In 1959 Y. Aharonov and D. Bohm [ Phys. Rev. 115 , 485–490 (1959)] shocked most of the physics community by inventing two " gedanken " (thought) experiments for which the electrons in a beam never exposed to an electric or magnetic field would have their interference fringes shifted by differences of either electrostatic scalar potential V or vector potential A between the two paths that produced the interference pattern. Most physicists disbelieved the paper since, in classical electromagnetic theory, the physical phenomena are all produced by the fields and the potentials are introduced as mathematical functions from which the fields are obtained by differentiation. Wendell Furry and I at first doubted the Aharonov–Bohm (AB) paper but tried to understand it. Eventually we convinced ourselves that their paper was correct and the AB effects were essential for assuring the consistency of quantum mechanics and of complementarity. We showed (Paper 6.2) that the two gedanken devices invented by Aharonov and Bohm could, with modifications, be used to detect along which of the two interfering paths the electron traveled. But, by complementarity, it must be impossible both to observe interference fringes and to know through which path the electron passed. This contradiction is prevented by the AB effects of potentials since the zero point oscillations of the potentials, through the AB effects, destroy the interference pattern just as the device becomes sufficiently sensitive to detect the electron path. We pointed out that a key difference between a classical and a quantum particle is that a quantum particle, through its wave function, can be affected simultaneously by potentials along two different paths while this is impossible for a classical point particle. This peculiarity gave me the opportunity to project, at scientific meetings, the then new Charles Addams cartoon of a skier coming down a slope with one track on one each side of a tree. I pointed out that for classical particles such a picture was a joke whereas a quantum particle could be affected by the potentials on both paths. This cartoon was later reproduced in one of my published papers [ Quantum Coherence and Reality (p. 39), edited by J. S. Anandam, World Scientific Publishing Co., 1994]. The night before I first presented this work at a meeting, I learned that L. Marton and his associates had that day presented a postdeadline paper claiming to show that the AB effects did not exist. As an experimentalist presenting a theoretical paper, I felt uncomfortable on learning that our paper had possibly been disproved experimentally, so I arranged a meeting with Marton before my talk. Initially their experiment appeared convincing, but I discovered they had omitted a direct magnetic effect; with its inclusion their experimental results could be explained only by including both the direct and the AB effects. Later, Marton and his associates presented their experiment as evidence for, rather than against, the AB effect.
In 1959 Y. Aharonov and D. Bohm [ Phys. Rev. 115 , 485–490 (1959)] shocked most of the physics community by inventing two " gedanken " (thought) experiments for which the electrons in a beam never exposed to an electric or magnetic field would have their interference fringes shifted by differences of either electrostatic scalar potential V or vector potential A between the two paths that produced the interference pattern. Most physicists disbelieved the paper since, in classical electromagnetic theory, the physical phenomena are all produced by the fields and the potentials are introduced as mathematical functions from which the fields are obtained by differentiation. Wendell Furry and I at first doubted the Aharonov–Bohm (AB) paper but tried to understand it. Eventually we convinced ourselves that their paper was correct and the AB effects were essential for assuring the consistency of quantum mechanics and of complementarity. We showed (Paper 6.2) that the two gedanken devices invented by Aharonov and Bohm could, with modifications, be used to detect along which of the two interfering paths the electron traveled. But, by complementarity, it must be impossible both to observe interference fringes and to know through which path the electron passed. This contradiction is prevented by the AB effects of potentials since the zero point oscillations of the potentials, through the AB effects, destroy the interference pattern just as the device becomes sufficiently sensitive to detect the electron path. We pointed out that a key difference between a classical and a quantum particle is that a quantum particle, through its wave function, can be affected simultaneously by potentials along two different paths while this is impossible for a classical point particle. This peculiarity gave me the opportunity to project, at scientific meetings, the then new Charles Addams cartoon of a skier coming down a slope with one track on one each side of a tree. I pointed out that for classical particles such a picture was a joke whereas a quantum particle could be affected by the potentials on both paths. This cartoon was later reproduced in one of my published papers [ Quantum Coherence and Reality (p. 39), edited by J. S. Anandam, World Scientific Publishing Co., 1994]. The night before I first presented this work at a meeting, I learned that L. Marton and his associates had that day presented a postdeadline paper claiming to show that the AB effects did not exist. As an experimentalist presenting a theoretical paper, I felt uncomfortable on learning that our paper had possibly been disproved experimentally, so I arranged a meeting with Marton before my talk. Initially their experiment appeared convincing, but I discovered they had omitted a direct magnetic effect; with its inclusion their experimental results could be explained only by including both the direct and the AB effects. Later, Marton and his associates presented their experiment as evidence for, rather than against, the AB effect.
At a conference honoring Y. Aharonov, I was urged to present a paper on my work with Wendell Furry (Paper 6.2) that had played such a major role in convincing the skeptical physics community of the validity of the original Aharonov–Bohm theory. However, I was reluctant to do so, since the field was far from my usual research. I then realized I might be able to develop analogous theorems for electrically neutral particles and for the sharp interference pattern with the separated oscillatory fields method. In Paper 6.5, I showed that in a neutron beam magnetic resonance experiment one can design an apparatus to determine the orientation state of the neutron in the intermediate region between the two oscillatory fields. However, if one does such an experiment, just as the sensitivity is good enough to determine the orientation state, the neutron resonance becomes sufficiently blurred by the Aharonov–Casher effect that a sharp interference pattern is no longer observable. This loss of the sharp resonance is analogous to the loss of the two-slit interference pattern in the AB effect. Although the two cases are analogous, there is an important difference. In the separated oscillatory fields method with a neutron spin there is a clear physical meaning to the linear superposition of states with spin up and spin down; it corresponds to a state with angular momentum orthogonal to the original orientations. As a result, the separated oscillatory fields method can be described classically by saying that in the first oscillatory field the spin vector is flipped π/2 radians, and if it precesses in the intermediate region by the same amount as the oscillator oscillates, the second oscillatory field will induce a similar π/2 rotation, giving rise to a sharp narrow resonance. Such an explanation is not possible with an electron two-slit experiment, since there is no classical analog of an electron being a superposition of two position states. The difference arises from the angular momentum being a three-dimensional vector so that a linear superposition of a spin up and a spin down state is a state of orthogonal angular momentum.
The AB (Aharonov-Bohm) effect is a pivotal quantum mechanical phenomenon that illustrates the fundamental role of the electromagnetic vector potential A in determining the phase of a charged particle's wave function, even in regions where the magnetic field B is zero.This effect demonstrates that quantum particles are influenced not only by the fields directly present but also by the potentials associated with those fields.In the AB effect, an electron beam is split into two paths, with one path encircling a solenoid and the other bypassing it.Despite the absence of a magnetic field in the regions traversed by the beams, the vector potential A associated with the magnetic flux through the solenoid induces a phase shift in the electron's wave function.This phase shift, quantified by qc , manifests as a change in the interference pattern observed in the detection screen.The phenomenon underscores the principle of gauge invariance in QED (quantum electrodynamics), where physical observables remain invariant under local gauge transformations of the vector and scalar potentials.This reinforces the notion that the vector potential A has a profound impact on quantum systems, beyond its classical role.This article outlines the AB effect, including its theoretical framework, experimental observations, and implications.The focus on the role of the vector potential in quantum mechanics provides a comprehensive understanding of this important phenomenon.
The seminal paper of Aharonov and Bohm [Phys. Rev. 115, 485 (1959)]10.1103/PhysRev.115.485 is at the origin of a very extensive literature in some of the more fundamental issues in physics. They claimed that electromagnetic fields can act at a distance on charged particles even if they are identically zero in the region of space where the particles propagate, that the fundamental electromagnetic quantities in quantum physics are not only the electromagnetic fields but also the circulations of the electromagnetic potentials; what gives them a real physical significance. They proposed two experiments to verify their theoretical conclusions. The magnetic Aharonov-Bohm effect, where an electron is influenced by a magnetic field that is zero in the region of space accessible to the electron, and the electric Aharonov-Bohm effect where an electron is affected by a time-dependent electric potential that is constant in the region where the electron is propagating, i.e., such that the electric field vanishes along its trajectory. The Aharonov-Bohm effects imply such a strong departure from the physical intuition coming from classical physics that it is no wonder that they remain a highly controversial issue after more than fifty years, in spite of the fact that they are discussed in most of the text books in quantum mechanics. The magnetic case has been studied extensively. The experimental issues were settled by the remarkable experiments of Tonomura et al. [Phys. Rev. Lett. 48, 1443 (1982); Phys. Rev. Lett. 56, 792 (1986)] with toroidal magnets, that gave a strong evidence of the existence of the effect, and by the recent experiment of Caprez et al. [Phys. Rev. Lett. 99, 210401 (2007)]10.1103/PhysRevLett.99.210401 that shows that the results of the Tonomura et al. experiments cannot be explained by the action of a force. The theoretical issues were settled by Ballesteros and Weder [Commun. Math. Phys. 285, 345 (2009)10.1007/s00220-008-0579-1; J. Math. Phys. 50, 122108 (2009)10.1063/1.3266176; Commun. Math. Phys. 303, 175 (2011)]10.1007/s00220-010-1166-9 who rigorously proved that quantum mechanics predicts the experimental results of Tonomura et al. and of Caprez et al. The electric Aharonov-Bohm effect has been much less studied. Actually, its existence, that has not been confirmed experimentally, is a very controversial issue. In their 1959 paper Aharonov and Bohm proposed an ansatz for the solution to the Schrödinger equation in regions where there is a time-dependent electric potential that is constant in space. It consists in multiplying the free evolution by a phase given by the integral in time of the potential. The validity of this ansatz predicts interference fringes between parts of a coherent electron beam that are subjected to different potentials. In this paper we prove that the exact solution to the Schrödinger equation is given by the Aharonov-Bohm ansatz up to an error bound in norm that is uniform in time and that decays as a constant divided by the velocity. Our results give, for the first time, a rigorous proof that quantum mechanics predicts the existence of the electric Aharonov-Bohm effect, under conditions that we provide. We hope that our results will stimulate the experimental research on the electric Aharonov-Bohm effect.
The implications of complementarity on two-path neutron interferences and on separated-oscillatory-field resonances are discussed. The studies are extensions of those by Furry and Ramsey [Phys. Rev. 118, 623 (1960)] on two-path electron interferences which showed that an apparatus used to determine the electron path introduces uncertainties in the scalar and vector potentials which in turn disturb the phase of the electron wave function so much through the Aharonov-Bohm effects [Phys. Rev. 115, 485 (1959)] that the interference fringes disappear. A similar result is derived here for the neutron, but with the phase uncertainties coming from the magnetic moment's motion through an electric field as discussed by Anandan [Phys. Rev. Lett. 48, 1660 (1982)], and Aharonov and Casher [Phys. Rev. Lett. 53, 319 (1984)]. A corresponding result is also obtained for separated-oscillatory-fields resonances, which can be interpreted as an interference between two different paths in spin space. An interesting difference between the separated-path and separated-oscillatory-field experiments is that the latter may be interpreted classically.
The Aharonov-Bohm effect is a quantum mechanical effect, that is, has no classical counterpart. The effect was predicted in 1959 in a seminal paper of Y. Aharonov and D. Bohm [AB59] in which they demonstrated that a beam of electrons is affected by the existence of the electric/magnetic field even though electrons travel through field-free regions. Aharonov and Bohm carried out two hypothetical experiments to support their claim that potentials are more fundamental than fields and they are respon-sible of the effect. Since then, the debate has arisen around whether potentials are mathematical tools or fundamental entities in physics. Different arguments have been set to explain the results predicted by Aharonov and Bohm and experimentally confirmed. Amongst these arguments, the first argument adopted by Aharonov and Bohm was that potentials are physically significant. Many have claimed that fields do have non-local features, i.e. action at a distance. Others have claimed that topological effects may interpret the effect in which potentials are modeled as connections in higher-dimensional fiber bun-dle geometries. The most recent argument has been proposed by Vaidman [Vai12] who claimed that the the composite system is represented by one state, an entangled state, and due to the electromagnetic interactions part of this state is changed, hence, the total state. In the present essay, I will discuss the latter argument as well as reviewing some other arguments. i