Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review A

Quantum versus semiclassical description of light interaction with atomic ensembles: Revision of the Maxwell-Bloch equations and single-photon superradiance

Anatoly A. Svidzinsky, Xiwen Zhang, Marlan O. Scully

Published Jul 1, 2015• 20 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Interaction of atoms with quantum states of light is a long-standing problem that apart from fundamental physics has potential applications for optical quantum-state storage, quantum communication, and quantum information. A fully quantum mechanical treatment of this problem is usually very complicated mathematically. Here we show, however, that quantum mechanical evolution equations describing single-photon emission (absorption) by atomic ensembles can be written in a form equivalent to the semiclassical Maxwell-Bloch equations. This connection allows us to find exact analytical solutions of the fully quantum mechanical problem. We also found that semiclassical Maxwell-Bloch equations should be written in a form different from those commonly used. Namely, the classical limit of the quantum problem gives a propagation equation with the Laplacian operator on the right-hand side rather than with the second-order time derivative.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.92.013801

Related papers

Atoms in Light: Semiclassical Theory

Peter W. Milonni

Abstract The atom-field interaction is treated in semiclassical radiation theory, starting from the transformation from the minimal coupling Hamiltonian to the electric dipole form used extensively in quantum optics. The Heisenberg and density matrix approaches are developed and applied to two-state atoms, Bloch equations, Rabi oscillations, Maxwell-Bloch equations, and transition rates for absorption and emission. Einstein’s theory of blackbody radiation based on momentum fluctuations and dissipation is reviewed. The Einstein fluctuation formula is derived and used to introduce wave-particle duality, Hanbury Brown-Twiss correlations, and photon bunching.

•Jan 31, 2019•0 citations

Pedagogical Overview of Maxwell-Bloch Equations for Two Level Atoms Using Quantum Master Equation Approach

Abhirup Chatterjee

This tutorial article provides a detailed mathematical overview of the Optical Bloch equation describing the interaction of the two level atom with the Electromagnetic radi- ation field. The equations have been derived in the weak atom field coupling limit. The notion of the optical Bloch equations has been introduced in a systematic process starting from the interaction of the two level atom with the semiclassical radiation field which cannot completely the idea of the Spontaneous emission process later which was included theoretically by,Weigner-Weisskopf theory of spontaneous emission .In the later part of the article the optical Bloch equations has been derived exactly by treating the radiation field quantum mechanically. The radiation field has been quantized using the free field quantization techniques in the Coloumb Gauge with which the Lindblad Master equation has been derived systematically in the weak coupling limit. The optical Bloch equations has been derived for the resonantly driven two level atom from the Lindblad type master equation and later those equations has been solved in the steady state limit. The article also discuss the analytical aspects of describing the theory of atom matter interaction using full-fledged quantum mechanical approach.

•Nov 20, 2025•0 citations

Optical Bloch equations

Malin Premaratne, Govind Prasad Agrawal

The analysis in Chapter 3 used a phenomenological form of the permittivity to describe active materials. A proper understanding of optical amplification requires a quantum-mechanical approach for describing the interaction of light with atoms of an active medium [1]. However, even a relatively simple atom such as hydrogen or helium allows so many energy transitions that its full description is intractable even with modern computing machinery [2, 3]. The only solution is to look for idealized models that contain the most essential features of a realistic system. The semiclassical two-level-atom model has proven to be quite successful in this respect [4]. Even though a real atom has infinitely many energy levels, two energy levels whose energy difference nearly matches the photon energy suffice to understand the interaction dynamics when the atom interacts with nearly monochromatic radiation. Moreover, if the optical field contains a sufficiently large number of photons (> 100), it can be treated classically using a set of optical Bloch equations. In this chapter, we learn the underlying physical concepts behind the optical Bloch equations. We apply these equations in subsequent chapters to actual optical amplifiers and show that they can be solved analytically under certain conditions to provide a realistic description of optical amplifiers. It is essential to have a thorough understanding of the concept of a quantum state [5]. To effectively use the modern machinery of quantum mechanics, physical states need to be represented as vectors in so-called Hilbert space [6].

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Feb 3, 2011•1 citation

Nonlinear Schrödinger equation and semiclassical description of the light–atom interaction

Sergey A. Rashkovskiy

In this paper, we consider the nonlinear Schrödinger equation describing the light-atom interaction while taking into account damping due to spontaneous emission.We demonstrate that the optical Bloch equations with damping due to spontaneous emission can be derived immediately from the nonlinear Schrödinger equation without any phenomenology and quantization of radiation.The steady-state solutions of the nonlinear optical Bloch equations are obtained and compared with those obtained for linear optical equations.In this approximation, the light scattering by an atom is considered........

arXiv:1603.02102•Progress of Theoretical and Experimental Physics•Nov 10, 2016•10 citations

Semiclassical Maxwell-Bloch equations in superradiance theory by input-output formalism of quantum stochastic differential equations

Ashat M. Basharov

Collective spontaneous relaxation of identical atoms without any quantum correlation has been shown to give a semiclassical description of superradiance. The Maxwell- Bloch equation follows from the N atomic master equation which was derived within the framework of quantum stochastic differential equations.

Journal of Physics Conference Series•May 7, 2015•0 citations

Derivation of coupled Maxwell-Schrödinger equations describing matter-laser interaction from first principles of quantum electrodynamics

Milan Šindelka

We study the general problem of matter-laser interaction within the framework of nonrelativistic quantum electrodynamics, with particular emphasis on strong laser field effects. Consequently, we formulate a well-defined approximation leading in a straightforward manner toward the conventional semiclassical mode of description. Namely, we arrive naturally to two coupled equations of motion: (i) the Schr\"odinger equation which governs the quantum dynamics of an atomic system driven by classically described radiation field (composed of an incoming laser pulse plus radiation emitted from the atom), and (ii) the classical Maxwell wave equation which describes the emission of radiation from the mentioned atomic source. Employing the formalism of adiabatic Floquet theory, we derive a simple criterion of validity of the just described semiclassical approach. It shows that the semiclassical treatment is justified in most situations. On the other hand, it turns out that the semiclassical approximation breaks down completely in certain special but realistic cases, regardless of the fact that the incoming laser pulse contains a huge number of photons. Under such special circumstances, we anticipate new effects arising due to the quantized nature of the radiation field, to be observable, for example, in harmonic generation spectra. Our considerations are illustrated more explicitly using a simple model of a two-level atom strongly driven by a laser. The quantum dynamics of this model problem is resolved within the framework of quantum electrodynamics while adopting well-defined and physically justifiable approximations. As an outcome, analytic formulas are found serving as a quantitative criterion of (non)applicability of the semiclassical approach and demonstrating the breakdown of semiclassical theory under well-defined conditions. An illustrative numerical calculation is provided.

Physical Review A•Mar 18, 2010•15 citations
Interaction of atoms with quantum states of light is a long-standing problem that apart from fundamental physics has potential applications for optical quantum-state storage, quantum communication, and quantum information. A fully quantum mechanical treatment of this problem is usually very complicated mathematically. Here we show, however, that quantum mechanical evolution equations describing single-photon emission (absorption) by atomic ensembles can be written in a form equivalent to the semiclassical Maxwell-Bloch equations. This connection allows us to find exact analytical solutions of the fully quantum mechanical problem. We also found that semiclassical Maxwell-Bloch equations should be written in a form different from those commonly used. Namely, the classical limit of the quantum problem gives a propagation equation with the Laplacian operator on the right-hand side rather than with the second-order time derivative.
Abstract The atom-field interaction is treated in semiclassical radiation theory, starting from the transformation from the minimal coupling Hamiltonian to the electric dipole form used extensively in quantum optics. The Heisenberg and density matrix approaches are developed and applied to two-state atoms, Bloch equations, Rabi oscillations, Maxwell-Bloch equations, and transition rates for absorption and emission. Einstein’s theory of blackbody radiation based on momentum fluctuations and dissipation is reviewed. The Einstein fluctuation formula is derived and used to introduce wave-particle duality, Hanbury Brown-Twiss correlations, and photon bunching.
This tutorial article provides a detailed mathematical overview of the Optical Bloch equation describing the interaction of the two level atom with the Electromagnetic radi- ation field. The equations have been derived in the weak atom field coupling limit. The notion of the optical Bloch equations has been introduced in a systematic process starting from the interaction of the two level atom with the semiclassical radiation field which cannot completely the idea of the Spontaneous emission process later which was included theoretically by,Weigner-Weisskopf theory of spontaneous emission .In the later part of the article the optical Bloch equations has been derived exactly by treating the radiation field quantum mechanically. The radiation field has been quantized using the free field quantization techniques in the Coloumb Gauge with which the Lindblad Master equation has been derived systematically in the weak coupling limit. The optical Bloch equations has been derived for the resonantly driven two level atom from the Lindblad type master equation and later those equations has been solved in the steady state limit. The article also discuss the analytical aspects of describing the theory of atom matter interaction using full-fledged quantum mechanical approach.
The analysis in Chapter 3 used a phenomenological form of the permittivity to describe active materials. A proper understanding of optical amplification requires a quantum-mechanical approach for describing the interaction of light with atoms of an active medium [1]. However, even a relatively simple atom such as hydrogen or helium allows so many energy transitions that its full description is intractable even with modern computing machinery [2, 3]. The only solution is to look for idealized models that contain the most essential features of a realistic system. The semiclassical two-level-atom model has proven to be quite successful in this respect [4]. Even though a real atom has infinitely many energy levels, two energy levels whose energy difference nearly matches the photon energy suffice to understand the interaction dynamics when the atom interacts with nearly monochromatic radiation. Moreover, if the optical field contains a sufficiently large number of photons (> 100), it can be treated classically using a set of optical Bloch equations. In this chapter, we learn the underlying physical concepts behind the optical Bloch equations. We apply these equations in subsequent chapters to actual optical amplifiers and show that they can be solved analytically under certain conditions to provide a realistic description of optical amplifiers. It is essential to have a thorough understanding of the concept of a quantum state [5]. To effectively use the modern machinery of quantum mechanics, physical states need to be represented as vectors in so-called Hilbert space [6].
In this paper, we consider the nonlinear Schrödinger equation describing the light-atom interaction while taking into account damping due to spontaneous emission.We demonstrate that the optical Bloch equations with damping due to spontaneous emission can be derived immediately from the nonlinear Schrödinger equation without any phenomenology and quantization of radiation.The steady-state solutions of the nonlinear optical Bloch equations are obtained and compared with those obtained for linear optical equations.In this approximation, the light scattering by an atom is considered........
We study the general problem of matter-laser interaction within the framework of nonrelativistic quantum electrodynamics, with particular emphasis on strong laser field effects. Consequently, we formulate a well-defined approximation leading in a straightforward manner toward the conventional semiclassical mode of description. Namely, we arrive naturally to two coupled equations of motion: (i) the Schr\"odinger equation which governs the quantum dynamics of an atomic system driven by classically described radiation field (composed of an incoming laser pulse plus radiation emitted from the atom), and (ii) the classical Maxwell wave equation which describes the emission of radiation from the mentioned atomic source. Employing the formalism of adiabatic Floquet theory, we derive a simple criterion of validity of the just described semiclassical approach. It shows that the semiclassical treatment is justified in most situations. On the other hand, it turns out that the semiclassical approximation breaks down completely in certain special but realistic cases, regardless of the fact that the incoming laser pulse contains a huge number of photons. Under such special circumstances, we anticipate new effects arising due to the quantized nature of the radiation field, to be observable, for example, in harmonic generation spectra. Our considerations are illustrated more explicitly using a simple model of a two-level atom strongly driven by a laser. The quantum dynamics of this model problem is resolved within the framework of quantum electrodynamics while adopting well-defined and physically justifiable approximations. As an outcome, analytic formulas are found serving as a quantitative criterion of (non)applicability of the semiclassical approach and demonstrating the breakdown of semiclassical theory under well-defined conditions. An illustrative numerical calculation is provided.