Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Molecular Physics

Performance of Bootstrap Embedding for long-range interactions and 2D systems

Nathan D. Ricke, Matthew Welborn, Hong‐Zhou Ye, Troy Van Voorhis

Published Feb 16, 2017• 31 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Fragment embedding approaches offer the possibility of accurate description of strongly correlated systems with low-scaling computational expense. In particular, wave function embedding approaches have demonstrated the ability to subdivide systems across highly entangled regions, promising wide applicability for a number of challenging systems. In this paper, we focus on the wave function embedding method Bootstrap Embedding, extending it to the Pariser–Parr–Pople and 2D Hubbard models in order to evaluate the behaviour of the method in systems that are less amenable to local fragment embedding. We find that Bootstrap Embedding remains accurate for these systems, and we investigate how fragment size, shape, and choice of matching conditions affect the results. We also evaluate the properties of Bootstrap Embedding that lead to the method's favourable convergence properties.

DOI
10.1080/00268976.2017.1290839

Related papers

Bootstrap embedding: An internally consistent fragment-based method

Matthew Welborn, Takashi Tsuchimochi, Troy Van Voorhis

Strong correlation poses a difficult problem for electronic structure theory, with computational cost scaling quickly with system size. Fragment embedding is an attractive approach to this problem. By dividing a large complicated system into smaller manageable fragments "embedded" in an approximate description of the rest of the system, we can hope to ameliorate the steep cost of correlated calculations. While appealing, these methods often converge slowly with fragment size because of small errors at the boundary between fragment and bath. We describe a new electronic embedding method, dubbed "Bootstrap Embedding," a self-consistent wavefunction-in-wavefunction embedding theory that uses overlapping fragments to improve the description of fragment edges. We apply this method to the one dimensional Hubbard model and a translationally asymmetric variant, and find that it performs very well for energies and populations. We find Bootstrap Embedding converges rapidly with embedded fragment size, overcoming the surface-area-to-volume-ratio error typical of many embedding methods. We anticipate that this method may lead to a low-scaling, high accuracy treatment of electron correlation in large molecular systems.

The Journal of Chemical Physics•Aug 15, 2016•96 citations

Bootstrap Embedding for Molecules

Hong‐Zhou Ye, Nathan D. Ricke, Henry K. Tran +1 more

Fragment embedding is one way to circumvent the high computational scaling of accurate electron correlation methods. The challenge of applying fragment embedding to molecular systems primarily lies in the strong entanglement and correlation that prevent accurate fragmentation across chemical bonds. Recently, Schmidt decomposition has been shown effective for embedding fragments that are strongly coupled to a bath in several model systems. In this work, we extend a recently developed quantum embedding scheme, bootstrap embedding (BE), to molecular systems. The resulting method utilizes the matching conditions naturally arising from using overlapping fragments to optimize the embedding. Numerical simulation suggests that the accuracy of the embedding improves rapidly with fragment size for small molecules, whereas larger fragments that include orbitals from different atoms may be needed for larger molecules. BE scales linearly with system size (apart from an integral transform) and hence can potentially be useful for large-scale calculations.

Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation•Jul 25, 2019•61 citations

Bootstrap embedding for interacting electrons in phonon coherent-state mean field

Shariful Islam, Joel Bierman, Yuan Liu

We develop a Fermi-Bose bootstrap embedding framework for the ground state of interacting electrons coupled to a phonon mean field. The method combines bootstrap embedding for correlated electrons with a self-consistent coherent-state mean-field treatment for phonons. This method models the interacting electron-phonon problem as a system of correlated electrons traveling in a self-consistently specified potential landscape, allowing for efficient treatment of large lattice systems. Convergence of the methods for fragment size and total system size is demonstrated for the one-dimensional Hubbard-Holstein model for up to 350 sites. Finite-size scaling is performed to extrapolate to the infinite system size. Benchmarking against the density matrix renormalization group for a small 8-site system at half- and quarter-filling shows an orders-of-magnitude runtime advantage. The comparison further reveals that the method performs best in regimes dominated by localization, such as the Mott insulating phase and the strong-coupling tiny polaron regime, where the local embedding ansatz is still valid. However, due to the mean-field treatment for phonons, we find limitations of our methods in the weakly coupled delocalized region and at the Peierls transition, where quantum phonon fluctuations and long-range kinetic correlations become substantial.

arXiv:2603.11463•The Journal of Chemical Physics•Mar 26, 2026•0 citations

Variational Quantum Eigensolver-Based Quantum Bootstrap Embedding for Molecules

Derek Peng

Simulating strongly correlated molecular systems on near-term quantum hardware remains challenging because current hardware offers limited quantum volume and moderate-fidelity qubits. One way to address this challenge is through bootstrap embedding (BE). Bootstrap embedding partitions molecules into smaller fragments that are then embedded in the ``bath'' of other fragments iteratively. Bootstrap embedding is appealing for quantum simulation because fragmentation reduces the qubit requirements of each fragment problem. In this work, we develop a quantum bootstrap embedding (QBE) workflow that uses variational quantum eigensolver (VQE) fragment solvers and examines the algorithmic choices that determine the success of the overall VQE-QBE procedure. To improve efficiency, we introduce FastAdaptVQE, a sparse-matrix-accelerated form of the adaptive variational quantum eigensolver (ADAPT-VQE) that replaces symbolic commutator evaluation with direct statevector calculations, and MatrixFreeAdaptVQE, a matrix-free extension that removes the sparse-matrix memory bottleneck that arises for larger fragments. We also explore modifying the ADAPT-VQE operator-selection step by replacing the purely greedy choice with a lookahead strategy. Benchmarks on H$_4$, F$_2$, and selected geometries of H$_6$ reach chemical accuracy, within 1 kcal/mol of BE results obtained with a full configuration interaction (FCI) solver. For $n$-butane, density-matching residuals converged, but energy errors remained outside chemical accuracy. These results show that combining QBE with VQE can accurately compute molecular energies, while density convergence alone does not ensure energy accuracy. This work lays the foundation for extending these energy calculations to larger molecular systems and quantum materials on near-term quantum hardware.

physics.chem-phCross-listedarXiv:2606.17095•Jun 16, 2026•0 citations

Bootstrap Embedding For Large Molecular Systems

Hong‐Zhou Ye, Henry K. Tran, Troy Van Voorhis

Recent developments in quantum embedding theories have provided attractive approaches to correlated calculations for large systems. In this work, we extend our previous work [ J. Chem. Theory Comput. 2019, 15, 4497–4506; J. Phys. Chem. Lett. 2019, 10, 6368–6374] on bootstrap embedding (BE) to enable correlated ab initio calculations at the coupled cluster with singles and doubles (CCSD) level for large molecules. We introduce several new algorithmic developments that significantly reduce the computational cost of BE, while maintaining its accuracy. The resulting implementation scales as O ( N 3 ) for the integral transform and O ( N ) for the CCSD calculation. Numerical results on a series of conjugated molecules suggest that BE with reasonably sized fragments can recover more than 99.5% of the total correlation energy of a full CCSD calculation, while the required computational resources (time and storage) compare favorably to one popular local correlation scheme: domain localized pair natural orbital (DLPNO). The largest BE calculation in this work involves ∼2900 basis functions and can be performed on a single node with 16 CPU cores and 64 GB of memory in a few days. We anticipate that these developments represent an important step toward the application of BE to solve practical problems.

Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation•Jun 26, 2020•40 citations

Exact entanglement studies of strongly correlated systems: role of long-range interactions and symmetries of the system

Shaon Sahoo, V. M. L. Durga Prasad Goli, S. Ramasesha +1 more

We study the bipartite entanglement of strongly correlated systems using exact diagonalization techniques. In particular, we examine how the entanglement changes in the presence of long-range interactions by studying the Pariser-Parr-Pople model with long-range interactions. We compare the results for this model with those obtained for the Hubbard and Heisenberg models with short-range interactions. This study helps us to understand why the density matrix renormalization group (DMRG) technique is so successful even in the presence of long-range interactions. To better understand the behavior of long-range interactions and why the DMRG works well with it, we study the entanglement spectrum of the ground state and a few excited states of finite chains. We also investigate if the symmetry properties of a state vector have any significance in relation to its entanglement. Finally, we make an interesting observation on the entanglement profiles of different states (across the energy spectrum) in comparison with the corresponding profile of the density of states. We use isotropic chains and a molecule with non-Abelian symmetry for these numerical investigations.

arXiv:1109.3587•Journal of Physics Condensed Matter•Feb 21, 2012•25 citations
Fragment embedding approaches offer the possibility of accurate description of strongly correlated systems with low-scaling computational expense. In particular, wave function embedding approaches have demonstrated the ability to subdivide systems across highly entangled regions, promising wide applicability for a number of challenging systems. In this paper, we focus on the wave function embedding method Bootstrap Embedding, extending it to the Pariser–Parr–Pople and 2D Hubbard models in order to evaluate the behaviour of the method in systems that are less amenable to local fragment embedding. We find that Bootstrap Embedding remains accurate for these systems, and we investigate how fragment size, shape, and choice of matching conditions affect the results. We also evaluate the properties of Bootstrap Embedding that lead to the method's favourable convergence properties.
Strong correlation poses a difficult problem for electronic structure theory, with computational cost scaling quickly with system size. Fragment embedding is an attractive approach to this problem. By dividing a large complicated system into smaller manageable fragments "embedded" in an approximate description of the rest of the system, we can hope to ameliorate the steep cost of correlated calculations. While appealing, these methods often converge slowly with fragment size because of small errors at the boundary between fragment and bath. We describe a new electronic embedding method, dubbed "Bootstrap Embedding," a self-consistent wavefunction-in-wavefunction embedding theory that uses overlapping fragments to improve the description of fragment edges. We apply this method to the one dimensional Hubbard model and a translationally asymmetric variant, and find that it performs very well for energies and populations. We find Bootstrap Embedding converges rapidly with embedded fragment size, overcoming the surface-area-to-volume-ratio error typical of many embedding methods. We anticipate that this method may lead to a low-scaling, high accuracy treatment of electron correlation in large molecular systems.
Fragment embedding is one way to circumvent the high computational scaling of accurate electron correlation methods. The challenge of applying fragment embedding to molecular systems primarily lies in the strong entanglement and correlation that prevent accurate fragmentation across chemical bonds. Recently, Schmidt decomposition has been shown effective for embedding fragments that are strongly coupled to a bath in several model systems. In this work, we extend a recently developed quantum embedding scheme, bootstrap embedding (BE), to molecular systems. The resulting method utilizes the matching conditions naturally arising from using overlapping fragments to optimize the embedding. Numerical simulation suggests that the accuracy of the embedding improves rapidly with fragment size for small molecules, whereas larger fragments that include orbitals from different atoms may be needed for larger molecules. BE scales linearly with system size (apart from an integral transform) and hence can potentially be useful for large-scale calculations.
We develop a Fermi-Bose bootstrap embedding framework for the ground state of interacting electrons coupled to a phonon mean field. The method combines bootstrap embedding for correlated electrons with a self-consistent coherent-state mean-field treatment for phonons. This method models the interacting electron-phonon problem as a system of correlated electrons traveling in a self-consistently specified potential landscape, allowing for efficient treatment of large lattice systems. Convergence of the methods for fragment size and total system size is demonstrated for the one-dimensional Hubbard-Holstein model for up to 350 sites. Finite-size scaling is performed to extrapolate to the infinite system size. Benchmarking against the density matrix renormalization group for a small 8-site system at half- and quarter-filling shows an orders-of-magnitude runtime advantage. The comparison further reveals that the method performs best in regimes dominated by localization, such as the Mott insulating phase and the strong-coupling tiny polaron regime, where the local embedding ansatz is still valid. However, due to the mean-field treatment for phonons, we find limitations of our methods in the weakly coupled delocalized region and at the Peierls transition, where quantum phonon fluctuations and long-range kinetic correlations become substantial.
Simulating strongly correlated molecular systems on near-term quantum hardware remains challenging because current hardware offers limited quantum volume and moderate-fidelity qubits. One way to address this challenge is through bootstrap embedding (BE). Bootstrap embedding partitions molecules into smaller fragments that are then embedded in the ``bath'' of other fragments iteratively. Bootstrap embedding is appealing for quantum simulation because fragmentation reduces the qubit requirements of each fragment problem. In this work, we develop a quantum bootstrap embedding (QBE) workflow that uses variational quantum eigensolver (VQE) fragment solvers and examines the algorithmic choices that determine the success of the overall VQE-QBE procedure. To improve efficiency, we introduce FastAdaptVQE, a sparse-matrix-accelerated form of the adaptive variational quantum eigensolver (ADAPT-VQE) that replaces symbolic commutator evaluation with direct statevector calculations, and MatrixFreeAdaptVQE, a matrix-free extension that removes the sparse-matrix memory bottleneck that arises for larger fragments. We also explore modifying the ADAPT-VQE operator-selection step by replacing the purely greedy choice with a lookahead strategy. Benchmarks on H4_44​, F2_22​, and selected geometries of H6_66​ reach chemical accuracy, within 1 kcal/mol of BE results obtained with a full configuration interaction (FCI) solver. For nnn-butane, density-matching residuals converged, but energy errors remained outside chemical accuracy. These results show that combining QBE with VQE can accurately compute molecular energies, while density convergence alone does not ensure energy accuracy. This work lays the foundation for extending these energy calculations to larger molecular systems and quantum materials on near-term quantum hardware.
Recent developments in quantum embedding theories have provided attractive approaches to correlated calculations for large systems. In this work, we extend our previous work [ J. Chem. Theory Comput. 2019, 15, 4497–4506; J. Phys. Chem. Lett. 2019, 10, 6368–6374] on bootstrap embedding (BE) to enable correlated ab initio calculations at the coupled cluster with singles and doubles (CCSD) level for large molecules. We introduce several new algorithmic developments that significantly reduce the computational cost of BE, while maintaining its accuracy. The resulting implementation scales as O ( N 3 ) for the integral transform and O ( N ) for the CCSD calculation. Numerical results on a series of conjugated molecules suggest that BE with reasonably sized fragments can recover more than 99.5% of the total correlation energy of a full CCSD calculation, while the required computational resources (time and storage) compare favorably to one popular local correlation scheme: domain localized pair natural orbital (DLPNO). The largest BE calculation in this work involves ∼2900 basis functions and can be performed on a single node with 16 CPU cores and 64 GB of memory in a few days. We anticipate that these developments represent an important step toward the application of BE to solve practical problems.
We study the bipartite entanglement of strongly correlated systems using exact diagonalization techniques. In particular, we examine how the entanglement changes in the presence of long-range interactions by studying the Pariser-Parr-Pople model with long-range interactions. We compare the results for this model with those obtained for the Hubbard and Heisenberg models with short-range interactions. This study helps us to understand why the density matrix renormalization group (DMRG) technique is so successful even in the presence of long-range interactions. To better understand the behavior of long-range interactions and why the DMRG works well with it, we study the entanglement spectrum of the ground state and a few excited states of finite chains. We also investigate if the symmetry properties of a state vector have any significance in relation to its entanglement. Finally, we make an interesting observation on the entanglement profiles of different states (across the energy spectrum) in comparison with the corresponding profile of the density of states. We use isotropic chains and a molecule with non-Abelian symmetry for these numerical investigations.