Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Schrodinger’s Register: Foundational Issues and Physical Realization

Stephen Pink, Stanley Martens

Published Sep 25, 2011• 0 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

This work-in-progress paper consists of four points which relate to the foundations and physical realization of quantum computing. The first point is that the qubit cannot be taken as the basic unit for quantum computing, because not every superposition of bit-strings of length n can be factored into a string of n-qubits. The second point is that the “No-cloning” theorem does not apply to the copying of one quantum register into another register, because the mathematical representation of this copying is the identity operator, which is manifestly linear. The third point is that quantum parallelism is not destroyed only by environmental decoherence. There are two other forms of decoherence, which we call measurement decoherence and internal decoherence, that can also destroy quantum parallelism. The fourth point is that processing the contents of a quantum register “one qubit at a time” destroys entanglement. Keywords-qubit; entanglement; decoherence; no-cloning theorem; quantum register.

Related papers

UNDAMENTALS OF INFORMATION AND COMPUTATION IN THE REALM OF THE QUANTA

John Henry Reina

Information is a physical. Physical systems register and process information. These facts generated enormus interest in the development of novel quantum tecnologies, especially because the construction of smaller electronic devices ultimately leads to a consideration of quantum mechanical effects in electronic and computer desingns. The notion of the classical bit of information theory was formally pushed into the realm of the quanta with the introduction of the quantum bit or qubit, in the seminal works of Deutsch (Deutsch, 1985) and Shor (Shor, 1994). They demostrated that, indeed, controlled multipartite qubit interference effects could provide the means for a radical new way of computing, allowing the computation of many intractable computational problems, such as the factoring of large number or exact simulation of large quantum systems. The field of experimental and theoretical research in quantum information and computation has emerged as very important player in the understanding of quantum phenomena the both the basic and technological levels. This has attracted the attention of numerous researchers with backgrounds ranging from computer science, mathematics and engineerin, to the physical sciences, and we now have an interdisciplinary field where great efforts are being made in order to build devices that allow the progressing of information at a quantum level. A concise introduction to the field of quantum information and quantum computation is presented. This stars with the bassic definitions of bits, quantum registers, through to the universal gate-set for building the universal quantum computer, from a quantum network model of computation. The work shows how two-qubit gates suffice for quantum computation, emphasing the power of the quantum circuit representation for entagling and disentagling quantum states. This leads to the “no-cloning theorem”, which leads us to many interesting applications, such as quantum cryptography. Two alternative approaches or performing quantum computation are also described i) the one-way or measurement based quantum computer method, and ii) holonomic or geometric quantum computation. Following this, quantum entaglement quantification is highlighted, particulary its usefulness as a communication resource, in order to describe some of its most celebrated practical applications to date: quantum teleportation, cryptography, dens coding, and data compression. Deutsch’s concept of quantum parallelism is enphasized in order to gain insight into the potential for efficiently solving certain classically intratable algorithms. A subject central to the field of QIP- quantum decoherence- is then introduced.. Possible ways to overcome it, in particular quantum error correction, are discussed. A descriptios of some of the currently available hardware of the practical implementation of quantum computation is provided with a discussion of the main physical quantum bits that are currently employed (or proposed) for a such a purpose.

Revista de la Academia Colombiana de Ciencias Exactas Físicas y Naturales•Dec 2, 2023•1 citation

Quantum Computing for Security Professionals

Timur Qader

This chapter connects key quantum mechanics principles to quantum computing. It begins by contrasting classical computing's binary logic with quantum computing's use of superposition, entanglement, and interference. It explains how qubits differ from bits by existing in multiple states simultaneously, allowing parallel computation. The chapter introduces quantum gates (Pauli-X, CNOT) and their functions in manipulating qubit states. It describes quantum circuits, measurement, and the collapse of qubit states upon observation. Key mathematical tools, such as Dirac notation and complex vector spaces, are introduced to support quantum operations. The no-cloning theorem is noted for its role in quantum information integrity. Finally, the chapter outlines current challenges in coherence, error correction, and decoherence in quantum systems. It closes by emphasizing how these principles form the operational basis for quantum algorithms, providing the foundation for later discussions on security applications and quantum resilience.

CRC Press eBooks•Dec 16, 2025•0 citations

The Quantum Computing Delusion and the Twelve Barriers: Why Practical Quantum Computers Are Fundamentally Impossible

Damir Duvnjak

This paper argues that quantum computing is not merely "5-10 years away" but fundamentally impossible. It identifies three foundational lies: (1) qubits can be identical (no two qubits are physically identical), (2) superposition represents actual simultaneous states (it is epistemic uncertainty), (3) entanglement enables faster-than-classical computation (it is mere correlation). It then presents twelve fatal barriers that make practical quantum computers impossible: no-cloning theorem prevents error correction at scale, Bell violations prove only correlation not computation, calibration overhead scales exponentially, quantum volume metrics are dishonest marketing, thermodynamic costs are astronomical, hybrid algorithms are classical with quantum noise, limited connectivity destroys parallelism, decoherence-free subspaces are too small, reproducibility crisis signals fraud, economic sunk costs create Ponzi dynamics, treating the wavefunction as ontological is a category error, and the measurement bottleneck violates information theory (Shannon). Each barrier is individually fatal. Together they form an impenetrable wall. The paper concludes that quantum computing is a billion-dollar delusion and recommends redirecting funding to classical alternatives that actually work

•Apr 19, 2026•0 citations

A Review On Quantum Technologies: From Fundamentals To Applications

Sudheshwar Singh

In this section we provide a broad overview of the basic principles of quantum mechanics and how they enable modern quantum technologies. The starting point is the concept of superposition, which allows quantum systems to be in multiple states at the same time and forms the basis of quantum computation using qubits and parallel processing of information. The conversation then turns to quantum entanglement, a non-classical effect that creates strong correlations between particles, and has applications in secure communication and quantum teleportation. Also mentioned is the quantum coherence, which preserves phase relations between quantum states and makes it possible for quantum systems to function correctly. But it is also emphasized that quantum coherence is fragile to environmental perturbations. This chapter also covers quantum measurement, taking into account the probabilistic nature of quantum mechanics, and how the act of observation results in the collapse of a quantum state to a definite outcome. These principles together constitute the theoretical basis of quantum computing, where quantum gates and algorithms and qubits take advantage of superposition, entanglement and interference to offer computational benefits over classical systems. The most important algorithms like Shor’s and Grover’s algorithms that demonstrate a considerable speed-up in solving the problem are discussed along with different models of quantum computing, such as gate, adiabatic and measurement-based models. Furthermore, the section reviews some physical realizations of quantum systems, such as superconducting qubits, trapped ions, photonic systems and topological qubits, with their advantages and difficulties. Overall, this discussion shows how the basic principles of quantum mechanics are the foundation for the development of advanced quantum technologies, while also dealing with the practical difficulties that arise in their implementation.

Nanotechnology Perceptions•Nov 10, 2014•0 citations

A REPORT ON QUANTUM COMPUTING

Achintya A. Paradkar

Today's computers work on bits that exist as either 0 or 1. Quantum computers aren't limited to two states; they encode information as quantum bits, or qubits, which can exist in superposition. Qubits represent atoms, ions, photons or electrons and their respective control devices that are working together to act as computer memory and a processor. Because a quantum computer can contain these multiple states simultaneously, it has the potential to be millions of times more powerful than today's most powerful supercomputers. A processor that can use registers of qubits will be able to perform calculations using all the possible values of the input registers simultaneously. This superposition causes a phenomenon called quantum parallelism, and is the motivating force behind the research being carried out in quantum computing. Due to technical obstacles, till date, a quantum computer has not yet been realized. But the concepts and ideas of quantum computing has been demonstrated using various methods like NMR, Ion Trap, Quantum Dot, Optical Methods, etc. A quantum computer manipulates qubits by executing a series of quantum gates, each a unitary transformation acting on a single qubit or pair of qubits. In applying these gates in succession, a quantum computer can perform a complicated unitary transformation to a set of qubits in some initial state. The qubits can then be measured, with this measurement serving as the final computational result. Research must devise a way to maintain decoherence and other potential sources of error at an acceptable level. Probably the most important idea in this field is the application of error correction in phase coherence as a means to extract information and reduce error in a quantum system without actually measuring that system. Thereby, quantum computers will emerge as the superior computational devices and perhaps one day make today's modern computer obsolete.

International Journal of Students Research in Technology & Management•Sep 26, 2015•1 citation

Prospects and challenges for the realization of quantum computers

Eric Donkor, Patrick D. Kumavor

A quantum computer is an information processing systems that utilizes invertible logic elements to perform reversible logic operations. It can also perform irreversible logic operations. Thus, in principle, it can compute the information transformation rule of any physical system for which the rules are known. A quantum computer can be designed to perform parallel computation on a massive scale, and therefore can have fast execution time. The basic structure of a quantum computer includes 1) a quantum register, or a configuration of quantum-mechanical energy states to store quantum bits (qubits) of information, 2) a quantum processor designed to induce quantum mechanical interactions between any arbitrary pair of qubits to perform a specified logic operations. 3) a quantum bus or network for transferring qubits from the registers to the processor and vice versa, and 4) a physical mechanisms for non-destructive measurements on the qubits. Quantum mechanical systems with the potential for realizing quantum computers include ion-trap quantum computers, cavity quantum electrodynamics quantum computers, photon-trap quantum computers, nuclear magnetic resonance quantum computers, and superconducting quantum computers. Decoherence [1 ,2] possesses the greatest challenge to the practical realization of quantum computers, because it causes the collapse of the quantum superposition states that contain the vital results of qubit manipulations. Decoherence processes are measurement-induced, noise-induced, and environment-induced [3] . Schemes to correct or circumvent the detrimental effects of decoherence in quantum processors fall into active error-correction schemes, and passive error-correction schemes [4]. Active error-correction schemes are designed to detect and correct for errors during computation. Algorithmic fault-tolerant computing [5, 6] is the most promising active-error correction scheme. In fault-tolerant computing, ancillary qubits are encoded into data blocks of the quantum registers. They are then used to detect errors. Once detected appropriate error-correction algorithms are then employed to rectify the errors. The implementation of fault-tolerant quantum computing has been hampered by the lack of practical universal set of quantum gates that can process an encoded data without propagating or introducing additional errors. Passive-error correction schemes [7] attempt to finding Hilbert subspaces that are intrinsically free of decoherence effects [8]. The key to quantum computing in such a decoherence-free subspace is the identification of mechanisms that can effect quantum mechanical interactions between the decoherence-free states without taking the system out of the decoherence-free environment. The challenge is to identify and employ physical processes that can achieve these goals.

Proceedings of SPIE, the International Society for Optical Engineering/Proceedings of SPIE•Jul 31, 2002•2 citations
This work-in-progress paper consists of four points which relate to the foundations and physical realization of quantum computing. The first point is that the qubit cannot be taken as the basic unit for quantum computing, because not every superposition of bit-strings of length n can be factored into a string of n-qubits. The second point is that the “No-cloning” theorem does not apply to the copying of one quantum register into another register, because the mathematical representation of this copying is the identity operator, which is manifestly linear. The third point is that quantum parallelism is not destroyed only by environmental decoherence. There are two other forms of decoherence, which we call measurement decoherence and internal decoherence, that can also destroy quantum parallelism. The fourth point is that processing the contents of a quantum register “one qubit at a time” destroys entanglement. Keywords-qubit; entanglement; decoherence; no-cloning theorem; quantum register.
Information is a physical. Physical systems register and process information. These facts generated enormus interest in the development of novel quantum tecnologies, especially because the construction of smaller electronic devices ultimately leads to a consideration of quantum mechanical effects in electronic and computer desingns. The notion of the classical bit of information theory was formally pushed into the realm of the quanta with the introduction of the quantum bit or qubit, in the seminal works of Deutsch (Deutsch, 1985) and Shor (Shor, 1994). They demostrated that, indeed, controlled multipartite qubit interference effects could provide the means for a radical new way of computing, allowing the computation of many intractable computational problems, such as the factoring of large number or exact simulation of large quantum systems. The field of experimental and theoretical research in quantum information and computation has emerged as very important player in the understanding of quantum phenomena the both the basic and technological levels. This has attracted the attention of numerous researchers with backgrounds ranging from computer science, mathematics and engineerin, to the physical sciences, and we now have an interdisciplinary field where great efforts are being made in order to build devices that allow the progressing of information at a quantum level. A concise introduction to the field of quantum information and quantum computation is presented. This stars with the bassic definitions of bits, quantum registers, through to the universal gate-set for building the universal quantum computer, from a quantum network model of computation. The work shows how two-qubit gates suffice for quantum computation, emphasing the power of the quantum circuit representation for entagling and disentagling quantum states. This leads to the “no-cloning theorem”, which leads us to many interesting applications, such as quantum cryptography. Two alternative approaches or performing quantum computation are also described i) the one-way or measurement based quantum computer method, and ii) holonomic or geometric quantum computation. Following this, quantum entaglement quantification is highlighted, particulary its usefulness as a communication resource, in order to describe some of its most celebrated practical applications to date: quantum teleportation, cryptography, dens coding, and data compression. Deutsch’s concept of quantum parallelism is enphasized in order to gain insight into the potential for efficiently solving certain classically intratable algorithms. A subject central to the field of QIP- quantum decoherence- is then introduced.. Possible ways to overcome it, in particular quantum error correction, are discussed. A descriptios of some of the currently available hardware of the practical implementation of quantum computation is provided with a discussion of the main physical quantum bits that are currently employed (or proposed) for a such a purpose.
This chapter connects key quantum mechanics principles to quantum computing. It begins by contrasting classical computing's binary logic with quantum computing's use of superposition, entanglement, and interference. It explains how qubits differ from bits by existing in multiple states simultaneously, allowing parallel computation. The chapter introduces quantum gates (Pauli-X, CNOT) and their functions in manipulating qubit states. It describes quantum circuits, measurement, and the collapse of qubit states upon observation. Key mathematical tools, such as Dirac notation and complex vector spaces, are introduced to support quantum operations. The no-cloning theorem is noted for its role in quantum information integrity. Finally, the chapter outlines current challenges in coherence, error correction, and decoherence in quantum systems. It closes by emphasizing how these principles form the operational basis for quantum algorithms, providing the foundation for later discussions on security applications and quantum resilience.
This paper argues that quantum computing is not merely "5-10 years away" but fundamentally impossible. It identifies three foundational lies: (1) qubits can be identical (no two qubits are physically identical), (2) superposition represents actual simultaneous states (it is epistemic uncertainty), (3) entanglement enables faster-than-classical computation (it is mere correlation). It then presents twelve fatal barriers that make practical quantum computers impossible: no-cloning theorem prevents error correction at scale, Bell violations prove only correlation not computation, calibration overhead scales exponentially, quantum volume metrics are dishonest marketing, thermodynamic costs are astronomical, hybrid algorithms are classical with quantum noise, limited connectivity destroys parallelism, decoherence-free subspaces are too small, reproducibility crisis signals fraud, economic sunk costs create Ponzi dynamics, treating the wavefunction as ontological is a category error, and the measurement bottleneck violates information theory (Shannon). Each barrier is individually fatal. Together they form an impenetrable wall. The paper concludes that quantum computing is a billion-dollar delusion and recommends redirecting funding to classical alternatives that actually work
In this section we provide a broad overview of the basic principles of quantum mechanics and how they enable modern quantum technologies. The starting point is the concept of superposition, which allows quantum systems to be in multiple states at the same time and forms the basis of quantum computation using qubits and parallel processing of information. The conversation then turns to quantum entanglement, a non-classical effect that creates strong correlations between particles, and has applications in secure communication and quantum teleportation. Also mentioned is the quantum coherence, which preserves phase relations between quantum states and makes it possible for quantum systems to function correctly. But it is also emphasized that quantum coherence is fragile to environmental perturbations. This chapter also covers quantum measurement, taking into account the probabilistic nature of quantum mechanics, and how the act of observation results in the collapse of a quantum state to a definite outcome. These principles together constitute the theoretical basis of quantum computing, where quantum gates and algorithms and qubits take advantage of superposition, entanglement and interference to offer computational benefits over classical systems. The most important algorithms like Shor’s and Grover’s algorithms that demonstrate a considerable speed-up in solving the problem are discussed along with different models of quantum computing, such as gate, adiabatic and measurement-based models. Furthermore, the section reviews some physical realizations of quantum systems, such as superconducting qubits, trapped ions, photonic systems and topological qubits, with their advantages and difficulties. Overall, this discussion shows how the basic principles of quantum mechanics are the foundation for the development of advanced quantum technologies, while also dealing with the practical difficulties that arise in their implementation.
Today's computers work on bits that exist as either 0 or 1. Quantum computers aren't limited to two states; they encode information as quantum bits, or qubits, which can exist in superposition. Qubits represent atoms, ions, photons or electrons and their respective control devices that are working together to act as computer memory and a processor. Because a quantum computer can contain these multiple states simultaneously, it has the potential to be millions of times more powerful than today's most powerful supercomputers. A processor that can use registers of qubits will be able to perform calculations using all the possible values of the input registers simultaneously. This superposition causes a phenomenon called quantum parallelism, and is the motivating force behind the research being carried out in quantum computing. Due to technical obstacles, till date, a quantum computer has not yet been realized. But the concepts and ideas of quantum computing has been demonstrated using various methods like NMR, Ion Trap, Quantum Dot, Optical Methods, etc. A quantum computer manipulates qubits by executing a series of quantum gates, each a unitary transformation acting on a single qubit or pair of qubits. In applying these gates in succession, a quantum computer can perform a complicated unitary transformation to a set of qubits in some initial state. The qubits can then be measured, with this measurement serving as the final computational result. Research must devise a way to maintain decoherence and other potential sources of error at an acceptable level. Probably the most important idea in this field is the application of error correction in phase coherence as a means to extract information and reduce error in a quantum system without actually measuring that system. Thereby, quantum computers will emerge as the superior computational devices and perhaps one day make today's modern computer obsolete.
A quantum computer is an information processing systems that utilizes invertible logic elements to perform reversible logic operations. It can also perform irreversible logic operations. Thus, in principle, it can compute the information transformation rule of any physical system for which the rules are known. A quantum computer can be designed to perform parallel computation on a massive scale, and therefore can have fast execution time. The basic structure of a quantum computer includes 1) a quantum register, or a configuration of quantum-mechanical energy states to store quantum bits (qubits) of information, 2) a quantum processor designed to induce quantum mechanical interactions between any arbitrary pair of qubits to perform a specified logic operations. 3) a quantum bus or network for transferring qubits from the registers to the processor and vice versa, and 4) a physical mechanisms for non-destructive measurements on the qubits. Quantum mechanical systems with the potential for realizing quantum computers include ion-trap quantum computers, cavity quantum electrodynamics quantum computers, photon-trap quantum computers, nuclear magnetic resonance quantum computers, and superconducting quantum computers. Decoherence [1 ,2] possesses the greatest challenge to the practical realization of quantum computers, because it causes the collapse of the quantum superposition states that contain the vital results of qubit manipulations. Decoherence processes are measurement-induced, noise-induced, and environment-induced [3] . Schemes to correct or circumvent the detrimental effects of decoherence in quantum processors fall into active error-correction schemes, and passive error-correction schemes [4]. Active error-correction schemes are designed to detect and correct for errors during computation. Algorithmic fault-tolerant computing [5, 6] is the most promising active-error correction scheme. In fault-tolerant computing, ancillary qubits are encoded into data blocks of the quantum registers. They are then used to detect errors. Once detected appropriate error-correction algorithms are then employed to rectify the errors. The implementation of fault-tolerant quantum computing has been hampered by the lack of practical universal set of quantum gates that can process an encoded data without propagating or introducing additional errors. Passive-error correction schemes [7] attempt to finding Hilbert subspaces that are intrinsically free of decoherence effects [8]. The key to quantum computing in such a decoherence-free subspace is the identification of mechanisms that can effect quantum mechanical interactions between the decoherence-free states without taking the system out of the decoherence-free environment. The challenge is to identify and employ physical processes that can achieve these goals.