Introduction Indefinite causal structure poses particular problems for theory formulation since many of the core ideas used in the usual approaches to theory construction depend on having definite causal structure. For example, the notion of a state across space evolving in time requires that we have some definite causal structure so we can define a state on a space-like hypersurface. We will see that many of these problems are mitigated if we are able to formulate the theory in a formalism-local (or F-local) fashion. A formulation of a physical theory is said to be F-local if, in making predictions for any given arbitrary space-time region, we need only refer to mathematical objects pertaining to that region. This is a desirable property both on the grounds of efficiency and since, if we have indefinite causal structure, it is not clear how to select some other space-time region on which our calculations may depend. The usual ways of formulating physical theories (the time-evolving state picture, the histories approach, and the local-equations approach) are not F-local. We set up a framework for probabilistic theories with indefinite causal structure. This, the causaloid framework, is F-local. We describe how quantum theory can be formulated in the causaloid framework (in an F-local fashion). This provides yet another formulation of quantum theory. This formulation, however, may be particularly relevant to the problem of finding a theory of quantum gravity. The problem of quantum gravity is to find a theory that reduces in appropriate limits to general relativity and quantum theory (including, at least, those situations in which those two theories have been experimentally confirmed).
In 1948, Schwinger developed a local Lorentz-covariant formulation of relativistic quantum electrodynamics in space-time which is fundamentally inconsistent with any delocalized interpretation of quantum mechanics. An interpretation compatible with Schwinger’s theory is presented, which reproduces all of the standard empirical predictions of conventional delocalized quantum theory in configuration space. This is an explicit, unambiguous, and Lorentz-covariant “local hidden variable theory” in space-time, whose existence proves definitively that such theories are possible. This does not conflict with Bell’s theorem because it is a local many-worlds theory. Each physical system is characterized by a wave-field, which is a set of indexed piece-wise single-particle wavefunctions in space-time, each with its own coefficient, along with a memory which contains the separate local Hilbert-space quantum state at each event in space-time. Each single-particle wavefunction of a fundamental system describes the motion of a portion of a conserved fluid in space-time, with the fluid decomposing into many classical point particles, each following a world-line and recording a local memory. Local interactions between two systems take the form of local boundary conditions between the differently indexed pieces of those systems’ wave-fields, with new indexes encoding each orthogonal outcome of the interaction. The general machinery is introduced, including the local mechanisms for entanglement and interference. The experience of collapse, Born rule probability, and environmental decoherence are discussed, and a number of illustrative examples are given.
Detection times are routinely recorded in quantum experiments. We show that, under natural covariance and consistency requirements, the observables describing these times cannot be algebraically localized in any bounded spacetime region, even when the records themselves are localized. This challenges the identification of algebraic localization with the physical localization of measurements and shows why microcausality alone does not establish non-signalling for measurements in quantum field theory.
Relativistic quantum theory is formulated as a theory of successive local observations, consistent with all the fundamental requirements of relativistic invariance. Based on the causal structure of the space–time of special relativity, it is argued that the nonrelativistic notion of a ’’time-ordered sequence of instantaneous observations’’should be replaced in a relativistic theory by the notion of a ’’causally ordered sequence of local observations.’’ The fundamental statistical law of relativistic quantum theory is then formulated such that it provides an unambigous prescription for the statistical correlations between the outcomes of any causally ordered sequence of local observations. It is also shown that the fundamental statistical law of the theory is consistent with the so-called ’’principle of local causes’’ which essentially states that the probability connections between a set of local events do not depend on local observations carried out in space–time regions which lie outside of their causal past. Finally, an equivalent formulation of the theory in terms of a relativistically covariant generalization of the collapse postulate is presented.