Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physics World

Cracks in the glass menagerie of science

David Pierre Ruelle

Published Dec 1, 1994• 2 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Time and time again reputable scientists have disagreed with some part of accepted scientific doctrine. And one thing they can then do is write a book for the general public, letting us have a piece of their minds. In this way Ilya Prigogine has expressed his ideas on the irreversibility of time and Roger Penrose his own special views on consciousness and the collapse of wave packets.

DOI
10.1088/2058-7058/7/12/31

Related papers

Inside Penrose's universe

In the years following his hugely successful book The Emperor's New Mind , in which he argued that there is a quantum aspect to human consciousness, Roger Penrose has acquired a reputation among his peers for writing beautiful books that advocate controversial ideas.

Physics World•Dec 1, 2010•0 citations

Minds, quantum measurement, and gravity

Michael Berry

Roger Penrose has provoked a great deal of discussion and controversy with his recent book The Emperor's New Mind(Oxford University Press 1989). (For a summary and review of the book's arguments by Frank Tipler, see Physics World, November 1989, p45) Its main proposal is that three problems which are usually regarded as separate are actually part of the same problem, and so might eventually find a common solution.

Physics World•Oct 1, 1990•0 citations

Schrödinger's cat among the neurons

Tony Leggett

It is possible that discussion of the perennial mind-body problem has been vitiated by a misunderstanding, not of the philosophy or psychology involved, but of the physics? Michael Lockwood thinks so. 'In the preface to mind, Brain and the Quantum he writes' 'In reflecting on the relation of consciousness to the matter of the brain, philosophers have been apt to take matter for granted, assuming that it is mind rather than matter that is philosophicallly problematic.' However,(p178) 'quantum mechanics is not to be regarded as just another scientific theory... it demands a complete revolution in our way of looking at the world.' His thesis, then, is that a proper re-orientation of our view of the physical world in the light of quantum mechanics (or, more precisely, of his preferred view of the interpretation of the quantum formalism) will go at least a long way towards resolving the problem of the nature of 'mental' phenomena and processes.

Physics World•Mar 1, 1990•0 citations

Irreversibility in physics: Reflections on the evolution of ideas in mechanics and on the actual crisis in physics

Georges Lochak

Foundations of Physics•Aug 1, 1981•4 citations

Instability physics: Consciousness and collapse of the wave function

Alex Hankey

Abstract Roger Penrose has long supported the view that wave function collapse, or more accurately wave packet reduction, is one of the defining aspects of consciousness In collaboration with Stuart Hameroff, he has suggested that it can be achieved by quantum gravity, giving rise to their well-known Orch OR theory of wave function collapse Their theory has a fundamental disadvantage, however Quantum gravity is too general; it applies at all points where matter is present, ie in all kinds of circumstance where wave packet reduction is not observed There is no hint as to why cell interiors are of special importance That assumption cannot be justified However, the Orch OR approach does acknowledge that only a situation governed by purely non-linear physics can offer circumstances where quantum wave-packets will be reduced; non-linearity must be at the heart of the theory This paper identifies a biological condition of non-linearity providing an advantageous way to explain objective reduction, OR, of wave packets: critical instability in complexity biology, known as ‘criticality’ The condition provides a rigorous reason why wave packet reduction should occur; one grounded in well-accepted modern biology, complexity biology This paper develops the idea further: it demonstrates how critical instabilities are found not in the cytoplasmic reticulum where Penrose and Hameroff site their Orch OR, but under the very circumstances where one would expect consciousness to be located: at the loci of control of biological regulatory systems Wave packet reduction can then select the future that the organism desires, doing so on a microscopic quantum level

Journal of Physics Conference Series•Jun 1, 2019•1 citation

Quantum Physics & Consciousness - Thoughts of Founding Fathers of Quantum Physics and other Renowned Scholars

S. Gosh, B. D. Mundhra, K. V. Rao +1 more

•Jan 1, 2017•0 citations
Time and time again reputable scientists have disagreed with some part of accepted scientific doctrine. And one thing they can then do is write a book for the general public, letting us have a piece of their minds. In this way Ilya Prigogine has expressed his ideas on the irreversibility of time and Roger Penrose his own special views on consciousness and the collapse of wave packets.
It is possible that discussion of the perennial mind-body problem has been vitiated by a misunderstanding, not of the philosophy or psychology involved, but of the physics? Michael Lockwood thinks so. 'In the preface to mind, Brain and the Quantum he writes' 'In reflecting on the relation of consciousness to the matter of the brain, philosophers have been apt to take matter for granted, assuming that it is mind rather than matter that is philosophicallly problematic.' However,(p178) 'quantum mechanics is not to be regarded as just another scientific theory... it demands a complete revolution in our way of looking at the world.' His thesis, then, is that a proper re-orientation of our view of the physical world in the light of quantum mechanics (or, more precisely, of his preferred view of the interpretation of the quantum formalism) will go at least a long way towards resolving the problem of the nature of 'mental' phenomena and processes.
Abstract Roger Penrose has long supported the view that wave function collapse, or more accurately wave packet reduction, is one of the defining aspects of consciousness In collaboration with Stuart Hameroff, he has suggested that it can be achieved by quantum gravity, giving rise to their well-known Orch OR theory of wave function collapse Their theory has a fundamental disadvantage, however Quantum gravity is too general; it applies at all points where matter is present, ie in all kinds of circumstance where wave packet reduction is not observed There is no hint as to why cell interiors are of special importance That assumption cannot be justified However, the Orch OR approach does acknowledge that only a situation governed by purely non-linear physics can offer circumstances where quantum wave-packets will be reduced; non-linearity must be at the heart of the theory This paper identifies a biological condition of non-linearity providing an advantageous way to explain objective reduction, OR, of wave packets: critical instability in complexity biology, known as ‘criticality’ The condition provides a rigorous reason why wave packet reduction should occur; one grounded in well-accepted modern biology, complexity biology This paper develops the idea further: it demonstrates how critical instabilities are found not in the cytoplasmic reticulum where Penrose and Hameroff site their Orch OR, but under the very circumstances where one would expect consciousness to be located: at the loci of control of biological regulatory systems Wave packet reduction can then select the future that the organism desires, doing so on a microscopic quantum level