Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Contemporary mathematics - American Mathematical Society

Dressing up for length gauge: Mathematical aspects of a debate in quantum optics

Rainer Dick

Published Jan 1, 2018• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

We address the surprising issue that different gauges in quantum optics can yield very different results in the description of physical systems. This has been observed for many years for the description of the electromagnetic couplings of atoms and molecules in velocity gauge and length gauge. Indeed, we find that it is mathematically consistent to mix velocity gauge for some components of a material with length gauge for other components, although this should not be possible for a bona fide gauge transformation. For many-particle systems in a Hartree approximation, it is even possible to mix velocity gauge and length gauge for different particles of the same kind. We identify four main sources of analytic differences between velocity gauge and length gauge. These sources imply differences between velocity gauge and length gauge in particular for subfemtosecond spectroscopy and for experiments involving strong fields. Finally, we also emphasize that the transformation from velocity gauge to length gauge is just a particular example of a picture changing unitary transformation. However, all these transformations lead to non-unitary shifts of the Hamiltonian, irrespective of whether the transformation can be described as a gauge transformation or not. Therefore, all these descriptions of quantum optics in dipole approximation are formally equivalent if agreement is achieved which particular formulation of the time-dependent interaction terms perturbs the “true” energy eigenstates of a system. This is where the discrepancies between velocity gauge, length gauge, and also other formulations like acceleration gauge ultimately originate. On the basis of a reductionist approach, we argue that velocity gauge should be considered as the basic description of a quantum system in dipole approximation, and use of other gauges requires careful evaluations of the accompanying transformations of the basis of states. In particular, we find that atomic states in length gauge are dressed by a coherent photon state.

DOI
10.1090/conm/717/14454

Related papers

Velocity gauge formulation of nonlinear optical response in Floquet quantum systems

S. Sajad Dabiri, Reza Asgari

Using the velocity gauge formalism, we develop a theoretical framework for computing the nonlinear optical responses of time-periodic quantum systems. This approach complements the length gauge formulation and offers distinct advantages in both numerical and analytical treatments, particularly for atomic and solid-state systems with well-defined momentum-space structures. By applying our framework to the Rabi model, we derive numerical solutions in the velocity gauge and compare them with the length gauge, demonstrating full agreement between the two formulations. Our findings reveal rich optical phenomena, including photon-assisted transitions, frequency mixing effects, and emergent Floquet-induced photocurrents that are absent in static systems. We demonstrate that nonlinear responses in Floquet-driven systems exhibit resonances at integer multiples of the driving frequency, providing insights into ultrafast spectroscopy and Floquet engineering of quantum materials. The present formulation establishes a bridge between theoretical models and experimental observations in driven quantum systems, with potential applications in quantum optics, photonics, and next-generation optoelectronic devices.

arXiv:2503.12620•SciPost Physics Core•Jul 21, 2025•1 citation

Gauge invariance and the space-translation method

Donald H. Kobe

The space-translation method for treating the interaction of electromagnetic radiation and matter in the electric dipole approximation is investigated from the standpoint of gauge invariance. Unless the wavefunction of the space-translation method is properly transformed, the probability of finding the system in an energy eigenstate is not in general correct. In the electric dipole approximation the probability of finding the system in an energy eigenstate is most conveniently calculated in the electric field gauge where the interaction is of the length form. The length form of the interaction is not in general equal to the velocity form or the acceleration form which comes from the space-translation method. The charged harmonic oscillator is used as an example.

Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•Jan 11, 1984•7 citations

Light–matter interaction in the long-wavelength limit: no ground-state without dipole self-energy

Vasil Rokaj, Davis M. Welakuh, Michael Ruggenthaler +1 more

Abstract Most theoretical studies for correlated light–matter systems are performed within the long-wavelength limit, i.e., the electromagnetic field is assumed to be spatially uniform. In this limit the so-called length-gauge transformation for a fully quantized light–matter system gives rise to a dipole self-energy term in the Hamiltonian, i.e., a harmonic potential of the total dipole matter moment. In practice this term is often discarded as it is assumed to be subsumed in the kinetic energy term. In this work we show the necessity of the dipole self-energy term. First and foremost, without it the light–matter system in the long-wavelength limit does not have a ground-state, i.e., the combined light–matter system is unstable. Further, the mixing of matter and photon degrees of freedom due to the length-gauge transformation, which also changes the representation of the translation operator for matter, gives rise to the Maxwell equations in matter and the omittance of the dipole self-energy leads to a violation of these equations. Specifically we show that without the dipole self-energy the so-called ‘depolarization shift’ is not properly described. Finally we show that this term also arises if we perform the semi-classical limit after the length-gauge transformation. In contrast to the standard approach where the semi-classical limit is performed before the length-gauge transformation, the resulting Hamiltonian is bounded from below and thus supports ground-states. This is very important for practical calculations and for density-functional variational implementations of the non-relativistic QED formalism. For example, the existence of a combined light–matter ground-state allows one to calculate the Stark shift non-perturbatively.

arXiv:1807.03635•Journal of Physics B Atomic Molecular and Optical Physics•Nov 27, 2017•243 citations

Gauge and unitary transformations in multipolar quantum optics

M. Babiker

Multipolar quantum optics deals with the interaction of light with matter as a many-body bound system of charged particles where the coupling to electromagnetic fields is in terms of the multipolar electric polarization and magnetization. We describe two transformations applied to the conventional non-relativistic formalism, namely a gauge transformation applied directly to the fields at the Lagrangian stage and a unitary transformation applied to the old Hamiltonian. We show how such transformations lead to the same Power-Zienau-Woolley (PZW) formulation of the quantum electrodynamics (QED) of an overall electrically neutral many-body bound system of charges, including the internal motion as well as the gross dynamics of the centre of mass. Besides highlighting the utility of the multipolar formalism as a reliable and convenient platform in dealing with optical processes in atomic and molecular physics, it is shown how the analysis can also lead to the identification of the Röntgen effect arising from the gross motion of an electric dipole moment in a magnetic field and the Aharonov-Casher effect due to the motion of a magnetic dipole moment in an electric field. The importance of the two effects is pointed out in both experimental and theoretical contexts.This article is part of the theme issue 'The quantum theory of light'.

Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society A Mathematical Physical and Engineering Sciences•Dec 24, 2024•0 citations

Quantum delocalization, gauge, and quantum optics: Light-matter interaction in relativistic quantum information

Richard Lopp, Eduardo Martín-Martínez

We revisit the interaction of a first-quantized atomic system (consisting of two charged quantum particles) with the quantum electromagnetic field, pointing out the subtleties related to the gauge nature of electromagnetism and the effect of multipole approximations. We connect the full minimal-coupling model with the typical effective models used in quantum optics and relativistic quantum information such as the Unruh-DeWitt (UDW) model and the dipole coupling approximation. We point out in what regimes different degrees of approximation are reasonable and in what cases effective models need to be refined to capture the features of the light-matter interaction. This is particularly important when considering the center of mass (COM) of the atom as a quantum system that can be delocalized over multiple trajectories. For example, we show that the simplest UDW approximation with a quantum COM fails to capture crucial R\"ontgen terms coupling COM and internal atomic degrees of freedom with each other and the field. Finally we show how effective dipole interaction models can be covariantly prescribed for relativistically moving atoms.

arXiv:2008.12785•Physical Review A•Jan 6, 2021•83 citations

Operator Gauge Transformations in Nonrelativistic Quantum Electrodynamics

Raymond Dale Gray

A system of nonrelativistic charged particles and radiation is canonically quantized in the Coulomb gauge and Maxwell's equations in quantum electrodynamics are derived. By requiring form invariance of the Schrodinger equation under a space and time dependent unitary transformation, operator gauge transformations on the quantized electromagnetic potentials and state vectors are introduced. These gauge transformed potentials have the same form as gauge transformations in non-Abelian gauge field theories. A gauge-invariant method for solving the time-dependent Schrodinger equation in quantum electrodynamics is given. Maxwell's equations are written in a form which holds in all gauges and which has formal similarity to the equations of motion of non-Abelian gauge fields. A gauge-invariant derivation of conservation of energy in quantum electrodynamics is given. An operator gauge transformation is made to the multipolar gauge in which the potentials are expressed in terms of the electromagnetic fields. The multipolar Hamiltonian is shown to be the minimally coupled Hamiltonian with the electromagnetic potentials in the multipolar gauge. The model of a charged harmonic oscillator in a single-mode electromagnetic field is considered as an example. The gauge-invariant procedure for solving the time-dependent Schrodinger equation is used to obtain the gauge-invariant probabilities that the oscillator is in an energy eigenstate For comparison, the conventional approach is also used to solve the harmonic oscillator problem and is shown to give gauge-dependent amplitudes.

•Dec 1, 1982•0 citations
We address the surprising issue that different gauges in quantum optics can yield very different results in the description of physical systems. This has been observed for many years for the description of the electromagnetic couplings of atoms and molecules in velocity gauge and length gauge. Indeed, we find that it is mathematically consistent to mix velocity gauge for some components of a material with length gauge for other components, although this should not be possible for a bona fide gauge transformation. For many-particle systems in a Hartree approximation, it is even possible to mix velocity gauge and length gauge for different particles of the same kind. We identify four main sources of analytic differences between velocity gauge and length gauge. These sources imply differences between velocity gauge and length gauge in particular for subfemtosecond spectroscopy and for experiments involving strong fields. Finally, we also emphasize that the transformation from velocity gauge to length gauge is just a particular example of a picture changing unitary transformation. However, all these transformations lead to non-unitary shifts of the Hamiltonian, irrespective of whether the transformation can be described as a gauge transformation or not. Therefore, all these descriptions of quantum optics in dipole approximation are formally equivalent if agreement is achieved which particular formulation of the time-dependent interaction terms perturbs the “true” energy eigenstates of a system. This is where the discrepancies between velocity gauge, length gauge, and also other formulations like acceleration gauge ultimately originate. On the basis of a reductionist approach, we argue that velocity gauge should be considered as the basic description of a quantum system in dipole approximation, and use of other gauges requires careful evaluations of the accompanying transformations of the basis of states. In particular, we find that atomic states in length gauge are dressed by a coherent photon state.
Using the velocity gauge formalism, we develop a theoretical framework for computing the nonlinear optical responses of time-periodic quantum systems. This approach complements the length gauge formulation and offers distinct advantages in both numerical and analytical treatments, particularly for atomic and solid-state systems with well-defined momentum-space structures. By applying our framework to the Rabi model, we derive numerical solutions in the velocity gauge and compare them with the length gauge, demonstrating full agreement between the two formulations. Our findings reveal rich optical phenomena, including photon-assisted transitions, frequency mixing effects, and emergent Floquet-induced photocurrents that are absent in static systems. We demonstrate that nonlinear responses in Floquet-driven systems exhibit resonances at integer multiples of the driving frequency, providing insights into ultrafast spectroscopy and Floquet engineering of quantum materials. The present formulation establishes a bridge between theoretical models and experimental observations in driven quantum systems, with potential applications in quantum optics, photonics, and next-generation optoelectronic devices.
The space-translation method for treating the interaction of electromagnetic radiation and matter in the electric dipole approximation is investigated from the standpoint of gauge invariance. Unless the wavefunction of the space-translation method is properly transformed, the probability of finding the system in an energy eigenstate is not in general correct. In the electric dipole approximation the probability of finding the system in an energy eigenstate is most conveniently calculated in the electric field gauge where the interaction is of the length form. The length form of the interaction is not in general equal to the velocity form or the acceleration form which comes from the space-translation method. The charged harmonic oscillator is used as an example.
Abstract Most theoretical studies for correlated light–matter systems are performed within the long-wavelength limit, i.e., the electromagnetic field is assumed to be spatially uniform. In this limit the so-called length-gauge transformation for a fully quantized light–matter system gives rise to a dipole self-energy term in the Hamiltonian, i.e., a harmonic potential of the total dipole matter moment. In practice this term is often discarded as it is assumed to be subsumed in the kinetic energy term. In this work we show the necessity of the dipole self-energy term. First and foremost, without it the light–matter system in the long-wavelength limit does not have a ground-state, i.e., the combined light–matter system is unstable. Further, the mixing of matter and photon degrees of freedom due to the length-gauge transformation, which also changes the representation of the translation operator for matter, gives rise to the Maxwell equations in matter and the omittance of the dipole self-energy leads to a violation of these equations. Specifically we show that without the dipole self-energy the so-called ‘depolarization shift’ is not properly described. Finally we show that this term also arises if we perform the semi-classical limit after the length-gauge transformation. In contrast to the standard approach where the semi-classical limit is performed before the length-gauge transformation, the resulting Hamiltonian is bounded from below and thus supports ground-states. This is very important for practical calculations and for density-functional variational implementations of the non-relativistic QED formalism. For example, the existence of a combined light–matter ground-state allows one to calculate the Stark shift non-perturbatively.
Multipolar quantum optics deals with the interaction of light with matter as a many-body bound system of charged particles where the coupling to electromagnetic fields is in terms of the multipolar electric polarization and magnetization. We describe two transformations applied to the conventional non-relativistic formalism, namely a gauge transformation applied directly to the fields at the Lagrangian stage and a unitary transformation applied to the old Hamiltonian. We show how such transformations lead to the same Power-Zienau-Woolley (PZW) formulation of the quantum electrodynamics (QED) of an overall electrically neutral many-body bound system of charges, including the internal motion as well as the gross dynamics of the centre of mass. Besides highlighting the utility of the multipolar formalism as a reliable and convenient platform in dealing with optical processes in atomic and molecular physics, it is shown how the analysis can also lead to the identification of the Röntgen effect arising from the gross motion of an electric dipole moment in a magnetic field and the Aharonov-Casher effect due to the motion of a magnetic dipole moment in an electric field. The importance of the two effects is pointed out in both experimental and theoretical contexts.This article is part of the theme issue 'The quantum theory of light'.
We revisit the interaction of a first-quantized atomic system (consisting of two charged quantum particles) with the quantum electromagnetic field, pointing out the subtleties related to the gauge nature of electromagnetism and the effect of multipole approximations. We connect the full minimal-coupling model with the typical effective models used in quantum optics and relativistic quantum information such as the Unruh-DeWitt (UDW) model and the dipole coupling approximation. We point out in what regimes different degrees of approximation are reasonable and in what cases effective models need to be refined to capture the features of the light-matter interaction. This is particularly important when considering the center of mass (COM) of the atom as a quantum system that can be delocalized over multiple trajectories. For example, we show that the simplest UDW approximation with a quantum COM fails to capture crucial R\"ontgen terms coupling COM and internal atomic degrees of freedom with each other and the field. Finally we show how effective dipole interaction models can be covariantly prescribed for relativistically moving atoms.
A system of nonrelativistic charged particles and radiation is canonically quantized in the Coulomb gauge and Maxwell's equations in quantum electrodynamics are derived. By requiring form invariance of the Schrodinger equation under a space and time dependent unitary transformation, operator gauge transformations on the quantized electromagnetic potentials and state vectors are introduced. These gauge transformed potentials have the same form as gauge transformations in non-Abelian gauge field theories. A gauge-invariant method for solving the time-dependent Schrodinger equation in quantum electrodynamics is given. Maxwell's equations are written in a form which holds in all gauges and which has formal similarity to the equations of motion of non-Abelian gauge fields. A gauge-invariant derivation of conservation of energy in quantum electrodynamics is given. An operator gauge transformation is made to the multipolar gauge in which the potentials are expressed in terms of the electromagnetic fields. The multipolar Hamiltonian is shown to be the minimally coupled Hamiltonian with the electromagnetic potentials in the multipolar gauge. The model of a charged harmonic oscillator in a single-mode electromagnetic field is considered as an example. The gauge-invariant procedure for solving the time-dependent Schrodinger equation is used to obtain the gauge-invariant probabilities that the oscillator is in an energy eigenstate For comparison, the conventional approach is also used to solve the harmonic oscillator problem and is shown to give gauge-dependent amplitudes.