Proceedings of SPIE, the International Society for Optical Engineering/Proceedings of SPIE

Indications for quantum computation requirements from comparative brain analysis

Gustav Bernroider, Wolfgang Baer

Published Mar 31, 2010• 0 citations

Abstract

Whether or not neuronal signal properties can engage 'non-trivial', i.e. functionally significant, quantum properties, is the subject of an ongoing debate. Here we provide evidence that quantum coherence dynamics can play a functional role in ion conduction mechanism with consequences on the shape and associative character of classical membrane signals. In particular, these new perspectives predict that a specific neuronal topology (e.g. the connectivity pattern of cortical columns in the primate brain) is less important and not really required to explain abilities in perception and sensory-motor integration. Instead, this evidence is suggestive for a decisive role of the number and functional segregation of ion channel proteins that can be engaged in a particular neuronal constellation. We provide evidence from comparative brain studies and estimates of computational capacity behind visual flight functions suggestive for a possible role of quantum computation in biological systems.

DOI: 10.1117/12.850468

Related papers

Revisiting the Quantum Brain Hypothesis: Toward Quantum (Neuro)biology?

Peter Jedlička

The nervous system is a non-linear dynamical complex system with many feedback loops. A conventional wisdom is that in the brain the quantum fluctuations are self-averaging and thus functionally negligible. However, this intuition might be misleading in the case of non-linear complex systems. Because of an extreme sensitivity to initial conditions, in complex systems the microscopic fluctuations may be amplified and thereby affect the system's behavior. In this way quantum dynamics might influence neuronal computations. Accumulating evidence in non-neuronal systems indicates that biological evolution is able to exploit quantum stochasticity. The recent rise of quantum biology as an emerging field at the border between quantum physics and the life sciences suggests that quantum events could play a non-trivial role also in neuronal cells. Direct experimental evidence for this is still missing but future research should address the possibility that quantum events contribute to an extremely high complexity, variability and computational power of neuronal dynamics.

Frontiers in Molecular NeuroscienceNov 7, 201797 citations

Quantum-Classical Correspondence in the Brain : Scaling, Action Distances and Predictability behind Neural Signals

Gustav Bernroider, Sisir Roy

Neural Coding Abstract. Quantum models of higher level brain functions such as conscious experience, suggest that the neural correlate of mentation requires dynamical properties instantiated at the Planck-scale. Several candidate quantum processes have been suggested, but it remains to be seen how these quantum properties can relate to the established classical signals in the brain involving physical action twenty magnitudes above the quantum domain. In this paper we show the results of a systematic analysis of Lagrangian action order to brain processes at different scales of resolution. The results encompass processes at the macroscopic single cell level to processes at the sub-molecular and concerted molecular population level. It is shown that the state of ions in the permeation filter of channel proteins, as for example indicated by the MacKinnon KcsA K+ channel model, is a quantum phenomenon involving a Lagrangian in the order of 10–34 Js. Further, we show that the brain spans at least 20 orders of magnitudes of physical action with physiologically significant signal properties. We suggest that the quantum-classical correspondence in the brain is resolved by the spread of quantum-witness states that correlate with the gating states of voltage sensitive ion channels. 1.

FormaJun 1, 200422 citations

Quantum mechanisms in the brain: from conjectures and theories to experimental evidence

Travis J. A. Craddock

As the emerging field of quantum biology matures it is becoming possible to understand the fundamental workings of biological systems at the subatomic level. Understanding the complex function of the brain from this vantage point is no exception. Looking at the subcellular functions of neurons beyond the standard classical mechanisms of chemical and electrical signaling offers the potential to design advanced diagnostics and therapeutics for neurological disorders and mental illnesses based on quantum technologies and could even lead to a more comprehensive understanding of human cognition, behavior, or even consciousness itself. Towards this end there have been many theories proposed for how quantum mechanics may play a role in brain function. However, regardless of how promising these theories are, without experimental evidence to provide validation they are merely interesting conjectures. Here we present a review of current theoretical quantum mechanisms proposed to influence brain function (e.g., spin-based mechanisms, optical mechanisms) and place them in the context of existing experimental evidence. We find that experimental evidence does support quantum mechanisms that may exist in the brain, but significant challenges remain in explaining how such mechanisms may influence processes on relevant biological lengths and timescales. Potential approaches to address these challenges are also discussed.

Quantum Effects and Measurement Techniques in Biology and BiophotonicsMar 21, 20253 citations

Relevance of Quantum Mechanics in Circuit Implementation of Ion channels in Brain Dynamics

Mitra, Indranil, Sisir Roy

With an increasing amount of experimental evidence pouring in from neurobiological investigations, it is quite appropriate to study viable reductionist models which may explain some of the features of brain activities. It is now quite well known that the Hodgkin-Huxley (HH) Model has been quite successful in explaining the neural phenomena. The idea of circuit equivalents and the membrane voltages corresponding to neurons have been remarkable which is essentially a classical result. In view of some recent results which show that quantum mechanics may be important at suitable length scales inside the brain, the question which becomes quite important is to find out a proper quantum analogue of the HH scheme which will reduce to the well known HH model in a suitable limit. From the ideas of neuro-manifold and the relevance of quantum mechanics at some length scales in the ion channels, we investigate this situation in this paper by taking into consideration the Schrödinger equation in an arbitrary manifold with a metric, which is in some sense a special case of the heat kernel equation. The next important approach we have taken in order to bring about it's relevance in brain studies and to make connection with HH models is to find out a plausible circuit equivalents of it. What we do realize is that for a proper quantum mechanical description and it's circuit implementation of the same we need to incorporate the non commutativity inside the circuit model. It has been realized here that the metric is a dynamical entity governing space time and for considering equivalent circuits it plays a very distinct role. We have used the methods of stochastic quantization and have constructed a specific case here and see that HH model inductances gets renormalized in the quantum limit.

arXiv:q-bio/0606008Jun 8, 20063 citations

Plausibility of quantum coherent states in biological systems

Vahid Salari, Jack A. Tuszyński, M Rahnama +1 more

In this paper we briefly discuss the necessity of using quantum mechanics as a fundamental theory applicable to some key functional aspects of biological systems. This is especially relevant to three important parts of a neuron in the human brain, namely the cell membrane, microtubules (MT) and ion channels. We argue that the recently published papers criticizing the use of quantum theory in these systems are not convincing.

arXiv:1012.3879Journal of Physics Conference SeriesJul 8, 201141 citations

Quantum entanglement in brain neuronal circuitry

Nicolas Francisco Lori, José Machado

Abstract An assessment is made of the role of quantum entanglement in biological neuronal circuitry, in agreement with previous experimental evidence, which indicated that quantum tunneling plays an essential role in the occurrence of the sense of smell. It is here described how that can be physically realistic. Then, it is analyzed how the occurrence of quantum entanglement in multiple scales allows for the occurrence of consciousness in biological systems. We obtain that quantum mechanics (QM) allows for coherence to be maintained in living brains for regions in the scale of the minicollumn, but not much more. The QM waves can then be amplified into classical waves along the brain that transmit information, which existed in the quantum wave at minicollumn scale. For the quantum wave to be able to exist at the minicollumn scale at the temperature of a living brain, several physiological constraints need to occur within the neuronal circuitry. Here, we assess what those constraints are and propose forms for realistically theorizing that those constraints can occur in a living brain at the minicollumn scale. This analysis of the effects of quantum entanglement in biological neuronal circuitry assists in suggesting a new approach to neuronal nets, which we call a multidepth quantum neural net. We then analyze in what way it is likely that in the future a multidepth quantum neural net will be capable of achieving consciousness.

Logic Journal of IGPLOct 15, 20250 citations