Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Anais da Academia Brasileira de Ciências

Positive operator valued measures and the quantum Monty Hall problem

Claudia Zander, M. Casas, Angel Ricardo Plastino, Angel Ricardo Plastino

Published Sep 1, 2006• 7 citations
Publisher

Abstract

A quantum version of the Monty Hall problem, based upon the Positive Operator Valued Measures (POVM) formalism, is proposed. It is shown that basic normalization and symmetry arguments lead univocally to the associated POVM elements, and that the classical probabilities associated with the Monty Hall scenario are recovered for a natural choice of the measurement operators.

DOI
10.1590/s0001-37652006000300003

Related papers

Positive-Operator Valued Measure (POVM) Quantization

Jean‐Pierre Gazeau, Bárbara Heller

We present a general formalism for giving a measure space paired with a separable Hilbert space a quantum version based on a normalized positive operator-valued measure. The latter are built from families of density operators labeled by points of the measure space. We especially focus on various probabilistic aspects of these constructions. Simple ormore elaborate examples illustrate the procedure: circle, two-sphere, plane and half-plane. Links with Positive-Operator Valued Measure (POVM) quantum measurement and quantum statistical inference are sketched.

arXiv:1408.6090•Axioms•Dec 25, 2014•22 citations

THE QUANTUM MONTY HALL PROBLEM: SYMMETRY, ENTANGLEMENT, AND STATE MODIFICATION

Michael Aksman

The classical Monty Hall problem serves as a standard exercise in conditional probability. In this article, we examine its quantum mechanical extension to demonstrate how classical probability distributions are governed by symmetry and entanglement. By mapping the available choices to a three-level quantum system (qutrits) governed by SU(3) symmetry, the game is transformed into a formalized quantum system [1]. We establish that when the choices of the host and player are entangled, the act of revealing a door functions as a symmetry-breaking measurement that physically modifies the state space, illustrating that information acquisition in quantum systems is an active, geometric process with direct analogues in quantum field symmetries [2].

•Feb 21, 2026•0 citations

Quantum inferring acausal structures and the Monty Hall problem

Dariusz Kurzyk, Adam Glos

This paper presents a quantum version of the Monty Hall problem based upon the quantum inferring acausal structures, which can be identified with generalization of Bayesian networks. Considered structures are expressed in formalism of quantum information theory, where density operators are identified with quantum generalization of probability distributions. Conditional relations between quantum counterpart of random variables are described by quantum conditional operators. Presented quantum inferring structures are used to construct a model inspired by scenario of well-known Monty Hall game, where we show the differences between classical and quantum Bayesian reasoning.

arXiv:1504.01917•Quantum Information Processing•Sep 8, 2016•12 citations

Understanding the Monty Hall Problem Through a Quantum Measurement Analogy

Li, Mo

The Monty Hall problem is a classic probability puzzle known for its counterintuitive solution, revealing fundamental discrepancies between mathematical reasoning and human intuition. To bridge this gap, we introduce a novel explanatory framework inspired by quantum measurement theory. Specifically, we conceptualize the hosts' actions-opening doors to reveal non-prizes-as analogous to quantum measurements that cause asymmetric collapses of the probability distribution. This quantum-inspired interpretation not only clarifies why the intuitive misunderstanding arises but also provides generalized formulas consistent with standard Bayesian results. We further validate our analytical approach using Monte Carlo simulations across various problem settings, demonstrating precise agreement between theoretical predictions and empirical outcomes. Our quantum analogy thus offers a powerful pedagogical tool, enhancing intuitive understanding of conditional probability phenomena through the lens of probability redistribution and quantum-like measurement operations.

arXiv:2506.00012•May 17, 2025•0 citations

Quantum-Optical set-up for the Monty Hall problem

Luis Fernando Quezada, A. Martín-Ruiz, Adam Frank +1 more

Abstract A quantum version of the Monty Hall problem is proposed inspired by an experimentally-feasible, quantum-optical set-up that resembles the classical game. The expected payoff of the player is studied by analyzing the classical expectation values of the obtained quantum probabilities. Results are examined by considering both entanglement and non-entanglement between player and host, and using two different approaches: random and strategy-based. We also discuss the influence of noise on the game outcome when the parties play through a noisy quantum channel. The experimental set-up can be used to quickly verify the counter-intuitive result of the Monty Hall problem, adding pedagogic value to the proposal.

arXiv:1908.05774•Physica Scripta•Apr 2, 2020•4 citations

Monty Hall Problem and the Principle of Equal Probability in Measurement Theory

Shiro Ishikawa

In this paper, we study the principle of equal probability (i.e., unless we have sufficient reason to regard one possible case as more probable than another, we treat them as equally probable) in measurement theory (i.e., the theory of quantum mechanical world view), which is characterized as the linguistic turn of quantum mechanics with the Copenhagen interpretation. This turn from physics to language does not only realize theremarkable extensionof quantum mechanicsbut alsoestablish the method of science. Our study will be executed in the easy example of the Monty Hall problem. Although our argument is simple, we believe that it is worth pointing out the fact that the principle of equal probability can be, for the first time, clarified in measurement theory (based on the dualism) and not the conventional statistics (based on Kolmogorov’s probability theory).

Applied Mathematics•Jan 1, 2012•21 citations
A quantum version of the Monty Hall problem, based upon the Positive Operator Valued Measures (POVM) formalism, is proposed. It is shown that basic normalization and symmetry arguments lead univocally to the associated POVM elements, and that the classical probabilities associated with the Monty Hall scenario are recovered for a natural choice of the measurement operators.
We present a general formalism for giving a measure space paired with a separable Hilbert space a quantum version based on a normalized positive operator-valued measure. The latter are built from families of density operators labeled by points of the measure space. We especially focus on various probabilistic aspects of these constructions. Simple ormore elaborate examples illustrate the procedure: circle, two-sphere, plane and half-plane. Links with Positive-Operator Valued Measure (POVM) quantum measurement and quantum statistical inference are sketched.
The classical Monty Hall problem serves as a standard exercise in conditional probability. In this article, we examine its quantum mechanical extension to demonstrate how classical probability distributions are governed by symmetry and entanglement. By mapping the available choices to a three-level quantum system (qutrits) governed by SU(3) symmetry, the game is transformed into a formalized quantum system [1]. We establish that when the choices of the host and player are entangled, the act of revealing a door functions as a symmetry-breaking measurement that physically modifies the state space, illustrating that information acquisition in quantum systems is an active, geometric process with direct analogues in quantum field symmetries [2].
This paper presents a quantum version of the Monty Hall problem based upon the quantum inferring acausal structures, which can be identified with generalization of Bayesian networks. Considered structures are expressed in formalism of quantum information theory, where density operators are identified with quantum generalization of probability distributions. Conditional relations between quantum counterpart of random variables are described by quantum conditional operators. Presented quantum inferring structures are used to construct a model inspired by scenario of well-known Monty Hall game, where we show the differences between classical and quantum Bayesian reasoning.
The Monty Hall problem is a classic probability puzzle known for its counterintuitive solution, revealing fundamental discrepancies between mathematical reasoning and human intuition. To bridge this gap, we introduce a novel explanatory framework inspired by quantum measurement theory. Specifically, we conceptualize the hosts' actions-opening doors to reveal non-prizes-as analogous to quantum measurements that cause asymmetric collapses of the probability distribution. This quantum-inspired interpretation not only clarifies why the intuitive misunderstanding arises but also provides generalized formulas consistent with standard Bayesian results. We further validate our analytical approach using Monte Carlo simulations across various problem settings, demonstrating precise agreement between theoretical predictions and empirical outcomes. Our quantum analogy thus offers a powerful pedagogical tool, enhancing intuitive understanding of conditional probability phenomena through the lens of probability redistribution and quantum-like measurement operations.
Abstract A quantum version of the Monty Hall problem is proposed inspired by an experimentally-feasible, quantum-optical set-up that resembles the classical game. The expected payoff of the player is studied by analyzing the classical expectation values of the obtained quantum probabilities. Results are examined by considering both entanglement and non-entanglement between player and host, and using two different approaches: random and strategy-based. We also discuss the influence of noise on the game outcome when the parties play through a noisy quantum channel. The experimental set-up can be used to quickly verify the counter-intuitive result of the Monty Hall problem, adding pedagogic value to the proposal.
In this paper, we study the principle of equal probability (i.e., unless we have sufficient reason to regard one possible case as more probable than another, we treat them as equally probable) in measurement theory (i.e., the theory of quantum mechanical world view), which is characterized as the linguistic turn of quantum mechanics with the Copenhagen interpretation. This turn from physics to language does not only realize theremarkable extensionof quantum mechanicsbut alsoestablish the method of science. Our study will be executed in the easy example of the Monty Hall problem. Although our argument is simple, we believe that it is worth pointing out the fact that the principle of equal probability can be, for the first time, clarified in measurement theory (based on the dualism) and not the conventional statistics (based on Kolmogorov’s probability theory).