Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review

The Schrödinger Potential Function

R. M. Langer

Published Aug 15, 1931• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The notion of odd and even operators introduced by Schr\"odinger is generalized and developed in this paper. It is shown that, accepting the hypothesis of Schr\"odinger that "only even operators exist" the undesirable negative energy solutions of the Dirac equation are eliminated since they do not combine with the observed states, while at the same time the relativistically invariant form of the Dirac equation can be retained. The fine structure formula for the energy levels remains exact and not merely approximate. However, it is proposed to relinquish these apparent advantages in order to substitute for Schr\"odinger's hypothesis one easier to accept but practically equivalent. This is that the fundamental potential between charges is an even operator. Possible ways of forming even operators out of classical mixed ones are discussed. The decomposition of the fundamental operators, ${\ensuremath{\alpha}}_{i}$ the "spin" operator, and ${x}_{i}$ the coordinate operator, indicates a remarkably simple form for the odd and even parts. The even parts prove to be immediately connected with observable properties of the electron. This leads one to believe that the division into odd and even parts is a useful performance aside from its application to the question of negative energy solutions. While the positive to negative transitions are made to vanish identically, the direct transitions between positive states remain quite unaffected. The "Klein difficulty" is examined and it proves to disappear with the negative energy states. Possible experimental tests of the new theory are shown to exist. The values of hyperfine structure separations and also the x-ray levels of heavy atoms should depend markedly on whether the Coulomb potential or just its even part acts on the electron. Some interesting possibilities suggested by the theory are mentioned at the end of the paper.

DOI
10.1103/physrev.38.779

Related papers

Simplified solutions of the Dirac-Coulomb equation

Jeng-Yih Su

With the use of a simple similarity transformation which brings the radial wave equations of the Dirac-Coulomb problem into a form nearly identical to those of the Schr\"odinger and Klein-Gordon equations, we derive simplified solutions to the Dirac-Coulomb equation for both the bound and continuum states following the familiar standard procedure adopted in the derivation of the conventional solutions. We show that to obtain the desired form of the second-order radial equations we can still work with a first-order partial differential equation rather than with the second-order Dirac equation widely employed in the derivation of the simplified solutions, and thus we can avoid the task of reducing the solutions of the second-order equations to those of the original Dirac equation. The transformed Dirac-Coulomb radial equations are so simple that one can apply the WKB method to them in the same way that one applies the WKB approximation to the Schr\"odinger radial equation, without making the further approximations commonly invoked, and the Sommerfeld-Dirac discrete spectrum follows immediately. For small Z\ensuremath{\alpha}, we also present approximate expressions for both the transformed and the original Dirac-Coulomb wave functions, which are valid for all energies and certainly valid in the quasirelativistic approximation which takes account of relativistic effects. The structure of these approximate expressions also suggests one of the methods to obtain relativistic approximate wave functions from the Pauli-spinor wave function for more general central potentials arising in atoms, molecules, and solids.

Physical Review A•Dec 1, 1985•26 citations

General solution vs spin invariant eigenstates of the Dirac equation with the Coulomb potential

Larissa S. Brizhik, A. A. Eremko, В. М. Локтев

Solutions of the Dirac equation for an electron in the Coulomb potential are obtained using operator invariants of the equation, namely the Dirac, Johnson-Lippmann and recently found new invariant. It is demonstrated that these operators are the spin invariants. The generalized invariant is constructed and the exact general solution of the Dirac equation are found. In particular, the explicit expressions of the bispinors corresponding to the three complete sets of the invariants, their eigenvalues and quantum numbers are calculated. It is shown that the general solution of one center Coulomb Dirac equation contains free parameters. Changing one or more of these parameters, one can transform one solution of the Dirac equation into any other. It is shown for the first time that these invariants determine electron spatial probability amplitude and spin polarization in each quantum state. Electron probability densities and spin polarizations are explicitly calculated in the general form for several electron states in the hydrogen-like energy spectrum. Spatial distributions of these characteristics are shown to depend essentially on the invariant set, demonstrating, in spite of the accidental degeneracy of energy levels, physical difference of the states corresponding to different spin invariants.

arXiv:2111.08552•Nov 16, 2021•2 citations

Relativistic Quantum Mechanics and Spin

Masatoshi Kajita

Spin is one of the most important characteristics of particles, which results in a fine and hyperfine energy structure and Zeeman energy shift. Spin is a property of particles, independent of the density distribution given by the potential field. The spin eigenfunction should be described using a vector, and the spin operator is given by a matrix. The property of spin is not derived from the Schroedinger equation, which treats wave functions as scalars. The Dirac equation was developed to obtain wave functions from the relationship between frequency (energy) and wavenumber (momentum) given by the theory of special relativity, for which the equation is given by the 4 x 4 matrix and the wave functions are given by four-dimensional vectors. There are four solutions for one equation, which correspond to ± 1/2 spin states and the positive and negative rest energies. The existence of negative rest energy was confirmed by the discovery of positrons (antiparticles). The Zeeman shift induced by spin is derived from the exchange of matrix production.

BENTHAM SCIENCE PUBLISHERS eBooks•Mar 7, 2022•0 citations

Spin - 1/2 wave equations in relativistic quantum mechanics

D S Staudte

This thesis is concerned with the development of a new spin-1/2 wave equation in relativistic quantum mechanics. This equation is the spin-1/2 analogue of the spin-0 Feshbach-Villars equation. The thesis begins in chapter 1 with a review of the subject of relativistic wave equations and its place in the development of modern physics. Chapter 2 sees the derivation of the new equation (hereafter referred to as the FV1/2 equation). This derivation is presented at three levels of understanding, and is combined with an analysis of the equation using elements of the underlying mathematics of the theories of special relativity and quantum mechanics. The analysis justifies the methods of derivation of the equation, and its suitability as a wave equation in relativistic quantum mechanics. It is shown th a t the FV1/2 equation is different to the Dirac equation and other equations in the literature. One of the striking features of the FV1/2 equation is th a t it contains a less restrictive dynamics than the conventional Dirac equation. Chapter 3 examines the solution space and proves some results using the discrete symmetries C, P and T, which enable a subset of the solution space to be used for physical applications. It is possible to use a subset of solutions which contain the usual Dirac negative energy states, or it is possible to use a subset which contains only positive energy states, but includes states of opposite signs of charge. The second subset corresponds to the physical properties of particles and antiparticles and suggests th a t the FV1/2 equation could be useful in atomic physics. Chapter 4 represents a start on the development of the FV1/2 equation for use in atomic physics. It contains a study of hydrogenic atoms. The energy spectra and wavefunctions for hydrogenic atoms are derived using the FV1/2 equation. The method of solution is of comparable difficulty to th a t using the Dirac equation. The spectra are found to be identical to th a t of the Dirac equation, but the wavefunctions differ. A calculation of the expectation value of the Coulomb energy is performed and the results obtained differ from the Dirac equation results by 6 x 10-3% for Z — 1, and 40% for Z = 70. This suggests th a t physically measureable quantities should be calculated and compared using the FV1/2 and Dirac equations. A calculation is presented to show the energy spectra and wavefunctions obtained are consistent with the literature. The results obtained in this chapter (again) suggest th a t the FV1/2 equation could be useful for calculations in atomic physics. Chapter 5 discusses important further work which should be undertaken if the FV1/2 equation is to become useful to physics. The development in the previous chapters concentrated on the FV1/2 equation in relativistic quantum mechanics. It should be also considered as a quantised field equation. The two electron problem and the calculation of physical quantities are crucial tests of the FV1/2 equation’s applicability in atomic physics. The mathematical analysis in chapter 2 can be extended. Suggestions for gaining a deeper mathematical understanding of the less restrictive dynamics of the FV1/2 equation are given. Finally some conclusions on what has been achieved in the thesis are presented in chapter 6.

•Jan 1, 1993•0 citations

Relativistic Schrödinger Equation

Z. Ficek

This chapter introduces the concepts of the relativistic theory to basic problems of quantum physics, in particular, the extension of the Schrodinger equation to a relativistic form. Starting from the fundamental laws of relativity, the chapter evaluates the Klein–Gordon equation and investigates if the equation can be considered a generalization of the non-relativistic Schrodinger equation to the case of the relativistic energy. The chapter shows that the wave function, which is a solution to the Klein–Gordon equation, cannot be connected with the probability wave function. For this reason, the Dirac equation is used to solve the problems faced by the Klein–Gordon equation. The Dirac equation also includes the spin. The advantage of the Dirac equation over the Schrodinger and Klein–Gordon equations is that it naturally includes the spin. In the Schrodinger and Klein–Gordon equations, the spin is not present and has to be added to the wave function manually whenever the wave function determines a system with the spin.

•Mar 3, 2017•0 citations

On the Dirac Theory of Spin 1/2 Particles and Its Non-Relativistic Limit

Leslie L. Foldy, Siegfried A. Wouthuysen

By a canonical transformation on the Dirac Hamiltonian for a free particle, a representation of the Dirac theory is obtained in which positive and negative energy states are separately represented by two-component wave functions. Playing an important role in the new representation are new operators for position and spin of the particle which are physically distinct from these operators in the conventional representation. The components of the time derivative of the new position operator all commute and have for eigenvalues all values between $\ensuremath{-}c$ and $c$. The new spin operator is a constant of the motion unlike the spin operator in the conventional representation. By a comparison of the new Hamiltonian with the non-relativistic Pauli-Hamiltonian for particles of spin \textonehalf{}, one finds that it is these new operators rather than the conventional ones which pass over into the position and spin operators in the Pauli theory in the non-relativistic limit. The transformation of the new representation is also made in the case of interaction of the particle with an external electromagnetic field. In this way the proper non-relativistic Hamiltonian (essentially the Pauli-Hamiltonian) is obtained in the non-relativistic limit. The same methods may be applied to a Dirac particle interacting with any type of external field (various meson fields, for example) and this allows one to find the proper non-relativistic Hamiltonian in each such case. Some light is cast on the question of why a Dirac electron shows some properties characteristic of a particle of finite extension by an examination of the relationship between the new and the conventional position operators.

Physical Review•Apr 1, 1950•2,204 citations
The notion of odd and even operators introduced by Schr"odinger is generalized and developed in this paper. It is shown that, accepting the hypothesis of Schr"odinger that "only even operators exist" the undesirable negative energy solutions of the Dirac equation are eliminated since they do not combine with the observed states, while at the same time the relativistically invariant form of the Dirac equation can be retained. The fine structure formula for the energy levels remains exact and not merely approximate. However, it is proposed to relinquish these apparent advantages in order to substitute for Schr"odinger's hypothesis one easier to accept but practically equivalent. This is that the fundamental potential between charges is an even operator. Possible ways of forming even operators out of classical mixed ones are discussed. The decomposition of the fundamental operators, \ensuremathαi{\ensuremath{\alpha}}_{i}\ensuremathαi​ the "spin" operator, and xi{x}_{i}xi​ the coordinate operator, indicates a remarkably simple form for the odd and even parts. The even parts prove to be immediately connected with observable properties of the electron. This leads one to believe that the division into odd and even parts is a useful performance aside from its application to the question of negative energy solutions. While the positive to negative transitions are made to vanish identically, the direct transitions between positive states remain quite unaffected. The "Klein difficulty" is examined and it proves to disappear with the negative energy states. Possible experimental tests of the new theory are shown to exist. The values of hyperfine structure separations and also the x-ray levels of heavy atoms should depend markedly on whether the Coulomb potential or just its even part acts on the electron. Some interesting possibilities suggested by the theory are mentioned at the end of the paper.
With the use of a simple similarity transformation which brings the radial wave equations of the Dirac-Coulomb problem into a form nearly identical to those of the Schr\"odinger and Klein-Gordon equations, we derive simplified solutions to the Dirac-Coulomb equation for both the bound and continuum states following the familiar standard procedure adopted in the derivation of the conventional solutions. We show that to obtain the desired form of the second-order radial equations we can still work with a first-order partial differential equation rather than with the second-order Dirac equation widely employed in the derivation of the simplified solutions, and thus we can avoid the task of reducing the solutions of the second-order equations to those of the original Dirac equation. The transformed Dirac-Coulomb radial equations are so simple that one can apply the WKB method to them in the same way that one applies the WKB approximation to the Schr\"odinger radial equation, without making the further approximations commonly invoked, and the Sommerfeld-Dirac discrete spectrum follows immediately. For small Z\ensuremath{\alpha}, we also present approximate expressions for both the transformed and the original Dirac-Coulomb wave functions, which are valid for all energies and certainly valid in the quasirelativistic approximation which takes account of relativistic effects. The structure of these approximate expressions also suggests one of the methods to obtain relativistic approximate wave functions from the Pauli-spinor wave function for more general central potentials arising in atoms, molecules, and solids.
Solutions of the Dirac equation for an electron in the Coulomb potential are obtained using operator invariants of the equation, namely the Dirac, Johnson-Lippmann and recently found new invariant. It is demonstrated that these operators are the spin invariants. The generalized invariant is constructed and the exact general solution of the Dirac equation are found. In particular, the explicit expressions of the bispinors corresponding to the three complete sets of the invariants, their eigenvalues and quantum numbers are calculated. It is shown that the general solution of one center Coulomb Dirac equation contains free parameters. Changing one or more of these parameters, one can transform one solution of the Dirac equation into any other. It is shown for the first time that these invariants determine electron spatial probability amplitude and spin polarization in each quantum state. Electron probability densities and spin polarizations are explicitly calculated in the general form for several electron states in the hydrogen-like energy spectrum. Spatial distributions of these characteristics are shown to depend essentially on the invariant set, demonstrating, in spite of the accidental degeneracy of energy levels, physical difference of the states corresponding to different spin invariants.
Spin is one of the most important characteristics of particles, which results in a fine and hyperfine energy structure and Zeeman energy shift. Spin is a property of particles, independent of the density distribution given by the potential field. The spin eigenfunction should be described using a vector, and the spin operator is given by a matrix. The property of spin is not derived from the Schroedinger equation, which treats wave functions as scalars. The Dirac equation was developed to obtain wave functions from the relationship between frequency (energy) and wavenumber (momentum) given by the theory of special relativity, for which the equation is given by the 4 x 4 matrix and the wave functions are given by four-dimensional vectors. There are four solutions for one equation, which correspond to ± 1/2 spin states and the positive and negative rest energies. The existence of negative rest energy was confirmed by the discovery of positrons (antiparticles). The Zeeman shift induced by spin is derived from the exchange of matrix production.
This thesis is concerned with the development of a new spin-1/2 wave equation in relativistic quantum mechanics. This equation is the spin-1/2 analogue of the spin-0 Feshbach-Villars equation. The thesis begins in chapter 1 with a review of the subject of relativistic wave equations and its place in the development of modern physics. Chapter 2 sees the derivation of the new equation (hereafter referred to as the FV1/2 equation). This derivation is presented at three levels of understanding, and is combined with an analysis of the equation using elements of the underlying mathematics of the theories of special relativity and quantum mechanics. The analysis justifies the methods of derivation of the equation, and its suitability as a wave equation in relativistic quantum mechanics. It is shown th a t the FV1/2 equation is different to the Dirac equation and other equations in the literature. One of the striking features of the FV1/2 equation is th a t it contains a less restrictive dynamics than the conventional Dirac equation. Chapter 3 examines the solution space and proves some results using the discrete symmetries C, P and T, which enable a subset of the solution space to be used for physical applications. It is possible to use a subset of solutions which contain the usual Dirac negative energy states, or it is possible to use a subset which contains only positive energy states, but includes states of opposite signs of charge. The second subset corresponds to the physical properties of particles and antiparticles and suggests th a t the FV1/2 equation could be useful in atomic physics. Chapter 4 represents a start on the development of the FV1/2 equation for use in atomic physics. It contains a study of hydrogenic atoms. The energy spectra and wavefunctions for hydrogenic atoms are derived using the FV1/2 equation. The method of solution is of comparable difficulty to th a t using the Dirac equation. The spectra are found to be identical to th a t of the Dirac equation, but the wavefunctions differ. A calculation of the expectation value of the Coulomb energy is performed and the results obtained differ from the Dirac equation results by 6 x 10-3% for Z — 1, and 40% for Z = 70. This suggests th a t physically measureable quantities should be calculated and compared using the FV1/2 and Dirac equations. A calculation is presented to show the energy spectra and wavefunctions obtained are consistent with the literature. The results obtained in this chapter (again) suggest th a t the FV1/2 equation could be useful for calculations in atomic physics. Chapter 5 discusses important further work which should be undertaken if the FV1/2 equation is to become useful to physics. The development in the previous chapters concentrated on the FV1/2 equation in relativistic quantum mechanics. It should be also considered as a quantised field equation. The two electron problem and the calculation of physical quantities are crucial tests of the FV1/2 equation’s applicability in atomic physics. The mathematical analysis in chapter 2 can be extended. Suggestions for gaining a deeper mathematical understanding of the less restrictive dynamics of the FV1/2 equation are given. Finally some conclusions on what has been achieved in the thesis are presented in chapter 6.
This chapter introduces the concepts of the relativistic theory to basic problems of quantum physics, in particular, the extension of the Schrodinger equation to a relativistic form. Starting from the fundamental laws of relativity, the chapter evaluates the Klein–Gordon equation and investigates if the equation can be considered a generalization of the non-relativistic Schrodinger equation to the case of the relativistic energy. The chapter shows that the wave function, which is a solution to the Klein–Gordon equation, cannot be connected with the probability wave function. For this reason, the Dirac equation is used to solve the problems faced by the Klein–Gordon equation. The Dirac equation also includes the spin. The advantage of the Dirac equation over the Schrodinger and Klein–Gordon equations is that it naturally includes the spin. In the Schrodinger and Klein–Gordon equations, the spin is not present and has to be added to the wave function manually whenever the wave function determines a system with the spin.
By a canonical transformation on the Dirac Hamiltonian for a free particle, a representation of the Dirac theory is obtained in which positive and negative energy states are separately represented by two-component wave functions. Playing an important role in the new representation are new operators for position and spin of the particle which are physically distinct from these operators in the conventional representation. The components of the time derivative of the new position operator all commute and have for eigenvalues all values between $\ensuremath{-}c$ and ccc. The new spin operator is a constant of the motion unlike the spin operator in the conventional representation. By a comparison of the new Hamiltonian with the non-relativistic Pauli-Hamiltonian for particles of spin \textonehalf{}, one finds that it is these new operators rather than the conventional ones which pass over into the position and spin operators in the Pauli theory in the non-relativistic limit. The transformation of the new representation is also made in the case of interaction of the particle with an external electromagnetic field. In this way the proper non-relativistic Hamiltonian (essentially the Pauli-Hamiltonian) is obtained in the non-relativistic limit. The same methods may be applied to a Dirac particle interacting with any type of external field (various meson fields, for example) and this allows one to find the proper non-relativistic Hamiltonian in each such case. Some light is cast on the question of why a Dirac electron shows some properties characteristic of a particle of finite extension by an examination of the relationship between the new and the conventional position operators.