Contemporary mathematics - American Mathematical Society
Dressing up for length gauge: Mathematical aspects of a debate in quantum optics
Rainer Dick
Abstract
We address the surprising issue that different gauges in quantum optics can yield very different results in the description of physical systems. This has been observed for many years for the description of the electromagnetic couplings of atoms and molecules in velocity gauge and length gauge. Indeed, we find that it is mathematically consistent to mix velocity gauge for some components of a material with length gauge for other components, although this should not be possible for a bona fide gauge transformation. For many-particle systems in a Hartree approximation, it is even possible to mix velocity gauge and length gauge for different particles of the same kind. We identify four main sources of analytic differences between velocity gauge and length gauge. These sources imply differences between velocity gauge and length gauge in particular for subfemtosecond spectroscopy and for experiments involving strong fields. Finally, we also emphasize that the transformation from velocity gauge to length gauge is just a particular example of a picture changing unitary transformation. However, all these transformations lead to non-unitary shifts of the Hamiltonian, irrespective of whether the transformation can be described as a gauge transformation or not. Therefore, all these descriptions of quantum optics in dipole approximation are formally equivalent if agreement is achieved which particular formulation of the time-dependent interaction terms perturbs the “true” energy eigenstates of a system. This is where the discrepancies between velocity gauge, length gauge, and also other formulations like acceleration gauge ultimately originate. On the basis of a reductionist approach, we argue that velocity gauge should be considered as the basic description of a quantum system in dipole approximation, and use of other gauges requires careful evaluations of the accompanying transformations of the basis of states. In particular, we find that atomic states in length gauge are dressed by a coherent photon state.