Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

The Angular-Momentum Dilemma

Jens Peder Dahl

Published Jan 1, 1999• 0 citations
OpenAlex

Related papers

ANGULAR MOMENTUM REVISITED

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Feb 19, 2019•0 citations

The Angular Momentum Dilemma and Born–Jordan Quantization

Maurice A. de Gosson

The rigorous equivalence of the Schrödinger and Heisenberg pictures requires that one uses Born-Jordan quantization in place of Weyl quantization. We confirm this by showing that the much discussed " angular momentum dilemma" disappears if one uses Born-Jordan quantization. We argue that the latter is the only physically correct quantization procedure. We also briefly discuss a possible redefinition of phase space quantum mechanics, where the usual Wigner distribution has to be replaced with a new quasi-distribution associated with Born-Jordan quantization, and which has proven to be successful in time-frequency analysis.

arXiv:1502.04998•Foundations of Physics•Oct 7, 2016•4 citations

Double standards when describing helium and positronium atoms

Igor Pavlovich Popov

The purpose of the work is to check the validity of generalizing the an-gular momentum ћ of a Cooper pair to any many-particle quantum system, including positronium. Methodology. For the purposes of this work, a semiclassical consideration is quite sufficient. To increase the reliability for helium, a quantum solution is additionally given. It is believed that the total minimum angular momentum of a two-particle quan-tum system – positronium is equal to ћ. When generalizing the angular momentum ћ of a Cooper pair and an electron-positron pair to a pair of helium electrons, its radius turns out to be almost four times less than the established value. And this means only one thing – the generalization of the angular momentum ћ of a Cooper pair to a pair of helium electrons is illegal. Therefore, each helium electron has a minimum angular mo-mentum equal to ћ. And the angular momentum of a pair of helium electrons is equal to the sum of the angular momentum of each electron. The double standards lie in the fact that, on the one hand, a quantum system – an electron-positron pair – is endowed with a quantum of angular momentum ћ, and on the other hand, a quantum system – a pair of helium electrons – is not endowed with this quantum (it is endowed with two quanta). And since double standards are unacceptable, an elementary dilemma arises – either the radius of helium should be quadrupled, or the radius of positronium should be quadrupled. The task is simplified by the fact that recently the value of the radius of positronium was completely unambiguously corrected, which turned out to be exactly four times larger than was commonly believed. Thus, the helium atom retains its size. It has been established that endowing a Cooper pair of electrons with a quantum of angular momentum ћ is just as illegitimate as in the case of positronium. The angular momentum of a many-particle quantum system, due to its additivity, must be divided between the particles of the system. It has been established that the quantum of angular momentum ћ can be attributed to only one quantum particle, and cannot be attributed to a quantum collection of particles.

Vestnik Тomskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta Khimiya•Jan 1, 2024•4 citations

Angular Momentum Coupling

J. Suhonen

Theoretical and mathematical physics•Jan 1, 2007•0 citations

Angular momentum II

Institute of Physics eBooks•Nov 26, 2004•0 citations

The JWKB Method in Central-Field Problems. Planar Radial Wave Equation and Resolution of Kramers' Dilemma

Jens Peder Dahl, Wolfgang P. Schleich

It is well-known that applications of the JWKB method to central-field problems in three dimensions require half-integral quantization of the angular momentum for their success. Thus, the square of the angular momentum must be represented by the term (𝓁 + 1 / 2 ) 2 ℏ 2 rather than 𝓁 (𝓁 + 1)ℏ 2 . This was first shown by Kramers in 1926 and has subsequently been discussed by several authors including, in particular, Langer (1937). While Kramers based his discussion on the ordinary radial variable r, Langer switched to the variable x defined by r = e x . In this new representation of the central-field problem, the expression (𝓁 + 1 / 2 ) 2 ℏ 2 emerges naturally. The ad hoc character of the Langer transformation has, however, often been emphasized. In the present communication, we choose a different entry to the problem. We keep the variable r and focus on physically equivalent forms of the radial Schrödinger equation in this variable. This leads to a smoother emergence of the (𝓁 + 1 / 2 ) 2 ℏ 2 term. Our analysis is carried out for a general dimension D . For a given D, there are D physically equivalent radial equations, corresponding to the subdimensions d = 1, 2, ..., D . We show that it is only the d = 2 equation that can be satisfactorily treated by the JWKB approximation. In the past, the focus was always on the d = 1 equation, and this was the reason behind the problems encountered by Kramers and Langer. As to the d = 2 equation, we finally show that this equation also is the most convenient starting point for determining the exact solutions of a central-field problem for general values of D and angular-momentum quantum number L .

The Journal of Physical Chemistry A•Apr 21, 2004•8 citations
The rigorous equivalence of the Schrödinger and Heisenberg pictures requires that one uses Born-Jordan quantization in place of Weyl quantization. We confirm this by showing that the much discussed " angular momentum dilemma" disappears if one uses Born-Jordan quantization. We argue that the latter is the only physically correct quantization procedure. We also briefly discuss a possible redefinition of phase space quantum mechanics, where the usual Wigner distribution has to be replaced with a new quasi-distribution associated with Born-Jordan quantization, and which has proven to be successful in time-frequency analysis.
The purpose of the work is to check the validity of generalizing the an-gular momentum ћ of a Cooper pair to any many-particle quantum system, including positronium. Methodology. For the purposes of this work, a semiclassical consideration is quite sufficient. To increase the reliability for helium, a quantum solution is additionally given. It is believed that the total minimum angular momentum of a two-particle quan-tum system – positronium is equal to ћ. When generalizing the angular momentum ћ of a Cooper pair and an electron-positron pair to a pair of helium electrons, its radius turns out to be almost four times less than the established value. And this means only one thing – the generalization of the angular momentum ћ of a Cooper pair to a pair of helium electrons is illegal. Therefore, each helium electron has a minimum angular mo-mentum equal to ћ. And the angular momentum of a pair of helium electrons is equal to the sum of the angular momentum of each electron. The double standards lie in the fact that, on the one hand, a quantum system – an electron-positron pair – is endowed with a quantum of angular momentum ћ, and on the other hand, a quantum system – a pair of helium electrons – is not endowed with this quantum (it is endowed with two quanta). And since double standards are unacceptable, an elementary dilemma arises – either the radius of helium should be quadrupled, or the radius of positronium should be quadrupled. The task is simplified by the fact that recently the value of the radius of positronium was completely unambiguously corrected, which turned out to be exactly four times larger than was commonly believed. Thus, the helium atom retains its size. It has been established that endowing a Cooper pair of electrons with a quantum of angular momentum ћ is just as illegitimate as in the case of positronium. The angular momentum of a many-particle quantum system, due to its additivity, must be divided between the particles of the system. It has been established that the quantum of angular momentum ћ can be attributed to only one quantum particle, and cannot be attributed to a quantum collection of particles.
It is well-known that applications of the JWKB method to central-field problems in three dimensions require half-integral quantization of the angular momentum for their success. Thus, the square of the angular momentum must be represented by the term (𝓁 + 1 / 2 ) 2 ℏ 2 rather than 𝓁 (𝓁 + 1)ℏ 2 . This was first shown by Kramers in 1926 and has subsequently been discussed by several authors including, in particular, Langer (1937). While Kramers based his discussion on the ordinary radial variable r, Langer switched to the variable x defined by r = e x . In this new representation of the central-field problem, the expression (𝓁 + 1 / 2 ) 2 ℏ 2 emerges naturally. The ad hoc character of the Langer transformation has, however, often been emphasized. In the present communication, we choose a different entry to the problem. We keep the variable r and focus on physically equivalent forms of the radial Schrödinger equation in this variable. This leads to a smoother emergence of the (𝓁 + 1 / 2 ) 2 ℏ 2 term. Our analysis is carried out for a general dimension D . For a given D, there are D physically equivalent radial equations, corresponding to the subdimensions d = 1, 2, ..., D . We show that it is only the d = 2 equation that can be satisfactorily treated by the JWKB approximation. In the past, the focus was always on the d = 1 equation, and this was the reason behind the problems encountered by Kramers and Langer. As to the d = 2 equation, we finally show that this equation also is the most convenient starting point for determining the exact solutions of a central-field problem for general values of D and angular-momentum quantum number L .