Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Zeitschrift für Physikalische Chemie

Position and Momentum Space Variables

V. H. Jr. Smith

Published Jan 1, 2001• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The use of position space and momentum space variables, coordinates and operators, is discussed with emphasis on the controversy in the case of spherical polar coordinates.
DOI
10.1524/zpch.2001.215.10.1237

Related papers

Alternative Formulations for Angular Momentum Operators, Cartesian and Spherical Polar Forms

Carl W David

The conversion between representations of angular momentum in spherical polar and cartesian form is discussed.

•Jan 1, 2006•0 citations

Simple and fast method for obtaining the angular momentum operators L x, L y, L z, and L2 in terms of spherical polar coordinates

Victor Namias

American Journal of Physics•Aug 1, 1977•0 citations

Geometric momentum distribution for three-dimensional isotropic hormonic oscillator

Quanhui Liu, Zhang Meng-Nan, Shi-Fa Xiao +1 more

The geometric momentum was originally introduced for defining the momentum of particle constrained on a hypersurface, but it is in fact not necessarily defined on a curved surface only. If a coordinate system contains a family of hypersurfaces and a normal vector on hypersurface used as a unit vector, the geometric momentum can be defined on the family of hypersurfaces and can be used to determine a complete set of commuting observables. For instance, the spherical polar coordinate system is such a kind of coordinate, in which for a given value of radial position, the spherical surface is a hypersurface. It is well-known that any vector in the space can be decomposed into components along each axis of the spherical polar coordinates, but the geometric momentum has a different decomposition, for it requires a projection of the momentum on the hypersurface, and then needs to decompose the projection into the Cartesian coordinates of the original space where the whole spherical coordinates are defined. Explicitly, with a relation-iħ▽= p Σ + p n where-iħ▽ can be usual momentum operator in Cartesian coordinates, and p Σ is the momentum component on the hypersurface which turns out to be the geometric momentum, and p n is the momentum component along the radial direction, we have a nontrivial definition of radial momentum as p n ≡-iħ▽- p Σ. Once-iħ▽ and p Σ are measurable, p n is then indirectly measurable. The three-dimensional isotropic harmonic oscillator can be described in both the Cartesian and the spherical polar coordinates, whose quantum states thus can be examined in terms of both momentum and geometric momentum distributions. The distributions of the radial momentum are explicitly given for some states. The radial momentum operator that was introduced by Dirac has clear physical significance, in contrast to widely spreading belief that it is not measurable due to its non-self-adjoint.

Acta Physica Sinica•Jan 1, 2019•0 citations

Chapter 11. Angular Momentum and the Position Operators

Dennis Morris

De Gruyter eBooks•May 27, 2016•0 citations

Helicity representations of the coordinate, momentum, and angular momentum operators

Annals of Physics•Aug 1, 1970•0 citations

Reality of linear and angular momentum expectation values in bound states

Utpal Roy, Suranjana Ghosh, T. Shreecharan +1 more

In quantum mechanics textbooks the momentum operator is defined in the Cartesian coordinates and rarely the form of the momentum operator in spherical polar coordinates is discussed. Consequently one always generalizes the Cartesian prescription to other coordinates and falls in a trap. In this work we introduce the difficulties one faces when the question of the momentum operator in spherical polar coordinate comes. We have tried to point out most of the elementary quantum mechanical results, related to the momentum operator, which has coordinate dependence. We explicitly calculate the momentum expectation values in various bound states and show that the expectation value really turns out to be zero, a consequence of the fact that the momentum expectation value is real. We comment briefly on the status of the angular variables in quantum mechanics and the problems related in interpreting them as dynamical variables. At the end, we calculate the Heisenberg's equation of motion for the radial component of the momentum for the Hydrogen atom.

arXiv:0704.0373•Apr 3, 2007•4 citations
The geometric momentum was originally introduced for defining the momentum of particle constrained on a hypersurface, but it is in fact not necessarily defined on a curved surface only. If a coordinate system contains a family of hypersurfaces and a normal vector on hypersurface used as a unit vector, the geometric momentum can be defined on the family of hypersurfaces and can be used to determine a complete set of commuting observables. For instance, the spherical polar coordinate system is such a kind of coordinate, in which for a given value of radial position, the spherical surface is a hypersurface. It is well-known that any vector in the space can be decomposed into components along each axis of the spherical polar coordinates, but the geometric momentum has a different decomposition, for it requires a projection of the momentum on the hypersurface, and then needs to decompose the projection into the Cartesian coordinates of the original space where the whole spherical coordinates are defined. Explicitly, with a relation-iħ▽= p Σ + p n where-iħ▽ can be usual momentum operator in Cartesian coordinates, and p Σ is the momentum component on the hypersurface which turns out to be the geometric momentum, and p n is the momentum component along the radial direction, we have a nontrivial definition of radial momentum as p n ≡-iħ▽- p Σ. Once-iħ▽ and p Σ are measurable, p n is then indirectly measurable. The three-dimensional isotropic harmonic oscillator can be described in both the Cartesian and the spherical polar coordinates, whose quantum states thus can be examined in terms of both momentum and geometric momentum distributions. The distributions of the radial momentum are explicitly given for some states. The radial momentum operator that was introduced by Dirac has clear physical significance, in contrast to widely spreading belief that it is not measurable due to its non-self-adjoint.
In quantum mechanics textbooks the momentum operator is defined in the Cartesian coordinates and rarely the form of the momentum operator in spherical polar coordinates is discussed. Consequently one always generalizes the Cartesian prescription to other coordinates and falls in a trap. In this work we introduce the difficulties one faces when the question of the momentum operator in spherical polar coordinate comes. We have tried to point out most of the elementary quantum mechanical results, related to the momentum operator, which has coordinate dependence. We explicitly calculate the momentum expectation values in various bound states and show that the expectation value really turns out to be zero, a consequence of the fact that the momentum expectation value is real. We comment briefly on the status of the angular variables in quantum mechanics and the problems related in interpreting them as dynamical variables. At the end, we calculate the Heisenberg's equation of motion for the radial component of the momentum for the Hydrogen atom.