Maxwell-Boltzmann Gas Pressure Ideas Applied to a Single Particle Yields exp(ipx)?
Francesco R. Ruggeri
A Maxwell-Boltzmann gas with no external potential V(x) has a constant spatial density. The value of this spatial density alone does not yield the pressure because this also depends on T through the ideal gas law Pressure = density(x) RT, where T is temperature (associated with a conserved average energy), but also the average single particle pressure. Taking d/density(x) of Pressure yields the single particle average pressure value RT, yet at the same time single particle pressure is a stochastic value evaluated as the average of constant v p where p is momentum and v velocity. The quadratic form of p arises, we argue, because one has more than one particle, thus v distinguishes between the particles and relative speed becomes important. In the case of a single particle (as in a single free quantum particle) moving at constant p (speed as well) there is again a constant spatial density as in the MB gas with no V(x). Given the value of the constant density 1/L (L=length), one has no information about momentum p. In the case of a single particle, impulse and not pressure is the important quantity, we argue, because there is no need for a v as there is no relative motion. One only needs to know impulse which is proportional to p. If one speculates that a free quantum particle may follow the model of pressure in an MB gas, one would require a function F(p,x) such that d/d something F = p where p is the single particle impulse. In the MB case, “something” is density, but this is not appropriate for a single particle as density consists of many particles. Without changing T, one may change pressure in an MB gas by changing density i.e. changing the x value of particles. For a quantum particle, we suggest that the conjugate variable to p is x. One may change x of the single particle. Furthermore an association between d/dx and p exists in Fermat’s Least Time Principle. T Thus we suggest d/dx F(p,x) = p where F is unknown both in form and meaning. Pressure, however, is a statistical quantity so F should also be a statistical quantity i.e. one could have d/dx P(p,x) / P(p/x) = constant p where P(p,x) is a kind of unnormalized probability. This suggests, however, that P(p,x) is an eigenfunction of d/dx and represents a kind of unnormalized probability. This, we argue, leads to the notion of exp(ipx) because one does not want a monotonically growing or decreasing probability in x for a constant p. The “constant” is then i. Thus, we argue that if one mimics the pressure behaviour of a MB gas, and applies its properties to a single particle moving at constant speed, one obtains an unusual unnormalized kind of probability exp(ipx) i.e. the quantum free particle wavefunction. At the same time, a constant spatial probability or density 1/L exists. The two are linked in that exp(ipx) exp(-ipx) =1. The overall idea is that the stochastic force i.e. the entropic pressure in an MB gas has an analogy even for a single particle with constant momentum.
•Apr 25, 2023•0 citations