Atlantis studies in mathematical physics

Lecture 3: Axioms, States, Observables, Measurement, Difficulties

Gianfausto Dell’Antonio

Published Jan 1, 2015• 0 citations

Abstract

In “ Lecture 1: Elements of the History of Quantum Mechanics I” and “ Lecture 2: Elements of the History of Quantum Mechanics II” we have presented experimental results, theoretical analysis, models, analogies and insights that were accumulated for the description of physics at the scale of atoms. We described also the theoretical formulations that were developed in very few years and are the basis of a new theory for the dynamics of atomic systems: Quantum Mechanics.

DOI: 10.2991/978-94-6239-118-5_3

Related papers

Central concepts in classical mechanics

M. Kira, S. W. Koch

Historically, the scientific exploration of new phenomena has often been guided by systematic studies of observations, i.e., experimentally verifiable facts, which can be used as the basis to construct the underlying physical laws. As the apex of the investigations, one tries to identify the minimal set of fundamental assumptions – referred to as the axioms – needed to describe correctly the experimental observations. Even though the axioms form the basis to predict the system's behavior completely, they themselves have no rigorous derivation or interpretation. Thus, the axioms must be viewed as the elementary postulates that allow us to formulate a systematic description of the studied system based on well-defined logical reasoning. Even though it might seem unsatisfactory that axioms cannot be “derived,” one has to acknowledge the paramount power of well-postulated axioms to predict even the most exotic effects. As is well known, the theory of classical mechanics can be constructed using only the three Newtonian axioms. On this basis, an infinite variety of phenomena can be explained, ranging from the cyclic planetary motion all the way to the classical chaos. In this book, we are mainly interested in understanding how the axioms of classical and quantum mechanics can be applied to obtain a systematic description for the phenomena of interest. Especially, we want to understand how many-particle systems can be modeled, how quantum features of light emerge, and how these two aspects can be combined and utilized to explore new intriguing phenomena in semiconductor quantum optics.

Cambridge University Press eBooksNov 17, 20110 citations

1 On the Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics

L.D. Faddeev, L.A. Khalfin, I.V. Komarov

The modern physics is characterized by deeper and deeper penetration into the laws of the world of atoms and other minute particles of matter. These laws require not only new experimental techniques to be developed, but also new notions to formulate them. To describe atomic phenomena new methods that are completely diﬀerent from those used to investigate larger objects of our world are required. The new problem of description of atomic objects is of particular practical importance since the arising notions could be applied to other ﬁelds of knowledge. Therefore on the ground of the modern physics some questions of the philosophical character arise. We are going to consider them here.

CRC Press eBooksMay 21, 20040 citations

Logica Quanta II

Larry Lim Kheng Cheong

Logica Quanta II introduces the missing physical mechanism underlying discrete quantum outcomes: accumulated wave interference. Building on Logica Quanta I, which reframed modern physics as interacting waves rather than particles, this paper identifies history as the absent variable in standard quantum mechanics. While conventional formulations treat collapse as instantaneous and memoryless, many physical systems—from tunneling barriers to decohering environments—experience sustained wave–environment coupling over time. This work argues that interference is not merely instantaneous but accumulates, producing a form of wave stress analogous to material fatigue. When accumulated interference exceeds a stability threshold, collapse-like transitions occur naturally, without randomness, observers, or duality. The concept is developed at the level of physical logic rather than formal mathematics, positioning accumulated interference as a measurable state variable compatible with quantum mechanics, decoherence theory, and known experimental platforms. Logica Quanta II serves as the mechanistic bridge between conceptual reinterpretation (Logica Quanta I) and experimental falsification (Logica Quanta III).

Dec 21, 20250 citations

Quantum Measure Theory: A New Interpretation

Yousef Ghazi-Tabatabai

Quantum measure theory can be introduced as a histories based reformulation (and generalisation) of Copenhagen quantum mechanics in the image of classical stochastic theories. These classical models lend themselves to a simple interpretation in which a single history (a single element of the sample space) is deemed to be 'real'; we require only that this real history should not be ruled out by the dynamics, the axioms of which ensure that not all histories are precluded. However, applying this interpretation naively to quantum measure theory we can find experimentally realisable systems (notably the Peres-Kochen-Specker system) in which every history is ruled out by the dynamics, challenging us to formulate a deeper realist framework. Our first response is to hold on to our existing interpretative framework and attempt a revision of the dynamics that would reduce quantum measure theory to a classical dynamics. We explore this approach by examining the histories formulation of a stochastic-collapse model on a simple (discrete) null-lattice, concluding that the drawbacks of this approach outweigh the benefits. Our second response is to abandon our classically inspired interpretation in favour of Sorkin's 'co-events', a more general ontology that still allows for strict realism. In this case the 'potentially real' objects of the theory (the 'beables' in Bell's language) are not individual histories but truth valuation maps, or co-events. We develop & evaluate various co-event schemes that have been suggested to date, finally adopting the multiplicative scheme; the current working model of co-event theory and a promising interpretation of quantum measure theory, though still a work in progress. We conclude by exploring the expression of the dynamics & predictions in this new framework.

arXiv:0906.0294Jun 1, 200915 citations

The Essentials of Quantum Mechanics

Radhika Vathsan

How do we describe the state of a quantum mechanical physical system in a mathematically precise way? How do we ascribe physical properties to this system? How does the system evolve in time? How do its properties change when it interacts with another system or a force? How do we measure and determine its properties? These are the questions whose answers are encoded in the laws of quantum mechanics to be set down in this chapter. They have been inscribed in this form after nearly half a century of experimental observations, theoretical modeling, and intellectual gymnastics to tie up the two in a satisfactory and robust structure.

CRC Press eBooksJul 21, 20150 citations

Quantum mechanics

Valia Allori

This is a brief review of the history and development of quantum theories. Starting from the experimental findings and theoretical results which marked the crisis of the classical framework, I overview the rise of axiomatic quantum mechanics through matrix and wave mechanics. I discuss conceptual problems such as the measurement problem that led scientific realists to explore other, more satisfactory, quantum theories, as well as Bell’s theorem and quantum nonlocality, concluding with a short review of relativistic theories.

Routledge eBooksDec 16, 20250 citations