Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Communications in Theoretical Physics

Operator Ordering Problem and Coordinate-Free Nature of Geometric Quantization

Dehai Bao, Z.Y. Zhu

Published Mar 15, 1996• 1 citation
Publisher

Abstract

Operator ordering problem in geometric quantization is investigated. While the quantum operator for given by geometric quantization is found to be ordered via the rule invariant under general coordinate transformations, it is shown that the quantum operators for where cannot be well-defined by geometric quantization. This is considered as a natural consequence of the coordinate-free nature of geometric quantization and the Van Hove's theorem.

DOI
10.1088/0253-6102/25/2/189

Related papers

Ordering problem in geometrical quantization

Dehai Bao, Zhongyuan Zhu

The operator ordering problem is investigated in the framework of geometrical quantization in the Schrodinger coordinate representation. It is shown that, for quantization of polarization-preserving classical observables pf(q), correct Hermitian quantum operators are derived; for quantization of polarization-unpreserving classical observables p 2 f(q), the BKS kernel method actually defines an ordering rule which is not Weyl's rule, but is the GCT-invariant rule proposed by DeWitt (1957).

Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•Apr 21, 1992•3 citations

On GCT-Invariant Operator Ordering Rule

Dehai Bao, Zhongyuan Zhu

With an observation that the general coordinate transformation (GCT) invariant operator ordering rule proposed by DeWitt is valid only for some cases, a careful classification for classical observables that can be related through the well-defined GCT is presented and a generalized GCT-invariant ordering rule is derived.

Communications in Theoretical Physics•Mar 1, 1993•0 citations

Geometric Quantization, Coherent States and Stochastic Measurements

Blagovest A. Nikolov, D. A. Trifonov

The geometric quantization problem is considered from the point of view of the Davies and Lewis approach to quantum mechanics. The influence of the measuring device is accounted in the classical and quantum case and it is shown that the conditions of the measurement define the type of quantization (Weyl, normal, antinormal, etc.). The quantum states and quantum operators are obtained by means of the projection, defined from the system of generalized coherent states.

arXiv:quant-ph/0408096•Aug 14, 2004•0 citations

No-Go theorems and quantization

Hishamuddin B Zainuddin, Toh Sing Poh, Nurisya Mohd Shah +4 more

In this review, we would like to highlight the three known no-go theorems in quantum physics in relation to the processof quantization that maps classical observables to quantum ones. The quantization approach considered is a mixture ofIsham’s group-theoretic quantization and geometric quantization with special emphasis on underlying compact phasespace geometry of spheres. The first is Groenewold-van Hove theorem that states the obstruction of quantizing the fullalgebra of observables and in the sphere case, only limited to the spin observables plus the constant functions. Theother two are theorems of Bell and Kochen-Specker stating that the only hidden variable theories allowed by quantumphysics are nonlocal and contextual ones. We give simple examples of these no-go theorems and indicate someinteresting problems arising from them for the field of quantization.

Malaysian Journal of Fundamental and Applied Sciences•Jun 16, 2014•1 citation

Introduction to coherent quantization

Arnold Neumaier, Arash Ghaani Farashahi

Abstract This paper studies coherent quantization, the way operators in the quantum space of a coherent space—defined in the recent book ’Coherent Quantum Mechanics’ by the first author—can be studied in terms of objects defined directly on the coherent space. The results may be viewed as a generalization of geometric quantization, including the non-unitary case. Care has been taken to work with the weakest meaningful topology and to assume as little as possible about the spaces and groups involved. Unlike in geometric quantization, the groups are not assumed to be compact, locally compact, or finite-dimensional. This implies that the setting can be successfully applied to quantum field theory, where the groups involved satisfy none of these properties. The paper characterizes linear operators acting on the quantum space of a coherent space in terms of their coherent matrix elements. Coherent maps and associated symmetry groups for coherent spaces are introduced, and formulas are derived for the quantization of coherent maps. The importance of coherent maps for quantum mechanics is due to the fact that there is a quantization map that associates homomorphically with every coherent map a linear operator from the quantum space into itself. The quantization map generalizes the second quantization procedure for free classical fields to symmetry groups of general coherent spaces. Field quantization is obtained by specialization to Klauder spaces, whose quantum spaces are the bosonic Fock spaces. Implied by the new approach is a short, coordinate-free derivation of all basic properties of creation and annihilation operators in Fock spaces.

arXiv:1804.01400•Analysis and Mathematical Physics•Jun 17, 2022•3 citations

Quantization of three-dimensional space

Boris Leaf

Geometrical properties of space are described by relations between quantum observables, functions of generalized coordinate and momentum operators of a physical system. Space comprises the set of eigenvalues of the coordinate observables, which may be a discrete set of points instead of the continuum of classical geometry. Differentiation on coordinates and momenta is defined by commutation operations. Well-known formulas from classical geometry for gradient and divergence operators, connections, covariant differentiation, tangent vectors, geodesics, and the Riemann curvature tensor are derived as relations between quantum operators. The quantum formulation retains the symmetry between coordinate and momentum representations required by the principle of complementarity.

Journal of Mathematical Physics•Mar 1, 1984•1 citation
Operator ordering problem in geometric quantization is investigated. While the quantum operator for given by geometric quantization is found to be ordered via the rule invariant under general coordinate transformations, it is shown that the quantum operators for where cannot be well-defined by geometric quantization. This is considered as a natural consequence of the coordinate-free nature of geometric quantization and the Van Hove's theorem.
In this review, we would like to highlight the three known no-go theorems in quantum physics in relation to the processof quantization that maps classical observables to quantum ones. The quantization approach considered is a mixture ofIsham’s group-theoretic quantization and geometric quantization with special emphasis on underlying compact phasespace geometry of spheres. The first is Groenewold-van Hove theorem that states the obstruction of quantizing the fullalgebra of observables and in the sphere case, only limited to the spin observables plus the constant functions. Theother two are theorems of Bell and Kochen-Specker stating that the only hidden variable theories allowed by quantumphysics are nonlocal and contextual ones. We give simple examples of these no-go theorems and indicate someinteresting problems arising from them for the field of quantization.
Abstract This paper studies coherent quantization, the way operators in the quantum space of a coherent space—defined in the recent book ’Coherent Quantum Mechanics’ by the first author—can be studied in terms of objects defined directly on the coherent space. The results may be viewed as a generalization of geometric quantization, including the non-unitary case. Care has been taken to work with the weakest meaningful topology and to assume as little as possible about the spaces and groups involved. Unlike in geometric quantization, the groups are not assumed to be compact, locally compact, or finite-dimensional. This implies that the setting can be successfully applied to quantum field theory, where the groups involved satisfy none of these properties. The paper characterizes linear operators acting on the quantum space of a coherent space in terms of their coherent matrix elements. Coherent maps and associated symmetry groups for coherent spaces are introduced, and formulas are derived for the quantization of coherent maps. The importance of coherent maps for quantum mechanics is due to the fact that there is a quantization map that associates homomorphically with every coherent map a linear operator from the quantum space into itself. The quantization map generalizes the second quantization procedure for free classical fields to symmetry groups of general coherent spaces. Field quantization is obtained by specialization to Klauder spaces, whose quantum spaces are the bosonic Fock spaces. Implied by the new approach is a short, coordinate-free derivation of all basic properties of creation and annihilation operators in Fock spaces.
Geometrical properties of space are described by relations between quantum observables, functions of generalized coordinate and momentum operators of a physical system. Space comprises the set of eigenvalues of the coordinate observables, which may be a discrete set of points instead of the continuum of classical geometry. Differentiation on coordinates and momenta is defined by commutation operations. Well-known formulas from classical geometry for gradient and divergence operators, connections, covariant differentiation, tangent vectors, geodesics, and the Riemann curvature tensor are derived as relations between quantum operators. The quantum formulation retains the symmetry between coordinate and momentum representations required by the principle of complementarity.