Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Iterative path integral calculations of non-linear spectra and entanglement dynamics

Mohammad Mehdi Sahrapour

Published May 24, 2013• 0 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

We review an iterative path integral method that allows the computation of exact, long-time dynamics of small systems interacting with a dissipative bath. The method takes advantage of the finite memory of large environments at finite temperature to allow an iterative evaluation of the dynamics, thereby replacing an exponential scaling in simulation time with a linear scaling. This method is applied to calculate the dynamics of two model systems. The first consists of two-qubits interacting with a common bath. In this case we observe a variety of entanglement effects. If the qubits are initially separable, through an indirect coupling, the bath can create steady state entanglement between the qubits. This effect is due to the existence of a decoherence-free subspace as a result of the form of the qubit Hamiltonian and system-bath coupling. Entanglement created by the bath is shown to decrease with increasing temperature and system-bath coupling strength. However large system-bath coupling causes a faster increase in the entanglement. Initially entangled qubits lose their entanglement as a result of interactions with the bath, an effect that is heightened at higher temperatures. Direct coupling between the qubits is shown to slow the decay of entanglement and preserve some entanglement at long times; however at high temperatures this steady state entanglement becomes negligible. The second system we consider is vibrational degree of freedom coupled to a bath of harmonic oscillators or two-level systems. We compute four-time correlation functions which are used to calculate response functions relevant to third order infrared or seventh order Raman experiments for harmonic, Morse, and quadratic-quartic potentials. Our calculations reveal the role of potential features (anharmonicity and eigenvalue spectrum), both on short and long time scales, on the response function. Further, thermal excitation causes dramatic changes in the appearance of the response function, introducing symmetry with respect to the main diagonal. Finally, coupling to harmonic dissipative baths leads to decay of the response function (primarily along the t3 direction) and a broadening of the peaks in its Fourier transform. At high temperatures two-level-system baths are less efficient in destroying coherence than harmonic baths of similar parameters.

Related papers

Tunneling, decoherence, and entanglement of two spins interacting with a dissipative bath

Mohammad Mehdi Sahrapour, Nancy Makri

We use numerically exact iterative path integral methods to investigate the decoherence and entanglement dynamics of a tunneling pair of two coupled qubits (spins) system interacting with a dissipative bath. We find that decoherence is generally accompanied by the destruction of entanglement, although the specifics of this destruction depend sensitively on the parameters of the Hamiltonian (qubit-qubit coupling and/or energy bias), the strength of dissipation, the temperature, and the choice of initial condition. We also observe that dissipation can in some cases generate a substantial amount of entanglement. Finally, if an entangled eigenstate exists which does not couple to the environment, the long-time entanglement can significantly exceed the value corresponding to the Boltzmann equilibrium state.

The Journal of Chemical Physics•Mar 20, 2013•21 citations

Iterative path integral formulation of equilibrium correlation functions for quantum dissipative systems

Jiushu Shao, Nancy Makri

We present an iterative path integral algorithm for computing multitime correlation functions of a quantum system coupled to a dissipative bath of harmonic oscillators. By splitting the Boltzmann operator into two parts and reordering the propagators in the expression for canonical correlation functions, we are able to transform the evolution time contour into a symmetric one so that a forward propagation and a backward one are specified. Because the memory induced by the bath through the Feynman–Vernon influence functional decays rapidly in the complex time plane, long-time correlations are negligible. Taking advantage of this fact, we show that the correlation function can be obtained via an iterative procedure. The method is used to calculate three-time correlation functions of a dissipative two-level system.

The Journal of Chemical Physics•Jan 8, 2002•79 citations

Path integral renormalization for quantum dissipative dynamics with multiple timescales

Nancy Makri

The reduced density matrix of a system coupled to a harmonic dissipative bath can be obtained accurately using an iterative path integral methodology that involves a propagator tensor, whose rank is roughly equal to the number of time steps that span the bath-induced memory. The present work shows that even in situations where the bath is characterized by high-frequency modes (which necessitate a small time step) and slow oscillators (which give rise to very long memory), efficient propagation that takes into account the memory on all time scales is feasible by renormalizing the propagator matrix to include successively larger-length influence functional correlations. At its crudest level, the renormalized propagator is an ordinary matrix, thus the computational demands of the method are very modest, similar to those for propagating the bare system. Yet, test applications on dissipative two-level systems show that the method produces accurate results in demanding situations. By including memory on successively increasing time scales, the method is capable of capturing nonexponential kinetics induced by sluggish solvents.

Molecular Physics•May 10, 2012•30 citations

Path integral formulation of dissipative quantum dynamics

Alexey Novikov

In this thesis the path integral formalism is applied to the calculation of the dynamics of dissipative quantum systems. The time evolution of a system of bilinearly coupled bosonic modes is treated using the real-time path integral technique in coherent-state representation. This method is applied to a damped harmonic oscillator within the Caldeira-Leggett model. In order to get the stationary trajectories the corresponding Lagrangian function is diagonalized and then the path integrals are evaluated by means of the stationary-phase method. The time evolution of the reduced density matrix in the basis of coherent states is given in simple analytic form for weak system-bath coupling, i.e. the so-called rotating-wave terms can be evaluated exactly but the non-rotating-wave terms only in a perturbative manner. The validity range of the rotating-wave approximation is discussed from the viewpoint of spectral equations. In addition, it is shown that systems without initial system-bath correlations can exhibit initial jumps in the population dynamics even for rather weak dissipation. Only with initial correlations the classical trajectories for the system coordinate can be recovered. The path integral formalism in a combined phase-space and coherent-state representation is applied to the problem of curve-crossing dynamics. The system of interest is described by two coupled one-dimensional harmonic potential energy surfaces interacting with a heat bath. The mapping approach is used to rewrite the Lagrangian function of the electronic part of the system. Using the Feynman-Vernon influence-functional method the bath is eliminated whereas the non-Gaussian part of the path integral is treated using the perturbation theory in the small coordinate shift between potential energy surfaces. The vibrational and the population dynamics is considered in a lowest order of the perturbation. The dynamics of a Gaussian wave packet is analyzed along a one-dimensional reaction coordinate. Also the damping rate of coherence in the electronic part of the relevant system is evaluated within the ordinary and variational perturbation theory. The analytic expressions for the rate functions are obtained in the low and high temperature regimes.

•Jan 20, 2005•0 citations

Real time path integral methods for a system coupled to an anharmonic bath

Gregory Ilk, Nancy Makri

We propose an efficient path integral scheme for calculating the quantum dynamics of an arbitrary one-dimensional system coupled nonlinearly to many anharmonic noninteracting ‘‘bath’’ degrees of freedom. The starting point is an improved discretization of the path integral in terms of numerically constructed propagators [Chem. Phys. Lett. 193, 435 (1992)]. The resulting influence functional is comprised of one-dimensional correlation functions with step-structured time-dependent potentials and therefore is similar in structure to that employed in the spin-boson calculations of Coalson [J. Chem. Phys. 86, 995 (1987)]. In the present case, though, the influence functional is nonlinear and is computed using numerical iterative wave function propagation methods. Numerical tests on a system coupled to ten anharmonic oscillators demonstrate the efficiency of the proposed scheme, which requires numerical effort that scales only linearly with the number of anharmonic bath degrees of freedom.

The Journal of Chemical Physics•Oct 15, 1994•50 citations

Dissipative quantum dynamics with the surrogate Hamiltonian approach. A comparison between spin and harmonic baths

David Gelman, Christiane P. Koch, Ronnie Kosloff

The dissipative quantum dynamics of an anharmonic oscillator coupled to a bath is studied with the purpose of elucidating the differences between the relaxation to a spin bath and to a harmonic bath. Converged results are obtained for the spin bath by the surrogate Hamiltonian approach. This method is based on constructing a system-bath Hamiltonian, with a finite but large number of spin bath modes, that mimics exactly a bath with an infinite number of modes for a finite time interval. Convergence with respect to the number of simultaneous excitations of bath modes can be checked. The results are compared to calculations that include a finite number of harmonic modes carried out by using the multiconfiguration time-dependent Hartree method of Nest and Meyer [J. Chem. Phys. 119, 24 (2003)]. In the weak coupling regime, at zero temperature and for small excitations of the primary system, both methods converge to the Markovian limit. When initially the primary system is significantly excited, the spin bath can saturate restricting the energy acceptance. An interaction term between bath modes that spreads the excitation eliminates the saturation. The loss of phase between two cat states has been analyzed and the results for the spin and harmonic baths are almost identical. For stronger couplings, the dynamics induced by the two types of baths deviate. The accumulation and degree of entanglement between the bath modes have been characterized. Only in the spin bath the dynamics generate entanglement between the bath modes.

arXiv:quant-ph/0402144•The Journal of Chemical Physics•Jun 23, 2004•51 citations
We review an iterative path integral method that allows the computation of exact, long-time dynamics of small systems interacting with a dissipative bath. The method takes advantage of the finite memory of large environments at finite temperature to allow an iterative evaluation of the dynamics, thereby replacing an exponential scaling in simulation time with a linear scaling. This method is applied to calculate the dynamics of two model systems. The first consists of two-qubits interacting with a common bath. In this case we observe a variety of entanglement effects. If the qubits are initially separable, through an indirect coupling, the bath can create steady state entanglement between the qubits. This effect is due to the existence of a decoherence-free subspace as a result of the form of the qubit Hamiltonian and system-bath coupling. Entanglement created by the bath is shown to decrease with increasing temperature and system-bath coupling strength. However large system-bath coupling causes a faster increase in the entanglement. Initially entangled qubits lose their entanglement as a result of interactions with the bath, an effect that is heightened at higher temperatures. Direct coupling between the qubits is shown to slow the decay of entanglement and preserve some entanglement at long times; however at high temperatures this steady state entanglement becomes negligible. The second system we consider is vibrational degree of freedom coupled to a bath of harmonic oscillators or two-level systems. We compute four-time correlation functions which are used to calculate response functions relevant to third order infrared or seventh order Raman experiments for harmonic, Morse, and quadratic-quartic potentials. Our calculations reveal the role of potential features (anharmonicity and eigenvalue spectrum), both on short and long time scales, on the response function. Further, thermal excitation causes dramatic changes in the appearance of the response function, introducing symmetry with respect to the main diagonal. Finally, coupling to harmonic dissipative baths leads to decay of the response function (primarily along the t3 direction) and a broadening of the peaks in its Fourier transform. At high temperatures two-level-system baths are less efficient in destroying coherence than harmonic baths of similar parameters.
We use numerically exact iterative path integral methods to investigate the decoherence and entanglement dynamics of a tunneling pair of two coupled qubits (spins) system interacting with a dissipative bath. We find that decoherence is generally accompanied by the destruction of entanglement, although the specifics of this destruction depend sensitively on the parameters of the Hamiltonian (qubit-qubit coupling and/or energy bias), the strength of dissipation, the temperature, and the choice of initial condition. We also observe that dissipation can in some cases generate a substantial amount of entanglement. Finally, if an entangled eigenstate exists which does not couple to the environment, the long-time entanglement can significantly exceed the value corresponding to the Boltzmann equilibrium state.
We present an iterative path integral algorithm for computing multitime correlation functions of a quantum system coupled to a dissipative bath of harmonic oscillators. By splitting the Boltzmann operator into two parts and reordering the propagators in the expression for canonical correlation functions, we are able to transform the evolution time contour into a symmetric one so that a forward propagation and a backward one are specified. Because the memory induced by the bath through the Feynman–Vernon influence functional decays rapidly in the complex time plane, long-time correlations are negligible. Taking advantage of this fact, we show that the correlation function can be obtained via an iterative procedure. The method is used to calculate three-time correlation functions of a dissipative two-level system.
The reduced density matrix of a system coupled to a harmonic dissipative bath can be obtained accurately using an iterative path integral methodology that involves a propagator tensor, whose rank is roughly equal to the number of time steps that span the bath-induced memory. The present work shows that even in situations where the bath is characterized by high-frequency modes (which necessitate a small time step) and slow oscillators (which give rise to very long memory), efficient propagation that takes into account the memory on all time scales is feasible by renormalizing the propagator matrix to include successively larger-length influence functional correlations. At its crudest level, the renormalized propagator is an ordinary matrix, thus the computational demands of the method are very modest, similar to those for propagating the bare system. Yet, test applications on dissipative two-level systems show that the method produces accurate results in demanding situations. By including memory on successively increasing time scales, the method is capable of capturing nonexponential kinetics induced by sluggish solvents.
In this thesis the path integral formalism is applied to the calculation of the dynamics of dissipative quantum systems. The time evolution of a system of bilinearly coupled bosonic modes is treated using the real-time path integral technique in coherent-state representation. This method is applied to a damped harmonic oscillator within the Caldeira-Leggett model. In order to get the stationary trajectories the corresponding Lagrangian function is diagonalized and then the path integrals are evaluated by means of the stationary-phase method. The time evolution of the reduced density matrix in the basis of coherent states is given in simple analytic form for weak system-bath coupling, i.e. the so-called rotating-wave terms can be evaluated exactly but the non-rotating-wave terms only in a perturbative manner. The validity range of the rotating-wave approximation is discussed from the viewpoint of spectral equations. In addition, it is shown that systems without initial system-bath correlations can exhibit initial jumps in the population dynamics even for rather weak dissipation. Only with initial correlations the classical trajectories for the system coordinate can be recovered. The path integral formalism in a combined phase-space and coherent-state representation is applied to the problem of curve-crossing dynamics. The system of interest is described by two coupled one-dimensional harmonic potential energy surfaces interacting with a heat bath. The mapping approach is used to rewrite the Lagrangian function of the electronic part of the system. Using the Feynman-Vernon influence-functional method the bath is eliminated whereas the non-Gaussian part of the path integral is treated using the perturbation theory in the small coordinate shift between potential energy surfaces. The vibrational and the population dynamics is considered in a lowest order of the perturbation. The dynamics of a Gaussian wave packet is analyzed along a one-dimensional reaction coordinate. Also the damping rate of coherence in the electronic part of the relevant system is evaluated within the ordinary and variational perturbation theory. The analytic expressions for the rate functions are obtained in the low and high temperature regimes.
We propose an efficient path integral scheme for calculating the quantum dynamics of an arbitrary one-dimensional system coupled nonlinearly to many anharmonic noninteracting ‘‘bath’’ degrees of freedom. The starting point is an improved discretization of the path integral in terms of numerically constructed propagators [Chem. Phys. Lett. 193, 435 (1992)]. The resulting influence functional is comprised of one-dimensional correlation functions with step-structured time-dependent potentials and therefore is similar in structure to that employed in the spin-boson calculations of Coalson [J. Chem. Phys. 86, 995 (1987)]. In the present case, though, the influence functional is nonlinear and is computed using numerical iterative wave function propagation methods. Numerical tests on a system coupled to ten anharmonic oscillators demonstrate the efficiency of the proposed scheme, which requires numerical effort that scales only linearly with the number of anharmonic bath degrees of freedom.
The dissipative quantum dynamics of an anharmonic oscillator coupled to a bath is studied with the purpose of elucidating the differences between the relaxation to a spin bath and to a harmonic bath. Converged results are obtained for the spin bath by the surrogate Hamiltonian approach. This method is based on constructing a system-bath Hamiltonian, with a finite but large number of spin bath modes, that mimics exactly a bath with an infinite number of modes for a finite time interval. Convergence with respect to the number of simultaneous excitations of bath modes can be checked. The results are compared to calculations that include a finite number of harmonic modes carried out by using the multiconfiguration time-dependent Hartree method of Nest and Meyer [J. Chem. Phys. 119, 24 (2003)]. In the weak coupling regime, at zero temperature and for small excitations of the primary system, both methods converge to the Markovian limit. When initially the primary system is significantly excited, the spin bath can saturate restricting the energy acceptance. An interaction term between bath modes that spreads the excitation eliminates the saturation. The loss of phase between two cat states has been analyzed and the results for the spin and harmonic baths are almost identical. For stronger couplings, the dynamics induced by the two types of baths deviate. The accumulation and degree of entanglement between the bath modes have been characterized. Only in the spin bath the dynamics generate entanglement between the bath modes.