Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review Letters

Momentum Transfer to a Free Floating Double Slit: Realization of a Thought Experiment from the Einstein-Bohr Debates

L. Ph. H. Schmidt, J. Lower, T. Jahnke, Sven Schössler, Markus S Schöffler, Adrian J. Menssen, Camille Lévêque, Nicolas Sisourat, Richard Taïeb, H. Schmidt‐Böcking, R. Dörner

Published Sep 5, 2013• 34 citations
Publisher

Abstract

We simultaneously measured the momentum transferred to a free-floating molecular double slit and the momentum change of the atom scattering from it. Our experimental results are compared to quantum mechanical and semiclassical models. The results reveal that a classical description of the slits, which was used by Einstein in his debate with Bohr, provides a surprisingly good description of the experimental results, even for a microscopic system, if momentum transfer is not ascribed to a specific pathway but shared coherently and simultaneously between both.

DOI
10.1103/physrevlett.111.103201

Related papers

Einstein–Bohr recoiling double-slit gedanken experiment performed at the molecular level

X.-J. Liu, Quan Miao, Faris Gel’mukhanov +6 more

Double-slit experiments illustrate proof for wave–particle complementarity. The essence of Einstein–Bohr's debate about wave–particle duality was whether the momentum transfer between a particle and a recoiling slit could mark the path, thus destroying the interference. We realized this recoiling double-slit gedanken experiment by resonant X-ray photoemission from molecular oxygen for geometries near equilibrium (coupled slits) and in a dissociative state far away from equilibrium (decoupled slits). Interference is observed in the former case, while the electron momentum transfer quenches the interference in the latter case.

Journal of Physics Conference Series•Sep 7, 2015•1 citation

Molecular ‘double-slit’ experiment

Physicists at the SOLEIL synchrotron in France are the closest yet to realizing a thought experiment proposed in 1927 by Albert Einstein that is a variation of the classic double-slit experiment. Using two excited atoms instead of two slits, the researchers show that if one can determine which atom has emitted an electron, the interference pattern will vanish.

Physics World•Jan 1, 2015•0 citations

Double-slit experiment in momentum space

Igor P Ivanov, D. Seipt, A. Surzhykov +1 more

Young's classic double-slit experiment demonstrates the reality of interference when waves and particles travel simultaneously along two different spatial paths. Here, we propose a double-slit experiment in momentum space, realized in the free-space elastic scattering of vortex electrons. We show that this process proceeds along two paths in momentum space, which are well localized and well separated from each other. For such vortex beams, the (plane-wave) amplitudes along the two paths acquire adjustable phase shifts and produce interference fringes in the final angular distribution. We argue that this experiment can be realized with the present-day technology. We show that it gives experimental access to the Coulomb phase, a quantity which plays an important role in all charged particle scattering but which usual scattering experiments are insensitive to.

arXiv:1606.04732•Europhysics Letters (EPL)•Aug 1, 2016•14 citations

Fringe visibility and which-way information in Young's double-slit experiments with light scattered from single atoms

Hanzhen Lin, Yu‐Kun Lu, Vitaly Fedoseev +3 more

Young's double slit experiment has often been used to illustrate the concept of complementarity in quantum mechanics. If information can in principle be obtained about the path of the photon, then the visibility of the interference fringes is reduced or even destroyed. This Gedanken experiment discussed by Bohr and Einstein can be realized when the slit is replaced by individual atoms sensitive to the transferred recoil momentum of a photon which "passes through the slit". Early pioneering experiments were done with trapped ions and atom pairs created via photo-dissociation. Recently, it became possible to perform interference experiments with single neutral atoms cooled to the absolute ground state of a harmonic oscillator potential. The slits are now single atoms representing a two-level system, and the excitation in the harmonic oscillator potential is the which-way marker. In this note, we analyze and generalize two recent experiments performed with single atoms and emphasize the different ways they record which-way information.

arXiv:2507.19801•Physical Review A•Dec 3, 2025•1 citation

Tunable Einstein-Bohr Recoiling-Slit Gedankenexperiment at the Quantum Limit

Yu-Chen Zhang, Haowen Cheng, Zhao-Qiu Zengxu +7 more

In 1927, during the fifth Solvay Conference, Einstein and Bohr described a double-slit interferometer with a "movable slit" that can detect the momentum recoil of one photon. Their debate centered on this Gedankenexperiment has provided profound insights into the central concepts of quantum mechanics. Despite many efforts to reproduce this conceptual experiment, a linear-optical version with a movable, quantum-limited slit and tunable momentum width remained challenging. Here, we report a realization of the Einstein-Bohr interferometer using a single atom in an optical tweezer, which is cooled to the motional ground state in three dimensions such that its momentum uncertainty is comparable to that of a single photon. We design an interferometric configuration where the single atom serves as an ultralight, quantum-limit beam splitter that is momentum entangled with the input photon. By varying the trap depth of the optical tweezer, we dynamically tune the atom's intrinsic momentum uncertainty, thus enabling the observation of a gradual shift in the visibility of single-photon interference. The interferometer also allows us to distinguish the classical noise caused by atom heating from the quantum-limited noise due to the momentum transfer, illustrating a quantum-to-classical transition.

arXiv:2410.10664•Physical Review Letters•Oct 17, 2025•14 citations

Complementarity and the Nature of Uncertainty Relations in Einstein–Bohr Recoiling Slit Experiment

Shogo Tanimura

A model of the Einstein–Bohr recoiling slit experiment is formulated in a fully quantum theoretical setting. In this model, the state and dynamics of a movable wall that has two slits in it, as well as the state of a particle incoming to the two slits, are described by quantum mechanics. Using this model, we analyzed complementarity between exhibiting an interference pattern and distinguishing the particle path. Comparing the Kennard–Robertson type and the Ozawa-type uncertainty relations, we conclude that the uncertainty relation involved in the double-slit experiment is not the Ozawa-type uncertainty relation but the Kennard-type uncertainty relation of the position and the momentum of the double-slit wall. A possible experiment to test the complementarity relation is suggested. It is also argued that various phenomena which occur at the interface of a quantum system and a classical system, including distinguishability, interference, decoherence, quantum eraser, and weak value, can be understood as aspects of entanglement. Quanta 2015; 4: 1–9.

arXiv:quant-ph/0703118•Quanta•Jul 15, 2015•6 citations
We simultaneously measured the momentum transferred to a free-floating molecular double slit and the momentum change of the atom scattering from it. Our experimental results are compared to quantum mechanical and semiclassical models. The results reveal that a classical description of the slits, which was used by Einstein in his debate with Bohr, provides a surprisingly good description of the experimental results, even for a microscopic system, if momentum transfer is not ascribed to a specific pathway but shared coherently and simultaneously between both.
Double-slit experiments illustrate proof for wave–particle complementarity. The essence of Einstein–Bohr's debate about wave–particle duality was whether the momentum transfer between a particle and a recoiling slit could mark the path, thus destroying the interference. We realized this recoiling double-slit gedanken experiment by resonant X-ray photoemission from molecular oxygen for geometries near equilibrium (coupled slits) and in a dissociative state far away from equilibrium (decoupled slits). Interference is observed in the former case, while the electron momentum transfer quenches the interference in the latter case.
Young's classic double-slit experiment demonstrates the reality of interference when waves and particles travel simultaneously along two different spatial paths. Here, we propose a double-slit experiment in momentum space, realized in the free-space elastic scattering of vortex electrons. We show that this process proceeds along two paths in momentum space, which are well localized and well separated from each other. For such vortex beams, the (plane-wave) amplitudes along the two paths acquire adjustable phase shifts and produce interference fringes in the final angular distribution. We argue that this experiment can be realized with the present-day technology. We show that it gives experimental access to the Coulomb phase, a quantity which plays an important role in all charged particle scattering but which usual scattering experiments are insensitive to.
Young's double slit experiment has often been used to illustrate the concept of complementarity in quantum mechanics. If information can in principle be obtained about the path of the photon, then the visibility of the interference fringes is reduced or even destroyed. This Gedanken experiment discussed by Bohr and Einstein can be realized when the slit is replaced by individual atoms sensitive to the transferred recoil momentum of a photon which "passes through the slit". Early pioneering experiments were done with trapped ions and atom pairs created via photo-dissociation. Recently, it became possible to perform interference experiments with single neutral atoms cooled to the absolute ground state of a harmonic oscillator potential. The slits are now single atoms representing a two-level system, and the excitation in the harmonic oscillator potential is the which-way marker. In this note, we analyze and generalize two recent experiments performed with single atoms and emphasize the different ways they record which-way information.
In 1927, during the fifth Solvay Conference, Einstein and Bohr described a double-slit interferometer with a "movable slit" that can detect the momentum recoil of one photon. Their debate centered on this Gedankenexperiment has provided profound insights into the central concepts of quantum mechanics. Despite many efforts to reproduce this conceptual experiment, a linear-optical version with a movable, quantum-limited slit and tunable momentum width remained challenging. Here, we report a realization of the Einstein-Bohr interferometer using a single atom in an optical tweezer, which is cooled to the motional ground state in three dimensions such that its momentum uncertainty is comparable to that of a single photon. We design an interferometric configuration where the single atom serves as an ultralight, quantum-limit beam splitter that is momentum entangled with the input photon. By varying the trap depth of the optical tweezer, we dynamically tune the atom's intrinsic momentum uncertainty, thus enabling the observation of a gradual shift in the visibility of single-photon interference. The interferometer also allows us to distinguish the classical noise caused by atom heating from the quantum-limited noise due to the momentum transfer, illustrating a quantum-to-classical transition.
A model of the Einstein–Bohr recoiling slit experiment is formulated in a fully quantum theoretical setting. In this model, the state and dynamics of a movable wall that has two slits in it, as well as the state of a particle incoming to the two slits, are described by quantum mechanics. Using this model, we analyzed complementarity between exhibiting an interference pattern and distinguishing the particle path. Comparing the Kennard–Robertson type and the Ozawa-type uncertainty relations, we conclude that the uncertainty relation involved in the double-slit experiment is not the Ozawa-type uncertainty relation but the Kennard-type uncertainty relation of the position and the momentum of the double-slit wall. A possible experiment to test the complementarity relation is suggested. It is also argued that various phenomena which occur at the interface of a quantum system and a classical system, including distinguishability, interference, decoherence, quantum eraser, and weak value, can be understood as aspects of entanglement. Quanta 2015; 4: 1–9.