Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Oxford University Press eBooks

Strongly Interacting Quantum Systems out of Equilibrium

Thierry Giamarchi, Andrew J. Millis, Olivier Parcollet, Hubert Saleur, Leticia F. Cugliandolo

Published Jun 23, 2016• 43 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Over the last decade new experimental tools and theoretical concepts are providing new insights into collective nonequilibrium behavior of quantum systems. The exquisite control provided by laser trapping and cooling techniques allows us to observe the behavior of condensed bose and degenerate Fermi gases under nonequilibrium drive or after quenches' in which a Hamiltonian parameter is suddenly or slowly changed. On the solid state front, high intensity short-time pulses and fast (femtosecond) probes allow solids to be put into highly excited states and probed before relaxation and dissipation occur. Experimental developments are matched by progress in theoretical techniques ranging from exact solutions of strongly interacting nonequilibrium models to new approaches to nonequilibrium numerics. The summer school Strongly interacting quantum systems out of equilibrium' held at the Les Houches School of Physics as its XCIX session was designed to summarize this progress, lay out the open questions and define directions for future work. This books collects the lecture notes of the main courses given in this summer school.

DOI
10.1093/acprof:oso/9780198768166.001.0001

Related papers

Nonequilibrium quantum fields: from cold atoms to cosmology

Jürgen Berges

Lecture notes of the Les Houches Summer School on 'Strongly interacting quantum systems out of equilibrium'.

arXiv:1503.02907•Oxford University Press eBooks•Jun 23, 2016•80 citations

Collective instabilities in light-matter interactions

Gordon R. M. Robb

This is a book chapter in the following descried book: This book collects together the lecture courses and seminars given at the Les Houches Summer School 2008 on Long-Range Interacting Systems, reviewing the state-of-the-art developments in this field and providing an essential background to future studies, all in writing that is accessible to Masters and PhD students and researchers wishing to enter this field. Leading scientists in different fields of mathematics and physics present their views on this fast growing and interdisciplinary field of research, exploring such topics as fundamental problems of probability, transport theory, equilibrium and non-equilibrium statistical mechanics, condensed matter physics, astrophysics and cosmology, physics of plasmas, and hydrodynamics. In particular, the book examines the thermodynamic and dynamical properties of systems with long-range interactions, which have been poorly understood until recently.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Jan 1, 2010•2 citations

Quantum Theory from Small to Large Scales

Jürg Martin Fröhlich, Manfred Salmhofer B, Vieri Mastropietro +2 more

This book collects lecture courses and seminars given at the Les Houches Summer School 2010 on ‘Quantum Theory: From Small to Large Scales’. Fundamental quantum phenomena appear on all scales, from microscopic to macroscopic. Some of the pertinent questions include the onset of decoherence, the dynamics of collective modes, the influence of external randomness, and the emergence of dissipative behaviour. Our understanding of such phenomena has been advanced by the study of model systems and by the derivation and analysis of effective dynamics for large systems and over long times. In this field, research in mathematical physics has regularly contributed results that were recognized as essential in the physics community. During the last few years, the key questions have been sharpened and progress on answering them has been particularly strong. This book reviews the state-of-the-art developments in this field and provides the necessary background for future studies.

Oxford University Press eBooks•May 24, 2012•52 citations

Nonequilibrium Quantum States of Matter

Lorenzo Piroli

Among the few lessons that Physics teaches us on a daily basis, one in particular is hard to miss: thermalization processes are ubiquitous. With the same degree of certainty, one can predict an apple to fall onto the ground if its stalk is cut, or a cup of tea to be found cold if left on the table for too long. In this respect, generic classical and quantum mechanical systems seem to behave in the same way. This is also one of the main difficulties in the experimental observation of the bizarre effects predicted from the quantum theory, as several of these are known to disappear at finite temperatures. It has been known for a long time that thermalization is associated with “chaotic” behavior at the microscopic level, but recently systematic efforts, both theoretical and experimental, have allowed us to understand its mechanisms at an unprecedented level of accuracy. Indeed, it has been realized that thermalization generally occurs also in isolated systems, where the absence of interactions with the environment allows for first principle theoretical investigations1. In this case thermalization takes place locally, as the whole system acts as a thermal bath for its own subsystems. Theoretical research has been motivated and paralleled by exciting experimental progress in cold-atom physics, which has provided robust, nearly ideal realizations of several theoretical models2. As an established piece of knowledge, recent research has now confirmed that two outstanding exceptions actually exist in the quantum realm, where thermalization is prevented to occur. These are many-body localized systems3, where disorder plays a crucial role, and integrable ones, which are protected by the existence of higher conservation laws. By their own nature, these systems display exceptional non-equilibrium features, which are not washed out by the onset of thermalization as relaxation occurs. At the core of the present thesis lie the remarkable properties of integrable systems out of equilibrium, with a special attention to physical effects which could be observed in cold-atom realizations. The work collected here is part of a large theoretical effort4 which in the past decade has focused on the study of relatively simple protocols to bring a quantum system out of equilibrium, such as the so-called quantum quench. In these “theoretical laboratories” it has been possible to provide quantitative predictions which helped us to develop an intuition on general questions regarding non-equilibrium and thermalization processes. Furthermore, in some cases these studies have highlighted interesting physical effects which could be directly probed experimentally within cold-atom settings. The contribution of the present thesis is two-fold. On the one hand, we have developed new technical tools for the study of integrable systems out of equilibrium, and for the computation of measurable physical quantities such as correlation functions. The techniques employed are mainly analytical and rooted within the mathematical structures of integrability. On the other hand, we have singled out physically relevant nonequilibrium situations where exotic, non-thermal states of matter emerge after relaxation occurs, and provided quantitative analytical predictions in these cases. A comprehensive discussion of the motivations and results of our work will be presented in Chapter 1, where we provide a complete overview of this thesis and discuss the organization of its content.

•Oct 8, 2018•0 citations

Out Of Equilibrium Phenomena In Ultra-Cold Gases

Stefan S. Natu

The study of out-of-equilibrium dynamics in ultra-cold gases is a new and exciting field, driven largely by the recent experimental advances in controlling and imaging cold clouds. The experimental and theoretical work thus far has been somewhat exploratory and largely numerical in nature, as the very paradigms for thinking about these systems are not well established. In this thesis I consider several different scenarios of ultra-cold bosonic and fermionic gases driven out of equilibrium and study their properties. In Chapter 1, I provide an overview of the phenomenology of ultra-cold gases, highlighting the timescales governing these systems and how the experimentalist can tune them. I discuss how cold gases can be cooled and trapped and discuss the basic physics behind optical lattices. I also discuss experimental probes of these gases, in particular the new high resolution imaging techniques developed recently at Chicago, Munich and Harvard. In Chapter 2, I discuss an early experiment (circa. 2008) which observed long lived spin dynamics in a thermal spin-1/2 Fermi gas. This experiment is an nice illustration of interesting physics resulting from the separation of timescales between spin and collisional dynamics. In my opinion, it is an excellent example of why cold gases are naturally suited to studying non-equilibrium dynamics. I simulate the experiment numerically using a collisionless Boltzmann equation and explain the observed spin dynamics both qualitatively and quantitively. In Chapter 3, I continue the discussion of spin waves in thermal gases by extending previous works on spin-1/2 gases to spin-1 Bose gases. In contrast to Chapter 2, the bulk of the work in this Chapter is analytic in nature. In particular, I find a spin wave instability in the thermal spin-1 Bose gas, which is the high temperature analog of the polar to ferromagnetic transition in a spin-1 Bose Einstein condensate. In Chapter 3, I turn my attention to bosonic systems and briefly review the the Bogoliubov mean-field theory. I calculate the momentum distribution and density-density correlation function of an interacting Bose gas within the Bogoliubov framework. Then I consider bosons in an optical lattice, and introduce the Bose Hubbard model. I calculate the mean-field phase diagram of the Bose Hubbard model and then consider fluctuations about the mean field, and derive the excitation spectrum of the lattice gas in the superfluid and insulating regimes. In Chapter 4, I ask what we learn by studying the dynamics of correlation functions following a sudden change in the interactions in a superfluid. Using the Bogoliubov theory developed in Chapter 3, I will show how the underlying excitation spectrum influences the long and short time behavior of the correlation functions. By considering a lattice dispersion, I study the analogous problem in a weak optical lattice and discuss how the lattice dispersion leads to additional features in the correlation functions. I will also discuss the timescale governing the revival of the condensate fraction in a quantum depleted gas. In Chapter 5, I derive equations of motion governing the dynamics of one and two body correlation functions in the single-band Bose Hubbard model, applicable to bosons in deep lattices. I then consider a simple quench from a Mott insulating initial state to a weakly interacting final state and produce analytic expressions describing the dynamics of correlations following such a quench. I discuss the timescale for the development of long range order following such a quench. I study the problem of chapter 4 using an equations of motion approach. This approach complements the Bogoliubov approach of Chapter 4. First, I derive exact expressions for a quench to a non-interacting state. I then consider how interactions redistribute quasi-momentum to first order in perturbation theory in different dimensions. In Chapter 6, I calculate the relevant timescales for local and global dynamics in trapped lattice Bose gases, a work done in collaboration with Dr. Kaden R. A Hazzard. Using a time-dependent Gutzwiller mean-field theory, I show that the timescale for local equilibration in these systems is fast in experimental terms. I then show that due to the spatial inhomogeneities inherent to cold gases, achieving global equilibrium can be quite complicated, sometimes taking longer than the lifetime of the experiment, an issue of practical importance to current day experiments. I continue this discussion in Chapter 7 which is a collaborative work with experimentalists David McKay and Prof. Brian DeMarco from the University of Toronto and the University of Illinois, Urbana Champaign. Using experimental and numerical methods, we show that the rapid timescales for local dynamics in interacting systems invalidates a frequently used cold atom technique for mapping out the momentum distribution of atoms in an optical lattice.

•Jan 28, 2013•0 citations

Nonlinear Response Of Strongly Interacting Quantum Systems in Nonequilibrium

Khadijeh Najafi

The recent developments in experimental techniques such as pump-probe spectroscopy, new technologies in building two dimensional materials, and the advent of highly tunable systems in the form of ultracold optical lattices, trapped ions and array of atoms have opened a new path to investigate the dynamics of strongly correlated system out of equilibrium, which would not be possible with the conventional methods.These new developments not only provided a powerful tool to study some of the most fundamental questions in the nonequilibrium regime of quantum systems but also made it possible to explore new phenomena which has not been observed before.Motivated by some of these experiments, in this thesis, we study a wide range of strongly correlated systems out of equilibrium.We will use a combination of theoretical and computational methods such as sum rules, nonequilibrium Green's function, nonequilibrium dynamical mean-eld theory (DMFT), and an exact solution of the non-interacting model to address a wide spectrum of systems out of equilibrium.First, we have generalized a formalism for the nth derivative of a time-dependent operator in the Heisenberg representation and employ it to the spectral sum rules in which we obtain a qualitative understanding of the pump eect on electron-phonon coupling in high T c superconductors.Then, by using the nonequilibrium DMFT for the Falicov-Kimball model, we obtain the current-voltage prole of a multilayer device which consists of a single barrier region (usually insulator plane) connected to a number of metallic leads in both sides.To improve the conservation of current and lling 6.12 ∆ ln (t) for the XX chain with dierent initial states . . . . . . . . . .6.13 ∆ ln (t) for the XY chain with various γ and h parameters . . . . . . .6.14 |C ln | 2 , |F ln | 2 , and ∆ ln (t) for the XY chain . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .6.15 The continuous blue curve is the function -Ai 2 (-X) . . . . . . . . .6.16 The evolution of the entanglement entropy in the XY chain . . . . . .6.17 v e max (2) and v e max (1) for dierent values of a and h . . . . . . . . . . .6.18 Π(l, L)αl for periodic system with total length L = 2000 . . . . . .6.19 Π(l, L)αl for open system with total length L = 2000 . . . . . . . .6.20 The coecient of the logarithmic term for two congurations . . . . .6.21 Π(l, L)αl for periodic system with total length L = 300 with respect to l . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .6.22 Values of f (x), α min and α max with respect to x . . . . . . . . . . . .6.23 The contributions of dierent ranks k in the Shannon information for two sizes l = 14 and 26 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .6.24 The error E(x m , l) in the evaluation of Shannon information coming from the truncation at the rank k = x m l . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .6.25 The contributions of dierent ranks k in the Shannon information . .6.26 The evolution of logarithmic formation probability of dierent congurations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .6.27 The evolution of Shannon information of a subsystem with dierent sizes201 6.28 The mutual information between a pair of dimers . . . . . . . . . . .6.29 The evolution of mutual information between two adjacent subsystems in two dierent cases . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

Georgetown University-Graduate School of Arts & Sciences•Jan 1, 2018•0 citations
Over the last decade new experimental tools and theoretical concepts are providing new insights into collective nonequilibrium behavior of quantum systems. The exquisite control provided by laser trapping and cooling techniques allows us to observe the behavior of condensed bose and degenerate Fermi gases under nonequilibrium drive or after quenches' in which a Hamiltonian parameter is suddenly or slowly changed. On the solid state front, high intensity short-time pulses and fast (femtosecond) probes allow solids to be put into highly excited states and probed before relaxation and dissipation occur. Experimental developments are matched by progress in theoretical techniques ranging from exact solutions of strongly interacting nonequilibrium models to new approaches to nonequilibrium numerics. The summer school Strongly interacting quantum systems out of equilibrium' held at the Les Houches School of Physics as its XCIX session was designed to summarize this progress, lay out the open questions and define directions for future work. This books collects the lecture notes of the main courses given in this summer school.
This is a book chapter in the following descried book: This book collects together the lecture courses and seminars given at the Les Houches Summer School 2008 on Long-Range Interacting Systems, reviewing the state-of-the-art developments in this field and providing an essential background to future studies, all in writing that is accessible to Masters and PhD students and researchers wishing to enter this field. Leading scientists in different fields of mathematics and physics present their views on this fast growing and interdisciplinary field of research, exploring such topics as fundamental problems of probability, transport theory, equilibrium and non-equilibrium statistical mechanics, condensed matter physics, astrophysics and cosmology, physics of plasmas, and hydrodynamics. In particular, the book examines the thermodynamic and dynamical properties of systems with long-range interactions, which have been poorly understood until recently.
This book collects lecture courses and seminars given at the Les Houches Summer School 2010 on ‘Quantum Theory: From Small to Large Scales’. Fundamental quantum phenomena appear on all scales, from microscopic to macroscopic. Some of the pertinent questions include the onset of decoherence, the dynamics of collective modes, the influence of external randomness, and the emergence of dissipative behaviour. Our understanding of such phenomena has been advanced by the study of model systems and by the derivation and analysis of effective dynamics for large systems and over long times. In this field, research in mathematical physics has regularly contributed results that were recognized as essential in the physics community. During the last few years, the key questions have been sharpened and progress on answering them has been particularly strong. This book reviews the state-of-the-art developments in this field and provides the necessary background for future studies.
Among the few lessons that Physics teaches us on a daily basis, one in particular is hard to miss: thermalization processes are ubiquitous. With the same degree of certainty, one can predict an apple to fall onto the ground if its stalk is cut, or a cup of tea to be found cold if left on the table for too long. In this respect, generic classical and quantum mechanical systems seem to behave in the same way. This is also one of the main difficulties in the experimental observation of the bizarre effects predicted from the quantum theory, as several of these are known to disappear at finite temperatures. It has been known for a long time that thermalization is associated with “chaotic” behavior at the microscopic level, but recently systematic efforts, both theoretical and experimental, have allowed us to understand its mechanisms at an unprecedented level of accuracy. Indeed, it has been realized that thermalization generally occurs also in isolated systems, where the absence of interactions with the environment allows for first principle theoretical investigations1. In this case thermalization takes place locally, as the whole system acts as a thermal bath for its own subsystems. Theoretical research has been motivated and paralleled by exciting experimental progress in cold-atom physics, which has provided robust, nearly ideal realizations of several theoretical models2. As an established piece of knowledge, recent research has now confirmed that two outstanding exceptions actually exist in the quantum realm, where thermalization is prevented to occur. These are many-body localized systems3, where disorder plays a crucial role, and integrable ones, which are protected by the existence of higher conservation laws. By their own nature, these systems display exceptional non-equilibrium features, which are not washed out by the onset of thermalization as relaxation occurs. At the core of the present thesis lie the remarkable properties of integrable systems out of equilibrium, with a special attention to physical effects which could be observed in cold-atom realizations. The work collected here is part of a large theoretical effort4 which in the past decade has focused on the study of relatively simple protocols to bring a quantum system out of equilibrium, such as the so-called quantum quench. In these “theoretical laboratories” it has been possible to provide quantitative predictions which helped us to develop an intuition on general questions regarding non-equilibrium and thermalization processes. Furthermore, in some cases these studies have highlighted interesting physical effects which could be directly probed experimentally within cold-atom settings. The contribution of the present thesis is two-fold. On the one hand, we have developed new technical tools for the study of integrable systems out of equilibrium, and for the computation of measurable physical quantities such as correlation functions. The techniques employed are mainly analytical and rooted within the mathematical structures of integrability. On the other hand, we have singled out physically relevant nonequilibrium situations where exotic, non-thermal states of matter emerge after relaxation occurs, and provided quantitative analytical predictions in these cases. A comprehensive discussion of the motivations and results of our work will be presented in Chapter 1, where we provide a complete overview of this thesis and discuss the organization of its content.
The study of out-of-equilibrium dynamics in ultra-cold gases is a new and exciting field, driven largely by the recent experimental advances in controlling and imaging cold clouds. The experimental and theoretical work thus far has been somewhat exploratory and largely numerical in nature, as the very paradigms for thinking about these systems are not well established. In this thesis I consider several different scenarios of ultra-cold bosonic and fermionic gases driven out of equilibrium and study their properties. In Chapter 1, I provide an overview of the phenomenology of ultra-cold gases, highlighting the timescales governing these systems and how the experimentalist can tune them. I discuss how cold gases can be cooled and trapped and discuss the basic physics behind optical lattices. I also discuss experimental probes of these gases, in particular the new high resolution imaging techniques developed recently at Chicago, Munich and Harvard. In Chapter 2, I discuss an early experiment (circa. 2008) which observed long lived spin dynamics in a thermal spin-1/2 Fermi gas. This experiment is an nice illustration of interesting physics resulting from the separation of timescales between spin and collisional dynamics. In my opinion, it is an excellent example of why cold gases are naturally suited to studying non-equilibrium dynamics. I simulate the experiment numerically using a collisionless Boltzmann equation and explain the observed spin dynamics both qualitatively and quantitively. In Chapter 3, I continue the discussion of spin waves in thermal gases by extending previous works on spin-1/2 gases to spin-1 Bose gases. In contrast to Chapter 2, the bulk of the work in this Chapter is analytic in nature. In particular, I find a spin wave instability in the thermal spin-1 Bose gas, which is the high temperature analog of the polar to ferromagnetic transition in a spin-1 Bose Einstein condensate. In Chapter 3, I turn my attention to bosonic systems and briefly review the the Bogoliubov mean-field theory. I calculate the momentum distribution and density-density correlation function of an interacting Bose gas within the Bogoliubov framework. Then I consider bosons in an optical lattice, and introduce the Bose Hubbard model. I calculate the mean-field phase diagram of the Bose Hubbard model and then consider fluctuations about the mean field, and derive the excitation spectrum of the lattice gas in the superfluid and insulating regimes. In Chapter 4, I ask what we learn by studying the dynamics of correlation functions following a sudden change in the interactions in a superfluid. Using the Bogoliubov theory developed in Chapter 3, I will show how the underlying excitation spectrum influences the long and short time behavior of the correlation functions. By considering a lattice dispersion, I study the analogous problem in a weak optical lattice and discuss how the lattice dispersion leads to additional features in the correlation functions. I will also discuss the timescale governing the revival of the condensate fraction in a quantum depleted gas. In Chapter 5, I derive equations of motion governing the dynamics of one and two body correlation functions in the single-band Bose Hubbard model, applicable to bosons in deep lattices. I then consider a simple quench from a Mott insulating initial state to a weakly interacting final state and produce analytic expressions describing the dynamics of correlations following such a quench. I discuss the timescale for the development of long range order following such a quench. I study the problem of chapter 4 using an equations of motion approach. This approach complements the Bogoliubov approach of Chapter 4. First, I derive exact expressions for a quench to a non-interacting state. I then consider how interactions redistribute quasi-momentum to first order in perturbation theory in different dimensions. In Chapter 6, I calculate the relevant timescales for local and global dynamics in trapped lattice Bose gases, a work done in collaboration with Dr. Kaden R. A Hazzard. Using a time-dependent Gutzwiller mean-field theory, I show that the timescale for local equilibration in these systems is fast in experimental terms. I then show that due to the spatial inhomogeneities inherent to cold gases, achieving global equilibrium can be quite complicated, sometimes taking longer than the lifetime of the experiment, an issue of practical importance to current day experiments. I continue this discussion in Chapter 7 which is a collaborative work with experimentalists David McKay and Prof. Brian DeMarco from the University of Toronto and the University of Illinois, Urbana Champaign. Using experimental and numerical methods, we show that the rapid timescales for local dynamics in interacting systems invalidates a frequently used cold atom technique for mapping out the momentum distribution of atoms in an optical lattice.
The recent developments in experimental techniques such as pump-probe spectroscopy, new technologies in building two dimensional materials, and the advent of highly tunable systems in the form of ultracold optical lattices, trapped ions and array of atoms have opened a new path to investigate the dynamics of strongly correlated system out of equilibrium, which would not be possible with the conventional methods.These new developments not only provided a powerful tool to study some of the most fundamental questions in the nonequilibrium regime of quantum systems but also made it possible to explore new phenomena which has not been observed before.Motivated by some of these experiments, in this thesis, we study a wide range of strongly correlated systems out of equilibrium.We will use a combination of theoretical and computational methods such as sum rules, nonequilibrium Green's function, nonequilibrium dynamical mean-eld theory (DMFT), and an exact solution of the non-interacting model to address a wide spectrum of systems out of equilibrium.First, we have generalized a formalism for the nth derivative of a time-dependent operator in the Heisenberg representation and employ it to the spectral sum rules in which we obtain a qualitative understanding of the pump eect on electron-phonon coupling in high T c superconductors.Then, by using the nonequilibrium DMFT for the Falicov-Kimball model, we obtain the current-voltage prole of a multilayer device which consists of a single barrier region (usually insulator plane) connected to a number of metallic leads in both sides.To improve the conservation of current and lling 6.12 ∆ ln (t) for the XX chain with dierent initial states . . . . . . . . . .6.13 ∆ ln (t) for the XY chain with various γ and h parameters . . . . . . .6.14 |C ln | 2 , |F ln | 2 , and ∆ ln (t) for the XY chain . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .6.15 The continuous blue curve is the function -Ai 2 (-X) . . . . . . . . .6.16 The evolution of the entanglement entropy in the XY chain . . . . . .6.17 v e max (2) and v e max (1) for dierent values of a and h . . . . . . . . . . .6.18 Π(l, L)αl for periodic system with total length L = 2000 . . . . . .6.19 Π(l, L)αl for open system with total length L = 2000 . . . . . . . .6.20 The coecient of the logarithmic term for two congurations . . . . .6.21 Π(l, L)αl for periodic system with total length L = 300 with respect to l . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .6.22 Values of f (x), α min and α max with respect to x . . . . . . . . . . . .6.23 The contributions of dierent ranks k in the Shannon information for two sizes l = 14 and 26 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .6.24 The error E(x m , l) in the evaluation of Shannon information coming from the truncation at the rank k = x m l . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .6.25 The contributions of dierent ranks k in the Shannon information . .6.26 The evolution of logarithmic formation probability of dierent congurations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .6.27 The evolution of Shannon information of a subsystem with dierent sizes201 6.28 The mutual information between a pair of dimers . . . . . . . . . . .6.29 The evolution of mutual information between two adjacent subsystems in two dierent cases . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .