Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Breaking two laser axioms: Lasing without inversion and thermal equilibrium

Rafi Weill, Michael Zhurahov, Boris Levit, Baruch Fischer, Alexander M. Bekker

Published Jul 6, 2016• 1 citation
OpenAlex

Abstract

We demonstrate thermalization and Bose-Einstein (BE) distribution of photons in standard erbium-doped fibers (edf) in a broad spectral range up to ~200nm at the 1550nm wavelength regime. Our measurements were done at a room temperature ~300K and 77K. It is a special demonstration of thermalization of photons in fiber cavities and even in open fibers. They are one-dimensional (1D), meters-long, with low finesse, high loss and small capture fraction of the spontaneous emission. Moreover, we find in the edf cavities coexistence of thermal equilibrium (TE) and lasing without an overall inversion. The experimental results are supported by a theoretical analysis based on the rate equations.

Related papers

Thermalization of one-dimensional photon gas and thermal lasers in erbium-doped fibers

Rafi Weill, Alexander Bekker, Boris Levit +2 more

We demonstrate thermalization and Bose-Einstein (BE) distribution of photons in standard erbium-doped fibers (edf) in a broad spectral range up to ~200nm at the 1550nm wavelength regime. Our measurements were done at a room temperature ~300K and 77K. It is a special demonstration of thermalization of photons in fiber cavities and even in open fibers. They are one-dimensional (1D), meters-long, with low finesse, high loss and small capture fraction of the spontaneous emission. Moreover, we find in the edf cavities coexistence of thermal-equilibrium (TE) and thermal lasing without an overall inversion (T-LWI). The experimental results are supported by a theoretical analysis based on the rate equations.

arXiv:1607.01681•Optics Express•Jul 27, 2017•12 citations

Thermal equilibrium of photons and lasing without an overall inversion in standard erbium-doped fibers

Rafi Weill, Alexander Bekker, Boris Levit +2 more

Contrary to what is commonly accepted in lasers, we show that photons in standard erbium-doped fibers (edf) and lasers can be in thermal equilibrium and show lasing without an overall population inversion. The thermalization with Bose-Einstein spectra is found in edf cavities and even in open fibers in a broad spectral range up to ~200nm at the 1550nm wavelength regime. We also find in the edf cavities coexistence of thermal-equilibrium with oscillation without an overall inversion that can be attributed to lasing or Bose-Einstein condensation (BEC). The experimental results are supported by a theoretical analysis based on the rate equations.

Conference on Lasers and Electro-Optics Pacific Rim (CLEO-PR)•Jul 1, 2017•0 citations

Thermal equilibrium of Photons and Lasing without an Overall Inversion in Standard Erbium-Doped Fibers

Rafi Weill, Alexander M. Bekker, Boris Levit +2 more

We show thermal-equilibrium (TE) and Bose-Einstein distribution of photons in standard erbium–doped fibers. We also find a coexistence of TE with oscillation without an overall inversion that can be attributed to lasing or BEC.

Conference on Lasers and Electro-Optics•Jan 1, 2017•0 citations

Bose–Einstein condensation of photons in an erbium–ytterbium co-doped fiber cavity

Rafi Weill, Alexander M. Bekker, Boris Levit +1 more

Abstract Bose–Einstein condensation (BEC) is a special many-boson phenomenon that was observed in atomic particles at ultra-low temperatures. Later, BEC was also shown for non-atomic bosons, such as photons. Those experiments were usually done in micron-size cavities, where the power (particle number) was varied, and not the temperature, until condensation was reached. Here we demonstrate BEC of photons in a few-meters-long one-dimensional (1D) erbium–ytterbium co-doped fiber cavity at, below and above room temperature, between 100 K and 415 K. The experiments were done at about the 1550 nm wavelength regime having a few to tens of μW intra-cavity light power (107−108 photons). By varying the power and also the temperature, we found linear dependence of the condensation on power for various temperatures and of the critical power (for condensation) on temperature. These findings agree, functionally and quantitatively, with the theoretical BEC prediction without any adjustable parameter.

Nature Communications•Feb 14, 2019•39 citations

Thermalization and breakdown of thermalization in photon condensates

Peter Kirton, Jonathan Keeling

We examine in detail the mechanisms behind thermalization and Bose-Einstein condensation (BEC) of a gas of photons in a dye-filled microcavity. We derive a microscopic quantum model, based on that of a standard laser, and show how this model can reproduce the behavior of recent experiments. Using the rate-equation approximation of this model, we show how a thermal distribution of photons arises. We go on to describe how the nonequilibrium effects in our model can cause thermalization to break down as one moves away from the experimental parameter values. In particular, we examine the effects of changing cavity length, and of altering the vibrational spectrum of the dye molecules. We are able to identify two measures which quantify whether the system is in thermal equilibrium. Using these, we plot ``phase diagrams'' distinguishing BEC and standard lasing regimes. Going beyond the rate-equation approximation, our quantum model allows us to investigate both the second-order coherence ${g}^{(2)}$ and the linewidth of the emission from the cavity. We show how the linewidth collapses as the system transitions to a Bose condensed state, and compare the results to the Schawlow-Townes linewidth.

arXiv:1410.6632•Physical Review A•Mar 20, 2015•90 citations

Nonequilibrium Model of Photon Condensation

Peter Kirton, Jonathan Keeling

We develop a nonequilibrium model of condensation and lasing of photons in a dye filled microcavity. We examine in detail the nature of the thermalization process induced by absorption and emission of photons by the dye molecules, and investigate when the photons are able to reach a thermal equilibrium Bose-Einstein distribution. At low temperatures, or large cavity losses, the absorption and emission rates are too small to allow the photons to reach thermal equilibrium and the behavior becomes more like that of a conventional laser.

arXiv:1303.3459•Physical Review Letters•Sep 4, 2013•162 citations
We demonstrate thermalization and Bose-Einstein (BE) distribution of photons in standard erbium-doped fibers (edf) in a broad spectral range up to ~200nm at the 1550nm wavelength regime. Our measurements were done at a room temperature ~300K and 77K. It is a special demonstration of thermalization of photons in fiber cavities and even in open fibers. They are one-dimensional (1D), meters-long, with low finesse, high loss and small capture fraction of the spontaneous emission. Moreover, we find in the edf cavities coexistence of thermal equilibrium (TE) and lasing without an overall inversion. The experimental results are supported by a theoretical analysis based on the rate equations.
We demonstrate thermalization and Bose-Einstein (BE) distribution of photons in standard erbium-doped fibers (edf) in a broad spectral range up to ~200nm at the 1550nm wavelength regime. Our measurements were done at a room temperature ~300K and 77K. It is a special demonstration of thermalization of photons in fiber cavities and even in open fibers. They are one-dimensional (1D), meters-long, with low finesse, high loss and small capture fraction of the spontaneous emission. Moreover, we find in the edf cavities coexistence of thermal-equilibrium (TE) and thermal lasing without an overall inversion (T-LWI). The experimental results are supported by a theoretical analysis based on the rate equations.
Contrary to what is commonly accepted in lasers, we show that photons in standard erbium-doped fibers (edf) and lasers can be in thermal equilibrium and show lasing without an overall population inversion. The thermalization with Bose-Einstein spectra is found in edf cavities and even in open fibers in a broad spectral range up to ~200nm at the 1550nm wavelength regime. We also find in the edf cavities coexistence of thermal-equilibrium with oscillation without an overall inversion that can be attributed to lasing or Bose-Einstein condensation (BEC). The experimental results are supported by a theoretical analysis based on the rate equations.
Abstract Bose–Einstein condensation (BEC) is a special many-boson phenomenon that was observed in atomic particles at ultra-low temperatures. Later, BEC was also shown for non-atomic bosons, such as photons. Those experiments were usually done in micron-size cavities, where the power (particle number) was varied, and not the temperature, until condensation was reached. Here we demonstrate BEC of photons in a few-meters-long one-dimensional (1D) erbium–ytterbium co-doped fiber cavity at, below and above room temperature, between 100 K and 415 K. The experiments were done at about the 1550 nm wavelength regime having a few to tens of μW intra-cavity light power (107−108 photons). By varying the power and also the temperature, we found linear dependence of the condensation on power for various temperatures and of the critical power (for condensation) on temperature. These findings agree, functionally and quantitatively, with the theoretical BEC prediction without any adjustable parameter.
We examine in detail the mechanisms behind thermalization and Bose-Einstein condensation (BEC) of a gas of photons in a dye-filled microcavity. We derive a microscopic quantum model, based on that of a standard laser, and show how this model can reproduce the behavior of recent experiments. Using the rate-equation approximation of this model, we show how a thermal distribution of photons arises. We go on to describe how the nonequilibrium effects in our model can cause thermalization to break down as one moves away from the experimental parameter values. In particular, we examine the effects of changing cavity length, and of altering the vibrational spectrum of the dye molecules. We are able to identify two measures which quantify whether the system is in thermal equilibrium. Using these, we plot ``phase diagrams'' distinguishing BEC and standard lasing regimes. Going beyond the rate-equation approximation, our quantum model allows us to investigate both the second-order coherence g(2){g}^{(2)}g(2) and the linewidth of the emission from the cavity. We show how the linewidth collapses as the system transitions to a Bose condensed state, and compare the results to the Schawlow-Townes linewidth.
We develop a nonequilibrium model of condensation and lasing of photons in a dye filled microcavity. We examine in detail the nature of the thermalization process induced by absorption and emission of photons by the dye molecules, and investigate when the photons are able to reach a thermal equilibrium Bose-Einstein distribution. At low temperatures, or large cavity losses, the absorption and emission rates are too small to allow the photons to reach thermal equilibrium and the behavior becomes more like that of a conventional laser.