Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Canadian Journal of Physics

de Broglie clock, electron channeling, and time in quantum mechanics

M. Bauer

Published May 17, 2018• 4 citations
Publisher

Abstract

De Broglie’s association of a wave to particles is a fundamental concept in the quantum mechanical description of nature. The wave oscillation is referred to alternatively as the “de Broglie clock”, the “Compton clock”, or the “de Broglie periodic phenomenon”. In the present paper it is shown that Dirac’s relativistic quantum mechanics, complemented with the dynamical time operator recently introduced, provides a consistent theoretical description of: (i) the generation of the de Broglie wave through Lorentz boosts; and (ii) the characteristics of the resonance observed in electron channeling through thin crystals as responding to both the periodicity derived from the adjustment of the de Broglie period to the crystal interatomic distance (resonance energy) and the periodicity of the predicted trembling motion (Zitterbewegung). One can conclude that the channeling experiments provide the first direct evidence of the electron Zitterbewegung, and that the de Broglie period is an intrinsic property of matter arising from a self-adjoint dynamical time operator.

DOI
10.1139/cjp-2017-0571

Related papers

Electron channeling, de Broglie's clock and the relativistic time operator

M. Bauer

Electron channeling in silicon crystals has brought forward the possibility of having detected a particle's "internal clock", as an intrinsic oscillation with de Broglie's frequency. The transmission probability along a major axial direction is reduced with respect to neighboring angles, except for a sharp peak at the atomic row direction. The pattern observed is a "W" instead of a "U". This central peak is attributed to a process known as "rosette motion", in which the crossing of successive atoms would be related to the de Broglie frequency. A classical multiple scattering calculation found that, to represent the experimental results, the interaction frequency had to be about twice the de Broglie's clock frequency; that is, the "Zitterbewegung" frequency. In the present paper, the observed characteristics of this process are shown to be consistent with a free particle quantum mechanical motion described by Dirac's Hamiltonian, albeit with an effective mass resulting from the interaction with the crystal atoms. The introduction of a self-adjoint dynamic time operator provides the connection with an internal "system time", the de Broglie clock.

arXiv:1403.4580•Mar 18, 2014•2 citations

On electron channeling and the de Broglie internal clock

M. Bauer

Electron channeling in silicon crystals has brought forward the possibility of having detected the particle's "de Broglie internal clock", as giving rise to the observed resonance peak at the center of the expected transmission probability dip. A classical multiple scattering calculation fails to represent the experimental results unless, surprisingly, the interaction frequency is twice the de Broglie's clock frequency, that is, the "Zitterbewegung" frequency. In the present paper, the observed characteristics of this process are shown to be consistent with a free particle quantum mechanical motion described by Dirac's Hamiltonian.

arXiv:1409.0888•Sep 2, 2014•0 citations

A Unified Geometrical Interpretation of Zitterbewegung and de Broglie Matter Waves

Hidemi Munakata

Zitterbewegung and de Broglie matter waves are both phenomena associated with the quantum-mechanical properties of the electron, but they are usually discussed in different contexts. Zitterbewegung is understood as a rapid oscillatory motion appearing in the Dirac equation, whereas the de Broglie matter wave is understood as a wave corresponding to the linear momentum of a particle. Some previous studies have attempted to derive the de Broglie matter wave from an internal clock of the electron or from Zitterbewegung. In the present study, however, no causal relation in which the matter wave is generated by Zitterbewegung is assumed. Instead, the two are regarded as different geometrical representations of a common phase degree of freedom. Specifically, Zitterbewegung is interpreted as a phenomenon corresponding to an internal rotational degree of freedom, while the de Broglie matter wave is interpreted as spatial phase progression associated with linear momentum. and are interpreted, respectively, as the rates of phase progression in the temporal and spatial directions. Furthermore, using the relation introduced in previous work, and reinterpreting it as the ratio of the internal rotational velocity to the external propagation velocity, this study shows the possibility of describing internal rotation, translational motion, matter waves, and the fine-structure constant within a common phase geometry.

•Aug 14, 2026•0 citations

About the Nature of De Broglie Wave

Isaak Man’kin

In this article, it is shown that if a particle is at rest and has some harmonic oscillation, then a traveling particle with a constant speed corresponds to a De Broglie Wave.In 1924, De Broglie proposed that particles of matter exhibit wave like behavior, the expression for which became fundamental in the creation of wave mechanics (quantum mechanics).The main equation for this is the Schrödinger equation, which in the case of free motion of a particle becomes the expression for the De Broglie wave.This hypothesis is supported by many early experiments on the diffraction of electrons, and later the development of modern physics.However until now, the origin of this hypothesis remains unclear.We show that the expression for the De Broglie wavelength can be obtained from a more general well-known concept, that any particle at rest has a corresponding harmonic oscillation that transforms into a wave of a moving particle with the help of relativistic change of coordinates (the Lorentz transformations).In this way, a De Broglie wave can be explained as a spacetime wave.

OALib•Jan 1, 2022•1 citation

A dynamical time operator in Dirac's relativistic quantum mechanics

M. Bauer

A self-adjoint dynamical time operator is introduced in Dirac's relativistic formulation of quantum mechanics and shown to satisfy a commutation relation with the Hamiltonian analogous to that of the position and momentum operators. The ensuing time-energy uncertainty relation involves the uncertainty in the instant of time when the wave packet passes a particular spatial position and the energy uncertainty associated with the wave packet at the same time, as envisaged originally by Bohr. The instantaneous rate of change of the position expectation value with respect to the simultaneous expectation value of the dynamical time operator is shown to be the phase velocity, in agreement with de Broglie's hypothesis of a particle associated wave whose phase velocity is larger than c. Thus, these two elements of the original basis and interpretation of quantum mechanics are integrated into its formal mathematical structure. Pauli's objection is shown to be resolved or circumvented. Possible relevance to current developments in electron channeling, in interference in time, in Zitterbewegung-like effects in spintronics, graphene and superconducting systems and in cosmology is noted.

arXiv:0908.2789•International Journal of Modern Physics A•Mar 4, 2014•38 citations

Measuring the internal clock of the electron

M. Rivas

The existence of an internal frequency associated to any elementary particle conjectured by de Broglie is compared with a classical description of the electron, where this internal structure corresponds to the motion of the centre of charge around the centre of mass of the particle. This internal motion has a frequency twice de Broglie's frequency, which corresponds to the frequency found by Dirac when analysing the electron structure. To get evidence of this internal electron clock a kind of experiment as the one performed by Gouanére et al. \cite{Gouanere} will show a discrete set of momenta at which a resonant scattering effect, appears. The resonant momenta of the electron beam are given by $p_k=161.748/k$ MeV$/c$, $k=1,2,3,...$, where only, the corresponding to $k=2$, was within the range of Gouanére et al. experiment. The extension of the experiment to other values of $p_k$, would show the existence of this phenomenon.

arXiv:0809.3635•Sep 22, 2008•4 citations
De Broglie’s association of a wave to particles is a fundamental concept in the quantum mechanical description of nature. The wave oscillation is referred to alternatively as the “de Broglie clock”, the “Compton clock”, or the “de Broglie periodic phenomenon”. In the present paper it is shown that Dirac’s relativistic quantum mechanics, complemented with the dynamical time operator recently introduced, provides a consistent theoretical description of: (i) the generation of the de Broglie wave through Lorentz boosts; and (ii) the characteristics of the resonance observed in electron channeling through thin crystals as responding to both the periodicity derived from the adjustment of the de Broglie period to the crystal interatomic distance (resonance energy) and the periodicity of the predicted trembling motion (Zitterbewegung). One can conclude that the channeling experiments provide the first direct evidence of the electron Zitterbewegung, and that the de Broglie period is an intrinsic property of matter arising from a self-adjoint dynamical time operator.
Electron channeling in silicon crystals has brought forward the possibility of having detected a particle's "internal clock", as an intrinsic oscillation with de Broglie's frequency. The transmission probability along a major axial direction is reduced with respect to neighboring angles, except for a sharp peak at the atomic row direction. The pattern observed is a "W" instead of a "U". This central peak is attributed to a process known as "rosette motion", in which the crossing of successive atoms would be related to the de Broglie frequency. A classical multiple scattering calculation found that, to represent the experimental results, the interaction frequency had to be about twice the de Broglie's clock frequency; that is, the "Zitterbewegung" frequency. In the present paper, the observed characteristics of this process are shown to be consistent with a free particle quantum mechanical motion described by Dirac's Hamiltonian, albeit with an effective mass resulting from the interaction with the crystal atoms. The introduction of a self-adjoint dynamic time operator provides the connection with an internal "system time", the de Broglie clock.
Electron channeling in silicon crystals has brought forward the possibility of having detected the particle's "de Broglie internal clock", as giving rise to the observed resonance peak at the center of the expected transmission probability dip. A classical multiple scattering calculation fails to represent the experimental results unless, surprisingly, the interaction frequency is twice the de Broglie's clock frequency, that is, the "Zitterbewegung" frequency. In the present paper, the observed characteristics of this process are shown to be consistent with a free particle quantum mechanical motion described by Dirac's Hamiltonian.
Zitterbewegung and de Broglie matter waves are both phenomena associated with the quantum-mechanical properties of the electron, but they are usually discussed in different contexts. Zitterbewegung is understood as a rapid oscillatory motion appearing in the Dirac equation, whereas the de Broglie matter wave is understood as a wave corresponding to the linear momentum of a particle. Some previous studies have attempted to derive the de Broglie matter wave from an internal clock of the electron or from Zitterbewegung. In the present study, however, no causal relation in which the matter wave is generated by Zitterbewegung is assumed. Instead, the two are regarded as different geometrical representations of a common phase degree of freedom. Specifically, Zitterbewegung is interpreted as a phenomenon corresponding to an internal rotational degree of freedom, while the de Broglie matter wave is interpreted as spatial phase progression associated with linear momentum. and are interpreted, respectively, as the rates of phase progression in the temporal and spatial directions. Furthermore, using the relation introduced in previous work, and reinterpreting it as the ratio of the internal rotational velocity to the external propagation velocity, this study shows the possibility of describing internal rotation, translational motion, matter waves, and the fine-structure constant within a common phase geometry.
In this article, it is shown that if a particle is at rest and has some harmonic oscillation, then a traveling particle with a constant speed corresponds to a De Broglie Wave.In 1924, De Broglie proposed that particles of matter exhibit wave like behavior, the expression for which became fundamental in the creation of wave mechanics (quantum mechanics).The main equation for this is the Schrödinger equation, which in the case of free motion of a particle becomes the expression for the De Broglie wave.This hypothesis is supported by many early experiments on the diffraction of electrons, and later the development of modern physics.However until now, the origin of this hypothesis remains unclear.We show that the expression for the De Broglie wavelength can be obtained from a more general well-known concept, that any particle at rest has a corresponding harmonic oscillation that transforms into a wave of a moving particle with the help of relativistic change of coordinates (the Lorentz transformations).In this way, a De Broglie wave can be explained as a spacetime wave.
A self-adjoint dynamical time operator is introduced in Dirac's relativistic formulation of quantum mechanics and shown to satisfy a commutation relation with the Hamiltonian analogous to that of the position and momentum operators. The ensuing time-energy uncertainty relation involves the uncertainty in the instant of time when the wave packet passes a particular spatial position and the energy uncertainty associated with the wave packet at the same time, as envisaged originally by Bohr. The instantaneous rate of change of the position expectation value with respect to the simultaneous expectation value of the dynamical time operator is shown to be the phase velocity, in agreement with de Broglie's hypothesis of a particle associated wave whose phase velocity is larger than c. Thus, these two elements of the original basis and interpretation of quantum mechanics are integrated into its formal mathematical structure. Pauli's objection is shown to be resolved or circumvented. Possible relevance to current developments in electron channeling, in interference in time, in Zitterbewegung-like effects in spintronics, graphene and superconducting systems and in cosmology is noted.
The existence of an internal frequency associated to any elementary particle conjectured by de Broglie is compared with a classical description of the electron, where this internal structure corresponds to the motion of the centre of charge around the centre of mass of the particle. This internal motion has a frequency twice de Broglie's frequency, which corresponds to the frequency found by Dirac when analysing the electron structure. To get evidence of this internal electron clock a kind of experiment as the one performed by Gouanére et al. \cite{Gouanere} will show a discrete set of momenta at which a resonant scattering effect, appears. The resonant momenta of the electron beam are given by pk=161.748/kp_k=161.748/kpk​=161.748/k MeV/c/c/c, k=1,2,3,...k=1,2,3,...k=1,2,3,..., where only, the corresponding to k=2k=2k=2, was within the range of Gouanére et al. experiment. The extension of the experiment to other values of pkp_kpk​, would show the existence of this phenomenon.