Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Foundations of probability and physics

"COMPLEMENTARITY" OR SCHIZOPHRENIA: IS PROBABILITY IN QUANTUM MECHANICS INFORMATION OR ONTA?

Aloysius F. Kracklauer

Published Dec 1, 2001• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Of the various "complimentarities" or "dualities" evident in Quantum Mechanics (QM), among the most vexing is that afflicting the character of a 'wave function,' which at once is to be something ontological because it diffracts at material boundaries, and something epistemological because it carries only probabilistic information. Herein a description of a paradigm, a conceptual model of physical effects, will be presented that perhaps can provide an understanding of this schizophrenic nature of wave functions. It is based on Stochastic Electrodynamics (SED), a candidate theory to elucidate the mysteries of QM. The fundamental assumption underlying SED is the supposed existence of a certain sort of random, electromagnetic background, the nature of which, it is hoped, will ultimately account for the behavior of atomic scale entities as described usually by QM. In addition, the interplay of this paradigm with Bell's 'no-go' theorem for local, realistic extentions of QM will be analyzed.

DOI
10.1142/9789812810809_0016

Related papers

The Physics Underlying Quantum Phenomena

Ana María Cetto, Luis de la Peña

The Physics Underlying Quantum Phenomena At this point, after having studied the previous chapters, you should be sufficiently familiar with quantum formalism to be ready to pause for a moment and delve into the underlying physics.It is likely that along the way you have been puzzled by some strange or counter-intuitive quantum features and have kept your puzzlement to yourself.This chapter is devoted to explaining some of the basic physics behind the theory, and in this respect it differs from most textbooks.Although you can skip this material if you are only interested in a more formal or conventional course in QM, we strongly recommend that you take the opportunity to join us in this exciting and timely endeavor.The aim is that you come away with a clearer picture of quantum behavior and its causes, which will also hopefully make it easier for you to understand the further reading.We have learned from previous chapters that randomness enters the description in the form of "quantum fluctuations," considered to be a signature of quantumness.A number of different stochastic theories have been developed over the years to shed light on the nature of quantum stochasticity.In particular, stochastic quantum mechanics (SQM) and stochastic electrodynamics (SED) provide valuable and complementary insights, as we shall see.The phenomenological approach of SQM, which is schematically presented in the next section, uses simple and straightforward mathematics with a clear physical meaning.However, like any phenomenological theory, it has the drawback that the source of the stochasticity remains unidentified.We recall that already in Section 2.9.1 the interaction with the fluctuating electromagnetic vacuum or zero-point field (ZPF) was pointed out as a natural cause for both, the quantum stochasticity and the presence of wave-like phenomena; this is the starting point for SED.In this chapter we will show that it is indeed possible to clarify central aspects of QM by considering the coupling of matter with the radiation field, including the zero-point component.In particular, the intriguing operator formalism finds a first-principles explanation that gives substance to the basic postulates introduced by Heisenberg a century ago.Finally, Section 5 introduces the hydrodynamic quantum analogue (HQA) of a walking droplet, a striking macroscopic example of a particle-wave system capable of expressing quantum-like features under appropriate conditions.The discussion of characteristic wave-like manifestations arising from the particle-field interaction in the case of quantum systems is left to future chapters.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Dec 18, 2025•0 citations

Does probabilism solve the great quantum mystery?

What sort of entities are electrons, photons and atoms given their wave-like and particle-like properties?Is nature fundamentally deterministic or probabilistic?Orthodox quantum theory (OQT) evades answering these two basic questions by being a theory about the results of performing measurements on quantum systems.But this evasion results in OQT being a seriously defective theory.A rival, somewhat ignored strategy is to conjecture that the quantum domain is fundamentally probabilistic.This means quantum entities, interacting with one another probabilistically, must differ radically from the entities of deterministic classical physics, the classical wave or particle.It becomes possible to conceive of quantum entities as a new kind of fundamentally probabilistic entity, the "propensiton", neither wave nor particle.A fully micro realistic, testable rival to OQT results.

UCL Press eBooks•Sep 26, 2017•0 citations

An Intuitive Paradigm for Quantum Mechanics

Aloysius F. Kracklauer

Use is made of a relativistic kinematic modulation effect to compliment imagery from Stochastic Electrodynamics to provide intuitive paradigms for Quantum Mechanics. Based on these paradigms, resolutions for epistemological problems vexing conventional interpretations of Quantum Mechanics are proposed and discussed.

Physics Essays•Jun 1, 1992•18 citations

QUANTUM REALISM, INFORMATION, AND EPISTEMOLOGICAL MODESTY

Alexei Grinbaum

It is usually asserted that physical theories, in particular quantum mechanics, support a certain view of what the world really is. To such claims I oppose an attitude of epistemological modesty. Ontological statements on the nature of reality, when made on the basis of quantum mechanics, appear unwarranted. I suggest that an epistemic loop connects physical theory grounded in informational notions, and a theory of information developed through a theoretical account of the physical support of information.

•Mar 5, 2014•2 citations

A Conceptual Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics Based on Environmental Interaction, Wave–Particle Duality, and Measurement Constraints

Mokhdum Azam Mashrafi Mokhdum Azam Mashrafi

Quantum mechanics describes physical systems through probabilistic wave functions, accounting for phenomena such as wave–particle duality and the uncertainty principle. Although the mathematical formalism of quantum mechanics is well established, conceptual understanding of how quantum entities transition between wave-like and particle-like behavior remains an active area of research. In this work, quantum mechanical principles are re-examined from an interaction-based perspective, emphasizing the roles of environmental coupling, measurement geometry, and energy exchange. Using the photoelectric effect, de Broglie relations, and Heisenberg’s uncertainty principle as foundational elements, a conceptual framework is proposed in which particle identity emerges dynamically from wave interaction with matter and measurement constraints. This interpretation provides an intuitive bridge between classical reasoning and quantum behavior while fully preserving the standard mathematical structure of quantum mechanics...........Please check the attachment for details

•Dec 22, 2025•0 citations

THE PHYSICS OF QUANTUM INFORMATION: COMPLEMENTARITY, UNCERTAINTY, AND ENTANGLEMENT

Joseph M. Renes

Complementarity is one of the central mysteries of quantum mechanics, dramatically illustrated by the wave-particle duality in Young's double-slit experiment, and famously regarded by Feynman as "impossible, absolutely impossible to describe classically, [and] which has in it the heart of quantum mechanics" (emphasis original).1 The overarching goal of this thesis is to demonstrate that complementarity is also at the heart of quantum information theory, that it allows us to make (some) sense of just what information "quantum information" refers to, and that it is useful in understanding and constructing quantum information processing protocols.

arXiv:1212.2379•International Journal of Quantum Information•Dec 1, 2013•15 citations
Of the various "complimentarities" or "dualities" evident in Quantum Mechanics (QM), among the most vexing is that afflicting the character of a 'wave function,' which at once is to be something ontological because it diffracts at material boundaries, and something epistemological because it carries only probabilistic information. Herein a description of a paradigm, a conceptual model of physical effects, will be presented that perhaps can provide an understanding of this schizophrenic nature of wave functions. It is based on Stochastic Electrodynamics (SED), a candidate theory to elucidate the mysteries of QM. The fundamental assumption underlying SED is the supposed existence of a certain sort of random, electromagnetic background, the nature of which, it is hoped, will ultimately account for the behavior of atomic scale entities as described usually by QM. In addition, the interplay of this paradigm with Bell's 'no-go' theorem for local, realistic extentions of QM will be analyzed.
The Physics Underlying Quantum Phenomena At this point, after having studied the previous chapters, you should be sufficiently familiar with quantum formalism to be ready to pause for a moment and delve into the underlying physics.It is likely that along the way you have been puzzled by some strange or counter-intuitive quantum features and have kept your puzzlement to yourself.This chapter is devoted to explaining some of the basic physics behind the theory, and in this respect it differs from most textbooks.Although you can skip this material if you are only interested in a more formal or conventional course in QM, we strongly recommend that you take the opportunity to join us in this exciting and timely endeavor.The aim is that you come away with a clearer picture of quantum behavior and its causes, which will also hopefully make it easier for you to understand the further reading.We have learned from previous chapters that randomness enters the description in the form of "quantum fluctuations," considered to be a signature of quantumness.A number of different stochastic theories have been developed over the years to shed light on the nature of quantum stochasticity.In particular, stochastic quantum mechanics (SQM) and stochastic electrodynamics (SED) provide valuable and complementary insights, as we shall see.The phenomenological approach of SQM, which is schematically presented in the next section, uses simple and straightforward mathematics with a clear physical meaning.However, like any phenomenological theory, it has the drawback that the source of the stochasticity remains unidentified.We recall that already in Section 2.9.1 the interaction with the fluctuating electromagnetic vacuum or zero-point field (ZPF) was pointed out as a natural cause for both, the quantum stochasticity and the presence of wave-like phenomena; this is the starting point for SED.In this chapter we will show that it is indeed possible to clarify central aspects of QM by considering the coupling of matter with the radiation field, including the zero-point component.In particular, the intriguing operator formalism finds a first-principles explanation that gives substance to the basic postulates introduced by Heisenberg a century ago.Finally, Section 5 introduces the hydrodynamic quantum analogue (HQA) of a walking droplet, a striking macroscopic example of a particle-wave system capable of expressing quantum-like features under appropriate conditions.The discussion of characteristic wave-like manifestations arising from the particle-field interaction in the case of quantum systems is left to future chapters.
What sort of entities are electrons, photons and atoms given their wave-like and particle-like properties?Is nature fundamentally deterministic or probabilistic?Orthodox quantum theory (OQT) evades answering these two basic questions by being a theory about the results of performing measurements on quantum systems.But this evasion results in OQT being a seriously defective theory.A rival, somewhat ignored strategy is to conjecture that the quantum domain is fundamentally probabilistic.This means quantum entities, interacting with one another probabilistically, must differ radically from the entities of deterministic classical physics, the classical wave or particle.It becomes possible to conceive of quantum entities as a new kind of fundamentally probabilistic entity, the "propensiton", neither wave nor particle.A fully micro realistic, testable rival to OQT results.
It is usually asserted that physical theories, in particular quantum mechanics, support a certain view of what the world really is. To such claims I oppose an attitude of epistemological modesty. Ontological statements on the nature of reality, when made on the basis of quantum mechanics, appear unwarranted. I suggest that an epistemic loop connects physical theory grounded in informational notions, and a theory of information developed through a theoretical account of the physical support of information.
Quantum mechanics describes physical systems through probabilistic wave functions, accounting for phenomena such as wave–particle duality and the uncertainty principle. Although the mathematical formalism of quantum mechanics is well established, conceptual understanding of how quantum entities transition between wave-like and particle-like behavior remains an active area of research. In this work, quantum mechanical principles are re-examined from an interaction-based perspective, emphasizing the roles of environmental coupling, measurement geometry, and energy exchange. Using the photoelectric effect, de Broglie relations, and Heisenberg’s uncertainty principle as foundational elements, a conceptual framework is proposed in which particle identity emerges dynamically from wave interaction with matter and measurement constraints. This interpretation provides an intuitive bridge between classical reasoning and quantum behavior while fully preserving the standard mathematical structure of quantum mechanics...........Please check the attachment for details
Complementarity is one of the central mysteries of quantum mechanics, dramatically illustrated by the wave-particle duality in Young's double-slit experiment, and famously regarded by Feynman as "impossible, absolutely impossible to describe classically, [and] which has in it the heart of quantum mechanics" (emphasis original).1 The overarching goal of this thesis is to demonstrate that complementarity is also at the heart of quantum information theory, that it allows us to make (some) sense of just what information "quantum information" refers to, and that it is useful in understanding and constructing quantum information processing protocols.