We revisit the quantum phase operator
Φ introduced by Garrison and Wong. Denoting by
N the number operator, we provide a detailed proof of the Heisenberg commutation relation
ΦN−NΦ=iI on the natural maximal domain
D(ΦN)∩D(NΦ) as well as the failure of the Weyl commutation relations, and discuss some further interesting properties of this pair.
It is familiar that a well behaved operator of the harmonic oscillator phase does not exist. Therefore, Turski's phase operator and the operator of Garrison and Wong may be at most defined in an interesting fashion and yield useful quantum expectation values. In this paper we touch on a recent incomplete definition of a phase operator which has also failed in the respect that it can be completed only to a definition of an 'incomplete' phase operator. We discuss, however, a possibility of completion of the definition and a relationship to the phase operator from an s-parametrized quasidistribution.