Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Semina Scientiarum

The concepts of an atom and chemical bond in physics and chemistry: the role of approximations

Andrzej Koleżyński

Published Jan 1, 2011• 1 citation
Publisher

Abstract

It is well known from the history of science, that almost all crucial concepts are subject to change during the evolution of scientific theories. There is, however, another (often forgotten or omitted) aspect of this process, i.e. a role of some approximations, necessarily applied to any system of interest, in practically every single calculation carried out within quantum mechanical formalism, which can also result in change of the meaning of some of these concepts. In this paper, the two concepts of great importance in chemistry and physics, namely the concept of an atom, and the concept of a chemical bond are analyzed, both from the point of view of classical chemistry and quantum mechanics. The evolution of their meaning, due to the approximations, resulting in some important differences is highlighted.

DOI
10.15633/ss.1555

Related papers

Quantum Mechanics

G. Spinolo, Paolo Ghigna

When compared to classical mechanics (CM), quantum mechanics (QM) clearly appears as a difficult topic to the beginner. However, some knowledge of the basics of QM is a real need also for learners with predominant interest in experimental chemistry. Indeed, QM is the physical theory explaining most fundamental aspects of Chemistry, such as the periodic table of the elements and the chemical bond now called covalent, found by 19th century chemists and for a long time recognized as incompatible with the physical theories of the time (CM and classical electromagnetism). Going beyond the historical point of view, many peculiar aspects of QM and its very language permeate all modern chemistry so that a trustworthy understanding is required to deal with the matter in a sensible way.

CRC Press eBooks•Jun 26, 2026•0 citations

Foundations of Quantum Information for Physical Chemistry

Weijun Wu, Gregory D. Scholes

Quantum information, a field in which great advances have been made in the past decades, now presents opportunities for advanced chemistry. One roadblock to progress, especially for experimental chemical science, is that new concepts and technical definitions need to be learned. In this paper, we review some basic, but sometimes misunderstood, concepts of quantum information based on the mathematical formulation of quantum mechanics that will be useful for chemists interested in discovering ways that chemistry can contribute to the quantum information field. We cover topics including qubits and their density matrix formalism, quantum measurement as a quantum operation, information theory, and entanglement. We focus on the difference between the concepts in the quantum context and the classic context. We also discuss the relation and distinction among entanglement, correlation, and coherence. We aim to clarify the rigorous definition of these concepts and then indicate some examples in physical chemistry.

arXiv:2311.12238•The Journal of Physical Chemistry Letters•Apr 8, 2024•22 citations

Theoretical Chemistry en route to a Theory of Chemistry

Anton Amann, Werner Gans

Abstract Quantum mechanical and classical aspects are of equal importance in chemistry, and theoretical chemistry must be able to deal with this situation. Classical quantities with which a chemist has to deal include, for example, the temperature and the chemical potential of a substance, and chirality, knot‐type and tertiary structures of molecules. Classical concepts of this type are no more consequences of traditional quantum chemistry than is the theory of complex chemical processes (for example adsorption, heterogeneous catalysis) and macroscopic systems. Algebraic quantum mechanics affords a general framework for the discussion of classical quantities and large systems. There are other independent approaches for the theoretical treatment of chemical problems; these can be summarized by using the keywords “fractals”, “chaotic motion”, “quasicrystals” and “knot theory”. The relationships between these four research topics and their connection with algebraic quantum mechanics, as well as their importance for theoretical chemistry, were discussed at a NATO Workshop in 1987 (see Ref. [1]). In an extended theoretical chemistry, the notion of “molecules” will not play a role as central as it does in quantum chemistry. In the theory of large systems in particular, the introduction of complementary approaches appears to be appropriate; the term “molecule” as used by the chemist does not appear either in the description of disordered systems by means of fractals or in the thermodynamic limit of algebraic statistical mechanics.

Angewandte Chemie International Edition in English•Mar 1, 1989•20 citations

Chemistry and quantum mechanics

John F. Ogilvie

Abstract Of quantum physics, quantum chemistry, and quantum mechanics, the latter is least directly useful for both chemical education and the practice of chemistry as a science concerned with the reactions and properties of chemical substances. We show that quantum mechanics must be viewed as a collection of methods, numbering at least 13, that one might apply to make calculations on a system of an atomic scale. Instead of quantum mechanics, we advocate the quantum laws or laws of discreteness, which have simple roots in laws of conservation and which have practical applications in various areas of observations of chemical phenomena. We conclude that quantum mechanics is largely irrelevant for the general practice of chemistry.

Journal of the Chinese Chemical Society•Aug 16, 2021•4 citations

Introduction

N. J. B. Green

This introductory chapter provides an overview of quantum mechanics, which is a subject of central importance in chemistry, and is by nature a mathematical theory. The chemist's approach to the understanding of matter and its chemical transformations is to take a microscopic view, connecting experimental observation with the properties of constituent molecules. However, at the microscopic level, atoms, molecules, and their constituent particles do not obey the familiar laws of mechanics that pertain to the everyday macroscopic world. For example, the existence of molecular line spectra indicates that molecules can be found only at certain well-defined energies, unlike objects at our own scale whose energy appears to be continuously variable. This book aims to explain the fundamentals of quantum mechanics from the point of view of chemistry; describe the areas of chemistry where quantum mechanics is most important; and show how quantum mechanics is applied to chemical problems.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Sep 11, 1997•0 citations

Quantum Mechanics 1

N. J. B. Green

Quantum Mechanics 1 starts from the basis that quantum mechanics is of central importance in chemistry. To understand matter and its chemical transformation it is necessary to take a microscopic view connecting experimental observation to the properties of constituent molecules. However, at this microscopic level, atoms and sub-atomic particles do not obey the classical laws of mechanics that pertain to the everyday macroscopic world. They obey the laws of quantum mechanics. This text explains the fundamentals of quantum mechanics from the point of view of chemistry; describes areas of chemistry where quantum mechanics is most important; and shows how quantum mechanics is applied to chemical problems. To this end, the book is divided into two parts: the first deals with the foundations of quantum mechanics (concentrating on exactly soluble problems and the reduction of complicated problems to simple foundations) and the second is a tool kit for applying quantum mechanics to chemical problems (thus concentrating on approximate methods).

Oxford University Press eBooks•Sep 11, 1997•9 citations
It is well known from the history of science, that almost all crucial concepts are subject to change during the evolution of scientific theories. There is, however, another (often forgotten or omitted) aspect of this process, i.e. a role of some approximations, necessarily applied to any system of interest, in practically every single calculation carried out within quantum mechanical formalism, which can also result in change of the meaning of some of these concepts. In this paper, the two concepts of great importance in chemistry and physics, namely the concept of an atom, and the concept of a chemical bond are analyzed, both from the point of view of classical chemistry and quantum mechanics. The evolution of their meaning, due to the approximations, resulting in some important differences is highlighted.
When compared to classical mechanics (CM), quantum mechanics (QM) clearly appears as a difficult topic to the beginner. However, some knowledge of the basics of QM is a real need also for learners with predominant interest in experimental chemistry. Indeed, QM is the physical theory explaining most fundamental aspects of Chemistry, such as the periodic table of the elements and the chemical bond now called covalent, found by 19th century chemists and for a long time recognized as incompatible with the physical theories of the time (CM and classical electromagnetism). Going beyond the historical point of view, many peculiar aspects of QM and its very language permeate all modern chemistry so that a trustworthy understanding is required to deal with the matter in a sensible way.
Quantum information, a field in which great advances have been made in the past decades, now presents opportunities for advanced chemistry. One roadblock to progress, especially for experimental chemical science, is that new concepts and technical definitions need to be learned. In this paper, we review some basic, but sometimes misunderstood, concepts of quantum information based on the mathematical formulation of quantum mechanics that will be useful for chemists interested in discovering ways that chemistry can contribute to the quantum information field. We cover topics including qubits and their density matrix formalism, quantum measurement as a quantum operation, information theory, and entanglement. We focus on the difference between the concepts in the quantum context and the classic context. We also discuss the relation and distinction among entanglement, correlation, and coherence. We aim to clarify the rigorous definition of these concepts and then indicate some examples in physical chemistry.
Abstract Quantum mechanical and classical aspects are of equal importance in chemistry, and theoretical chemistry must be able to deal with this situation. Classical quantities with which a chemist has to deal include, for example, the temperature and the chemical potential of a substance, and chirality, knot‐type and tertiary structures of molecules. Classical concepts of this type are no more consequences of traditional quantum chemistry than is the theory of complex chemical processes (for example adsorption, heterogeneous catalysis) and macroscopic systems. Algebraic quantum mechanics affords a general framework for the discussion of classical quantities and large systems. There are other independent approaches for the theoretical treatment of chemical problems; these can be summarized by using the keywords “fractals”, “chaotic motion”, “quasicrystals” and “knot theory”. The relationships between these four research topics and their connection with algebraic quantum mechanics, as well as their importance for theoretical chemistry, were discussed at a NATO Workshop in 1987 (see Ref. [1]). In an extended theoretical chemistry, the notion of “molecules” will not play a role as central as it does in quantum chemistry. In the theory of large systems in particular, the introduction of complementary approaches appears to be appropriate; the term “molecule” as used by the chemist does not appear either in the description of disordered systems by means of fractals or in the thermodynamic limit of algebraic statistical mechanics.
Abstract Of quantum physics, quantum chemistry, and quantum mechanics, the latter is least directly useful for both chemical education and the practice of chemistry as a science concerned with the reactions and properties of chemical substances. We show that quantum mechanics must be viewed as a collection of methods, numbering at least 13, that one might apply to make calculations on a system of an atomic scale. Instead of quantum mechanics, we advocate the quantum laws or laws of discreteness, which have simple roots in laws of conservation and which have practical applications in various areas of observations of chemical phenomena. We conclude that quantum mechanics is largely irrelevant for the general practice of chemistry.
This introductory chapter provides an overview of quantum mechanics, which is a subject of central importance in chemistry, and is by nature a mathematical theory. The chemist's approach to the understanding of matter and its chemical transformations is to take a microscopic view, connecting experimental observation with the properties of constituent molecules. However, at the microscopic level, atoms, molecules, and their constituent particles do not obey the familiar laws of mechanics that pertain to the everyday macroscopic world. For example, the existence of molecular line spectra indicates that molecules can be found only at certain well-defined energies, unlike objects at our own scale whose energy appears to be continuously variable. This book aims to explain the fundamentals of quantum mechanics from the point of view of chemistry; describe the areas of chemistry where quantum mechanics is most important; and show how quantum mechanics is applied to chemical problems.
Quantum Mechanics 1 starts from the basis that quantum mechanics is of central importance in chemistry. To understand matter and its chemical transformation it is necessary to take a microscopic view connecting experimental observation to the properties of constituent molecules. However, at this microscopic level, atoms and sub-atomic particles do not obey the classical laws of mechanics that pertain to the everyday macroscopic world. They obey the laws of quantum mechanics. This text explains the fundamentals of quantum mechanics from the point of view of chemistry; describes areas of chemistry where quantum mechanics is most important; and shows how quantum mechanics is applied to chemical problems. To this end, the book is divided into two parts: the first deals with the foundations of quantum mechanics (concentrating on exactly soluble problems and the reduction of complicated problems to simple foundations) and the second is a tool kit for applying quantum mechanics to chemical problems (thus concentrating on approximate methods).