Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Single photons for quantum information processing

Michael Nock

Published Jan 1, 2006• 2 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

Single photons are the smallest excitation states of the elctromagnetic field. They can be experimentally created but there is no apparatus that performs this task with 100% efficiency. Many techniques and theorems of optical quantum information theory use single photons. In order to utilize them for information processing, it is reasonable to know if they had been successfully produced. In other words: One needs heralded single photons. How to achieve this, is the main result of this diploma thesis. The task has been to improve the efficiency of already existing single photon sources. An apparatus had to be found which postprocesses the output of such sources in order to either herald the photons or at least to improve the efficiency. This apparatus is explicitly allowed to use other optical sources, for example coherent states (laser). The situation has been formally represented by the assumption that single photon sources produce a mixture of vacuum and the single photon state. It is known that experimental set-ups also create higher photon contributions. These contributions are considered to be small in corresponding publications. For some cases they even seem to vanish at all. One can distinguish two regimes concerning the techniques which have been used in this work: linear and nonlinear optics. Linear optical tools, for example the beam splitter, do not absorb photons in the ideal case, but it is not easy to implement useful transformations by their means. Absorption and weak coupling are drawbacks which arise mainly in nonlinear optical media. This work shows that the interactions two-photon absorption and cross phase modulation can be used in schemes, which enable the heralding of single photons. Already there are some linear optical quantum gates which manipulate optical states by means of single photons. Photons do not interact with each other directly, in contrast to electrons for example. Therefore quantum gates which act on more than one mode are interesting. The effective interaction of these gates is not quitecomparable to unitary dynamics. Moreover, these gates do not function in each case. Measurements required in auxiliary modes yield different results for each single case and in order to obtain the desired effect the cases have to be selected according to the measurement results. It has been investigated, how such gates perform if they have statistical mixtures as a resource instead of perfect single-photon states. Yet, no improvement of the single-photon contribution has been accomplished by means of these apparatuses. Hereby it has not been disproved that it is possible to achieve this goal using other apparatuses and techniques of linear optics. Yet, it has been shown that an enhancement is possible but then a non-vanishing two-photon contribution is appended. One of the most basic quantum gates is the conditional sign flip. The optical 8 interaction cross phase modulation acts in quite the same way considering only single photons. This effect enables the heralding of single photons in the ideal case. Within this work it has been shown that a Mach-Zehnder interferometer, a cross phase modulating medium and a photo-detector can be employed for this purpose. One could use any source of light as input to the interferometer but a strong coherent state (laser) may be preferred for the purpose of enhancing the interaction. The absorption of two-photon states is another non-linear effect. Astonishingly this effect serves to generate a heralded single-photon state given two imperfect single-photon sources. First the photon adding tool is employed which consists of a beam splitter and a photo-detector. By means of that and the statistical mixtures of two single-photon sources one creates a mixture which contains vacuum, the single-photon state and additionally the two-photon Fock state. This mixture propagates through a Mach-Zehnder interferometer. The interferometer is adjusted such that it is transparent for incoming light. In addition to the interferometer alone a two-photon absorbing medium is placed in one of its arms. For this reason there is a chance that the two-photon contribution entering the interferometer is absorbed within this medium. We cannot exclude this unfortunate case. A detector is placed in one of the two output modes. The interferometer is adjusted such that the single photon state does not leave in the mode in which the detector is placed, but always in the other mode. The detector can only click if the two-photon state propagates through the interferometer and if it is not destroyed in the absorbing medium. If the detector then receives one photon it is obvious that another one must leave in the other mode. The whole phenomenon is very similar to the concept of null measurement. Although not a main result, it has been shown here that the so-called Hong-Ou-Mandel effect can be generalized. It has been proven that the beam splitter transforms Fock states with equal Fock number into superpositions of Fock numbers which are even in each mode. Another effect on special odd Fock states is conjectured.

Related papers

Generation of heralded single photons in pure quantum states

Peter J. Mosley, Mosley, Peter

Single photons - discrete wavepackets of light - are one of the most fundamental entities in physics. In recent years, the ability to consistently create and manipulate both single photons and pairs of photons has facilitated everything from tests of quantum theory to the implementation of quantum-enhanced precision measurements. These activities all fall within the scope of the rapidly-growing field of quantum information - the exploitation of the properties of quantum states (and specifically their capability to exist in superpositions) to accomplish tasks that would not be possible with classical objects. One stated goal of research in quantum information is to build a device consisting of a network of quantum logic gates that can evaluate quantum algorithms. The photonic implementation of individual logic gates has already been demonstrated. However, partly due to standard methods of preparing single photons, current schemes have severe limitations in terms of scaling up from a single logic gate to multiple concatenated operations. Until now it has not been proven that single photons can be generated in pure and indistinguishable quantum states, something upon which the successful operation of optical quantum logic gates relies. This thesis presents an experimental demonstration of simultaneous generation of almost identical single photons in highly pure states from two independent sources based on parametric downconversion. This is a process of photon pair generation during the passage of a light beam through a nonlinear crystal; one photon from the resulting pair is detected to herald the other. The work herein describes, refines, and implements a technique that minimises the strong quantum correlations usually present within each pair by spectral engineering of the source. This allows the heralded single photons to be in pure states, a property that is confirmed by observing a high-visibility two-photon interference effect without spectral filtering.

•Jan 1, 2007•17 citations

Hybrid quantum state and mode engineering of light

Luca Costanzo

In this thesis work, after a brief introduction of some basic concepts of quantum optics, some experimental techniques useful for the manipulation of quantum states of light are presented. In particular, I focused on two transformations operated at the single-photon level, like the addition and the subtraction of a single photon from a travelling light beam. Both these methods share a probabilistic approach, that is their implementation has a non unitary success probability. Anyway, the detection of an additional photon in an ancillary mode exactly announces when the operation has been actually implemented. That's why this type of implementation is generally called heralded. Starting from these basic operations, a way to implement some of their superpositions is then analyzed. In the second part of this thesis, I describe two state-engineering experiments based on these fundamental operations. The first one realizes a so-called universal orthogonalizer, an universal strategy that, given an arbitrary input state, can be used to produce at the output an orthogonal one. The adjective universal refers to the fact that the procedure works equally well for arbitrary input fields. The other experiment uses coherent superpositions of basic quantum operations to emulate a strong Kerr nonlinearity at the few-photon level, and could be used to implement new logic gates for quantum computation. The third part of this thesis is dedicated to a different experimental approach, in some sense complementary to state engineering: mode engineering. Indeed, while in state engineering the purpose is the detection of an unknown state after its manipulation, in mode engineering experiments the perspective is completely reversed: the final state is assumed to be known and what has to be inferred are its spatio-temporal features. By following this alternative experimental approach, the interaction of broadband single photons with resonant atomic vapours is analyzed by observing the traces left on the photon temporal shape.

•Jan 1, 2017•0 citations

Single-photon sources using two-photon absorption

B. C. Jacobs

Although two-photon absorption (TPA) is a nonlinear optical process, it is not typically considered a fundamental resource for optical quantum information processing (QIP). We have recently shown that TPA and the quantum Zeno effect can be used to make deterministic quantum logic devices (Zeno gates) from an otherwise linear optical system. In a Zeno gate, TPA is used to suppress the failure events that would normally occur in a linear optics device when multiple photons exit the device in the same optical mode. We have also recently shown that additional two-photon absorbing media can be used in a more conventional manner, along with a Zeno gate, to convert weak laser pulses into heralded single photon pulses. Sources of this kind could have many potential benefits; however, the use of detectors and classical switches could limit their scalability, and therefore their usefulness in larger QIP systems. Here we describe how TPA and Zeno gates alone could be used to make more efficient, and possibly scalable, single-photon sources. Because the Zeno gates also rely on TPA, we show that the only critical enabling resource for this approach is an efficient TPA medium.

Proceedings of SPIE, the International Society for Optical Engineering/Proceedings of SPIE•Sep 13, 2007•0 citations

Quantum communication

Jonathan A. Jones, Dieter Jaksch

The natural choice of physical qubit for quantum communication is the photon: a photon can be transmitted quickly from the sender to a distant receiver and the technology for creating, manipulating, distributing, and measuring light pulses is well established. Many of these classical techniques can also be employed for quantum communication protocols. We will therefore focus our attention on optical setups for quantum communication. We will study a number of optical setups in the next few sections and use the conventions introduced in Chapter 4 to analyze them. In particular, we will assume that the qubits are encoded in the degrees of freedom of a single photon. Some of the main technical challenges in quantum communication arise from this need to work with single photon pulses. For instance, photons do not interact with each other in vacuum or linear media, and interactions between two photons in non-linear optical media are relatively small, so that realizing entangling two photon gates via coherent interactions is a challenging task. The quantum communication schemes discussed here circumvent this technical problem to a large extent. They only use non-linear optical materials for parametric down-conversion to create Bell-pairs of photons and then exploit standard linear optical devices and photo-detectors to manipulate them. No further non-linear entangling gates are required. Parametric down-conversion In non-linear optical media a single photon can be down-converted into a pair of photons. In this coherent process the incoming photon is destroyed and two photons of lower energy are created.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Jul 19, 2012•5 citations

Thermal activation of photon catalysis in difference-intensity Mach-Zehnder interferometry with squeezed thermal light

Kirtpreet Singh, Arvind

Realistic non-Gaussian operations, which can be implemented by mixing a nonclassical Gaussian state with a Fock state at a beam splitter and then heralding on a photon-number-resolving detector, are known to improve phase estimation in a Mach-Zehnder interferometer. The existing studies have considered the single-mode squeezed vacuum for difference-intensity and parity detection, and the two-mode squeezed thermal state for parity detection alone as the initial Gaussian resources. However, a real squeezer in the lab actually produces single-mode squeezed thermal light, which has not been studied in a coherent-plus-resource interferometer. We take up this case and using the phase space Wigner picture, we obtain the heralded state produced by photon subtraction, addition and catalysis on a single-mode squeezed thermal resource, and evaluate the corresponding phase sensitivities. Single-photon catalysis, which is useless on squeezed vacuum, becomes a useful operation for any thermal occupation above $\nth\simeq0.2$, and since it heralds with a probability near one-half, it turns out to be the best success-weighted operation over the whole thermal range. In the vacuum limit our results reproduce the known hierarchy, where two-photon catalysis is the best operation. The quantum Fisher information computations confirms that thermal noise enhances the phase information encoded in the catalyzed state, demonstrating that difference-intensity detection closely approaches the ultimate precision bound across most operational regimes, and, together with a loss analysis, verifies the robustness of the effect.

quant-pharXiv:2610.22004•Oct 16, 2026•0 citations

Quantum nonlinear optics at the single-photon level with cold Rydberg atoms

Padrón Brito, María Auxiliadora

Photons are good candidates for carrying quantum information because they are very stable particles: they interact weakly with the medium and barely with each other. However, this has drawbacks when you want to process the information because, in this case, it is preferable to have photon-photon interactions. For example, for applications in quantum repeaters, such interactions would allow deterministic Bell state measurements, increasing the entanglement distribution rate between two remote nodes. Getting two photons to interact with each other efficiently requires mapping them into a nonlinear medium at the single-photon level, that is, a medium that reacts differently when it interacts with a single photon than when it does with two. Such strong nonlinearity has been demonstrated with Rydberg atoms, which are atoms excited to a state with a high principal quantum number. In this thesis we have performed nonlinear quantum optics experiments using an ensemble of cold Rydberg atoms, where we have studied the properties of the quantum light emitted by these atoms. First, we demonstrated nonlinearities at the single-photon level. To reach this stage, we made several improvements to the previous experimental setup available in the group, of which the implementation of a dipole trap was especially relevant. We evidence quantum nonlinearity by measuring photon antibunching for the transmitted light after interacting with the Rydberg state under electromagnetically induced transparency (EIT). We also showed the generation of single photons on-demand after storing weak coherent states of light pulses as collective Rydberg excitations. Then, we studied the variation of the light statistic throughout the output pulse after propagating through the medium as Rydberg polaritons, which are superposition states of light and Rydberg excitations. We showed that the properties at the beginning and the end of the pulse were different from those of the steady state. In particular, the light detected after the input pulse was abruptly turned off gave much stronger suppression of two-photon events. Then, we investigated how to exploit this effect to generate single photons on demand. To do this, we analyzed the quality of the single photons detected at the end of the pulse as a function of the detection probability and compared the results with those obtained by storing the input pulse as collective Rydberg excitations. We showed that the photons were generated more efficiently when increasing the detection window at the cost of deteriorating the single photons statistics. Finally, we investigated the indistinguishability of the photons emitted by our Rydberg atomic ensemble, a crucial property for using Rydberg atoms as nodes in quantum networks. We also compared the single photons generated after storage under EIT conditions with those obtained using a two-photon Raman excitation to the Rydberg state. We measured the indistinguishability by making them interfere with weak coherent states of light in a Hong-Ou-Mandel experiment. And we showed that, although we obtained better photon statistics under EIT conditions, the indistinguishability from those obtained with Raman excitation was significantly higher.

•Apr 8, 2021•0 citations
Single photons are the smallest excitation states of the elctromagnetic field. They can be experimentally created but there is no apparatus that performs this task with 100% efficiency. Many techniques and theorems of optical quantum information theory use single photons. In order to utilize them for information processing, it is reasonable to know if they had been successfully produced. In other words: One needs heralded single photons. How to achieve this, is the main result of this diploma thesis. The task has been to improve the efficiency of already existing single photon sources. An apparatus had to be found which postprocesses the output of such sources in order to either herald the photons or at least to improve the efficiency. This apparatus is explicitly allowed to use other optical sources, for example coherent states (laser). The situation has been formally represented by the assumption that single photon sources produce a mixture of vacuum and the single photon state. It is known that experimental set-ups also create higher photon contributions. These contributions are considered to be small in corresponding publications. For some cases they even seem to vanish at all. One can distinguish two regimes concerning the techniques which have been used in this work: linear and nonlinear optics. Linear optical tools, for example the beam splitter, do not absorb photons in the ideal case, but it is not easy to implement useful transformations by their means. Absorption and weak coupling are drawbacks which arise mainly in nonlinear optical media. This work shows that the interactions two-photon absorption and cross phase modulation can be used in schemes, which enable the heralding of single photons. Already there are some linear optical quantum gates which manipulate optical states by means of single photons. Photons do not interact with each other directly, in contrast to electrons for example. Therefore quantum gates which act on more than one mode are interesting. The effective interaction of these gates is not quitecomparable to unitary dynamics. Moreover, these gates do not function in each case. Measurements required in auxiliary modes yield different results for each single case and in order to obtain the desired effect the cases have to be selected according to the measurement results. It has been investigated, how such gates perform if they have statistical mixtures as a resource instead of perfect single-photon states. Yet, no improvement of the single-photon contribution has been accomplished by means of these apparatuses. Hereby it has not been disproved that it is possible to achieve this goal using other apparatuses and techniques of linear optics. Yet, it has been shown that an enhancement is possible but then a non-vanishing two-photon contribution is appended. One of the most basic quantum gates is the conditional sign flip. The optical 8 interaction cross phase modulation acts in quite the same way considering only single photons. This effect enables the heralding of single photons in the ideal case. Within this work it has been shown that a Mach-Zehnder interferometer, a cross phase modulating medium and a photo-detector can be employed for this purpose. One could use any source of light as input to the interferometer but a strong coherent state (laser) may be preferred for the purpose of enhancing the interaction. The absorption of two-photon states is another non-linear effect. Astonishingly this effect serves to generate a heralded single-photon state given two imperfect single-photon sources. First the photon adding tool is employed which consists of a beam splitter and a photo-detector. By means of that and the statistical mixtures of two single-photon sources one creates a mixture which contains vacuum, the single-photon state and additionally the two-photon Fock state. This mixture propagates through a Mach-Zehnder interferometer. The interferometer is adjusted such that it is transparent for incoming light. In addition to the interferometer alone a two-photon absorbing medium is placed in one of its arms. For this reason there is a chance that the two-photon contribution entering the interferometer is absorbed within this medium. We cannot exclude this unfortunate case. A detector is placed in one of the two output modes. The interferometer is adjusted such that the single photon state does not leave in the mode in which the detector is placed, but always in the other mode. The detector can only click if the two-photon state propagates through the interferometer and if it is not destroyed in the absorbing medium. If the detector then receives one photon it is obvious that another one must leave in the other mode. The whole phenomenon is very similar to the concept of null measurement. Although not a main result, it has been shown here that the so-called Hong-Ou-Mandel effect can be generalized. It has been proven that the beam splitter transforms Fock states with equal Fock number into superpositions of Fock numbers which are even in each mode. Another effect on special odd Fock states is conjectured.
Single photons - discrete wavepackets of light - are one of the most fundamental entities in physics. In recent years, the ability to consistently create and manipulate both single photons and pairs of photons has facilitated everything from tests of quantum theory to the implementation of quantum-enhanced precision measurements. These activities all fall within the scope of the rapidly-growing field of quantum information - the exploitation of the properties of quantum states (and specifically their capability to exist in superpositions) to accomplish tasks that would not be possible with classical objects. One stated goal of research in quantum information is to build a device consisting of a network of quantum logic gates that can evaluate quantum algorithms. The photonic implementation of individual logic gates has already been demonstrated. However, partly due to standard methods of preparing single photons, current schemes have severe limitations in terms of scaling up from a single logic gate to multiple concatenated operations. Until now it has not been proven that single photons can be generated in pure and indistinguishable quantum states, something upon which the successful operation of optical quantum logic gates relies. This thesis presents an experimental demonstration of simultaneous generation of almost identical single photons in highly pure states from two independent sources based on parametric downconversion. This is a process of photon pair generation during the passage of a light beam through a nonlinear crystal; one photon from the resulting pair is detected to herald the other. The work herein describes, refines, and implements a technique that minimises the strong quantum correlations usually present within each pair by spectral engineering of the source. This allows the heralded single photons to be in pure states, a property that is confirmed by observing a high-visibility two-photon interference effect without spectral filtering.
In this thesis work, after a brief introduction of some basic concepts of quantum optics, some experimental techniques useful for the manipulation of quantum states of light are presented. In particular, I focused on two transformations operated at the single-photon level, like the addition and the subtraction of a single photon from a travelling light beam. Both these methods share a probabilistic approach, that is their implementation has a non unitary success probability. Anyway, the detection of an additional photon in an ancillary mode exactly announces when the operation has been actually implemented. That's why this type of implementation is generally called heralded. Starting from these basic operations, a way to implement some of their superpositions is then analyzed. In the second part of this thesis, I describe two state-engineering experiments based on these fundamental operations. The first one realizes a so-called universal orthogonalizer, an universal strategy that, given an arbitrary input state, can be used to produce at the output an orthogonal one. The adjective universal refers to the fact that the procedure works equally well for arbitrary input fields. The other experiment uses coherent superpositions of basic quantum operations to emulate a strong Kerr nonlinearity at the few-photon level, and could be used to implement new logic gates for quantum computation. The third part of this thesis is dedicated to a different experimental approach, in some sense complementary to state engineering: mode engineering. Indeed, while in state engineering the purpose is the detection of an unknown state after its manipulation, in mode engineering experiments the perspective is completely reversed: the final state is assumed to be known and what has to be inferred are its spatio-temporal features. By following this alternative experimental approach, the interaction of broadband single photons with resonant atomic vapours is analyzed by observing the traces left on the photon temporal shape.
Although two-photon absorption (TPA) is a nonlinear optical process, it is not typically considered a fundamental resource for optical quantum information processing (QIP). We have recently shown that TPA and the quantum Zeno effect can be used to make deterministic quantum logic devices (Zeno gates) from an otherwise linear optical system. In a Zeno gate, TPA is used to suppress the failure events that would normally occur in a linear optics device when multiple photons exit the device in the same optical mode. We have also recently shown that additional two-photon absorbing media can be used in a more conventional manner, along with a Zeno gate, to convert weak laser pulses into heralded single photon pulses. Sources of this kind could have many potential benefits; however, the use of detectors and classical switches could limit their scalability, and therefore their usefulness in larger QIP systems. Here we describe how TPA and Zeno gates alone could be used to make more efficient, and possibly scalable, single-photon sources. Because the Zeno gates also rely on TPA, we show that the only critical enabling resource for this approach is an efficient TPA medium.
The natural choice of physical qubit for quantum communication is the photon: a photon can be transmitted quickly from the sender to a distant receiver and the technology for creating, manipulating, distributing, and measuring light pulses is well established. Many of these classical techniques can also be employed for quantum communication protocols. We will therefore focus our attention on optical setups for quantum communication. We will study a number of optical setups in the next few sections and use the conventions introduced in Chapter 4 to analyze them. In particular, we will assume that the qubits are encoded in the degrees of freedom of a single photon. Some of the main technical challenges in quantum communication arise from this need to work with single photon pulses. For instance, photons do not interact with each other in vacuum or linear media, and interactions between two photons in non-linear optical media are relatively small, so that realizing entangling two photon gates via coherent interactions is a challenging task. The quantum communication schemes discussed here circumvent this technical problem to a large extent. They only use non-linear optical materials for parametric down-conversion to create Bell-pairs of photons and then exploit standard linear optical devices and photo-detectors to manipulate them. No further non-linear entangling gates are required. Parametric down-conversion In non-linear optical media a single photon can be down-converted into a pair of photons. In this coherent process the incoming photon is destroyed and two photons of lower energy are created.
Realistic non-Gaussian operations, which can be implemented by mixing a nonclassical Gaussian state with a Fock state at a beam splitter and then heralding on a photon-number-resolving detector, are known to improve phase estimation in a Mach-Zehnder interferometer. The existing studies have considered the single-mode squeezed vacuum for difference-intensity and parity detection, and the two-mode squeezed thermal state for parity detection alone as the initial Gaussian resources. However, a real squeezer in the lab actually produces single-mode squeezed thermal light, which has not been studied in a coherent-plus-resource interferometer. We take up this case and using the phase space Wigner picture, we obtain the heralded state produced by photon subtraction, addition and catalysis on a single-mode squeezed thermal resource, and evaluate the corresponding phase sensitivities. Single-photon catalysis, which is useless on squeezed vacuum, becomes a useful operation for any thermal occupation above $\nth\simeq0.2$, and since it heralds with a probability near one-half, it turns out to be the best success-weighted operation over the whole thermal range. In the vacuum limit our results reproduce the known hierarchy, where two-photon catalysis is the best operation. The quantum Fisher information computations confirms that thermal noise enhances the phase information encoded in the catalyzed state, demonstrating that difference-intensity detection closely approaches the ultimate precision bound across most operational regimes, and, together with a loss analysis, verifies the robustness of the effect.
Photons are good candidates for carrying quantum information because they are very stable particles: they interact weakly with the medium and barely with each other. However, this has drawbacks when you want to process the information because, in this case, it is preferable to have photon-photon interactions. For example, for applications in quantum repeaters, such interactions would allow deterministic Bell state measurements, increasing the entanglement distribution rate between two remote nodes. Getting two photons to interact with each other efficiently requires mapping them into a nonlinear medium at the single-photon level, that is, a medium that reacts differently when it interacts with a single photon than when it does with two. Such strong nonlinearity has been demonstrated with Rydberg atoms, which are atoms excited to a state with a high principal quantum number. In this thesis we have performed nonlinear quantum optics experiments using an ensemble of cold Rydberg atoms, where we have studied the properties of the quantum light emitted by these atoms. First, we demonstrated nonlinearities at the single-photon level. To reach this stage, we made several improvements to the previous experimental setup available in the group, of which the implementation of a dipole trap was especially relevant. We evidence quantum nonlinearity by measuring photon antibunching for the transmitted light after interacting with the Rydberg state under electromagnetically induced transparency (EIT). We also showed the generation of single photons on-demand after storing weak coherent states of light pulses as collective Rydberg excitations. Then, we studied the variation of the light statistic throughout the output pulse after propagating through the medium as Rydberg polaritons, which are superposition states of light and Rydberg excitations. We showed that the properties at the beginning and the end of the pulse were different from those of the steady state. In particular, the light detected after the input pulse was abruptly turned off gave much stronger suppression of two-photon events. Then, we investigated how to exploit this effect to generate single photons on demand. To do this, we analyzed the quality of the single photons detected at the end of the pulse as a function of the detection probability and compared the results with those obtained by storing the input pulse as collective Rydberg excitations. We showed that the photons were generated more efficiently when increasing the detection window at the cost of deteriorating the single photons statistics. Finally, we investigated the indistinguishability of the photons emitted by our Rydberg atomic ensemble, a crucial property for using Rydberg atoms as nodes in quantum networks. We also compared the single photons generated after storage under EIT conditions with those obtained using a two-photon Raman excitation to the Rydberg state. We measured the indistinguishability by making them interfere with weak coherent states of light in a Hong-Ou-Mandel experiment. And we showed that, although we obtained better photon statistics under EIT conditions, the indistinguishability from those obtained with Raman excitation was significantly higher.