Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Science Advances

Experimental nonlocal and surreal Bohmian trajectories

Dylan H. Mahler, Lee A. Rozema, Kent Bonsma-Fisher, L. Vermeyden, Kevin J. Resch, Howard M. Wiseman, Aephraim M. Steinberg

Published Feb 5, 2016• 137 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Weak measurement allows one to empirically determine a set of average trajectories for an ensemble of quantum particles. However, when two particles are entangled, the trajectories of the first particle can depend nonlocally on the position of the second particle. Moreover, the theory describing these trajectories, called Bohmian mechanics, predicts trajectories that were at first deemed "surreal" when the second particle is used to probe the position of the first particle. We entangle two photons and determine a set of Bohmian trajectories for one of them using weak measurements and postselection. We show that the trajectories seem surreal only if one ignores their manifest nonlocality.

DOI
10.1126/sciadv.1501466

Related papers

Measuring Bohm Trajectories of Entangled Photons

Dylan H. Mahler, Lee A. Rozema, Kent Bonsma-Fisher +5 more

We measure, using weak measurement, the Bohmian trajectories of one photon that is part of an entangled pair. Our results shed light on the nonlocality of the Bohm model, as well as its so-called “surrealism.”

•Jan 1, 2014•3 citations

Experimental nonlocal and surreal Bohmian trajectories

Dylan H. Mahler, Lee A. Rozema, Kent Bonsma-Fisher +4 more

Researchers reconstruct trajectories of two entangled photons showing the nonlocal and “surreal” nature of the trajectories in Bohmian mechanics.

Science Advances•Feb 19, 2016•24 citations

Measurements of Bohmian Trajectories

Florian Huber, Carlotta Versmold, Jan Dziewior +5 more

Standard quantum mechanics famously disallows to simultaneously measure particle position and momentum with arbitrary precision. In contrast, Bohmian mechanics, a hidden-variable interpretation, at the same time ascribes reality to the positions and momenta of quantum particles at the cost of a nonlocal ontology [1]. It thus allows to conceive of definite particle trajectories, while being fully compatible with the standard theory in all empirical predictions. To record such trajectories [2] we consider two optical settings using weak measurements in order to investigate different features of particle propagation in the Bohmian picture.

Conference on Lasers and Electro-Optics Europe & European Quantum Electronics Conference (CLEO/Europe-EQEC)•Jun 26, 2023•0 citations

Proposal to Observe the Nonlocality of Bohmian Trajectories with Entangled Photons

Boris Braverman, Christoph Simon

Bohmian mechanics reproduces all statistical predictions of quantum mechanics, which ensures that entanglement cannot be used for superluminal signaling. However, individual Bohmian particles can experience superluminal influences. We propose to illustrate this point using a double double-slit setup with path-entangled photons. The Bohmian velocity field for one of the photons can be measured using a recently demonstrated weak-measurement technique. The found velocities strongly depend on the value of a phase shift that is applied to the other photon, potentially at spacelike separation.

arXiv:1207.2794•Physical Review Letters•Feb 7, 2013•52 citations

The (un)detectability of trajectories in pilot-wave theory

Johannes Fankhauser

Abstract Pilot wave theory endows particles with de nite positions at all times governed by deterministic dynamics. However, individual particle trajectories are generically undetectable by experiment. This idea might seem to be contested in light of two proposals: (1) So-called ‘weak velocity measurements’, allegedly detecting Bohmian trajectories by weakly probing a quantum system without essentially disturbing it, and (2) the so-called ‘surrealistic’ trajectories experiment which supposedly establishes a conflict between the ‘actual’ position of a particle and its position derived from pilot wave theory. Although both attempts shed light on the nature of Bohmian particles, neither constitute empirical or theoretical evidence in favour or against pilot wave theory. Both instances admit a straightforward standard quantum mechanical interpretation compatible with the predictions of Bohmian theories. It is concluded that the puzzles arise from the absence of a coherent account of what quantum mechanical measurements signify.

arXiv:2503.07694•Apr 1, 2025•0 citations

Experimental nonlocal steering of Bohmian trajectories

Ya Xiao, Yaron Kedem, Jin‐Shi Xu +2 more

Interpretations of quantum mechanics (QM), or proposals for underlying theories, that attempt to present a definite realist picture, such as Bohmian mechanics, require strong non-local effects. Naively, these effects would violate causality and contradict special relativity. However if the theory agrees with QM the violation cannot be observed directly. Here, we demonstrate experimentally such an effect: we steer the velocity and trajectory of a Bohmian particle using a remote measurement. We use a pair of photons and entangle the spatial transverse position of one with the polarization of the other. The first photon is sent to a double-slit-like apparatus, where its trajectory is measured using the technique of Weak Measurements. The other photon is projected to a linear polarization state. The choice of polarization state, and the result, steer the first photon in the most intuitive sense of the word. The effect is indeed shown to be dramatic, while being easy to visualize. We discuss its strength and what are the conditions for it to occur.

arXiv:1706.05757•Optics Express•Jun 16, 2017•28 citations
Weak measurement allows one to empirically determine a set of average trajectories for an ensemble of quantum particles. However, when two particles are entangled, the trajectories of the first particle can depend nonlocally on the position of the second particle. Moreover, the theory describing these trajectories, called Bohmian mechanics, predicts trajectories that were at first deemed "surreal" when the second particle is used to probe the position of the first particle. We entangle two photons and determine a set of Bohmian trajectories for one of them using weak measurements and postselection. We show that the trajectories seem surreal only if one ignores their manifest nonlocality.
Standard quantum mechanics famously disallows to simultaneously measure particle position and momentum with arbitrary precision. In contrast, Bohmian mechanics, a hidden-variable interpretation, at the same time ascribes reality to the positions and momenta of quantum particles at the cost of a nonlocal ontology [1]. It thus allows to conceive of definite particle trajectories, while being fully compatible with the standard theory in all empirical predictions. To record such trajectories [2] we consider two optical settings using weak measurements in order to investigate different features of particle propagation in the Bohmian picture.
Bohmian mechanics reproduces all statistical predictions of quantum mechanics, which ensures that entanglement cannot be used for superluminal signaling. However, individual Bohmian particles can experience superluminal influences. We propose to illustrate this point using a double double-slit setup with path-entangled photons. The Bohmian velocity field for one of the photons can be measured using a recently demonstrated weak-measurement technique. The found velocities strongly depend on the value of a phase shift that is applied to the other photon, potentially at spacelike separation.
Abstract Pilot wave theory endows particles with de nite positions at all times governed by deterministic dynamics. However, individual particle trajectories are generically undetectable by experiment. This idea might seem to be contested in light of two proposals: (1) So-called ‘weak velocity measurements’, allegedly detecting Bohmian trajectories by weakly probing a quantum system without essentially disturbing it, and (2) the so-called ‘surrealistic’ trajectories experiment which supposedly establishes a conflict between the ‘actual’ position of a particle and its position derived from pilot wave theory. Although both attempts shed light on the nature of Bohmian particles, neither constitute empirical or theoretical evidence in favour or against pilot wave theory. Both instances admit a straightforward standard quantum mechanical interpretation compatible with the predictions of Bohmian theories. It is concluded that the puzzles arise from the absence of a coherent account of what quantum mechanical measurements signify.
Interpretations of quantum mechanics (QM), or proposals for underlying theories, that attempt to present a definite realist picture, such as Bohmian mechanics, require strong non-local effects. Naively, these effects would violate causality and contradict special relativity. However if the theory agrees with QM the violation cannot be observed directly. Here, we demonstrate experimentally such an effect: we steer the velocity and trajectory of a Bohmian particle using a remote measurement. We use a pair of photons and entangle the spatial transverse position of one with the polarization of the other. The first photon is sent to a double-slit-like apparatus, where its trajectory is measured using the technique of Weak Measurements. The other photon is projected to a linear polarization state. The choice of polarization state, and the result, steer the first photon in the most intuitive sense of the word. The effect is indeed shown to be dramatic, while being easy to visualize. We discuss its strength and what are the conditions for it to occur.