZED QUANTUM MECHANICS, NEW SMALL PARAMETER AND INFORMATION PROBLEM SOLVING

Alexander Shalyt-Margolin

Quantum Mechanics of the Early Universe is considered as deformation of a well-known Quantum Mechanics. Similar to previous works of the author, the principal approach is based on deformation of the density matrix with concurrent development of the wave function deformation in the respective Schrödinger picture, the associated deformation parameter being interpreted as a new small parameter. It is demonstrated that the existence of black holes in the suggested approach in the end twice causes non-unitary transitions resulting in the unitarity. In parallel this problem is considered in other terms: entropy density, Heisenberg algebra deformation terms, respective deformations of Statistical Mechanics — all showing the identity of the basic results. From this an explicit solution for Hawking's information paradox has been derived.

arXiv:hep-th/0311239•Modern Physics Letters A•Feb 6, 2004•24 citations

Quantum Electron Clouds near Black Holes: Black Atoms and Molecules

Hinako Iseki, Shin Sasaki, Kenta Shiozawa

We study quantum mechanical wavefunctions near highly curved spaces, i.e., black holes. By utilizing the formalism developed by DeWitt, we derive the Schrödinger equations in the vicinity of the Schwarzschild and the Reissner-Nordström black hole geometries. The quantum electron cloud for the "black hydrogen atom" - an electron trapped by black holes - is particularly studied. We solve the equations and find that black holes generally attract the wavefunctions, localizing them near the horizon where the electrons are most likely to be trapped. These results imply that not only classical objects but also the quantum material and even the chemical properties of the atoms are affected by strong gravity. We also discuss black hydrogen molecules composed of multi-centered Majumdar-Papapetrou black holes.

gr-qcCross-listedarXiv:2511.11173•Nov 17, 2025

Spherically-symmetric solutions of the Schrödinger-Newton equations

Irene M. Moroz, Roger Penrose, Paul Tod

As part of a programme in which quantum state reduction is understood as a gravitational phenomenon, we consider the Schrödinger-Newton equations. For a single particle, this is a coupled system consisting of the Schrödinger equation for the particle moving in its own gravitational field, where this is generated by its own probability density via the Poisson equation. Restricting to the spherically-symmetric case, we find numerical evidence for a discrete family of solutions, everywhere regular, and with normalizable wavefunctions. The solutions are labelled by the non-negative integers, the n th solution having n zeros in the wavefunction. Furthermore, these are the only globally defined solutions. Analytical support is provided for some of the features found numerically.

Classical and Quantum Gravity•Sep 1, 1998•458 citations

Relativistic Schrödinger equation and probability currents for free particles

David Carfì

In this work, we start from the problem of quantizing the relativistic Hamiltonian of a free massive particle (rest mass different from 0), a problem exceptionally difficult in the standard approaches to quantum mechanics. In fact, in tempered distribution state space, we find the natural way to define the relativistic Hamiltonian operator and its associated Schrödinger equation The existence of a linear continuous Hermitian operator associated with the Einstein's Hamiltonian of a free particle, defined on the entire tempered distribution space, automatically implies the conservation of Born probability flux (which doesn't mean the conservation of particles number, rather it implies the conservation of the total relativistic energy of the solution wave). We, then, deduce the continuity equation for the Born probability density and study some its different (but equivalent) expressions. We determine some possible forms of probability currents and flux velocity fields associated with the particle evolution. We provide the relativistic invariant expression for both Schrödinger equation and probability flux continuity equations.

Proceedings of the International Geometry Center•Jan 13, 2024•3 citations

Quantum fields out of thermal equilibrium

O. J. P. Éboli, R. Jackiw, So-Young Pi

The isoentropic, but energy-nonconserving, time evolution of mixed quantum states is studied in quantum mechanics and quantum field theory. A variational principle, which gives the Liouville--von Neumann equation, is implemented approximately by making a Gaussian Ansatz for the density matrix. The dynamical equations governing the parameters that define the Ansatz satisfy equations variously analogous to the Schr\"odinger equation and to mechanical problems. Interesting nonequilibrium evolution is found in special cases, as, for example, when the analog Schr\"odinger equation gives rise to reflectionless transmission. For field theory in an external, time-dependent metric we obtain equations that were previously derived in the many-field (spherical-model) limit.

Physical review. D. Particles, fields, gravitation, and cosmology/Physical review. D. Particles and fields•Jun 15, 1988•140 citations
We have investigated issues concerned with unitarity in some spherically symmetric
(1+3) dimensional inhomogeneous models. To be specific, we focused on the
dynamics of a spherical collapsing infinitesimally thin shell whose exterior in the
neutral case is described by the Schwarzschild metric and in the charged case, by
the Reissner-Nordstrom metric. We adopted the Wheeler-deWitt formalism for our
study which gave rise to the Functional Schrodinger method. To address the unitarity
issues, we computed the density matrix for the total outgoing radiation
in all the cases we investigated. We further computed the probability density plus
the probability current for the concerned wavefunctions and showed that they all
satisfy the continuity equation which in the Schrodinger picture implies unitarity.
The density matrix approach was previously done in some detail regarding the
Schwarzschild case and these models were shown to obey unitary evolution. However,
the authors therein had to resort to some numerical simulations for their end
results and plots. On the contrary, probability conservation which we demonstrate
in this work is purely analytic in nature. Furthermore, we improve upon the previous
works of and show that there density matrix approach can also be done analytically.
Additionally, checking unitarity by probability conservation is a novelty of
our work.
According to our current understanding of quantum mechanics, a `measurement' violates unitarity. In other words as the act of measurement `resets' the probabilities described by the Schrödinger equation, in the very `moment' of the collapse of the wavefunction, conservation of probability does not hold. To make progress in our understanding of the measurement problem it is thus expected that one must encompass in a single equation both otherwise mutually-exclusive processes of measurement and unitary evolution. In this light, turning to the continuity equation, we realize the possibility that if we allow for existence of sources and sinks in the `fluid of probability' we get closer to such a theory by arriving at nonlinear generalizations of Schrödinger and Klein-Gordon equations. The generalized equations derived are then shown to satisfy all conditions that are expected from a proper generalization: simplification to their linear counterparts by a well-defined dynamical condition, and Galilean and Lorentz invariance.
Quantum Mechanics of the Early Universe is considered as deformation of a well-known Quantum Mechanics. Similar to previous works of the author, the principal approach is based on deformation of the density matrix with concurrent development of the wave function deformation in the respective Schrödinger picture, the associated deformation parameter being interpreted as a new small parameter. It is demonstrated that the existence of black holes in the suggested approach in the end twice causes non-unitary transitions resulting in the unitarity. In parallel this problem is considered in other terms: entropy density, Heisenberg algebra deformation terms, respective deformations of Statistical Mechanics — all showing the identity of the basic results. From this an explicit solution for Hawking's information paradox has been derived.
We study quantum mechanical wavefunctions near highly curved spaces, i.e., black holes. By utilizing the formalism developed by DeWitt, we derive the Schrödinger equations in the vicinity of the Schwarzschild and the Reissner-Nordström black hole geometries. The quantum electron cloud for the "black hydrogen atom" - an electron trapped by black holes - is particularly studied. We solve the equations and find that black holes generally attract the wavefunctions, localizing them near the horizon where the electrons are most likely to be trapped. These results imply that not only classical objects but also the quantum material and even the chemical properties of the atoms are affected by strong gravity. We also discuss black hydrogen molecules composed of multi-centered Majumdar-Papapetrou black holes.
As part of a programme in which quantum state reduction is understood as a gravitational phenomenon, we consider the Schrödinger-Newton equations. For a single particle, this is a coupled system consisting of the Schrödinger equation for the particle moving in its own gravitational field, where this is generated by its own probability density via the Poisson equation. Restricting to the spherically-symmetric case, we find numerical evidence for a discrete family of solutions, everywhere regular, and with normalizable wavefunctions. The solutions are labelled by the non-negative integers, the n th solution having n zeros in the wavefunction. Furthermore, these are the only globally defined solutions. Analytical support is provided for some of the features found numerically.
In this work, we start from the problem of quantizing the relativistic Hamiltonian of a free massive particle (rest mass different from 0), a problem exceptionally difficult in the standard approaches to quantum mechanics. In fact, in tempered distribution state space, we find the natural way to define the relativistic Hamiltonian operator and its associated Schrödinger equation The existence of a linear continuous Hermitian operator associated with the Einstein's Hamiltonian of a free particle, defined on the entire tempered distribution space, automatically implies the conservation of Born probability flux (which doesn't mean the conservation of particles number, rather it implies the conservation of the total relativistic energy of the solution wave). We, then, deduce the continuity equation for the Born probability density and study some its different (but equivalent) expressions. We determine some possible forms of probability currents and flux velocity fields associated with the particle evolution. We provide the relativistic invariant expression for both Schrödinger equation and probability flux continuity equations.
The isoentropic, but energy-nonconserving, time evolution of mixed quantum states is studied in quantum mechanics and quantum field theory. A variational principle, which gives the Liouville--von Neumann equation, is implemented approximately by making a Gaussian Ansatz for the density matrix. The dynamical equations governing the parameters that define the Ansatz satisfy equations variously analogous to the Schr\"odinger equation and to mechanical problems. Interesting nonequilibrium evolution is found in special cases, as, for example, when the analog Schr\"odinger equation gives rise to reflectionless transmission. For field theory in an external, time-dependent metric we obtain equations that were previously derived in the many-field (spherical-model) limit.