Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

AIP conference proceedings

Propagation of finite mass (spin-0) particles in refraction phenomenon

Atirat Maksuwan, Wiwat Wongkokua, Pongpich Viriyasrisakul

Published Jan 1, 2016• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The first way of thinking that made the law about the behavior for rays of light evidence was discovered by Fermat in about 1650. His idea was all of the possible paths from one point to another point. The behavior for rays of light takes the path which requires the shortest time. The propose in this research, we investigated the refraction phenomenon by using the technique of the Green’s function together with the product of two Gaussian probability density functions (PDFs). The Green’s function was solved in detail with appropriate boundary originating an idea from the nonrelativistic propagator model of the finite mass (spin-0) particle in quantum field theory viewpoint. The finite mass (spin-0) particle was emitted from external sources or emitter in one medium and then propagates into another medium with the key idea: every point on the junction surface between two mediums can affect the particle in reaching the detector embedded in the second medium with different amplitude depend upon the impacting point. Our main results, we compared the amplitude by disregard about the material property, the most probable detection sighting occurred when the finite mass (spin-0) particle propagate subject to the route that takes the least time, which corresponds to the refraction property of Fermat’s principle of least time for geometrical optics in classical physics.

DOI
10.1063/1.4965167

Related papers

Fermat's Principle, Particles with Rest Mass and Quantum Mechanics

Francesco R. Ruggeri

Addendum Oct. 26, 2022 In ((3)) one should formally subtract i.e. d/dx{ -E1 t + (p1x) x +E2t + (p2x) x) = 0. Then p1x-p2x=0 and -E1 dt1/dx + E2 dt2/dx = 0. Thus conservation of momentum implies Fermat's principle. The minus sign between dt1/dx and dt2/dx follows from t1 being a variable of x and t2 of (L-x) where L is the length of the mirror such that initial and final y values have the same magnitude. (This does not change the conclusions made in the note we argue.) In a previous note (1) we argued that Fermat’s least time principle applied to light involved finding an expression for time in terms of spatial variables and the taking of d/dx where x is an invariant spatial variable in the problem. For example, for reflection from a stationary or constantly moving mirror in the y direction or refraction with different n(i) (indices of refraction in the y direction) x is invariant because there is no medium discontinuity in the x direction. We argued that Fermat’s principle is equivalent to a conservation law in the direction of the invariant variable and that this conservation is in fact that of momentum in this direction. In (2) we argued that E=pc with c=x/t i.e. the wave dispersion equation for light contains Fermat’s principle because one may write it as 0= -Et+px and apply d/dx using t(x) with x being the invariant variable. With conservation of momentum in the x direction and E1 = E2 for the two rays: dt1/dx + dt2/dx = 0 for a two ray problem. Fermat’s principle and E=pc pertain to light. The latter may be written as 0= -Et+px ((1)) for light with x/t=c which as we argued above leads to Fermat’s principle if one takes d/dx for two rays. One may note, however, that one also obtains Fermat’s principle for constant= -Et+px with momentum conservation in the x direction. Furthermore a particle with rest mass bouncing off a floor may behave like light. This we argue leads to the idea of considering two different frames. For light -E1 t1 + p1 x1 = 0 = -Et + px with x/t = x1/t1 = c. For a particle with rest mass -mo t1 + 0 = -Et+px with x/t=v where c=1 and mo is energy in a rest frame. (This is in fact the idea of a Lorentz invariant.) Thus Fermat’s principle for a free particle seems to appear in the form -Et+px = constant. The constant is 0 for light. The form -Et+px is consistent with a wavelength proportional to 1/p and a frequency to 1/E not only for light, but for the particle with rest mass. We argue that light moving in a medium is a complicated statistical process of scattering, but that the problem is treated in a “thermodynamical” manner by characterizing the medium by a single number i.e. single piece of information, namely the index of refraction i.e. c→c/n and p→pn for light. We argue that movement within the medium is like moving in a kind of constant potential for light. -Et+ (pn) x still holds and there is still conservation of momentum in the x direction for two media. Thus the idea of d/dx → p is already present in the photon form -Et+px which follows from Maxwell’s equations, but could also be derived from Fermat’s principle as argued in (2). In other words, ideas of quantum mechanics for a particle with rest mass could ultimately follow from Fermat’s principle, we argue. A free particle with rest mass is linked with constant= -Et+px and if one wishes to have an eigenfunction of momentum then: -id/dx exp(ipx) = p exp(ipx). For a constant potential, just like with light, p would change, but the form exp(ipx) would remain. Thus it seems that even in average situations (like refraction) one still wants to have a periodic type spatial function W(x) such that -d/dx d/dx W(x) /W(x) = <pp> such that <pp>/2m + V(x) = E for a particle with rest mass. This is the Schrodinger equation and it is found mathematically that only certain En are allowed if one wishes to have specific boundary conditions like W(x) →0 at +/- infinite for say an oscillator problem. Thus we argue that the fundamental idea of taking a derivative of an invariant spatial variable in Fermat’s principle which automatically yields conservation of momentum is a basic idea found in quantum mechanics even for a particle with rest mass, namely that d/dx is associated with momentum. Mathematically d/dx is a translation operator and so the link with Fermat’s principle shows how translation is linked with a spatially invariant spatial variable e.g. x. Furthermore Fermat’s principle shows that even complicated statistical scattering problems such as refraction (in which the photon scatters off of different molecules in different media) can be reduced to a periodic average problem with p→pn. This suggests that for a particle with a rest mass in a potential V(x) one should also have a periodic spatial variable such that d/dx d/dx is linked to average momentum, we argue.

•Oct 25, 2022•0 citations

Momentum ConservationIncluded In Fermat's Least Time Principle and Wave Mechanics

Francesco R. Ruggeri

According to (1) Fermat’s minimum time principle is identical to Hyugen’s wave principle. In a previous note (2) we considered two ray light systems (in particular Snell’s law and reflection from a mirror moving at constant velocity v) and argued that Fermat’s principle is equivalent to a hypothetical velocity approach where H sin(AA) = v(A relative) and H sin(BB = v(B relative). Here H is the hypothetical velocity which acts as a hypotenuse and AA and BB are the incident and reflected rays in the case of a moving mirror (measured relative to the normal) and the incident and refracted rays for Snell’s law. The hypothetical velocity approach, however, is exactly in the form needed for conservation of momentum parallel to the medium surface which holds for both the moving mirror and Snell’s law if: 1/wavelength(A) is proportional to 1/v(A relative) and the same result for B. This is equivalent to considering a fixed frequency f which applies to A and B (and is not 1/energy proportional to wavelength) so that vrel(A) = (same frequency) wavelength(A) and the same for B. As a result, conservation of momentum parallel to the medium surface is implicitly included in Fermat’s principle. In the case of quantum mechanics of a free particle represented by exp(ipx) where p is momentum, conservation of momentum is also built in because exp(ipx) is orthogonal to exp(ip1x). For <exp(ip1x) A W> where W is a wavelength only results consistent with conservation of momentum occur as is well-known in the literature. We argue that quantum mechanics of a free particle is statistical and linked to the idea of an equilibrium for which one does not consider time. Thus for exp(-iEt+ipx), t and x may be considered as independent. This implies that exp(ipx) must carry the idea of conservation of momentum by itself because one is not following a particle via x(t). “X’ may take on any value so this is an equilibrium type of scenario and the orthogonality of different exp(ipx) vectors ensures conservation of momentum. Thus a wave approach again implicitly contains the notion of conservation of momentum.

•Sep 20, 2022•0 citations

Information, Quantum Probability and Reflection/Refraction

Francesco R. Ruggeri

Quantum mechanics is known for its “square root” probability i.e. the existence of a wavefunction W(x) such that P(x) = W*(x)W(x). This begs the question: Why is this the case? In Maxwell’s electromagnetic theory of the photon, a similar situation arises except that one has energy density instead of P(x) which consists of .5C1 Electric field* Electric field + .5c2 Magnetic field*Magnetic field. The “square root” object is a physical observable (Electric field, Magnetic field) which both behave as cos(-Et+px) and so, more accessible than W(x). Alternatively one may use Fermat’s least time principle for light to show that i two dimensional problems (reflection/refraction) d/dx (used in extremization) is really the operator of momentum in that direction i.e. a spatial invariant direction. Thus A=px such that dA/dx=p = x component of momentum which may be generalized to A=-Et+p dot r. (p.r) may be written as -i ln(exp(ip dot r) with exp(i p dot r) representing a “kind of probability”. This probability may be considered a square root probability because for uniform motion (light) all x points along a ray should have equal probability. Thus exp(i p dot r) maps into a constant which happens if one takes the modulus. Both of the above approaches (using continuity at x or a kind of conservation of probability and a momentum) may be used to solve the problem of an incident beam of light moving in the positive x direction hitting a medium and both reflecting and refracting. For example see (1). The goal is to find the two intensity values associated with the reflected and refracted beams assuming the incident intensity is known. In this note, we take a different approach to finding the two unknowns, one that does not use the idea of the electric field proportional to cos(-Et+px) or the probability exp(ipx). We wish to solve the problem using only the idea of information and stress the importance of beginning with energy conservation a priori unlike the two approaches listed above. We postulate that there are two sets of information in this problem. First there is the notion of Energy = p(momentum in a vacuum) n c/n where n is the index of refraction. Thus the incident and reflected light are associated with pc1,c1 and the refracted with pc2, c2 with energy being the same for all. Second there is the idea of conservation of energy i.e. if ten photons with energy E hit the surface and a10 reflect and (1-a)10 refract, then the sum of the refracted and reflected energy equals the initial energy. Energy is then equated with intensity through Intensity/c = energy (1). Using only these two pieces of information we argue one should be able to find the intensity of both the reflected and refracted ray. This leads to an immediate problem because there are two unknowns and only one equation, namely conservation of energy i.e. I(A)/c1 = I(B)/c1 + I(C)/c2 where A is the incident beam, B the reflected and C the refracted. Writing as: I(A)/c1 - I(B)/c1 = I(C)/c2 (i.e. a spatial instead of time grouping) suggests a possible solution might be to employ a difference of squares noting that 1/c = p/E with E being a constant in the problem. Thus one may reduce the problem to A+B=C and p1A-p1B=p2C. This is of the form of a new kind of “square root” type probability, but leads to two equations with two unknowns (A is assumed to be known) which allows the problem to be solved.

•Dec 5, 2022•0 citations

Reflection and refraction of photons

Imants Bersons, Rita Veilande, Ojārs Balcers

Abstract Three linear equations are proposed as quantum-mechanical equations for the free propagating photons. The solution of these equations is the vector potential of the electromagnetic field and it is a product of the Gaussian functions for the transverse coordinates and the eigenfunction of the harmonic oscillator for the longitudinal coordinate. This solutions is used to describe the reflection and refraction of photons on the boundary between two dielectrics. The amplitude of the reflected field coincides with the Fresnel formulae for the plane waves, but the amplitude of the refracted field is different. These amplitudes are the probability’s amplitudes of reflection and refraction of photons—like in the quantum mechanics. The photons propagated from the first into the second medium increase (decrease) their transverse size in the plane of incidence, if the refraction index of the second medium is greater (smaller) than in the first medium. The increasing or decreasing grow when increasing the angle of incidence. The difference between the quantum mechanics of the particles with a mass and the photons, as well as the interpretation of the wave function of photons, is discussed.

Physica Scripta•Feb 1, 2022•5 citations

Fermat's Principle and Quantum Bound States

Francesco R. Ruggeri

In a previous note (1) we argued that Fermat’s principle of least time is present in the photon wave dispersion relationship E=pc which may be written as 0 = -Et+px with x/t=c. We argued that a nonzero constant = -Et+px applies to a free particle with rest mass, but that Fermat’s principle is still present. Furthemore the form -Et + px implies the existence of a frequency and wavelength for both a photon and free particle with rest mass. (Interestingly -Et+px is both the free particle relativistic action -mo t sqrt(1-vv/cc) and nonrelativistic .5mo t vv with c=1 and v=x/t. ) Fermat’s principle implies that d/dx → momentum (x component) as discussed in(1). An eigenfunction exp(ipx) demonstraties wave behaviour of a free particle with rest mass. In (1) we argued that if one knocks out a quantum bound particle it will be in a state exp(ipx). Thus this wave type information should also be included in the bound state so wepostulated a bound state represented by W(x) = Sum over p a(p)exp(ipx) (i.e. a wavefunction) such that the Fermat result d/dx → p still holds. In this note we wish to consider the idea of a statistical equilibrium and the concept of a constant energy. In the case of refraction it seems a complicated statistical scattering process occurs which slows down the motion of a photon i.e. c changes to c/n where n is the index of refraction. Thus one piece of information, namely n, describes the complicated statistical process as in thermodynamics. If E (energy) remains constant p→ pn. Thus in this complicated statistical scenario a cos(-Et+pn x) electric field pattern remains but p → pn i.e the wavelength has changed. The idea of a constant energy may even be applied to light scattering from a mirror moving with a constant v in the negative y direction. The actual energy and momentum of the incident and reflected rays are not equal, but for E1 special = p1 v(relative 1) and E2 special = p2 v(relative 2) with v(relative 1) = c- vcos(A) and v(relative 2)= c+vcos(B) where A and B are angles of incidence and reflection measured with respect to the y axis. E1 special t=E2 special. In this note we retain the idea that a particle knocked from a quantum single particle bound state is described by exp(ipx) in keeping with Femat’s principle. We consider the bound state to still have waves as Fermat’s principle suggests d/dx →p, but they cannot be of the same height and width because of the changing value of V(x) with x (i.e. the potential). According to Newton’s law one has conservation of energy i.e. pp/2m + V(x) = E, but we consider this to apply to a p (rms) = m v(rms) in the Schrodinger equation. If the forms exp(ipx)’s are to be retained within the bound quantum state (i.e. this information is not lost) and one has a constant E (energy) then the potential must be modified statistically to allow for the idea of conservation of energy for each p, but must also represent a constant potential to retain the form of exp(ipx). Thus in short the Schrodinger equation becomes a weighted sum of exp(i p(j) x) functions with each having a different wavelength (like refraction), but interacting with different constant potentials to ensure that E remains constant for each p(j). In other words we think of a potential V(x) as a statistical set of refraction discontinuities i.e. impulses which produce exp(ipx)’s which are like light moving through a homogeneous medium i.e. a momentum eigenstates. For this to happen, however, the various exp(ipx)’s need to combine with V(x) = Sum over k Vk exp(ikx) terms to create a Vmodified(p) exp(ipx) where Vmodiied(p) is a constant because each free particle exp(ipx) is associated with a different effective potential and a kinetic energy pp/2m, but the same energy En. We argue that this results from applying ideas of Femat’s principle to a particle with rest mass. Newton’s picture of a particle accelerating i.e. x(t) emerges if one considers rms values for which all information of exp(ipx) and crests/troughs of W(x) are ignored. In particular, W(x)=wavefunction may have crests and troughs, but -1/2m d/dx dW/dx/ W = KE(x) Newton which shows no crests or troughs, but simply balances V(x) in KE(x)+V(x) = E.

•Oct 28, 2022•0 citations

Spatial Invariance, Special Relativity and the Quantum Wave

Francesco R. Ruggeri

Newtonian mechanics (from the 1600s) defines a quantity called momentum p in terms of mv where m is mass and v=dx/dt with dx and dt tending to zero. Newton’s first law is equivalent to conservation of momentum in the absence of a force. The second demonstrates how p changes under a force. If one has equal action/reaction then overall momentum is conserved. As a consequence the idea of a “wave” associated with p does not arise. The main focus is on the idea of force. Fermat’s Least Time Principle for light (1600s), however, is based on minimizing the overall time traveled by light which reflects or refracts. Young’s interference experiments did not occur until the very early 1800s and Newton considered light to be a particle at this time. In fact light bounces off a foil creating an impact like a particle. Fermat’s principle does not directly make use of momentum or its conservation. It is focused on minimizing time. To do so, however, one must take a derivative with respect to a certain variable and set it equal to 0. This variable is the spatially invariant one in a problem. For example consider reflection (stationary or moving mirror) or refraction in two dimensions x,y. Let the mirror or medium face lie along the x axis at y=0. There exists a constraint on y and given a fixed starting point one cannot change y. This leaves x to be varied because it is invariant. Thus the extremization of time is really a statement of invariance of a spatial variable. In other words, Fermat’s principle is linked to the physical variables t and x while Newton’s focuses on p (momentum). This invariance in turn gives rise to conservation of momentum in the direction of the invariant variable i.e. (px). There is still the idea of Newton’s change in momentum as (py) abruptly changes in refraction as it hits the interface of media. The point we wish to make is that from Fermat’s least time principle one sees that conservation of momentum in the absence of a force is completely intertwined with invariance in space. The two cannot be separated in this approach and there is nothing unphysical about t or x. In fact, one may create a function A= -Et + (px)x + (py)y such that dA/dx partial = px = conserved quantity. In this function (px) and x are on the same footing. One does not have one without the other. This idea is carried over into special relativity as -Et+p dot r is a Lorentz invariant. Given that p momentum is physical (it manifests itself in impulse hits) and p and x are inseparable in (px)x we suggest there should exist a physical manifestation in x i.e. in space linked to the maintenance of conservation of momentum in this direction even in the absence of a force. This we argue leads to the physical idea of a wavelength which follows from A=-Et+px with A=0 in all constant velocity frames leading to a frequency proportional to 1/E and wavelength to 1/p. We have discussed these ideas in previous notes, but the main point we wish to make here is that equivalence of spatial invariance in the x direction in Fermat’s principle with conservation of momentum in the same direction suggests that if p is physical, the spatial invariance must also be manifested physically. It is not simply a mathematical convenience to link t to x to px, we argue. Furthermore this wavelength should be linked to establishing conservation of momentum as it does in quantum mechanics where the orthogonality of exp(ipx) i.e. Integral exp(-i p1 x) exp(ip x) dx automatically ensures p1=p without imposing momentum conservation a priori as in Newton’s first law. Both Newtonian mechanics and Fermat’s principle suggest that p may change abruptly due to a force or an immediate change in medium. The idea of a physical wavelength, however, suggests there may be interactions completely different from an abrupt change in p due to an impulse. In particular there may be interference or Bohm-Aharonov interactions. Newtonian Mechanics

•Nov 10, 2022•0 citations
The first way of thinking that made the law about the behavior for rays of light evidence was discovered by Fermat in about 1650. His idea was all of the possible paths from one point to another point. The behavior for rays of light takes the path which requires the shortest time. The propose in this research, we investigated the refraction phenomenon by using the technique of the Green’s function together with the product of two Gaussian probability density functions (PDFs). The Green’s function was solved in detail with appropriate boundary originating an idea from the nonrelativistic propagator model of the finite mass (spin-0) particle in quantum field theory viewpoint. The finite mass (spin-0) particle was emitted from external sources or emitter in one medium and then propagates into another medium with the key idea: every point on the junction surface between two mediums can affect the particle in reaching the detector embedded in the second medium with different amplitude depend upon the impacting point. Our main results, we compared the amplitude by disregard about the material property, the most probable detection sighting occurred when the finite mass (spin-0) particle propagate subject to the route that takes the least time, which corresponds to the refraction property of Fermat’s principle of least time for geometrical optics in classical physics.
Addendum Oct. 26, 2022 In ((3)) one should formally subtract i.e. d/dx{ -E1 t + (p1x) x +E2t + (p2x) x) = 0. Then p1x-p2x=0 and -E1 dt1/dx + E2 dt2/dx = 0. Thus conservation of momentum implies Fermat's principle. The minus sign between dt1/dx and dt2/dx follows from t1 being a variable of x and t2 of (L-x) where L is the length of the mirror such that initial and final y values have the same magnitude. (This does not change the conclusions made in the note we argue.) In a previous note (1) we argued that Fermat’s least time principle applied to light involved finding an expression for time in terms of spatial variables and the taking of d/dx where x is an invariant spatial variable in the problem. For example, for reflection from a stationary or constantly moving mirror in the y direction or refraction with different n(i) (indices of refraction in the y direction) x is invariant because there is no medium discontinuity in the x direction. We argued that Fermat’s principle is equivalent to a conservation law in the direction of the invariant variable and that this conservation is in fact that of momentum in this direction. In (2) we argued that E=pc with c=x/t i.e. the wave dispersion equation for light contains Fermat’s principle because one may write it as 0= -Et+px and apply d/dx using t(x) with x being the invariant variable. With conservation of momentum in the x direction and E1 = E2 for the two rays: dt1/dx + dt2/dx = 0 for a two ray problem. Fermat’s principle and E=pc pertain to light. The latter may be written as 0= -Et+px ((1)) for light with x/t=c which as we argued above leads to Fermat’s principle if one takes d/dx for two rays. One may note, however, that one also obtains Fermat’s principle for constant= -Et+px with momentum conservation in the x direction. Furthermore a particle with rest mass bouncing off a floor may behave like light. This we argue leads to the idea of considering two different frames. For light -E1 t1 + p1 x1 = 0 = -Et + px with x/t = x1/t1 = c. For a particle with rest mass -mo t1 + 0 = -Et+px with x/t=v where c=1 and mo is energy in a rest frame. (This is in fact the idea of a Lorentz invariant.) Thus Fermat’s principle for a free particle seems to appear in the form -Et+px = constant. The constant is 0 for light. The form -Et+px is consistent with a wavelength proportional to 1/p and a frequency to 1/E not only for light, but for the particle with rest mass. We argue that light moving in a medium is a complicated statistical process of scattering, but that the problem is treated in a “thermodynamical” manner by characterizing the medium by a single number i.e. single piece of information, namely the index of refraction i.e. c→c/n and p→pn for light. We argue that movement within the medium is like moving in a kind of constant potential for light. -Et+ (pn) x still holds and there is still conservation of momentum in the x direction for two media. Thus the idea of d/dx → p is already present in the photon form -Et+px which follows from Maxwell’s equations, but could also be derived from Fermat’s principle as argued in (2). In other words, ideas of quantum mechanics for a particle with rest mass could ultimately follow from Fermat’s principle, we argue. A free particle with rest mass is linked with constant= -Et+px and if one wishes to have an eigenfunction of momentum then: -id/dx exp(ipx) = p exp(ipx). For a constant potential, just like with light, p would change, but the form exp(ipx) would remain. Thus it seems that even in average situations (like refraction) one still wants to have a periodic type spatial function W(x) such that -d/dx d/dx W(x) /W(x) = <pp> such that <pp>/2m + V(x) = E for a particle with rest mass. This is the Schrodinger equation and it is found mathematically that only certain En are allowed if one wishes to have specific boundary conditions like W(x) →0 at +/- infinite for say an oscillator problem. Thus we argue that the fundamental idea of taking a derivative of an invariant spatial variable in Fermat’s principle which automatically yields conservation of momentum is a basic idea found in quantum mechanics even for a particle with rest mass, namely that d/dx is associated with momentum. Mathematically d/dx is a translation operator and so the link with Fermat’s principle shows how translation is linked with a spatially invariant spatial variable e.g. x. Furthermore Fermat’s principle shows that even complicated statistical scattering problems such as refraction (in which the photon scatters off of different molecules in different media) can be reduced to a periodic average problem with p→pn. This suggests that for a particle with a rest mass in a potential V(x) one should also have a periodic spatial variable such that d/dx d/dx is linked to average momentum, we argue.
According to (1) Fermat’s minimum time principle is identical to Hyugen’s wave principle. In a previous note (2) we considered two ray light systems (in particular Snell’s law and reflection from a mirror moving at constant velocity v) and argued that Fermat’s principle is equivalent to a hypothetical velocity approach where H sin(AA) = v(A relative) and H sin(BB = v(B relative). Here H is the hypothetical velocity which acts as a hypotenuse and AA and BB are the incident and reflected rays in the case of a moving mirror (measured relative to the normal) and the incident and refracted rays for Snell’s law. The hypothetical velocity approach, however, is exactly in the form needed for conservation of momentum parallel to the medium surface which holds for both the moving mirror and Snell’s law if: 1/wavelength(A) is proportional to 1/v(A relative) and the same result for B. This is equivalent to considering a fixed frequency f which applies to A and B (and is not 1/energy proportional to wavelength) so that vrel(A) = (same frequency) wavelength(A) and the same for B. As a result, conservation of momentum parallel to the medium surface is implicitly included in Fermat’s principle. In the case of quantum mechanics of a free particle represented by exp(ipx) where p is momentum, conservation of momentum is also built in because exp(ipx) is orthogonal to exp(ip1x). For <exp(ip1x) A W> where W is a wavelength only results consistent with conservation of momentum occur as is well-known in the literature. We argue that quantum mechanics of a free particle is statistical and linked to the idea of an equilibrium for which one does not consider time. Thus for exp(-iEt+ipx), t and x may be considered as independent. This implies that exp(ipx) must carry the idea of conservation of momentum by itself because one is not following a particle via x(t). “X’ may take on any value so this is an equilibrium type of scenario and the orthogonality of different exp(ipx) vectors ensures conservation of momentum. Thus a wave approach again implicitly contains the notion of conservation of momentum.
Quantum mechanics is known for its “square root” probability i.e. the existence of a wavefunction W(x) such that P(x) = W*(x)W(x). This begs the question: Why is this the case? In Maxwell’s electromagnetic theory of the photon, a similar situation arises except that one has energy density instead of P(x) which consists of .5C1 Electric field* Electric field + .5c2 Magnetic field*Magnetic field. The “square root” object is a physical observable (Electric field, Magnetic field) which both behave as cos(-Et+px) and so, more accessible than W(x). Alternatively one may use Fermat’s least time principle for light to show that i two dimensional problems (reflection/refraction) d/dx (used in extremization) is really the operator of momentum in that direction i.e. a spatial invariant direction. Thus A=px such that dA/dx=p = x component of momentum which may be generalized to A=-Et+p dot r. (p.r) may be written as -i ln(exp(ip dot r) with exp(i p dot r) representing a “kind of probability”. This probability may be considered a square root probability because for uniform motion (light) all x points along a ray should have equal probability. Thus exp(i p dot r) maps into a constant which happens if one takes the modulus. Both of the above approaches (using continuity at x or a kind of conservation of probability and a momentum) may be used to solve the problem of an incident beam of light moving in the positive x direction hitting a medium and both reflecting and refracting. For example see (1). The goal is to find the two intensity values associated with the reflected and refracted beams assuming the incident intensity is known. In this note, we take a different approach to finding the two unknowns, one that does not use the idea of the electric field proportional to cos(-Et+px) or the probability exp(ipx). We wish to solve the problem using only the idea of information and stress the importance of beginning with energy conservation a priori unlike the two approaches listed above. We postulate that there are two sets of information in this problem. First there is the notion of Energy = p(momentum in a vacuum) n c/n where n is the index of refraction. Thus the incident and reflected light are associated with pc1,c1 and the refracted with pc2, c2 with energy being the same for all. Second there is the idea of conservation of energy i.e. if ten photons with energy E hit the surface and a10 reflect and (1-a)10 refract, then the sum of the refracted and reflected energy equals the initial energy. Energy is then equated with intensity through Intensity/c = energy (1). Using only these two pieces of information we argue one should be able to find the intensity of both the reflected and refracted ray. This leads to an immediate problem because there are two unknowns and only one equation, namely conservation of energy i.e. I(A)/c1 = I(B)/c1 + I(C)/c2 where A is the incident beam, B the reflected and C the refracted. Writing as: I(A)/c1 - I(B)/c1 = I(C)/c2 (i.e. a spatial instead of time grouping) suggests a possible solution might be to employ a difference of squares noting that 1/c = p/E with E being a constant in the problem. Thus one may reduce the problem to A+B=C and p1A-p1B=p2C. This is of the form of a new kind of “square root” type probability, but leads to two equations with two unknowns (A is assumed to be known) which allows the problem to be solved.
Abstract Three linear equations are proposed as quantum-mechanical equations for the free propagating photons. The solution of these equations is the vector potential of the electromagnetic field and it is a product of the Gaussian functions for the transverse coordinates and the eigenfunction of the harmonic oscillator for the longitudinal coordinate. This solutions is used to describe the reflection and refraction of photons on the boundary between two dielectrics. The amplitude of the reflected field coincides with the Fresnel formulae for the plane waves, but the amplitude of the refracted field is different. These amplitudes are the probability’s amplitudes of reflection and refraction of photons—like in the quantum mechanics. The photons propagated from the first into the second medium increase (decrease) their transverse size in the plane of incidence, if the refraction index of the second medium is greater (smaller) than in the first medium. The increasing or decreasing grow when increasing the angle of incidence. The difference between the quantum mechanics of the particles with a mass and the photons, as well as the interpretation of the wave function of photons, is discussed.
In a previous note (1) we argued that Fermat’s principle of least time is present in the photon wave dispersion relationship E=pc which may be written as 0 = -Et+px with x/t=c. We argued that a nonzero constant = -Et+px applies to a free particle with rest mass, but that Fermat’s principle is still present. Furthemore the form -Et + px implies the existence of a frequency and wavelength for both a photon and free particle with rest mass. (Interestingly -Et+px is both the free particle relativistic action -mo t sqrt(1-vv/cc) and nonrelativistic .5mo t vv with c=1 and v=x/t. ) Fermat’s principle implies that d/dx → momentum (x component) as discussed in(1). An eigenfunction exp(ipx) demonstraties wave behaviour of a free particle with rest mass. In (1) we argued that if one knocks out a quantum bound particle it will be in a state exp(ipx). Thus this wave type information should also be included in the bound state so wepostulated a bound state represented by W(x) = Sum over p a(p)exp(ipx) (i.e. a wavefunction) such that the Fermat result d/dx → p still holds. In this note we wish to consider the idea of a statistical equilibrium and the concept of a constant energy. In the case of refraction it seems a complicated statistical scattering process occurs which slows down the motion of a photon i.e. c changes to c/n where n is the index of refraction. Thus one piece of information, namely n, describes the complicated statistical process as in thermodynamics. If E (energy) remains constant p→ pn. Thus in this complicated statistical scenario a cos(-Et+pn x) electric field pattern remains but p → pn i.e the wavelength has changed. The idea of a constant energy may even be applied to light scattering from a mirror moving with a constant v in the negative y direction. The actual energy and momentum of the incident and reflected rays are not equal, but for E1 special = p1 v(relative 1) and E2 special = p2 v(relative 2) with v(relative 1) = c- vcos(A) and v(relative 2)= c+vcos(B) where A and B are angles of incidence and reflection measured with respect to the y axis. E1 special t=E2 special. In this note we retain the idea that a particle knocked from a quantum single particle bound state is described by exp(ipx) in keeping with Femat’s principle. We consider the bound state to still have waves as Fermat’s principle suggests d/dx →p, but they cannot be of the same height and width because of the changing value of V(x) with x (i.e. the potential). According to Newton’s law one has conservation of energy i.e. pp/2m + V(x) = E, but we consider this to apply to a p (rms) = m v(rms) in the Schrodinger equation. If the forms exp(ipx)’s are to be retained within the bound quantum state (i.e. this information is not lost) and one has a constant E (energy) then the potential must be modified statistically to allow for the idea of conservation of energy for each p, but must also represent a constant potential to retain the form of exp(ipx). Thus in short the Schrodinger equation becomes a weighted sum of exp(i p(j) x) functions with each having a different wavelength (like refraction), but interacting with different constant potentials to ensure that E remains constant for each p(j). In other words we think of a potential V(x) as a statistical set of refraction discontinuities i.e. impulses which produce exp(ipx)’s which are like light moving through a homogeneous medium i.e. a momentum eigenstates. For this to happen, however, the various exp(ipx)’s need to combine with V(x) = Sum over k Vk exp(ikx) terms to create a Vmodified(p) exp(ipx) where Vmodiied(p) is a constant because each free particle exp(ipx) is associated with a different effective potential and a kinetic energy pp/2m, but the same energy En. We argue that this results from applying ideas of Femat’s principle to a particle with rest mass. Newton’s picture of a particle accelerating i.e. x(t) emerges if one considers rms values for which all information of exp(ipx) and crests/troughs of W(x) are ignored. In particular, W(x)=wavefunction may have crests and troughs, but -1/2m d/dx dW/dx/ W = KE(x) Newton which shows no crests or troughs, but simply balances V(x) in KE(x)+V(x) = E.
Newtonian mechanics (from the 1600s) defines a quantity called momentum p in terms of mv where m is mass and v=dx/dt with dx and dt tending to zero. Newton’s first law is equivalent to conservation of momentum in the absence of a force. The second demonstrates how p changes under a force. If one has equal action/reaction then overall momentum is conserved. As a consequence the idea of a “wave” associated with p does not arise. The main focus is on the idea of force. Fermat’s Least Time Principle for light (1600s), however, is based on minimizing the overall time traveled by light which reflects or refracts. Young’s interference experiments did not occur until the very early 1800s and Newton considered light to be a particle at this time. In fact light bounces off a foil creating an impact like a particle. Fermat’s principle does not directly make use of momentum or its conservation. It is focused on minimizing time. To do so, however, one must take a derivative with respect to a certain variable and set it equal to 0. This variable is the spatially invariant one in a problem. For example consider reflection (stationary or moving mirror) or refraction in two dimensions x,y. Let the mirror or medium face lie along the x axis at y=0. There exists a constraint on y and given a fixed starting point one cannot change y. This leaves x to be varied because it is invariant. Thus the extremization of time is really a statement of invariance of a spatial variable. In other words, Fermat’s principle is linked to the physical variables t and x while Newton’s focuses on p (momentum). This invariance in turn gives rise to conservation of momentum in the direction of the invariant variable i.e. (px). There is still the idea of Newton’s change in momentum as (py) abruptly changes in refraction as it hits the interface of media. The point we wish to make is that from Fermat’s least time principle one sees that conservation of momentum in the absence of a force is completely intertwined with invariance in space. The two cannot be separated in this approach and there is nothing unphysical about t or x. In fact, one may create a function A= -Et + (px)x + (py)y such that dA/dx partial = px = conserved quantity. In this function (px) and x are on the same footing. One does not have one without the other. This idea is carried over into special relativity as -Et+p dot r is a Lorentz invariant. Given that p momentum is physical (it manifests itself in impulse hits) and p and x are inseparable in (px)x we suggest there should exist a physical manifestation in x i.e. in space linked to the maintenance of conservation of momentum in this direction even in the absence of a force. This we argue leads to the physical idea of a wavelength which follows from A=-Et+px with A=0 in all constant velocity frames leading to a frequency proportional to 1/E and wavelength to 1/p. We have discussed these ideas in previous notes, but the main point we wish to make here is that equivalence of spatial invariance in the x direction in Fermat’s principle with conservation of momentum in the same direction suggests that if p is physical, the spatial invariance must also be manifested physically. It is not simply a mathematical convenience to link t to x to px, we argue. Furthermore this wavelength should be linked to establishing conservation of momentum as it does in quantum mechanics where the orthogonality of exp(ipx) i.e. Integral exp(-i p1 x) exp(ip x) dx automatically ensures p1=p without imposing momentum conservation a priori as in Newton’s first law. Both Newtonian mechanics and Fermat’s principle suggest that p may change abruptly due to a force or an immediate change in medium. The idea of a physical wavelength, however, suggests there may be interactions completely different from an abrupt change in p due to an impulse. In particular there may be interference or Bohm-Aharonov interactions. Newtonian Mechanics