Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Bulletin of the Georgia Academy of Science

Systems Exhibiting Alternative Futures

Ronald E. Mickens, Charmayne Patterson

Published Jan 1, 2017• 0 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

We construct an explicit example of a physical system having alternative futures (AFs). Several other such systems are also introduced and characterized, but not discussed in detail. Our major goal is to use these results to demonstrate the existence and meaning of the concept of counterfactual histories (CFHs). We find that any system having AFs will also exhibit the phenomenon of CFHs.

Related papers

Counterfactual History is Consistent with Physics

Charmayne Patterson, Ronald E. Mickens

Bulletin of the American Physical Society•Mar 16, 2017•2 citations

Alternate Futures

Ronald E. Mickens

This chapter describes a model certain aspects of human interactions and experiences with the physical universe. It introduces and examines the concepts of alternative futures and counterfactual histories. The essential purpose of the chapter is to give arguments for the proposition that alternative futures can exist. A very interacting, but important issue to note is that the presented general arguments do not depend on whether the systems satisfy classical or quantum physical laws. A branch or trajectory on the outcome tree gives a particular sequence of flippings. The different motions or movements occur within the confines of a bounded space. Counterfactual histories are defined as possible histories of a system that were not in fact actualized. The only requirement is that it be at least two. In the general, the value of the “splittings” may change from one interaction to another.

Chapman & Hall/CRC eBooks•Mar 24, 2022•0 citations

COUNTERFACTUAL HISTORIES OCCUR IN CLASSICAL PHYSICS

Ronald E. Mickens, Charmayne Patterson

Bulletin of the Georgia Academy of Science•Jan 1, 2017•0 citations

What Would It be Like to be Bohmians? Experiencing a Gestalt Switch in Physics as an Effect of Path Dependence

Léna Soler

The philosophical goal is to characterize ‘path dependence’ (PAD) in science by comparison to PAD in technology where the concept was initially introduced. I rely on quantum mechanics to substantiate the analyses, exploiting the contrast between standard versus Bohmian quantum physics (NQP/BQP). To achieve the goal, counterfactual history is mobilized as a means to generate instructive virtual alternatives to the actual scientific path: I design a ‘permuted-situations counterfactual scenario’ in which it is BQP, instead of NQP, that first acquires a monopoly on physics and is exclusively practiced in science education, before NQP is introduced. Then, I endeavor to ‘reenact’ – as forensic investigators carry out the re-enactment of a crime scene – how virtual mainstream Bohmians would assess NQP. Contrasting the two ‘views from inside’ – ‘what it is like to be’ a standard quantum physicist in our world (a physicist trained in NQP) and what it would be like to be a physicist exclusively trained in BQP – I attempt to come as close as possible to an ‘experience’ of the gestalt switch involved when shuttling back and forth between one scientific worldview to the other. The effects of PAD in physics are discussed on this basis.

Social Epistemology•Jul 11, 2023•2 citations

On Hegerfeldt's paradox

Ludger Hannibal

The acausal behavior of relativistic states exhibited by Hegerfeldt is shown not to be present in physical systems described by first order in time evolution equations.

arXiv:quant-ph/9511006•Nov 7, 1995•1 citation

Counterfactual computation revisited

Onur Hosten, Matthew T. Rakher, Julio T. Barreiro +2 more

Mitchison and Jozsa recently suggested that the "chained-Zeno" counterfactual computation protocol recently proposed by Hosten et al. is counterfactual for only one output of the computer. This claim was based on the existing abstract algebraic definition of counterfactual computation, and indeed according to this definition, their argument is correct. However, a more general definition (physically adequate) for counterfactual computation is implicitly assumed by Hosten et. al. Here we explain in detail why the protocol is counterfactual and how the "history tracking" method of the existing description inadequately represents the physics underlying the protocol. Consequently, we propose a modified definition of counterfactual computation. Finally, we comment on one of the most interesting aspects of the error-correcting protocol.

arXiv:quant-ph/0607101•Jul 14, 2006•9 citations
We construct an explicit example of a physical system having alternative futures (AFs). Several other such systems are also introduced and characterized, but not discussed in detail. Our major goal is to use these results to demonstrate the existence and meaning of the concept of counterfactual histories (CFHs). We find that any system having AFs will also exhibit the phenomenon of CFHs.
This chapter describes a model certain aspects of human interactions and experiences with the physical universe. It introduces and examines the concepts of alternative futures and counterfactual histories. The essential purpose of the chapter is to give arguments for the proposition that alternative futures can exist. A very interacting, but important issue to note is that the presented general arguments do not depend on whether the systems satisfy classical or quantum physical laws. A branch or trajectory on the outcome tree gives a particular sequence of flippings. The different motions or movements occur within the confines of a bounded space. Counterfactual histories are defined as possible histories of a system that were not in fact actualized. The only requirement is that it be at least two. In the general, the value of the “splittings” may change from one interaction to another.
The philosophical goal is to characterize ‘path dependence’ (PAD) in science by comparison to PAD in technology where the concept was initially introduced. I rely on quantum mechanics to substantiate the analyses, exploiting the contrast between standard versus Bohmian quantum physics (NQP/BQP). To achieve the goal, counterfactual history is mobilized as a means to generate instructive virtual alternatives to the actual scientific path: I design a ‘permuted-situations counterfactual scenario’ in which it is BQP, instead of NQP, that first acquires a monopoly on physics and is exclusively practiced in science education, before NQP is introduced. Then, I endeavor to ‘reenact’ – as forensic investigators carry out the re-enactment of a crime scene – how virtual mainstream Bohmians would assess NQP. Contrasting the two ‘views from inside’ – ‘what it is like to be’ a standard quantum physicist in our world (a physicist trained in NQP) and what it would be like to be a physicist exclusively trained in BQP – I attempt to come as close as possible to an ‘experience’ of the gestalt switch involved when shuttling back and forth between one scientific worldview to the other. The effects of PAD in physics are discussed on this basis.
Mitchison and Jozsa recently suggested that the "chained-Zeno" counterfactual computation protocol recently proposed by Hosten et al. is counterfactual for only one output of the computer. This claim was based on the existing abstract algebraic definition of counterfactual computation, and indeed according to this definition, their argument is correct. However, a more general definition (physically adequate) for counterfactual computation is implicitly assumed by Hosten et. al. Here we explain in detail why the protocol is counterfactual and how the "history tracking" method of the existing description inadequately represents the physics underlying the protocol. Consequently, we propose a modified definition of counterfactual computation. Finally, we comment on one of the most interesting aspects of the error-correcting protocol.