Turbulence appears in most natural and man-made flows. However, the analysis of turbulence is particularly difficult. Links between microscopic fluid dynamics and statistical signatures of turbulence appear unobtainable from the postulates of fluid dynamics making turbulence one of the most important unsolved theoretical problems in physics. Two-dimensional quantum turbulence (2DQT), an emerging field of study, involves turbulence in two-dimensional (2D) flows in superfluids, such as Bose-Einstein condensates (BECs). In 2D superfluids, a turbulent state can be characterized by a disordered distribution of numerous vortex cores. The question of how to effectively and efficiently generate turbulent states in superfluids is a fundamental question in the field of quantum turbulence. Therefore, experimental studies of vortex nucleation and the onset of turbulence in a superfluid are important for achieving a deeper understanding of the overall problem of turbulence. My PhD dissertation involves the study of vortex nucleation and the onset of turbulence in quasi-2D BECs. First, I discuss experimental apparatus advancements that now enable BECs to be created in a hybrid optical-magnetic trap, an atom trapping configuration conducive to 2DQT experiments. Next, I discuss the design and construction of a quantum vortex microscope and initial vortex detection tests. Finally, I present the first experiments aimed at studying 2DQT carried out in the updated apparatus. Thermal counterflow in superfluid helium, in which the normal and superfluid components flow in opposite directions, is known to create turbulence in the superfluid. However, this phenomenon has not been simulated or studied in dilute-gas BECs as a possible vortex nucleation method. In this dissertation, I present preliminary data from the first experiments aimed at understanding thermal counterflow turbulence in dilute-gas BECs.
Turbulence appears in most natural and man-made flows. However, the analysis of turbulence is particularly difficult. Links between microscopic fluid dynamics and statistical signatures of turbulence appear unobtainable from the postulates of fluid dynamics making turbulence one of the most important unsolved theoretical problems in physics. Two-dimensional quantum turbulence (2DQT), an emerging field of study, involves turbulence in two-dimensional (2D) flows in superfluids, such as Bose-Einstein condensates (BECs). In 2D superfluids, a turbulent state can be characterized by a disordered distribution of numerous vortex cores. The question of how to effectively and efficiently generate turbulent states in superfluids is a fundamental question in the field of quantum turbulence. Therefore, experimental studies of vortex nucleation and the onset of turbulence in a superfluid are important for achieving a deeper understanding of the overall problem of turbulence. My PhD dissertation involves the study of vortex nucleation and the onset of turbulence in quasi-2D BECs. First, I discuss experimental apparatus advancements that now enable BECs to be created in a hybrid optical-magnetic trap, an atom trapping configuration conducive to 2DQT experiments. Next, I discuss the design and construction of a quantum vortex microscope and initial vortex detection tests. Finally, I present the first experiments aimed at studying 2DQT carried out in the updated apparatus. Thermal counterflow in superfluid helium, in which the normal and superfluid components flow in opposite directions, is known to create turbulence in the superfluid. However, this phenomenon has not been simulated or studied in dilute-gas BECs as a possible vortex nucleation method. In this dissertation, I present preliminary data from the first experiments aimed at understanding thermal counterflow turbulence in dilute-gas BECs.
Bose-Einstein condensates (BECs), with their superfluid behavior, quantized vortices, and high-level of control over trap geometry and other system parameters provide a compelling environment for studies of quantum fluid dynamics. Recently there has been an influx of theoretical and numerical progress in understanding the superfluid dynamics associated with two-dimensional quantum turbulence, with expectations that complementary experiments will soon be realized. In this dissertation I present progress in the development of an experimental toolkit that will enable such experimental studies of two-dimensional quantum turbulence. My approach to developing this toolkit has been twofold: first, efforts aimed at the development of experimental techniques for generating large disordered vortex distributions within a BEC; and second, efforts directed towards the design, implementation, and characterization of a quantum vortex microscope. Quantum turbulence in a superfluid is generally regarded as a disordered tangle of quantized vortices in three dimensions, or a disordered planar distribution of quantized vortices in two dimensions. However, not all vortex distributions, even large disordered ones, are expected to exhibit robust signatures of quantum turbulence. Identification and development of techniques for controlled forcing or initialization of turbulent vortex distributions is now underway. In this dissertation, I will discuss experimental techniques that were examined during the course of my dissertation research, namely generation of large disordered distributions of vortices, and progress towards injecting clusters of vortices into a BEC. Complimentary to vortex generation is the need to image these vortex distributions. The nondeterministic nature of quantum turbulence and other far-from-equilibrium superfluid dynamics requires the development of new imaging techniques that allow one to obtain information about vortex dynamics from a single BEC. To this end, the first vortex microscope constructed as part of my dissertation research enabled the first in situ images of quantized vortices in a single-component BEC, obtained without prior expansion. I have further developed and characterized a second vortex microscope, which has enabled the acquisition of multiple in situ images of a lattice of vortex cores, as well as the acquisition of single in situ images of vortex cores in a BEC confined in a weak hybrid trap. In this dissertation, I will discuss the state-of-the-art of imaging vortices and other superfluid phenomena in the University of Arizona BEC lab, as indicated by the examined performance of the quantum vortex microscope.
Turbulence in classical fluids has been the subject of scientific study for centuries, yet there is still no complete general theory of classical turbulence connecting microscopic physics to macroscopic fluid flows, and this remains one of the open problems in physics. In contrast, the phenomenon of quantum turbulence in superfluids has well-defined theoretical descriptions, based on first principles and microscopic physics, and represents a realm of physics that can connect the classical and quantum worlds. Studies of quantum turbulence may thus be viewed as a path for progress on the long-standing problem of turbulence.A dilute-gas Bose-Einstein condensate (BEC) is, in most cases, a superfluid that supports quantized vortices, the primary structural elements of quantum turbulence. BECs are particularly convenient systems for the study of vortices, as standard techniques allow the microscopic structure and dynamics of the vortices to be investigated. Vortices in BECs can be created and manipulated using a variety of techniques, hence BECs are potentially powerful systems for the microscopic study of quantum turbulence.This dissertation focuses on quantized vortices in BECs, specifically experimental and numerical studies of their formation, dynamics, and decay, in an effort to understand the microscopic nature of vortices as elements of quantum turbulence. Four main experiments were performed, and are described in the main chapters of this dissertation, after introductions to vortices, experimental methods, and turbulence are presented. These experiments were aimed at understanding various aspects of how vortices are created and behave in a superfluid system. They involved vortex dipole nucleation in the breakdown of superfluidity, persistent current generation from a turbulent state in the presence of energy dissipation, decay of angular momentum of a BEC due to trapping potential impurities, and exploration of the spontaneous formation of vortices during the BEC phase transition. These experiments represent progress towards enhanced understanding of the formation, dynamics, and decay of vortices in BECs and thus may be foundational to more general studies of quantum turbulence in superfluids.
The presence of quantized vortices and a high level of control over trap geometries and other system parameters make dilute-gas Bose-Einstein condensates (BECs) a natural environment for studies of vortex dynamics and quantum turbulence in superfluids, primary interests of the BEC group at the University of Arizona. Such research may lead to deeper understanding of the nature of quantum fluid dynamics and far-from-equilbrium phenomena.Despite the importance of quantized vortex dynamics in the fields of superfluidity, superconductivity and quantum turbulence, direct imaging of vortices in trapped BECs remains a significant technical challenge. This is primarily due to the small size of the vortex core in a trapped gas, which is typically a few hundred nanometers in diameter. In this dissertation I present the design and construction of a new ^87Rb BEC apparatus with the goal of studying vortex dynamics in trapped BECs. The heart of the apparatus is a compact vacuum chamber with a custom, all-glass science cell designed to accommodate the use of commercial high-numerical-aperture microscope objectives for in situ imaging of vortices.The designs for the new system are, in part, based on prior work in our group on in situ imaging of vortices. Here I review aspects of our prior work and discuss some of the successes and limitations that are relevant to the new apparatus. The bulk of the thesis is used to described the major subsystems of the new apparatus which include the vacuum chamber, the laser systems, the magnetic transfer system and the final magnetic trap for the atoms. Finally, I demonstrate the creation of a BEC of ~2x10^6 ^87Rb atoms in our new system and show that the BEC can be transferred into a weak, spherical, magnetic trap with a well defined magnetic field axis that may be useful for future vortex imaging studies.
Dilute gas Bose-Einstein condensates (BECs) provide unique and powerful experimental platforms to study fluid turbulence. Some aspects of BEC hydrodynamics are specific to atomic quantum fluids such as quantized vortices and flexible trapping geometries. However, there are features of turbulence that are universal and simpler to understand in such systems. BECs are also of interest in fundamental physics in their own right and a rich synthesis of theory and experiment has yielded powerful numerical methods to simulate and study BEC dynamics. In this dissertation I present two experiments, one conducted and one proposed, describing novel aspects of the generation and detection of vorticity in Bose-Einstein condensates. Models of BEC dynamics at zero temperature are provided by the Gross-Pitaevskii equation. Simple and fast numerical solutions of this equation have yielded a wealth of literature. However, in experimental reality the atomic ensemble exists at a finite temperature and consists of a BEC coexisting with a thermal cloud of non-condensed atoms. The interaction between the condensate and the thermal fraction yields rich and complex physics that require more advanced models. We present an experiment demonstrating the relaxation dynamics of a BEC in a rotating trap perturbed by a repulsive laser barrier. The data provided by this experiment are valuable to further development of theoretical models that incorporate interactions between the BEC and noncondensed atoms. In the field of quantum fluid dynamics, an experimental method to determine the position and circulation of vortices is a highly sought-after capability. Onsager's point-vortex model of turbulence completely determines the kinetic energy spectrum of an incompressible fluid by these degrees of freedom. We present proof-of-principle simulations that describe a new method of spatially sampling the velocity field of a two-dimensional BEC by using an optical lattice analogously to a Shack-Hartmann Wavefront Sensor. Extracting vortex information from the appropriately sampled velocity field can be accomplished either qualitatively or with detection algorithms. This method requires minimal experimental infrastructure and is generally applicable across atomic species. The implications of measuring a condensate velocity field are broad and these initial results provide the first step towards realizing a valuable tool in BEC physics.
Abstract Chapter 5 delves into quantum turbulence in superfluid helium and atomic Bose-Einstein condensates (BECs). The foundation of quantum turbulence research lies in classical fluid dynamics and turbulence, which is why we begin by covering essential concepts like the Reynolds number and Kolmogorov’s -5/3 power law in the energy spectrum. These principles are crucial for understanding quantum turbulence. We then explore the shared aspects of quantum turbulence in superfluid helium and atomic BECs, such as the differences in vortex configurations compared to classical turbulence, energy spectra, cascades, and the distinction between quasiclassical (Kolmogorov) and ultraquantum (Vinen) turbulence, focusing on their decay behaviors. In superfluid helium, we emphasize experimental studies in thermal counterflow and numerical simulations using the Vortex Filament Model (VFM). The advent of visualization experiments in the mid-2000s was transformative, allowing the observation of normal fluid velocity profiles and accelerations via tracer particles, which led to more accurate simulations coupling the VFM with normal fluid dynamics. Another significant topic is the energy spectrum of quantum turbulence, and whether it mirrors classical turbulence remains a key question. In addition to thermal counterflow, localized quantum turbulence generated by oscillating objects has been a major area of study. We present research showing how quantized vortices grow and evolve into turbulence. Superfluid 3He-B also provides a platform for quantum turbulence, with advancements in microfabrication bringing MEMS and NEMS into focus for studying quantum hydrodynamics at micro- and nanoscale, influenced by boundary conditions. In atomic BECs, confined by potentials, turbulence is induced through techniques like shaking or moving potentials. A unique aspect of BECs is two-dimensional quantum turbulence, featuring inverse energy cascades, Onsager vortices, and negative temperature states. Finally, atomic BECs, being compressible, serve as a platform for both vortex and wave turbulence. Multicomponent BECs, such as spinor BECs, introduce spin turbulence, further diversifying the field.
In this thesis we have basically studied two aspects of BoseEinstein condensation (BEC) in trapped dilute gases: (i) superfluidity with the possible onset of quantum turbulence (QT), and (ii) nonuniformity, which suggests the definition of new variables in order to build a global thermodynamic description. Both analyses were performed in a 87Rb BEC magnetically trapped in a QuadrupoleIoffe configuration (QUIC) trap. Concerning the first item, vortices and QT were generated by applying an oscillatory excitation formed by a quadrupole magnetic field superimposed onto the QUIC trapping potential. Scanning both the excitation amplitude and its duration allowed us to observe different regimes, particularly one with regular, welldefined vortices and another, where the onset of QT is believed to have occurred. The transition between this two regimes were explained by considering the finitesize characteristic of trapped gases. Additionally, data analyses on three vortex configurations suggested the presence of both vortices and antivortices (opposite circulation sign), and the vortex nucleation mechanism was proposed to be related to a relative motion between the condensate and thermal components, namely a counterflow. As for the second item, the BEC transition in our experiment was characterized in terms of new global thermodynamic variables. A phase diagram was constructed and compared to the superfluid helium phase transition. Finally, we provide preliminary results on the calculation of a global heat capacity, and briefly discuss the advantages of this new approach over the local density approximation alternative, particularly on BEC clouds in the presence of vortices and QT.