Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Journal of Physics Conference Series

Connections between ’t Hooft’s beables and canonical descriptions of dissipative systems

Dieter Schuch, Massimo Blasone

Published Aug 1, 2017• 5 citations
Publisher

Abstract

According to a proposal by 't Hooft, information loss introduced by constraints in certain classical dissipative systems may lead to quantization. This scheme can be realized within the Bateman model of two coupled oscillators, one damped and one accelerated. In this paper we analyze the links of this approach to effective Hamiltonians where the environmental degrees of freedom do not appear explicitly but their effect leads to the same friction force appearing in the Bateman model. In particular, it is shown that by imposing constraints, the Bateman Hamiltonian can be transformed into an effective one expressed in expanding coordinates. This one can be transformed via a canonical transformation into Caldirola and Kanai's effective Hamiltonian that can be linked to the conventional system-plus-reservoir approach, for example, in a form used by Caldeira and Leggett.

DOI
10.1088/1742-6596/880/1/012050

Related papers

Connecting dissipation and noncommutativity: A Bateman system case study

Sayan Kumar Pal, Partha Nandi, Biswajit Chakraborty

We present an approach to the problem of quantization of the damped harmonic oscillator. To start with, we adopt the standard method of doubling the degrees of freedom of the system (Bateman form) and then, by introducing some new parameters, we get a generalized coupled set of equations from the Bateman form. Using the corresponding time-independent Lagrangian, quantum effects on a pair of Bateman oscillators embedded in an ambient noncommutative space (Moyal plane) are analyzed by using both path integral and canonical quantization schemes within the framework of the Hilbert--Schmidt operator formulation. Our method is distinct from those existing in the literature and where the ambient space was taken to be commutative. Our quantization shows that we end up again with a Bateman system except that the damping factor undergoes renormalization. Strikingly, the corresponding expression shows that the renormalized damping factor can be nonzero even if ``bare'' one is zero to begin with. In other words, noncommutativity can act as a source of dissipation. Conversely, the noncommutative parameter $\ensuremath{\theta}$, taken to be a free one now, can be fine tuned to get a vanishing renormalized damping factor. This indicates in some sense a ``duality'' between dissipation and noncommutativity. Our results match the existing results in the commutative limit.

arXiv:1803.03334•Physical Review A•Jun 11, 2018•17 citations

Effective description of the dissipative interaction between simple model-systems and their environment

Dieter Schuch

Chemical reactions are generally connected with energy transfer between reactands and their environment. There are different ways of taking this environment into account. The traditional system-plus-reservoir (S+R) approach couples the relevant system to a large number of environmental degrees of freedom, represented, e.g., by harmonic oscillators. However, this has the disadvantage—from a computational point of view—that a system of many coupled differential equations has to be solved due to the large number of degrees of freedom of the reservoir. The number of degrees of freedom can be drastically reduced if an effective description of the interaction between system and reservoir is applied. On the quantum mechanical level, the effect of the environment can be included, e.g., by the use of explicitly time-dependent Hamiltonians or nonlinear additions to the Schrödinger equation (SE). An advantage of the former method is the preservation of the canonical formalism and the linearity of the theory as well as the fact that its operators can be derived directly from the S+R approach. Therefore, it seems to be even more of a paradox that this method apparently violates the uncertainty principle. This violation does not occur in the nonlinear approaches but the nonlinearity seems, at first sight, to be problematic. However, it can be shown that a particular logarithmic nonlinear SE is equivalent to the approach using the time-dependent Hamiltonian and can be transformed into this. The fact that this transformation is nonunitary provides the key for the solution of the paradox and also allows one to show the equivalence of all three of the above-mentioned approaches. In investigating the classical counterpart, a noncanonical transformation is used between the dissipative physical level and the canonical formal level, which makes it even possible to transform the physical interacting system into a formal isolated system that can be treated in the conventional way. As a result, the effect of the interaction with the environment can be taken into account classically by noncanonical transformations and quantum mechanically by nonunitary transformations. ©1999 John Wiley & Sons, Inc. Int J Quant Chem 72: 537–547, 1999

International Journal of Quantum Chemistry•Jan 1, 1999•30 citations

A round trip from Caldirola to Bateman systems

Julio Guerrero, Francisco F. López-Ruiz, V. Aldaya +1 more

For the quantum Caldirola-Kanai Hamiltonian, describing a quantum damped harmonic oscillator, a couple of constant of motion operators generating the Heisenberg algebra can be found. The inclusion in this algebra, in a unitary manner, of the standard time evolution generator , which is not a constant of motion, requires a non-trivial extension of this basic algebra and the physical system itself, which now includes a new dual particle. This enlarged algebra, when exponentiated, leads to a group, named the Bateman group, which admits unitary representations with support in the Hilbert space of functions satisfying the Schrodinger equation associated with the quantum Bateman Hamiltonian, either as a second order differential operator as well as a first order one. The classical Bateman Hamiltonian describes a dual system of a damped (losing energy) particle and a dual (gaining energy) particle. The classical Bateman system has a solution submanifold containing the trajectories of the original system as a submanifold. When restricted to this submanifold, the Bateman dual classical Hamiltonian leads to the Caldirola-Kanai Hamiltonian for a single damped particle. This construction can also be done at the quantum level, and the Caldirola-Kanai Hamiltonian operator can be derived from the Bateman Hamiltonian operator when appropriate constraints are imposed.

Journal of Physics Conference Series•Mar 1, 2011•8 citations

The Quantum Arnold Transformation for the damped harmonic oscillator: from the Caldirola-Kanai model toward the Bateman model

Francisco F. López-Ruiz, Julio Guerrero, V. Aldaya +1 more

Using a quantum version of the Arnold transformation of classical mechanics, all quantum dynamical systems whose classical equations of motion are non-homogeneous linear second-order ordinary differential equations (LSODE), including systems with friction linear in velocity such as the damped harmonic oscillator, can be related to the quantum free-particle dynamical system. This implies that symmetries and simple computations in the free particle can be exported to the LSODE-system. The quantum Arnold transformation is given explicitly for the damped harmonic oscillator, and an algebraic connection between the Caldirola-Kanai model for the damped harmonic oscillator and the Bateman system will be sketched out.

Journal of Physics Conference Series•Aug 24, 2012•0 citations

A symmetry trip from Caldirola to Bateman damped systems

V. Aldaya, Cossío, F., Julio Guerrero +1 more

For the Caldirola-Kanai system, describing a quantum damped harmonic oscillator, a couple of constant-of-motion operators generating the Heisenberg algebra can be found. The inclusion of the standard time evolution symmetry in this algebra for damped systems, in a unitary manner, requires a non-trivial extension of this basic algebra and hence the physical system itself. Surprisingly, this extension leads directly to the so-called Bateman's dual system, which now includes a new particle acting as an energy reservoir. The group of symmetries of the dual system is presented, as well as a quantization that implies, in particular, a first-order Schrödinger equation. The usual second-order equation and the inclusion of the original Caldirola-Kanai model in Bateman's system are also discussed.

arXiv:1102.0990•Feb 4, 2011•2 citations

Symmetries of the quantum damped harmonic oscillator

J Guerrero, Francisco F. López-Ruiz, V. Aldaya +1 more

For the non-conservative Caldirola–Kanai system, describing a quantum damped harmonic oscillator, a couple of constant-of-motion operators generating the Heisenberg–Weyl algebra can be found. The inclusion of the standard time evolution generator (which is not a symmetry) as a symmetry in this algebra, in a unitary manner, requires a non-trivial extension of this basic algebra and hence of the physical system itself. Surprisingly, this extension leads directly to the so-called Bateman dual system, which now includes a new particle acting as an energy reservoir. In addition, the Caldirola–Kanai dissipative system can be retrieved by imposing constraints. The algebra of symmetries of the dual system is presented, as well as a quantization that implies, in particular, a first-order Schrödinger equation. As opposed to other approaches, where it is claimed that the spectrum of the Bateman Hamiltonian is complex and discrete, we obtain that it is real and continuous, with infinite degeneracy in all regimes.

arXiv:1210.4058•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Nov 8, 2012•15 citations
According to a proposal by 't Hooft, information loss introduced by constraints in certain classical dissipative systems may lead to quantization. This scheme can be realized within the Bateman model of two coupled oscillators, one damped and one accelerated. In this paper we analyze the links of this approach to effective Hamiltonians where the environmental degrees of freedom do not appear explicitly but their effect leads to the same friction force appearing in the Bateman model. In particular, it is shown that by imposing constraints, the Bateman Hamiltonian can be transformed into an effective one expressed in expanding coordinates. This one can be transformed via a canonical transformation into Caldirola and Kanai's effective Hamiltonian that can be linked to the conventional system-plus-reservoir approach, for example, in a form used by Caldeira and Leggett.
We present an approach to the problem of quantization of the damped harmonic oscillator. To start with, we adopt the standard method of doubling the degrees of freedom of the system (Bateman form) and then, by introducing some new parameters, we get a generalized coupled set of equations from the Bateman form. Using the corresponding time-independent Lagrangian, quantum effects on a pair of Bateman oscillators embedded in an ambient noncommutative space (Moyal plane) are analyzed by using both path integral and canonical quantization schemes within the framework of the Hilbert--Schmidt operator formulation. Our method is distinct from those existing in the literature and where the ambient space was taken to be commutative. Our quantization shows that we end up again with a Bateman system except that the damping factor undergoes renormalization. Strikingly, the corresponding expression shows that the renormalized damping factor can be nonzero even if ``bare'' one is zero to begin with. In other words, noncommutativity can act as a source of dissipation. Conversely, the noncommutative parameter $\ensuremath{\theta}$, taken to be a free one now, can be fine tuned to get a vanishing renormalized damping factor. This indicates in some sense a ``duality'' between dissipation and noncommutativity. Our results match the existing results in the commutative limit.
Chemical reactions are generally connected with energy transfer between reactands and their environment. There are different ways of taking this environment into account. The traditional system-plus-reservoir (S+R) approach couples the relevant system to a large number of environmental degrees of freedom, represented, e.g., by harmonic oscillators. However, this has the disadvantage—from a computational point of view—that a system of many coupled differential equations has to be solved due to the large number of degrees of freedom of the reservoir. The number of degrees of freedom can be drastically reduced if an effective description of the interaction between system and reservoir is applied. On the quantum mechanical level, the effect of the environment can be included, e.g., by the use of explicitly time-dependent Hamiltonians or nonlinear additions to the Schrödinger equation (SE). An advantage of the former method is the preservation of the canonical formalism and the linearity of the theory as well as the fact that its operators can be derived directly from the S+R approach. Therefore, it seems to be even more of a paradox that this method apparently violates the uncertainty principle. This violation does not occur in the nonlinear approaches but the nonlinearity seems, at first sight, to be problematic. However, it can be shown that a particular logarithmic nonlinear SE is equivalent to the approach using the time-dependent Hamiltonian and can be transformed into this. The fact that this transformation is nonunitary provides the key for the solution of the paradox and also allows one to show the equivalence of all three of the above-mentioned approaches. In investigating the classical counterpart, a noncanonical transformation is used between the dissipative physical level and the canonical formal level, which makes it even possible to transform the physical interacting system into a formal isolated system that can be treated in the conventional way. As a result, the effect of the interaction with the environment can be taken into account classically by noncanonical transformations and quantum mechanically by nonunitary transformations. ©1999 John Wiley & Sons, Inc. Int J Quant Chem 72: 537–547, 1999
For the quantum Caldirola-Kanai Hamiltonian, describing a quantum damped harmonic oscillator, a couple of constant of motion operators generating the Heisenberg algebra can be found. The inclusion in this algebra, in a unitary manner, of the standard time evolution generator , which is not a constant of motion, requires a non-trivial extension of this basic algebra and the physical system itself, which now includes a new dual particle. This enlarged algebra, when exponentiated, leads to a group, named the Bateman group, which admits unitary representations with support in the Hilbert space of functions satisfying the Schrodinger equation associated with the quantum Bateman Hamiltonian, either as a second order differential operator as well as a first order one. The classical Bateman Hamiltonian describes a dual system of a damped (losing energy) particle and a dual (gaining energy) particle. The classical Bateman system has a solution submanifold containing the trajectories of the original system as a submanifold. When restricted to this submanifold, the Bateman dual classical Hamiltonian leads to the Caldirola-Kanai Hamiltonian for a single damped particle. This construction can also be done at the quantum level, and the Caldirola-Kanai Hamiltonian operator can be derived from the Bateman Hamiltonian operator when appropriate constraints are imposed.
Using a quantum version of the Arnold transformation of classical mechanics, all quantum dynamical systems whose classical equations of motion are non-homogeneous linear second-order ordinary differential equations (LSODE), including systems with friction linear in velocity such as the damped harmonic oscillator, can be related to the quantum free-particle dynamical system. This implies that symmetries and simple computations in the free particle can be exported to the LSODE-system. The quantum Arnold transformation is given explicitly for the damped harmonic oscillator, and an algebraic connection between the Caldirola-Kanai model for the damped harmonic oscillator and the Bateman system will be sketched out.
For the Caldirola-Kanai system, describing a quantum damped harmonic oscillator, a couple of constant-of-motion operators generating the Heisenberg algebra can be found. The inclusion of the standard time evolution symmetry in this algebra for damped systems, in a unitary manner, requires a non-trivial extension of this basic algebra and hence the physical system itself. Surprisingly, this extension leads directly to the so-called Bateman's dual system, which now includes a new particle acting as an energy reservoir. The group of symmetries of the dual system is presented, as well as a quantization that implies, in particular, a first-order Schrödinger equation. The usual second-order equation and the inclusion of the original Caldirola-Kanai model in Bateman's system are also discussed.
For the non-conservative Caldirola–Kanai system, describing a quantum damped harmonic oscillator, a couple of constant-of-motion operators generating the Heisenberg–Weyl algebra can be found. The inclusion of the standard time evolution generator (which is not a symmetry) as a symmetry in this algebra, in a unitary manner, requires a non-trivial extension of this basic algebra and hence of the physical system itself. Surprisingly, this extension leads directly to the so-called Bateman dual system, which now includes a new particle acting as an energy reservoir. In addition, the Caldirola–Kanai dissipative system can be retrieved by imposing constraints. The algebra of symmetries of the dual system is presented, as well as a quantization that implies, in particular, a first-order Schrödinger equation. As opposed to other approaches, where it is claimed that the spectrum of the Bateman Hamiltonian is complex and discrete, we obtain that it is real and continuous, with infinite degeneracy in all regimes.