Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Why the Quantum?

Eric G. Cavalcanti

Published Jul 14, 2017• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

One of the burning questions within quantum foundations is “Why the Quantum?” — what makes quantum theory special, singling it out from the space of possible theories?
DOI
10.22331/qv-2017-07-14-2

Related papers

Why Physics Needs Quantum Foundations

Lucién Hardy, Robert W. Spekkens

We discuss the motivation for pursuing research on the foundations of quantum theory.

arXiv:1003.5008•Mar 25, 2010•57 citations

Operational theories and categorical quantum mechanics

Samson Abramsky, Chris Heunen

. A central theme in current work in quantum information and quantum foundations is to see quantum mechanics as occupying one point in a space of possible theories, and to use this perspective to understand the special features and properties which single it out, and the possibilities for alternative theories. Two formalisms which have been used in this context are operational theories , and categorical quantum mechanics . The aim of the present paper is to establish strong connections between these two formalisms. We show how models of categorical quantum mechanics have representations as operational theories. We then show how non-locality can be formulated at this level of generality, and study a number of examples from this point of view, including Hilbert spaces, sets and relations, and stochastic maps. The local, quantum, and no-signalling models are characterized in these terms. Introduction. A central theme in current work in quantum information and quantum foundations is to see quantum mechanics as occupying one point in a space of possible theories, and to use this perspective to understand the special features and properties which single it out, and the possibilities for alternative theories. Two formalisms which have been used in this context are operational theories [48, 41, 52, 47], and categorical quantum mechanics [6, 7]. • Operational theories allow general formulations of results in quantum foundations and quantum information [11, 12, 10]. They also play a prominent rôle in current work on axiomatizations of quantum mechanics [36, 19, 49, 25]. • Categorical quantum mechanics enables a high-level approach to quantum information and quantum foundations, which can be presented in terms of string-diagram representations of structures in monoidal categories [7]. This has proved very effective in providing a conceptually illuminating and technically powerful perspective on a range of topics, including quantum protocols [6], entanglement [24], measurement-based quantum computing [29], no-cloning [1], and non-locality [22]. The aim of the present paper is to establish strong connections between these two formalisms. We shall begin by reviewing operational theories. We then show how a proper formulation of compound systems within the operational framework leads to a view of operational theories as representations of monoidal categories of a particular form. We call these operational representations .

arXiv:1206.0921•Cambridge University Press eBooks•Feb 26, 2016•35 citations

Foundations of Quantum Mechanics

Robert W. Spekkens

The field of quantum foundations seeks to answer questions such as: What do the elements of the mathematical formalism of quantum theory represent? From what physical principles can the formalism be derived? What are the precise ways in which a quantum world differs from a classical world and other possible worlds? These lectures will cover some important foundational topics which touch upon these questions, in particular, operational and realist interpretations of the formalism, the quantum measurement problem, nonlocality and contextuality.

•Jan 1, 2016•0 citations

The Purification Principle

Giacomo Mauro D’Ariano, Giulio Chiribella, Paolo Perinotti

What makes quantum theory so special? Everyone has an opinion on that: one can point at entanglement, non-locality, complementarity, uncertainty, and many other features. In a trivial sense, every answer is legitimate: every feature in which quantum theory differs from other familiar theories can be taken as the distinctive feature, because it allows you to tell quantum theory apart from what you already know. But this would not take you very far. The real question is not how to distinguish quantum theory from theories that you already know, but how to distinguish it from all theories that you could possibly imagine. Most features are not good at that – for example, physicists have invented many toy theories that exhibit entanglement, non-locality, and complementarity and still are not quantum theory. In this chapter we put forward our answer to the question of what makes quantum theory special: purification. In the following, we will explore some of the most fundamental facts about quantum theory, like entanglement and teleportation, connecting purification with a deep stream of thought that goes back to Schrödinger and von Neumann. The results presented in this chapter are also a first example of how one can reason on quantum theory starting from first principles.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Nov 2, 2016•0 citations

1 What is quantum theory?

Michael Springborg, Meijuan Zhou

De Gruyter eBooks•Aug 23, 2021•0 citations

New logical perspectives on physics

Johan van Benthem, Sonja Smets

This special issue is situated at the interface between Logic and the Foundations of Physics.This interface, though not as active as the logical foundations of mathematics, has long existed-with highlights such as "quantum logic", or studies of the general logical structure of physical theories.In recent years, more themes have come to the fore, and we may be witnessing a revival.The papers presented here emanate from a symposium held at the University of Utrecht in January 2008 with the aim of charting established as well as new connections between the two fields.One of the main questions discussed was whether and how modern techniques coming from logic, computer science and information theory might be combined with state-of-the-art insights in the philosophy of physics to gain a better understanding of the main foundational issues and open problems in modern physics.The success of this symposium has shown that there are several possible answers to this question.

Synthese•Apr 21, 2011•1 citation
. A central theme in current work in quantum information and quantum foundations is to see quantum mechanics as occupying one point in a space of possible theories, and to use this perspective to understand the special features and properties which single it out, and the possibilities for alternative theories. Two formalisms which have been used in this context are operational theories , and categorical quantum mechanics . The aim of the present paper is to establish strong connections between these two formalisms. We show how models of categorical quantum mechanics have representations as operational theories. We then show how non-locality can be formulated at this level of generality, and study a number of examples from this point of view, including Hilbert spaces, sets and relations, and stochastic maps. The local, quantum, and no-signalling models are characterized in these terms. Introduction. A central theme in current work in quantum information and quantum foundations is to see quantum mechanics as occupying one point in a space of possible theories, and to use this perspective to understand the special features and properties which single it out, and the possibilities for alternative theories. Two formalisms which have been used in this context are operational theories [48, 41, 52, 47], and categorical quantum mechanics [6, 7]. • Operational theories allow general formulations of results in quantum foundations and quantum information [11, 12, 10]. They also play a prominent rôle in current work on axiomatizations of quantum mechanics [36, 19, 49, 25]. • Categorical quantum mechanics enables a high-level approach to quantum information and quantum foundations, which can be presented in terms of string-diagram representations of structures in monoidal categories [7]. This has proved very effective in providing a conceptually illuminating and technically powerful perspective on a range of topics, including quantum protocols [6], entanglement [24], measurement-based quantum computing [29], no-cloning [1], and non-locality [22]. The aim of the present paper is to establish strong connections between these two formalisms. We shall begin by reviewing operational theories. We then show how a proper formulation of compound systems within the operational framework leads to a view of operational theories as representations of monoidal categories of a particular form. We call these operational representations .
The field of quantum foundations seeks to answer questions such as: What do the elements of the mathematical formalism of quantum theory represent? From what physical principles can the formalism be derived? What are the precise ways in which a quantum world differs from a classical world and other possible worlds? These lectures will cover some important foundational topics which touch upon these questions, in particular, operational and realist interpretations of the formalism, the quantum measurement problem, nonlocality and contextuality.
What makes quantum theory so special? Everyone has an opinion on that: one can point at entanglement, non-locality, complementarity, uncertainty, and many other features. In a trivial sense, every answer is legitimate: every feature in which quantum theory differs from other familiar theories can be taken as the distinctive feature, because it allows you to tell quantum theory apart from what you already know. But this would not take you very far. The real question is not how to distinguish quantum theory from theories that you already know, but how to distinguish it from all theories that you could possibly imagine. Most features are not good at that – for example, physicists have invented many toy theories that exhibit entanglement, non-locality, and complementarity and still are not quantum theory. In this chapter we put forward our answer to the question of what makes quantum theory special: purification. In the following, we will explore some of the most fundamental facts about quantum theory, like entanglement and teleportation, connecting purification with a deep stream of thought that goes back to Schrödinger and von Neumann. The results presented in this chapter are also a first example of how one can reason on quantum theory starting from first principles.
This special issue is situated at the interface between Logic and the Foundations of Physics.This interface, though not as active as the logical foundations of mathematics, has long existed-with highlights such as "quantum logic", or studies of the general logical structure of physical theories.In recent years, more themes have come to the fore, and we may be witnessing a revival.The papers presented here emanate from a symposium held at the University of Utrecht in January 2008 with the aim of charting established as well as new connections between the two fields.One of the main questions discussed was whether and how modern techniques coming from logic, computer science and information theory might be combined with state-of-the-art insights in the philosophy of physics to gain a better understanding of the main foundational issues and open problems in modern physics.The success of this symposium has shown that there are several possible answers to this question.