Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review Letters

Persistent Ring Currents in an Ideal Bose Gas

John M. Blatt

Published Aug 1, 1961• 28 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The production and persistence of ring currents is investigated in a simple model, consisting of Bose-Einstein particles contained in a ring-shaped volume; the particles do not interact with each other, but interact with randomly distributed scattering centres, and carry a test charge through which they respond to external fields. Except for the Bose­ Einstein statistics, this model is identical with the model of Kohn and Luttinger, for which a normal, non-zero resistivity has been shown to exist. Furthermore, our model is known to give a qualitatively correct insight into the Meissner effect in actual superconductors, where the bosons are attractively correlated electron pairs. We are able to elucidate the mechanism by which ring currents are generated, and to prove that these ring currents, within our model, have infinite lifetime. There are similarities to the ideas of London, but also significant differences. Our model has no energy gap, and thus our explanation of persistent ring currents is qualitatively dissimilar to the two-fluid model of Bardeen, in which the energy gap is essential. The model is a simple example of a strictly non-ergodic system,. and therefore has some interest for the foundations of non­ equilibrium statistical mechanics. The model predicts a new, experimentally observable effect: If the ring is maintained between the poles of the magnet, and cooled well below the transition temperature, small ring currents are generated during this cooling. The effect of these ring currents is to force the flux through the ring very close to an integral number of flux units introduced by London. This approximate quantization of flux is destroyed when the ring is moved out of the external :field.

DOI
10.1103/physrevlett.7.82

Related papers

Persistent Ring Currents in an Ideal Bose Gas

John M. Blatt

The production and persistence of ring currents is investigated in a simple model, consisting of Bose-Einstein particles contained in a ring-shaped volume; the particles do not interact with each other, but interact with randomly distributed scattering centres, and carry a test charge through which they respond to external fields. Except for the Bose-Einstein statistics, this model is identical with the model of Kohn and Luttinger, for which a normal, non-zero resistivity has been shown to exist. Furthermore, our model is known to give a qualitatively correct insight into the Meissner effect in actual superconductors, where the “bosons” are attractively correlated electron pairs. We are able to elucidate the mechanism by which ring currents are generated, and to prove that these ring currents, within our model, have infinite lifetime. There are similarities to the ideas of London, but also significant differences. Our model has no energy gap, and thus our explanation of persistent ring currents is qualitatively dissimilar to the two-fluid model of Bardeen, in which the energy gap is essential. The model is a simple example of a strictly non-ergodic system, and therefore has some interest for the foundations of non-equilibrium statistical mechanics. The model predicts a new, experimentally observable effect: If the ring is maintained between the poles of the magnet, and cooled well below the transition temperature, small ring currents are generated during this cooling. The effect of these ring currents is to force the flux through the ring very close to an integral number of flux “units” introduced by London. This approximate quantization of flux is destroyed when the ring is moved out of the external field.

Progress of Theoretical Physics•Nov 1, 1961•15 citations

Model for the Formation of Persistent Mass Currents in Liquid Helium II

D. Bergmann

We propose a model to describe the creation of persistent mass currents in liquid helium II and we analyze its consequences for an experiment where these currents are formed by slowly bringing to rest a rotating ring containing a condensed boson gas in equilibrium at $T=0\ifmmode^\circ\else\textdegree\fi{}$K. The ring is assumed to contain, besides the noninteracting boson gas, a large number of randomly distributed scatterers which would presumably engender a normal viscosity at higher temperatures; thus the creation of supercurrents is not trivial. We have included the container and scatterers in the dynamical system; this brings about an effective interaction between bosons which is handled by the self-consistent-field method. With the help of additional approximations and numerical computations, we examine the time-dependent process of creating the mass current and conclude that it can indeed be formed under usual conditions.

Physical Review•May 5, 1967•0 citations

Spinless Hartree-Fock model of persistent current in rings with single scatterer: Comparison with correlated models

Radoslav Németh, Martin Moško

Using the self-consistent Hartree-Fock approximation for spinless electrons at zero temperature, we study the persistent current of the interacting electron gas in a one-dimensional continuous ring containing a single $δ$ barrier. We calculate the persistent current as a function of the ring circumference, magnetic flux threading the ring, barrier strength, etc. We compare our results with the results of correlated models like the Luttinger liquid model and the Hubbard model solved by means of the renormalization group. A good agreement is found. First, the persistent current decays with the increasing ring circumference ($L$) faster than $L^{-1}$ and eventually like $L^{-α-1}$, where $α>0$ depends only on the electron-electron interaction. Second, the persistent current is a sine-shaped function of magnetic flux. This sine-like dependence and in particular the universal power law $L^{-α-1}$ have sofar been believed to arise only in the correlated many-body models. Observation of these features within the Hartree-Fock model is a surprising result.

arXiv:cond-mat/0503146•Mar 7, 2005•6 citations

Stability of persistent currents in superfluid fermionic rings

Klejdja Xhani, Andrea Barresi, Marek Tylutki +2 more

We investigate the stability of persistent currents in superfluid fermionic gases confined to a ring geometry. Our study, conducted at zero temperature using time-dependent density functional theory, cover interaction regimes from strong (unitary Fermi gas) to weak (Bardeen-Cooper-Schrieffer regime) couplings. Stability is tested against the presence of an external defect within the ring. The dissipation mechanism associated with vortex generation is present in all interaction regimes. Vortex emission is accompanied by Cooper pair breaking, which occurs even beyond the vortex core in the weakly interacting regime. The pair-breaking mechanism prevents the imprinting of a persistent current with a winding number above a threshold, which decreases as the system approach the BCS regime. Our study reveals the existence of two types of critical winding numbers above which currents cease to be persistent in Fermi superfluids: one related to the proliferation of quantum vortices and the other to the onset of the pair-breaking mechanism.

arXiv:2406.10088•Physical Review Research•Feb 28, 2025•10 citations

Superconductivity of a Charged Ideal Bose Gas

M. R. Schafroth

It is shown that an ideal gas of charged bosons exhibits the essential equilibrium features of a superconductor. The onset of Bose-Einstein condensation marks the transition temperature ${T}_{c}$. Below ${T}_{c}$ a Meissner-Ochsenfeld effect is exhibited which is described in a very good approximation by London's equation.The singular nature of the condensed ideal Bose gas exhibits itself in a space dependence of the London constant $\ensuremath{\lambda}$, determined by the boundary conditions on the wave function. It is shown that the electrostatic repulsion between the bosons compensates this effect and leads to a spatially constant $\ensuremath{\lambda}$, independently of the boundary conditions.The critical field ${H}_{c}(T)$ is determined and found to be related to the penetration depth $d(T)$ by ${H}_{c}=\frac{\ensuremath{\hbar}c}{2e{d}^{2}}$ ($e$ being the boson charge).The $B(H)$ law is different from the one usually assumed for actual superconductors. Corresponding changes occur in the thermodynamical relation.A comparison with superconducting metals is made. The main conclusion is that if superconductivity in metals is due to the concurrence of bosons, then the number of these bosons must be strongly temperaturedependent below ${T}_{c}$.

Physical Review•Oct 15, 1955•360 citations

Persistent fluxon current via the Aharonov-Casher effect in one-dimensional mesoscopic rings: continuum model

Jian‐Xin Zhu, Z D Wang, Q. W. Shi

By extending Lieb and Liniger's (1963) Bose gas analysis to many hard-core bosons confined to a one-dimensional mesoscopic ring in the presence of Aharonov-Casher flux (AC), persistent fluxon currents are investigated for the first time, and are found to be periodic in the AC flux with period Phi 0=hc/e. The interesting mesoscopic parity effects due to evenness or oddness of the particle number N are discussed. More importantly, it is demonstrated exactly that, in the absence of the external AC flux, whether a self-sustained fluxon current exists depends only upon the choice of the boundary condition.

Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•Dec 7, 1994•6 citations
The production and persistence of ring currents is investigated in a simple model, consisting of Bose-Einstein particles contained in a ring-shaped volume; the particles do not interact with each other, but interact with randomly distributed scattering centres, and carry a test charge through which they respond to external fields. Except for the Bose­ Einstein statistics, this model is identical with the model of Kohn and Luttinger, for which a normal, non-zero resistivity has been shown to exist. Furthermore, our model is known to give a qualitatively correct insight into the Meissner effect in actual superconductors, where the bosons are attractively correlated electron pairs. We are able to elucidate the mechanism by which ring currents are generated, and to prove that these ring currents, within our model, have infinite lifetime. There are similarities to the ideas of London, but also significant differences. Our model has no energy gap, and thus our explanation of persistent ring currents is qualitatively dissimilar to the two-fluid model of Bardeen, in which the energy gap is essential. The model is a simple example of a strictly non-ergodic system,. and therefore has some interest for the foundations of non­ equilibrium statistical mechanics. The model predicts a new, experimentally observable effect: If the ring is maintained between the poles of the magnet, and cooled well below the transition temperature, small ring currents are generated during this cooling. The effect of these ring currents is to force the flux through the ring very close to an integral number of flux units introduced by London. This approximate quantization of flux is destroyed when the ring is moved out of the external :field.
The production and persistence of ring currents is investigated in a simple model, consisting of Bose-Einstein particles contained in a ring-shaped volume; the particles do not interact with each other, but interact with randomly distributed scattering centres, and carry a test charge through which they respond to external fields. Except for the Bose-Einstein statistics, this model is identical with the model of Kohn and Luttinger, for which a normal, non-zero resistivity has been shown to exist. Furthermore, our model is known to give a qualitatively correct insight into the Meissner effect in actual superconductors, where the “bosons” are attractively correlated electron pairs. We are able to elucidate the mechanism by which ring currents are generated, and to prove that these ring currents, within our model, have infinite lifetime. There are similarities to the ideas of London, but also significant differences. Our model has no energy gap, and thus our explanation of persistent ring currents is qualitatively dissimilar to the two-fluid model of Bardeen, in which the energy gap is essential. The model is a simple example of a strictly non-ergodic system, and therefore has some interest for the foundations of non-equilibrium statistical mechanics. The model predicts a new, experimentally observable effect: If the ring is maintained between the poles of the magnet, and cooled well below the transition temperature, small ring currents are generated during this cooling. The effect of these ring currents is to force the flux through the ring very close to an integral number of flux “units” introduced by London. This approximate quantization of flux is destroyed when the ring is moved out of the external field.
We propose a model to describe the creation of persistent mass currents in liquid helium II and we analyze its consequences for an experiment where these currents are formed by slowly bringing to rest a rotating ring containing a condensed boson gas in equilibrium at $T=0\ifmmode^\circ\else\textdegree\fi{}$K. The ring is assumed to contain, besides the noninteracting boson gas, a large number of randomly distributed scatterers which would presumably engender a normal viscosity at higher temperatures; thus the creation of supercurrents is not trivial. We have included the container and scatterers in the dynamical system; this brings about an effective interaction between bosons which is handled by the self-consistent-field method. With the help of additional approximations and numerical computations, we examine the time-dependent process of creating the mass current and conclude that it can indeed be formed under usual conditions.
Using the self-consistent Hartree-Fock approximation for spinless electrons at zero temperature, we study the persistent current of the interacting electron gas in a one-dimensional continuous ring containing a single δδδ barrier. We calculate the persistent current as a function of the ring circumference, magnetic flux threading the ring, barrier strength, etc. We compare our results with the results of correlated models like the Luttinger liquid model and the Hubbard model solved by means of the renormalization group. A good agreement is found. First, the persistent current decays with the increasing ring circumference (LLL) faster than L−1L^{-1}L−1 and eventually like L−α−1L^{-α-1}L−α−1, where α>0α>0α>0 depends only on the electron-electron interaction. Second, the persistent current is a sine-shaped function of magnetic flux. This sine-like dependence and in particular the universal power law L−α−1L^{-α-1}L−α−1 have sofar been believed to arise only in the correlated many-body models. Observation of these features within the Hartree-Fock model is a surprising result.
We investigate the stability of persistent currents in superfluid fermionic gases confined to a ring geometry. Our study, conducted at zero temperature using time-dependent density functional theory, cover interaction regimes from strong (unitary Fermi gas) to weak (Bardeen-Cooper-Schrieffer regime) couplings. Stability is tested against the presence of an external defect within the ring. The dissipation mechanism associated with vortex generation is present in all interaction regimes. Vortex emission is accompanied by Cooper pair breaking, which occurs even beyond the vortex core in the weakly interacting regime. The pair-breaking mechanism prevents the imprinting of a persistent current with a winding number above a threshold, which decreases as the system approach the BCS regime. Our study reveals the existence of two types of critical winding numbers above which currents cease to be persistent in Fermi superfluids: one related to the proliferation of quantum vortices and the other to the onset of the pair-breaking mechanism.
It is shown that an ideal gas of charged bosons exhibits the essential equilibrium features of a superconductor. The onset of Bose-Einstein condensation marks the transition temperature Tc{T}_{c}Tc​. Below Tc{T}_{c}Tc​ a Meissner-Ochsenfeld effect is exhibited which is described in a very good approximation by London's equation.The singular nature of the condensed ideal Bose gas exhibits itself in a space dependence of the London constant $\ensuremath{\lambda}$, determined by the boundary conditions on the wave function. It is shown that the electrostatic repulsion between the bosons compensates this effect and leads to a spatially constant $\ensuremath{\lambda}$, independently of the boundary conditions.The critical field Hc(T){H}_{c}(T)Hc​(T) is determined and found to be related to the penetration depth d(T)d(T)d(T) by ${H}_{c}=\frac{\ensuremath{\hbar}c}{2e{d}^{2}}$ (eee being the boson charge).The B(H)B(H)B(H) law is different from the one usually assumed for actual superconductors. Corresponding changes occur in the thermodynamical relation.A comparison with superconducting metals is made. The main conclusion is that if superconductivity in metals is due to the concurrence of bosons, then the number of these bosons must be strongly temperaturedependent below Tc{T}_{c}Tc​.
By extending Lieb and Liniger's (1963) Bose gas analysis to many hard-core bosons confined to a one-dimensional mesoscopic ring in the presence of Aharonov-Casher flux (AC), persistent fluxon currents are investigated for the first time, and are found to be periodic in the AC flux with period Phi 0=hc/e. The interesting mesoscopic parity effects due to evenness or oddness of the particle number N are discussed. More importantly, it is demonstrated exactly that, in the absence of the external AC flux, whether a self-sustained fluxon current exists depends only upon the choice of the boundary condition.