Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review A

Geometric phases and the Rabi Hamiltonian

Jean-Paul Saucier Calderón, F. De Zela

Published Mar 10, 2016• 4 citations
Publisher

Abstract

We address Berry phases that have been predicted to appear when a two-level system interacts with a quantized field, including the vacuum state. The issue became controversial after it was argued that the appearance of such Berry phases is an artifact of the rotating-wave approximation (RWA). As is widely believed, whenever the RWA applies, one may replace the Rabi model of a two-level system interacting with a quantized field by the analytically solvable Jaynes-Cummings model. Conflicting predictions of these two models under conditions that validate the RWA would signal a serious inconsistency of this approximation. We show that this is not the case and that claims to the contrary are inconsistent with analytical results concerning the Rabi model. We provide also numerical evidence supporting our analytical approach. Furthermore, we argue that the appearance of Berry phases in the addressed cases does not depend on adiabatic conditions nor on any particular Hamiltonian, but on the underlying vector space. Thus, the appropriate framework is given by the kinematic approach to geometric phases, which contains Berry's phase as a special case.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.93.033823

Related papers

On the rotating wave approximation in the adiabatic limit

Jonas Larson

I revisit a longstanding question in quantum optics; when is the rotating wave approximation justified? In terms of the Jaynes–Cummings and Rabi models I demonstrate that the approximation in general breaks down in the adiabatic limit regardless of system parameters. This is explicitly shown by comparing Berry phases of the two models, where it is found that this geometrical phase is strictly zero in the Rabi model contrary to the non-trivial Berry phase of the Jaynes–Cummings model. The source of this surprising result is traced back to different topologies in the two models.

arXiv:1208.1891•Physica Scripta•Mar 1, 2013•7 citations

Absence of Vacuum Induced Berry Phases without the Rotating Wave Approximation in Cavity QED

Jonas Larson

We revisit earlier studies on Berry phases suggested to appear in certain cavity QED settings. It has been especially argued that a nontrivial geometric phase is achievable even in the situation of no cavity photons. We, however, show that such results hinge on imposing the rotating wave approximation (RWA), while without the RWA no Berry phases occur in these schemes. A geometrical interpretation of our results is obtained by introducing semiclassical energy surfaces which in a simple way brings out the phase-space dynamics. With the RWA, a conical intersection between the surfaces emerges and encircling it gives rise to the Berry phase. Without the RWA, the conical intersection is absent and therefore the Berry phase vanishes. It is believed that this is a first example showing how the application of the RWA in the Jaynes-Cummings model may lead to false conclusions, regardless of the mutual strengths between the system parameters.

arXiv:1107.3447•Physical Review Letters•Jan 18, 2012•71 citations

Vacuum-induced Berry phase beyond the rotating-wave approximation

Tao Liu, Mang Feng, Kelin Wang

With reference to the vacuum-induced Berry phase (VIBP) obtained in the interaction of a spin-1/2 particle with quantized irradiation field under rotating-wave approximation (RWA), we present a completely different treatment for the VIBP by a fully quantum-mechanical treatment beyond the RWA, which gives different definition of the VIBP and indicates the validity of RWA to be relevant not only to the energy conservation and comparison of characteristic parameters, but also to more subtle physics, such as the geometric property of the state evolution. Our result is of conceptual importance and also of significant relevance to quantum-information processing.

arXiv:1111.0154•Physical Review A•Dec 13, 2011•13 citations

Geometric phase and non-adiabatic resonance of the Rabi model

Sijiang Liu, Zhiguo Lü, Hang Zheng

Abstract We investigate the effects of counterrotating terms on geometric phase and its relation to the resonance of the Rabi model. We apply the unitary transformation with a single parameter to the Rabi model and obtain the transformed Hamiltonian involving multiple harmonic terms. By combining the counter-rotating-hybridized rotating-wave method with time-dependent perturbation theory, we solve systematically time evolution operator and then obtain the geometric phase of the two-level system. Our results are beyond adiabatic approximation and rotating-wave approximation (RWA). Higher-order harmonic resonance happens when driving frequency is equal to higher-order subharmonic of the Rabi frequency. In comparison with numerically exact results, our calculated results are accurate over a wide range of parameters space, especially in higher-order harmonic resonance regimes. In these regimes we demonstrate geometric phases change dramatically while those of the RWA are smooth. The RWA is thoroughly invalid even if the driving strength is extremely weak. We find it is the higher-order harmonic terms that play an important role on the cyclic state and demonstrate the characters of geometric phase in higher-order harmonic resonance regime. We also present analytical formalism of the change rate of geometric phase and quasienergies, which agree well with numerically exact ones even in the strong driving case. The developed method can be applied to explore the dynamics of strongly driven qubits and physical properties of higher-order harmonic processes.

arXiv:2110.01158•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Sep 24, 2021•3 citations

Berry's phase in the two-level model

A.C. Aguiar Pinto, M. Moutinho, M. T. Thomaz

We study the adiabatic evolution of a two-level model in the presence of an external classical electric field. The coupling between the quantum model and the classical field is taken in the electric dipole approximation. In this regime, we show the absence of geometric phases in the interacting two-level model in the presence of any periodic real time-dependent classical electric field. We obtain a conservative scalar potential in the calculation of Berry's phases of the instantaneous eigenstates of the model. For complex electric fields, we recover the existence of geometric phases. In particular, the geometric phases of the instantaneous eigenstates of the model in the presence of a positive or of a negative frequency component of the monochromatic electric field differ by an overall sign. As a check on our results, we map this interacting two-level model onto a spin-1/2 model under the action of a classical magnetic field. We confirm that the first one acquires Berry's phase only in the rotating wave approximation [RWA].

arXiv:0904.1774•Brazilian Journal of Physics•Jun 1, 2009•5 citations

Berry's phase in the two-level model

A.C. Aguiar Pinto, Marcus V. O. Moutinho, M. T. Thomaz

We study the adiabatic evolution of a two-level model in the presence of an external classical electric field. The coupling between the quantum model and the classical field is taken in the electric dipole approximation. In this regime, we show the absence of geometric phases in the interacting two-level model in the presence of any periodic real time-dependent classical electric field. We obtain a conservative scalar potential in the calculation of Berry's phases of the instantaneous eigenstates of the model. For complex electric fields, we recover the existence of geometric phases. In particular, the geometric phases of the instantaneous eigenstates of the model in the presence of a positive or of a negative frequency component of the monochromatic electric field differ by an overall sign. As a check on our results, we map this interacting two-level model onto a spin-1/2 model under the action of a classical magnetic field. We confirm that the first one acquires Berry's phase only in the rotating wave approximation [RWA].

•Jan 1, 2009•6 citations
We address Berry phases that have been predicted to appear when a two-level system interacts with a quantized field, including the vacuum state. The issue became controversial after it was argued that the appearance of such Berry phases is an artifact of the rotating-wave approximation (RWA). As is widely believed, whenever the RWA applies, one may replace the Rabi model of a two-level system interacting with a quantized field by the analytically solvable Jaynes-Cummings model. Conflicting predictions of these two models under conditions that validate the RWA would signal a serious inconsistency of this approximation. We show that this is not the case and that claims to the contrary are inconsistent with analytical results concerning the Rabi model. We provide also numerical evidence supporting our analytical approach. Furthermore, we argue that the appearance of Berry phases in the addressed cases does not depend on adiabatic conditions nor on any particular Hamiltonian, but on the underlying vector space. Thus, the appropriate framework is given by the kinematic approach to geometric phases, which contains Berry's phase as a special case.
I revisit a longstanding question in quantum optics; when is the rotating wave approximation justified? In terms of the Jaynes–Cummings and Rabi models I demonstrate that the approximation in general breaks down in the adiabatic limit regardless of system parameters. This is explicitly shown by comparing Berry phases of the two models, where it is found that this geometrical phase is strictly zero in the Rabi model contrary to the non-trivial Berry phase of the Jaynes–Cummings model. The source of this surprising result is traced back to different topologies in the two models.
We revisit earlier studies on Berry phases suggested to appear in certain cavity QED settings. It has been especially argued that a nontrivial geometric phase is achievable even in the situation of no cavity photons. We, however, show that such results hinge on imposing the rotating wave approximation (RWA), while without the RWA no Berry phases occur in these schemes. A geometrical interpretation of our results is obtained by introducing semiclassical energy surfaces which in a simple way brings out the phase-space dynamics. With the RWA, a conical intersection between the surfaces emerges and encircling it gives rise to the Berry phase. Without the RWA, the conical intersection is absent and therefore the Berry phase vanishes. It is believed that this is a first example showing how the application of the RWA in the Jaynes-Cummings model may lead to false conclusions, regardless of the mutual strengths between the system parameters.
With reference to the vacuum-induced Berry phase (VIBP) obtained in the interaction of a spin-1/2 particle with quantized irradiation field under rotating-wave approximation (RWA), we present a completely different treatment for the VIBP by a fully quantum-mechanical treatment beyond the RWA, which gives different definition of the VIBP and indicates the validity of RWA to be relevant not only to the energy conservation and comparison of characteristic parameters, but also to more subtle physics, such as the geometric property of the state evolution. Our result is of conceptual importance and also of significant relevance to quantum-information processing.
Abstract We investigate the effects of counterrotating terms on geometric phase and its relation to the resonance of the Rabi model. We apply the unitary transformation with a single parameter to the Rabi model and obtain the transformed Hamiltonian involving multiple harmonic terms. By combining the counter-rotating-hybridized rotating-wave method with time-dependent perturbation theory, we solve systematically time evolution operator and then obtain the geometric phase of the two-level system. Our results are beyond adiabatic approximation and rotating-wave approximation (RWA). Higher-order harmonic resonance happens when driving frequency is equal to higher-order subharmonic of the Rabi frequency. In comparison with numerically exact results, our calculated results are accurate over a wide range of parameters space, especially in higher-order harmonic resonance regimes. In these regimes we demonstrate geometric phases change dramatically while those of the RWA are smooth. The RWA is thoroughly invalid even if the driving strength is extremely weak. We find it is the higher-order harmonic terms that play an important role on the cyclic state and demonstrate the characters of geometric phase in higher-order harmonic resonance regime. We also present analytical formalism of the change rate of geometric phase and quasienergies, which agree well with numerically exact ones even in the strong driving case. The developed method can be applied to explore the dynamics of strongly driven qubits and physical properties of higher-order harmonic processes.
We study the adiabatic evolution of a two-level model in the presence of an external classical electric field. The coupling between the quantum model and the classical field is taken in the electric dipole approximation. In this regime, we show the absence of geometric phases in the interacting two-level model in the presence of any periodic real time-dependent classical electric field. We obtain a conservative scalar potential in the calculation of Berry's phases of the instantaneous eigenstates of the model. For complex electric fields, we recover the existence of geometric phases. In particular, the geometric phases of the instantaneous eigenstates of the model in the presence of a positive or of a negative frequency component of the monochromatic electric field differ by an overall sign. As a check on our results, we map this interacting two-level model onto a spin-1/2 model under the action of a classical magnetic field. We confirm that the first one acquires Berry's phase only in the rotating wave approximation [RWA].
We study the adiabatic evolution of a two-level model in the presence of an external classical electric field. The coupling between the quantum model and the classical field is taken in the electric dipole approximation. In this regime, we show the absence of geometric phases in the interacting two-level model in the presence of any periodic real time-dependent classical electric field. We obtain a conservative scalar potential in the calculation of Berry's phases of the instantaneous eigenstates of the model. For complex electric fields, we recover the existence of geometric phases. In particular, the geometric phases of the instantaneous eigenstates of the model in the presence of a positive or of a negative frequency component of the monochromatic electric field differ by an overall sign. As a check on our results, we map this interacting two-level model onto a spin-1/2 model under the action of a classical magnetic field. We confirm that the first one acquires Berry's phase only in the rotating wave approximation [RWA].