Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Cambridge University Press eBooks

Why is nature described by quantum theory?

Lucién Hardy

Published Apr 22, 2004• 14 citations
Publisher

Abstract

John A. Wheeler's two favorite questions are: “How come existence?” and “How come the quantum?” (Wheeler 1998). It is difficult to know how to go about answering the first question. What shape would an answer take? This article is concerned instead with the second question which I will expand as: “Why is nature described by quantum theory?” What shape would an answer to this question take? We can get a handle on this by considering some historical examples. In the seventeenth century physicists were confronted by Kepler's laws of planetary motion. These laws were empirically adequate for predicting planetary motion and yet sufficiently abstract and ad hoc that they cannot really have been regarded as an explanation of “why” planets move the way they do. Later, Newton was able to show that Kepler's laws followed from a set of reasonable laws for the mechanics (his three laws) plus his law for gravitational forces. At this stage physicists could begin to assert with some degree of confidence that they understood “why” the planets move the way they do. Of course there were still mysteries. Newton was particularly bothered by the action at a distance of his inverse square law. What mediated the force? It was not until Einstein's theory of general relativity that an answer to this question became available.

DOI
10.1017/cbo9780511814990.006

Related papers

Quantum Theory Comes in Waves and Particles

Walter A. Harrison

Certainly there is no unique answer to Frank Wilczek’s question, “What Is Quantum Theory?” (Physics Today, June 2000, page 11). I was not certain that a pragmatic answer, which I proposed for a course in applied quantum mechanics, 1 1. W. A. Harrison, Applied Quantum Mechanics, World Scientific, River Edge, N.J. (2000). would be sustainable for the entire course, but it seems that it was. That answer was the assertion that everything is both a particle and a wave, and that everything else would follow from that one assertion. Planck’s constant arose when the velocity of a wave (the derivative of the frequency with respect to wavenumber) was equated to the velocity of a particle (the derivative of the energy with respect to momentum), so that energy is proportional to frequency and momentum to wavenumber, with the same proportionality constant ħ. When Hamiltonian mechanics was introduced, “everything” became anything that can be described by such mechanics, or anything that satisfies a wave equation. Quantum theory does not say what nature gives, only how to predict the behavior of what is given. If nature serves up particles with half-integral angular momentum, the wavefunction that describes them must go into its negative when they are interchanged, and they therefore obey the Pauli principle.Such principles, which historically arose as independent conjectures, now follow from the one assertion. It is a matter of seeing how this peculiar assertion can turn out to be absolutely true.The relation between quantum theory and the physical world was seen as follows: Quantum theory tells what future scenarios are consistent with some initial information, and what the relative probability of each scenario is. Quantum theory cannot tell more than that, but neither can any other theory.My pragmatic approach may not satisfy everyone’s philosophical needs. But the aim of an applied quantum course is to see how to use the theory and to introduce the many approximations that have made the theory accessible to physicists and engineers. If some basic consequences are difficult to accept, the problem must lie with the initial assertion from which the consequences follow.REFERENCESection:ChooseTop of pageREFERENCE <<1. W. A. Harrison, Applied Quantum Mechanics, World Scientific, River Edge, N.J. (2000). Google ScholarCrossref© 2001 American Institute of Physics.

Physics Today•Jun 1, 2001•0 citations

It from qubit

David Deutsch

Of John Wheeler's “Really Big Questions,” the one on which the most progress has been made is “It from bit?” – does information play a significant role at the foundations of physics? It is perhaps less ambitious than some of the other questions, such as “How come existence?”, because it does not necessarily require a metaphysical answer. And unlike, say, “Why the quantum?”, it does not require the discovery of new laws of nature: there was room for hope that it might be answered through a better understanding of the laws as we currently know them, particularly those of quantum physics. And this is what has happened: the better understanding is the quantum theory of information and computation.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Apr 22, 2004•35 citations

On the Nature of Quantum Geometry

Roger Penrose

As a way of honoring Professor Wheeler on his sixtieth birthday, I propose to take this opportunity to elaborate upon certain somewhat speculative ideas which I have tried to hint at on occasion, concerning the possible nature of a quantized space-time. The reader will not need to be too discerning to recognize some substantial differences between the ideas I am proposing here and those which Professor Wheeler has on many occasions so eloquently and forcefully put forward. Nonetheless, there is little doubt in my own mind as to the very great inspirational influence that Professor Wheeler’s own views have had in the development of several of the thoughts which I am expressing here. To begin with, let me make clear that I do not necessarily mean by “quantized space-time ” something which could be obtained by applying standard (or even non-standard) techniques of quantization to Einstein’s general theory of relativity. What I wish to say has its roots in something which is really more primitive than either quantum theory or relativity as such. This is the question of the fundamental role played by the mathematical concept of continuum in virtually the whole of accepted present-day physical theory. Not only does the continuum occupy a basic position in our mathematical models of space and time (with the concomitant implication of a continuous nature for many related physical concepts such as velocity, energy, momentum, temperature, etc.), but so also does present-day quantum theory rest crucially on a continuum concept, namely on the two-dimensional complex continuum of probability amplitudes, this being the continuum which also occurs in the superposition law. Let me say at the outset that I am not happy with this state of affairs in physical theory. The mathematical continuum has always seemed to me to contain many features which are really very foreign to physics. This point has been argued forcefully, particularly by Schrödinger [1] and also by a number of other physicists and philosophers [2]. If one is to accept the physical reality of the continuum, then one must accept that there are as 0 This paper originally appeared in Magic Without Magic, edited by J. Klauder, Freeman,

•Jan 1, 1972•46 citations

Gaussian optics

Paul Bamberg, Shlomo Sternberg

Chapter 9 presents an example of how the results of the first eight chapters can be applied to a physical theory – optics. It is all in the nature of applications, and can be omitted without any effect on the understanding of what follows. Theories of optics In the history of physics it is often the case that, when an older theory is superseded by a newer one, the older theory retains its validity, either as an approximation to the newer theory, an approximation that is valid for an interesting range of circumstances, or as a special case of the newer theory. Thus Newtonian mechanics can be regarded as an approximation to relativistic mechanics, valid when the velocities that arise are very small in comparison to the velocity of light. Similarly, Newtonian mechanics can be regarded as an approximation to quantum mechanics, valid when the bodies in question are sufficiently large. Kepler's laws of planetary motion are a special case of Newton's laws, valid for the inverse square law of force between two bodies. Kepler's laws can also be regarded as an approximation to the laws of motion derived from Newtonian mechanics when we ignore the effects of the planets on each other's motion.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Oct 27, 1988•0 citations

WHAT IS QUANTUM THEORY TELLING US ABOUT HOW NATURE WORKS?

Philip Goyal

www.philipgoyal.org Quantum theory is an extraordinarily successful physical theory. But what does it mean? What implications does it have for the mechanical conception of Nature that underlies classical physics? Remarkably, some eighty years after the creation of quantum theory, we still lack clear answers to these questions. In this paper, we discuss the nature of the obstacles that stand in our way, and describe recent work to overcome them by attempting to reconstruct the mathematics of quantum theory from a small number of simple physical ideas.

•Aug 1, 2010•0 citations

Wherefore Quantum Mechanics?

S. P. Boughn

After the development of a self-consistent quantum formalism nearly a century ago, there ensued a quest to understand the often counterintuitive predictions of the theory. These endeavors invariably begin with the assumption of the "truth" of the mathematical formalism of quantum mechanics and then proceed to investigate the theory's implications for the physical world. One of the outcomes has been endless discussions of the quantum measurement problem, wave/particle duality, the non-locality of entangled quantum states, Schroedinger's cat, and other philosophical conundrums. In this essay, I take the point of view that quantum mechanics is a mathematical model, a human invention, and rather than pondering what the theory implies about our world, I consider the transposed question: what is it about our world that leads us to a quantum mechanical model of it? One consequence is the realization that discrete quanta, the quantum of action in particular, leads to the wave nature and statistical behavior of matter rather than the other way around.

arXiv:1910.08069•Jan 1, 2019•2 citations
John A. Wheeler's two favorite questions are: “How come existence?” and “How come the quantum?” (Wheeler 1998). It is difficult to know how to go about answering the first question. What shape would an answer take? This article is concerned instead with the second question which I will expand as: “Why is nature described by quantum theory?” What shape would an answer to this question take? We can get a handle on this by considering some historical examples. In the seventeenth century physicists were confronted by Kepler's laws of planetary motion. These laws were empirically adequate for predicting planetary motion and yet sufficiently abstract and ad hoc that they cannot really have been regarded as an explanation of “why” planets move the way they do. Later, Newton was able to show that Kepler's laws followed from a set of reasonable laws for the mechanics (his three laws) plus his law for gravitational forces. At this stage physicists could begin to assert with some degree of confidence that they understood “why” the planets move the way they do. Of course there were still mysteries. Newton was particularly bothered by the action at a distance of his inverse square law. What mediated the force? It was not until Einstein's theory of general relativity that an answer to this question became available.
Certainly there is no unique answer to Frank Wilczek’s question, “What Is Quantum Theory?” (Physics Today, June 2000, page 11). I was not certain that a pragmatic answer, which I proposed for a course in applied quantum mechanics, 1 1. W. A. Harrison, Applied Quantum Mechanics, World Scientific, River Edge, N.J. (2000). would be sustainable for the entire course, but it seems that it was. That answer was the assertion that everything is both a particle and a wave, and that everything else would follow from that one assertion. Planck’s constant arose when the velocity of a wave (the derivative of the frequency with respect to wavenumber) was equated to the velocity of a particle (the derivative of the energy with respect to momentum), so that energy is proportional to frequency and momentum to wavenumber, with the same proportionality constant ħ. When Hamiltonian mechanics was introduced, “everything” became anything that can be described by such mechanics, or anything that satisfies a wave equation. Quantum theory does not say what nature gives, only how to predict the behavior of what is given. If nature serves up particles with half-integral angular momentum, the wavefunction that describes them must go into its negative when they are interchanged, and they therefore obey the Pauli principle.Such principles, which historically arose as independent conjectures, now follow from the one assertion. It is a matter of seeing how this peculiar assertion can turn out to be absolutely true.The relation between quantum theory and the physical world was seen as follows: Quantum theory tells what future scenarios are consistent with some initial information, and what the relative probability of each scenario is. Quantum theory cannot tell more than that, but neither can any other theory.My pragmatic approach may not satisfy everyone’s philosophical needs. But the aim of an applied quantum course is to see how to use the theory and to introduce the many approximations that have made the theory accessible to physicists and engineers. If some basic consequences are difficult to accept, the problem must lie with the initial assertion from which the consequences follow.REFERENCESection:ChooseTop of pageREFERENCE <<1. W. A. Harrison, Applied Quantum Mechanics, World Scientific, River Edge, N.J. (2000). Google ScholarCrossref© 2001 American Institute of Physics.
Of John Wheeler's “Really Big Questions,” the one on which the most progress has been made is “It from bit?” – does information play a significant role at the foundations of physics? It is perhaps less ambitious than some of the other questions, such as “How come existence?”, because it does not necessarily require a metaphysical answer. And unlike, say, “Why the quantum?”, it does not require the discovery of new laws of nature: there was room for hope that it might be answered through a better understanding of the laws as we currently know them, particularly those of quantum physics. And this is what has happened: the better understanding is the quantum theory of information and computation.
As a way of honoring Professor Wheeler on his sixtieth birthday, I propose to take this opportunity to elaborate upon certain somewhat speculative ideas which I have tried to hint at on occasion, concerning the possible nature of a quantized space-time. The reader will not need to be too discerning to recognize some substantial differences between the ideas I am proposing here and those which Professor Wheeler has on many occasions so eloquently and forcefully put forward. Nonetheless, there is little doubt in my own mind as to the very great inspirational influence that Professor Wheeler’s own views have had in the development of several of the thoughts which I am expressing here. To begin with, let me make clear that I do not necessarily mean by “quantized space-time ” something which could be obtained by applying standard (or even non-standard) techniques of quantization to Einstein’s general theory of relativity. What I wish to say has its roots in something which is really more primitive than either quantum theory or relativity as such. This is the question of the fundamental role played by the mathematical concept of continuum in virtually the whole of accepted present-day physical theory. Not only does the continuum occupy a basic position in our mathematical models of space and time (with the concomitant implication of a continuous nature for many related physical concepts such as velocity, energy, momentum, temperature, etc.), but so also does present-day quantum theory rest crucially on a continuum concept, namely on the two-dimensional complex continuum of probability amplitudes, this being the continuum which also occurs in the superposition law. Let me say at the outset that I am not happy with this state of affairs in physical theory. The mathematical continuum has always seemed to me to contain many features which are really very foreign to physics. This point has been argued forcefully, particularly by Schrödinger [1] and also by a number of other physicists and philosophers [2]. If one is to accept the physical reality of the continuum, then one must accept that there are as 0 This paper originally appeared in Magic Without Magic, edited by J. Klauder, Freeman,
Chapter 9 presents an example of how the results of the first eight chapters can be applied to a physical theory – optics. It is all in the nature of applications, and can be omitted without any effect on the understanding of what follows. Theories of optics In the history of physics it is often the case that, when an older theory is superseded by a newer one, the older theory retains its validity, either as an approximation to the newer theory, an approximation that is valid for an interesting range of circumstances, or as a special case of the newer theory. Thus Newtonian mechanics can be regarded as an approximation to relativistic mechanics, valid when the velocities that arise are very small in comparison to the velocity of light. Similarly, Newtonian mechanics can be regarded as an approximation to quantum mechanics, valid when the bodies in question are sufficiently large. Kepler's laws of planetary motion are a special case of Newton's laws, valid for the inverse square law of force between two bodies. Kepler's laws can also be regarded as an approximation to the laws of motion derived from Newtonian mechanics when we ignore the effects of the planets on each other's motion.
www.philipgoyal.org Quantum theory is an extraordinarily successful physical theory. But what does it mean? What implications does it have for the mechanical conception of Nature that underlies classical physics? Remarkably, some eighty years after the creation of quantum theory, we still lack clear answers to these questions. In this paper, we discuss the nature of the obstacles that stand in our way, and describe recent work to overcome them by attempting to reconstruct the mathematics of quantum theory from a small number of simple physical ideas.
After the development of a self-consistent quantum formalism nearly a century ago, there ensued a quest to understand the often counterintuitive predictions of the theory. These endeavors invariably begin with the assumption of the "truth" of the mathematical formalism of quantum mechanics and then proceed to investigate the theory's implications for the physical world. One of the outcomes has been endless discussions of the quantum measurement problem, wave/particle duality, the non-locality of entangled quantum states, Schroedinger's cat, and other philosophical conundrums. In this essay, I take the point of view that quantum mechanics is a mathematical model, a human invention, and rather than pondering what the theory implies about our world, I consider the transposed question: what is it about our world that leads us to a quantum mechanical model of it? One consequence is the realization that discrete quanta, the quantum of action in particular, leads to the wave nature and statistical behavior of matter rather than the other way around.