Physics World
Bit of a hype
Andrew M. Steane
Abstract
In their article "Solid start for solid-state quantum bits" (July pp2l–22), Caspar van der Wal and Leo Kouwenhoven report an excellent experiment in solid-state physics by Yasunoba Nakamura and colleagues (Nature 398 786). Both the original paper in Nature and the article about this paper in Physics World are examples of good research, carefully explained. However, I believe this work has been misrepresented by the editors of Physics World and by Nature.