Concepts in quantum state tomography and classical implementation with intense light: a tutorial
Ermes Toninelli, Bienvenu I. Ndagano, Adam Vallés, Bereneice Sephton, Isaac M. Nape, Antonio Ambrosio, Federico Capasso, Miles J. Padgett, Andrew Forbes
A tomographic measurement is a ubiquitous tool for estimating the properties of quantum states, and its application is known as quantum state tomography (QST). The process involves manipulating single photons in a sequence of projective measurements, often to construct a density matrix from which other information can be inferred, and is as laborious as it is complex. Here we unravel the steps of a QST and outline how it may be demonstrated in a fast and simple manner with intense (classical) light. We use scalar beams in a time reversal approach to simulate the outcome of a QST and exploit non-separability in classical vector beams as a means to treat the latter as a “classically entangled” state for illustrating QSTs directly. We provide a complete do-it-yourself resource for the practical implementation of this approach, complete with tutorial video, which we hope will facilitate the introduction of this core quantum tool into teaching and research laboratories alike. Our work highlights the value of using intense classical light as a means to study quantum systems and in the process provides a tutorial on the fundamentals of QSTs.
A tomographic measurement is a ubiquitous tool for estimating the properties of quantum states, and its application is known as quantum state tomography (QST). The process involves manipulating single photons in a sequence of projective measurements, often to construct a density matrix from which other information can be inferred, and is as laborious as it is complex. Here we unravel the steps of a QST and outline how it may be demonstrated in a fast and simple manner with intense (classical) light. We use scalar beams in a time reversal approach to simulate the outcome of a QST and exploit non-separability in classical vector beams as a means to treat the latter as a “classically entangled” state for illustrating QSTs directly. We provide a complete do-it-yourself resource for the practical implementation of this approach, complete with tutorial video, which we hope will facilitate the introduction of this core quantum tool into teaching and research laboratories alike. Our work highlights the value of using intense classical light as a means to study quantum systems and in the process provides a tutorial on the fundamentals of QSTs.
Quantum state tomography (QST) allows one to probe an unknown quantum state and is a ubiquitous tool in many quantum laboratories. Unfortunately it is a time consuming and complex procedure, and thus consequently is seldom demonstrated in teaching laboratories. Here we outline a simple demonstration of the essential features of QST in a manner that allows for its implementation in undergraduate laboratories. We exploit the fact that non-separability, the quintessential feature of entangled quantum states, is in fact not unique to quantum mechanics. Using this, we construct a 3D printed version of an equivalent system for QST but with bright classical light, and demonstrate all the essential features of this tool. The source code to print the elements and run the QST are all available on-line from our website. We hope that this will inspire the introduction of “practical” quantum mechanics into the teaching curriculum.
Quantum state tomography (QST) is a fundamental technique for characterizing quantum states, crucial for validating quantum technologies. However, traditional QST methods often suffer from limitations in measurement efficiency and accuracy, particularly when dealing with complex quantum systems. This work presents an advanced approach to QST utilizing entangled photon sources and a meticulously designed measurement strategy. The core of this method lies in exploiting the correlations inherent in entangled photon pairs to significantly enhance the reconstruction process. We detail a novel scheme that minimizes measurement errors and maximizes the information extracted from each measurement, leading to a substantial improvement in both the accuracy and resolution of the reconstructed quantum state. The theoretical framework outlines the key equations and algorithms used for state reconstruction, focusing on a practical implementation. The results presented suggest a pathway towards more robust and reliable QST, paving the way for more accurate characterization of quantum systems and the development of advanced quantum applications.
Quantum state tomography (QST) estimates an unknown quantum state from a measurement process typically performed on identical copies of the target state and plays a core role in characterizing quantum information systems. However, because quantum measurement outcomes are probabilistic, QST methods often require many shots per basis to achieve high-fidelity estimates, which hinders scalability to many-qubit applications and slows the transmission of quantum information. A more efficient procedure is therefore required for modern-day quantum operations in quantum computing, communications, and sensing. We address this need with an adaptive QST approach that measures a single-qubit state in a wide set of bases. We include bases beyond the Pauli triad {X,Y,Z} by leveraging the infinite-dimensional Hilbert space of quantum mechanics, increasing the likelihood of producing highly polarized measurement outcomes and finding an optimally informative basis. With this basis, the state can be identified with fewer measurements by focusing on directions that most reduce uncertainty of the state. In addition to theoretical innovation in [9], we experimentally verify in a simplified photonic realization using 13 bases that having many more available measurement bases than the Pauli triad benefits QST. This engineering implementation demonstrates that adaptive QST is both efficient in performance and practical to implement.
Quantum state tomography (QST) has been the traditional method for characterization of an unknown state. Recently, many direct measurement methods have been implemented to reconstruct the state in a resource efficient way. In this Letter, we present an interferometric method, in which any qubit state, whether mixed or pure, can be inferred from the visibility, phase shift, and average intensity of an interference pattern using a single-shot measurement-hence, we call it quantum state interferography. This provides us with a "black box" approach to quantum state estimation, wherein, between the incidence of the photon and extraction of state information, we are not changing any conditions within the setup, thus giving us a true single shot estimation of the quantum state. In contrast, standard QST requires at least two measurements for pure state qubit and at least three measurements for mixed state qubit reconstruction. We then go on to show that QSI is more resource efficient than QST for quantification of entanglement in pure bipartite qubits. We experimentally implement our method with high fidelity using the polarization degree of freedom of light. An extension of the scheme to pure states involving d-1 interferograms for d-dimensional systems is also presented. Thus, the scaling gain is even more dramatic in the qudit scenario for our method, where, in contrast, standard QST, without any assumptions, scales roughly as d^{2}.
Quantum state tomography (QST) refers to any method that allows one to reconstruct the accurate representation of a quantum system based on data obtainable from an experiment. In this paper, we concentrate on theoretical methods of quantum tomography, but some significant experimental results are also presented. Due to a considerable body of literature and intensive ongoing research activity in the field of QST, this overview is restricted to presenting selected ideas, methods, and results. First, we discuss tomography of pure states by distinguishing two aspects—complex vector reconstruction and wavefunction measurement. Then, we move on to the Wigner function reconstruction. Finally, the core section of the article is devoted to the stroboscopic tomography, which provides the optimal criteria for state recovery by including the dynamics in the scheme. Throughout the paper, we pay particular attention to photonic tomography, since multiple protocols in quantum optics require well-defined states of light.
Quantum computers solve ever more complex tasks using steadily growing system sizes.Characterizing these quantum systems is vital, yet becoming increasingly challenging.The gold-standard method for this task is quantum state tomography (QST), capable of fully reconstructing a quantum state without prior knowledge.The measurement and classical computing costs, however, increase exponentially with the number of constituents (e.g., qubits)-a daunting bottleneck given the scale of existing and nearterm quantum devices.Here, we demonstrate a scalable and practical QST approach that only uses a single measurement setting, namely symmetric informationally complete (SIC) positive operator-valued measures (POVMs).We implement these nonorthogonal measurements on an ion trap quantum processor by utilizing additional energy levels within each ion-without requiring ancillary ions to assist in measurements.More precisely, we locally map the SIC POVM to orthogonal states embedded in a higher-dimensional system, which we read out using repeated in-sequence detections, thereby providing full tomographic information in every shot.Combining this SIC tomography with the recently developed randomized measurement toolbox ("classical shadows") proves to be a powerful combination.SIC tomography alleviates the need for choosing measurement settings at random ("derandomization"), while classical shadows enable the estimation of arbitrary polynomial functions of the density matrix orders of magnitudes faster than standard methods.The latter enables in-depth entanglement characterization, which we experimentally showcase on a five-qubit absolutely maximally entangled state.Moreover, the fact that the full tomography information is available in every shot enables online QST in real time (i.e., while the experiment is running).We demonstrate this on an eight-qubit entangled state (which has 2 8 • 2 8 -1 = 65 535 degrees of freedom), as well as for fast state identification.All in all, these features single out SIC-based classical shadow estimation as a highly scalable and convenient tool for quantum state characterization.