In this paper, we investigate a cooperative communication system comprised of a source, a destination, and multiple decode-and-forward (DF) relays in the presence of a potential malicious eavesdropper is within or without the coverage area of the source. Based on the more general Nakagami-m fading channels, we analyze the security performance of the single-relay selection and multi-relay selection schemes for protecting the source against eavesdropping. In the single-relay selection scheme, only the best relay is chosen to assist in the source transmission. Differing from the single-relay selection, multi-relay selection scheme allows multiple relays to forward the source to the destination. We also consider the classic direct transmission as a benchmark scheme to compare with the two relay selection schemes. We derive the exact closed-form expressions of outage probability (OP) and intercept probability (IP) for the direct transmission, the single-relay selection as well as the multi-relay selection scheme over Nakagami-m fading channel when the eavesdropper is within and without the coverage area of the source. Moreover, the security-reliability tradeoff (SRT) of these three schemes are also analyzed. It is verified that the SRT of the multi-relay selection consistently outperforms the single-relay selection, which of both the single-relay and multi-relay selection schemes outperform the direct transmission when the number of relays is large, no matter the eavesdropper is within or without the coverage of the source. In addition, as the number of DF relays increases, the SRT of relay selection schemes improve notably. However, the SRT of both two relay selection approaches become worse when the eavesdropper is within the coverage area of the source.
In this paper, we investigate a cooperative communication system comprised of a source, a destination, and multiple decode-and-forward (DF) relays in the presence of a potential malicious eavesdropper is within or without the coverage area of the source. Based on the more general Nakagami-m fading channels, we analyze the security performance of the single-relay selection and multi-relay selection schemes for protecting the source against eavesdropping. In the single-relay selection scheme, only the best relay is chosen to assist in the source transmission. Differing from the single-relay selection, multi-relay selection scheme allows multiple relays to forward the source to the destination. We also consider the classic direct transmission as a benchmark scheme to compare with the two relay selection schemes. We derive the exact closed-form expressions of outage probability (OP) and intercept probability (IP) for the direct transmission, the single-relay selection as well as the multi-relay selection scheme over Nakagami-m fading channel when the eavesdropper is within and without the coverage area of the source. Moreover, the security-reliability tradeoff (SRT) of these three schemes are also analyzed. It is verified that the SRT of the multi-relay selection consistently outperforms the single-relay selection, which of both the single-relay and multi-relay selection schemes outperform the direct transmission when the number of relays is large, no matter the eavesdropper is within or without the coverage of the source. In addition, as the number of DF relays increases, the SRT of relay selection schemes improve notably. However, the SRT of both two relay selection approaches become worse when the eavesdropper is within the coverage area of the source.
Joint Relay and Eavesdropper Selection Strategy Against Multiple Eavesdroppers over Nakagami-m Fading Channels in Cooperative Decode-and-Forward Relay Networks
Physical layer security (PLS) in the presence of multiple eavesdroppers over Nakagami-m fading channels for cooperative decode-and-forward (DF) relay network that consists of one source, one destination, and multiple relays is investigated. Different from the recent PLS system model that only considers one eavesdropper during eavesdropping attack, this paper extends the one-eavesdropper case to a multiple-eavesdropper scenario and investigates joint relay and eavesdropper selection (JRES) strategy against eavesdropping attack over Nakagami-m fading channels. In the proposed strategy, the best relay is selected via the maximum relay forward channel capacity. In addition, since eavesdroppers are noncooperative, the worst case is considered. Namely, the wiretap channel between the best relay and the chosen eavesdropper has the maximum capacity. Traditional direct transmission and opportunistic relay selection (ORS) scheme in the presence of one eavesdropper over Rayleigh channel are regarded as benchmarks. Moreover, a security-reliability tradeoff (SRT) performance is analyzed, where the reliability performance is expressed by outage probability (OP), while the security performance is measured by intercept probability (IP). Closed-form expressions of OP and IP are derived. The numerical results show that the proposed JRES scheme outperforms the traditional direct transmission and the ORS scheme in the presence of one eavesdropper over Rayleigh channel. The SRT performance is enhanced obviously with the increasing of relay numbers and Nakagami channel fading factor m for a given number of eavesdroppers, which extends the PLS and SRT performance analysis to a more general case in a cooperative DF relay network.
In this paper, we analyze the security-reliability tradeoff (SRT) performance of the multi-relay cooperative networks over Nakagami-m fading channels. By considering the reliability of the first phase from the source to relay, a cooperative jamming (CJ) assisted secure transmission scheme is investigated to improve the security performance of the considered system. Specifically, we derive the approximate closed-form expression of the outage probability (OP) and exact closed-form expression of the intercepted probability (IP) for the CJ scheme to evaluate the SRT performance of the system. Finally, the simulation results verify the validity of our theoretical derivations and the advantage of the CJ scheme compared to the traditional scheme with no cooperative jammer.
In this paper, we investigate a novel joint multi-relay and jammer selection (JMRJS) scheme in order to improve the physical layer security of wireless networks. In the JMRJS scheme, all the relays succeeding in source decoding are selected to assist in the source signal transmission and meanwhile, all the remaining relay nodes are employed to act as friendly jammers to disturb the eavesdroppers by broadcasting artificial noise. Based on the more general Nakagami-m fading channel, we analyze the security performance of the JMRJS scheme for protecting the source signal against eavesdropping. The exact closed-form expressions of outage probability (OP) and intercept probability (IP) for the JMRJS scheme over Nakagami-m fading channel are derived. Moreover, we analyze the security-reliability tradeoff (SRT) of this scheme. Simulation results show that as the number of decode-and-forward (DF)relay nodes increases, the SRT of the JMRJS scheme improves notably. And when the transmit power is below a certain value, the SRT of the JMRJS scheme consistently outperforms the joint single-relay and jammer selection (JSRJS) scheme and joint equal-relay and jammer selection (JERJS) scheme respectively. In addition, the SRT of this scheme is always better than that of the multi-relay selection (MRS) scheme.
In this paper, we investigate the secure transmission problem of cooperative communication systems where a potential malicious eavesdropper is existing. Based on the more general Nakagami-m fading channels, we adopt a strategy to improve the system security performance by decoding and forwarding signals at the relay as well as sending interference signals simultaneously. In this model, the outage probability and the intercept probability which represent reliability and security respectively are derived, meanwhile, the influence of the power allocation of each node on the system performance is discussed. Simulations are provided to analyze the tradeoff between reliability and security of the system, and the variation in tradeoff performance under different power allocation.
This article examines secrecy coding aided wireless communications from a source to a destination in the presence of an eavesdropper from an SRT perspective. Explicitly, security is quantified in terms of the intercept probability experienced at the eavesdropper, while the outage probability encountered at the destination is used to measure transmission reliability. We characterize the SRT of conventional direct transmission from the source to the destination and show that if the outage probability is increased, the intercept probability decreases, and vice versa. We first demonstrate that the employment of relay nodes for assisting source-destination transmission is capable of defending against eavesdropping, followed by quantifying the benefits of SRS as well as MRS schemes. More specifically, in the SRS scheme, only the single "best" relay is selected for forwarding the source signal to the destination, whereas the MRS scheme allows multiple relays to participate in this process. It is illustrated that both the SRS and MRS schemes achieve a better SRT than conventional direct transmission, especially upon increasing the number of relays. Numerical results also show that, as expected, MRS outperforms SRS in terms of its SRT. Additionally, we present some open challenges and future directions for wireless relay aided physical-layer security.
In the last decade, multi-hop cooperation has evolved bringing several advantages including coverage improvement, more reliability of wireless links, and power consumption reduction. Still, its application has raised several challenges, such as the need for secure transmission at each hop, algorithms to perform relay selection and the accurate models to facilitate performance analysis. This paper addresses the problem of physical layer (PHY) security in a multi-hop wireless cooperative network, where communication at each hop is assisted by multiple relays forming a cluster, each cluster being surrounded by multiple eavesdroppers which together may tap transmissions from both the source and the relays. The main focus of the study is on analyzing the benefits of various relay selection schemes for protecting the source-destination transmission against the eavesdroppers, which can collude and combine information via diversity combining techniques. To be specific, four relay selection schemes, which differ in the way they employ available measures link quality, are considered to deliver the source information to the destination via a decode-and-forward (DF) strategy. To evaluate the security performance of the multi-hop cooperative link in the presence of colluding eavesdroppers, we derive novel closed-form analytical expressions for the secrecy outage probability (SOP) with consideration of special cases of practical interest.