Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Journal of Physics Conference Series

Harmonic oscillator states with integer and non-integer orbital angular momentum

Martin Land

Published Dec 6, 2011• 4 citations
Publisher

Abstract

We study the quantum mechanical harmonic oscillator in two and three dimensions, with particular attention to the solutions as basis states for representing their respective symmetry groups — O(2), O(1,1), O(3), and O(2,1). The goal of this study is to establish a correspondence between Hilbert space descriptions found by solving the Schrodinger equation in polar coordinates, and Fock space descriptions constructed by expressing the symmetry operators in terms of creation/annihilation operators. We obtain wavefunctions characterized by a principal quantum number, the group Casimir eigenvalue, and one group generator whose eigenvalue is m + s , for integer m and real constant parameter s . For the three groups that contain O(2), the solutions split into two inequivalent representations, one associated with s = 0, from which we recover the familiar description of the oscillator as a product of one-dimensional solutions, and the other with s > 0 (in three dimensions, solutions are found for s = 0 and s = 1/2) whose solutions are non-separable in Cartesian coordinates, and are hence overlooked by the standard Fock space approach. The O(1,1) solutions are singlet states, restricted to zero eigenvalue of the symmetry operator, which represents the boost, not angular momentum. For O(2), a single set of creation and annihilation operators forms a ladder representation for the allowed oscillator states for any s, and the degeneracy of energy states is always finite. However, in three dimensions, the integer and half-integer eigenstates are qualitatively different: the former can be expressed as finite dimensional irreducible tensors under O(3) or O(2,1) while the latter exhibit infinite degeneracy. Creation operators that produce the allowed integer states by acting on the non-degenerate ground state are constructed as irreducible tensor products of the fundamental vector representation. However, the half-integer eigenstates are infinite-dimensional, as expected for the non-compact O(2,1), and no Fock space description is found for this case. For all s ≠ 0 solutions, the SU(N) symmetry of the harmonic oscillator Hamiltonian recently discovered by Bars is spontaneously broken by the ground state. The connection of this symmetry breaking to the non-separability into one-dimensional Cartesian solutions is demonstrated. We conclude with a discussion of the O(2,1) solutions, and the problem of timelike ghost excitations.

DOI
10.1088/1742-6596/330/1/012014

Related papers

Harmonic Oscillator States with Non-Integer Orbital Angular Momentum

Martin Land

We study the quantum mechanical harmonic oscillator in two and three dimensions, with particular attention to the solutions as represents of their respective symmetry groups: O(2), O(3), and O(2,1). Solving the Schrodinger equation by separating variables in polar coordinates, we obtain wavefunctions characterized by a principal quantum number, the group Casimir eigenvalue, and one observable component of orbital angular momentum, with eigenvalue $m+s$, for integer $m$ and real constant parameter $s$. In each symmetry group, $s$ splits the solutions into two inequivalent representations, one associated with $s=0$, which recovers the familiar description of the oscillator as a product of one-dimensional solutions, and the other with $s>0$ (in three dimensions, $s=0, 1/2$) whose solutions are non-separable in Cartesian coordinates, and are hence overlooked by the standard Fock space approach. In two dimensions, a single set of creation and annihilation operators forms a ladder representation for the allowed oscillator states for any $s$, and the degeneracy of energy states is always finite. However, in three dimensions, the integer and half-integer eigenstates are qualitatively different: the former can be expressed as finite dimensional irreducible tensors under O(3) or O(2,1), and a ladder representation can be constructed via irreducible tensor products of the vector creation operator multiplet, while the latter exhibit infinite degeneracy and the finite-dimensional ladder representation fails for these states. These results are closely connected to the breaking of a unitary symmetry of the harmonic oscillator Hamiltonian recently discussed by Bars.

arXiv:0903.1757•Mar 10, 2009•4 citations

Search for a Universal Symmetry Group in Two Dimensions

Arturo Cisneros, Harold V. McIntosh

Recently several authors have proposed a universal symmetry group and demonstrated the classical validity of the concept. Supposedly, an SU(n) symmetry group could be constructed for whatsoever system of n degrees of freedom. The claim is assuredly valid for all classically degenerate systems, but is in contradiction with most of the well-known and widely accepted solutions of Schrödinger's equation. We examine the reasons for this discrepancy on the quantum-mechanical level. The construction of the universal symmetry group requires ladder operators, which in most cases are the ladder operators of Infeld and Hill. Complications which owe their origin entirely to numerical relationships imposed by quantization prevent these operators from forming a von Neumann algebra and, in turn, an SU(n) group of constants of the motion. Two important effects are those imposed by anisotropy, wherein not all quanta have the same size, and by non-Cartesian coordinates, wherein quanta in some dimensions are restricted in size by those in other dimensions. These effects can be seen quite clearly in two-dimensional systems: anisotropy in the Cartesian anisotropic harmonic oscillator, and conflict between dimensions in the polar form of the isotropic oscillator. Further complications arise when the two effects are combined, as in the harmonic oscillator or hydrogen atom with ``excess'' angular momentum. Enough residue of the universal symmetry concept remains that many similarities between the hydrogen atom and harmonic oscillator may be understood, including the fact that some levels of the hydrogen atom, which ordinarily transform according to an orthogonal group, may form irreducible representations of the unitary group.

Journal of Mathematical Physics•Mar 1, 1970•40 citations

The Quantum Harmonic Oscillator

Reinhold A. Bertlmann, Nicolai Friis

Abstract We consider the time-independent Schrödinger equation for the harmonic oscillator potential and determine its bound states and energy levels in one spatial dimension using two approaches: the algebraic and the analytic method. Using the former, we introduce ladder operators: the annihilation and creation operators, as well as the occupation-number operator, and determine the ground state of the harmonic oscillator to be a Gaussian wave packet, while the latter method yields the general bound state solutions in terms of the Hermite polynomials. We further discuss the zero-point energy and uncertainty relation for the quantum harmonic oscillator and make a comparison to the classical harmonic oscillator. Finally, we examine the three-dimensional harmonic oscillator, which leads us to the description of systems with multiple degrees of freedom via the tensor product

•Sep 7, 2023•0 citations

Factorizations of vector operators for the isotropic harmonic oscillator in an angular momentum basis

Owen L. de Lange

The factorization of four vector operators, D±(ω) and D±(−ω), which occur in a representation-independent, spectrum-generating algebra for the three-dimensional, isotropic harmonic oscillator in an angular momentum basis, is considered (ω is the angular frequency of the oscillator). The D±(ω) are quantum-mechanical analogs of the classical vectors (1∓iL̂×)Fc (ω), where Fc(ω)=−Mωr×L+pL is constant in a frame rotating with angular velocity ωL̂. It is shown that these four vector operators can be factorized in two different ways to yield operators that, apart from their dependence on a constant of the motion (L2), are linear in either p or r. In this way 20 abstract operators are obtained. The properties of these operators are discussed: (i) Twelve are ladder operators for the quantum numbers l, and l and m, in the eigenkets ‖lm〉 of L2 and Lz. In linearized, differential form six of these operators are ladder operators for the spherical harmonics in the coordinate representation, while the other six are the corresponding operators in the momentum representation. (ii) The remaining eight operators factorize linear combinations of the Hamiltonian and the dimension operator. In linearized, differential form four of these operators are ladder operators for energy and angular momentum in the radial part of the coordinate-space wave functions, while the other four are the corresponding operators in the momentum representation.

Journal of Mathematical Physics•Nov 1, 1987•2 citations

The isotropic harmonic oscillator in an angular momemtum basis: An algebraic formulation

Anthony J. Bracken, Howard I. Leemon

A completely algebraic and representation-independent solution is presented of the simultaneous eigenvalue problem for H, L2, and L3, where H is the Hamiltonian operator for the three-dimensional, isotropic harmonic oscillator, and L is its angular momemtum vector. It is shown that H can be written in the form h/ω(2ν°ν+λ°⋅λ+3/2), where ν° and ν are raising and lowering (boson) operators for ν°ν, which has nonnegative integer eigenvalues k; and λ° and λ are raising and lowering operators for λ°⋅λ, which has nonnegative integer eigenvalues l, the total angular momentum quantum number. Thus the eigenvalues of H appear in the familiar form h/ω(2k+l+3/2), previously obtained only by working in the coordinating the operators ν° and λ° to a ’’vacuum’’ vector on which ν and λ vanish. The Lie algebra so(2,1) ⊕ so(3,2) is shown to be a spectrum-generating algebra for this problem. It is suggested that coherent angular momentum states can be defined for the oscillator, as the eigenvectors of the lowering operators ν and λ. A brief discussion is given of the classical counterparts of ν,ν°, λ, and λ°, in order to clarify their physical interpretation.

Journal of Mathematical Physics•Aug 1, 1980•9 citations

Analysis on Complete Set of Fock States with Explicit Wavefunctions for the Covariant Harmonic Oscillator Problem

Suzana Bedić, Otto C. W. Kong

The earlier treatments of the Lorentz covariant harmonic oscillator have brought to light various difficulties, such as reconciling Lorentz symmetry with the full Fock space, and divergence issues with their functional representations. We present here a full solution avoiding those problems. The complete set of Fock states is obtained, together with the corresponding explicit wavefunctions and their inner product integrals free from any divergence problem and with Lorentz symmetry fully maintained without additional constraints imposed. By a simple choice of the pseudo-unitary representation of the underlying symmetry group, motivated from the perspective of the Minkowski spacetime as a representation for the Lorentz group, we obtain the natural non-unitary Fock space picture commonly considered, although not formulated and presented in the careful details given here. From a direct derivation of the appropriate basis state wavefunctions of the finite-dimensional irreducible representations of the Lorentz symmetry, the relation between the latter and the Fock state wavefunctions is also explicitly shown. Moreover, the full picture, including the states with a non-positive norm, may give a consistent physics picture as a version of Lorentz covariant quantum mechanics. The probability interpretation for the usual von Neumann measurements is not a problem, as all wavefunctions restricted to a definite value for the `time’ variable are just like those of the usual time independent quantum mechanics. A further understanding from a perspective of the dynamics from the symplectic geometry of the phase space is shortly discussed.

arXiv:2002.08467•Symmetry•Dec 23, 2019•5 citations
We study the quantum mechanical harmonic oscillator in two and three dimensions, with particular attention to the solutions as basis states for representing their respective symmetry groups — O(2), O(1,1), O(3), and O(2,1). The goal of this study is to establish a correspondence between Hilbert space descriptions found by solving the Schrodinger equation in polar coordinates, and Fock space descriptions constructed by expressing the symmetry operators in terms of creation/annihilation operators. We obtain wavefunctions characterized by a principal quantum number, the group Casimir eigenvalue, and one group generator whose eigenvalue is m + s , for integer m and real constant parameter s . For the three groups that contain O(2), the solutions split into two inequivalent representations, one associated with s = 0, from which we recover the familiar description of the oscillator as a product of one-dimensional solutions, and the other with s > 0 (in three dimensions, solutions are found for s = 0 and s = 1/2) whose solutions are non-separable in Cartesian coordinates, and are hence overlooked by the standard Fock space approach. The O(1,1) solutions are singlet states, restricted to zero eigenvalue of the symmetry operator, which represents the boost, not angular momentum. For O(2), a single set of creation and annihilation operators forms a ladder representation for the allowed oscillator states for any s, and the degeneracy of energy states is always finite. However, in three dimensions, the integer and half-integer eigenstates are qualitatively different: the former can be expressed as finite dimensional irreducible tensors under O(3) or O(2,1) while the latter exhibit infinite degeneracy. Creation operators that produce the allowed integer states by acting on the non-degenerate ground state are constructed as irreducible tensor products of the fundamental vector representation. However, the half-integer eigenstates are infinite-dimensional, as expected for the non-compact O(2,1), and no Fock space description is found for this case. For all s ≠ 0 solutions, the SU(N) symmetry of the harmonic oscillator Hamiltonian recently discovered by Bars is spontaneously broken by the ground state. The connection of this symmetry breaking to the non-separability into one-dimensional Cartesian solutions is demonstrated. We conclude with a discussion of the O(2,1) solutions, and the problem of timelike ghost excitations.
We study the quantum mechanical harmonic oscillator in two and three dimensions, with particular attention to the solutions as represents of their respective symmetry groups: O(2), O(3), and O(2,1). Solving the Schrodinger equation by separating variables in polar coordinates, we obtain wavefunctions characterized by a principal quantum number, the group Casimir eigenvalue, and one observable component of orbital angular momentum, with eigenvalue m+sm+sm+s, for integer mmm and real constant parameter sss. In each symmetry group, sss splits the solutions into two inequivalent representations, one associated with s=0s=0s=0, which recovers the familiar description of the oscillator as a product of one-dimensional solutions, and the other with s>0s>0s>0 (in three dimensions, s=0,1/2s=0, 1/2s=0,1/2) whose solutions are non-separable in Cartesian coordinates, and are hence overlooked by the standard Fock space approach. In two dimensions, a single set of creation and annihilation operators forms a ladder representation for the allowed oscillator states for any sss, and the degeneracy of energy states is always finite. However, in three dimensions, the integer and half-integer eigenstates are qualitatively different: the former can be expressed as finite dimensional irreducible tensors under O(3) or O(2,1), and a ladder representation can be constructed via irreducible tensor products of the vector creation operator multiplet, while the latter exhibit infinite degeneracy and the finite-dimensional ladder representation fails for these states. These results are closely connected to the breaking of a unitary symmetry of the harmonic oscillator Hamiltonian recently discussed by Bars.
Recently several authors have proposed a universal symmetry group and demonstrated the classical validity of the concept. Supposedly, an SU(n) symmetry group could be constructed for whatsoever system of n degrees of freedom. The claim is assuredly valid for all classically degenerate systems, but is in contradiction with most of the well-known and widely accepted solutions of Schrödinger's equation. We examine the reasons for this discrepancy on the quantum-mechanical level. The construction of the universal symmetry group requires ladder operators, which in most cases are the ladder operators of Infeld and Hill. Complications which owe their origin entirely to numerical relationships imposed by quantization prevent these operators from forming a von Neumann algebra and, in turn, an SU(n) group of constants of the motion. Two important effects are those imposed by anisotropy, wherein not all quanta have the same size, and by non-Cartesian coordinates, wherein quanta in some dimensions are restricted in size by those in other dimensions. These effects can be seen quite clearly in two-dimensional systems: anisotropy in the Cartesian anisotropic harmonic oscillator, and conflict between dimensions in the polar form of the isotropic oscillator. Further complications arise when the two effects are combined, as in the harmonic oscillator or hydrogen atom with ``excess'' angular momentum. Enough residue of the universal symmetry concept remains that many similarities between the hydrogen atom and harmonic oscillator may be understood, including the fact that some levels of the hydrogen atom, which ordinarily transform according to an orthogonal group, may form irreducible representations of the unitary group.
Abstract We consider the time-independent Schrödinger equation for the harmonic oscillator potential and determine its bound states and energy levels in one spatial dimension using two approaches: the algebraic and the analytic method. Using the former, we introduce ladder operators: the annihilation and creation operators, as well as the occupation-number operator, and determine the ground state of the harmonic oscillator to be a Gaussian wave packet, while the latter method yields the general bound state solutions in terms of the Hermite polynomials. We further discuss the zero-point energy and uncertainty relation for the quantum harmonic oscillator and make a comparison to the classical harmonic oscillator. Finally, we examine the three-dimensional harmonic oscillator, which leads us to the description of systems with multiple degrees of freedom via the tensor product
The factorization of four vector operators, D±(ω) and D±(−ω), which occur in a representation-independent, spectrum-generating algebra for the three-dimensional, isotropic harmonic oscillator in an angular momentum basis, is considered (ω is the angular frequency of the oscillator). The D±(ω) are quantum-mechanical analogs of the classical vectors (1∓iL̂×)Fc (ω), where Fc(ω)=−Mωr×L+pL is constant in a frame rotating with angular velocity ωL̂. It is shown that these four vector operators can be factorized in two different ways to yield operators that, apart from their dependence on a constant of the motion (L2), are linear in either p or r. In this way 20 abstract operators are obtained. The properties of these operators are discussed: (i) Twelve are ladder operators for the quantum numbers l, and l and m, in the eigenkets ‖lm〉 of L2 and Lz. In linearized, differential form six of these operators are ladder operators for the spherical harmonics in the coordinate representation, while the other six are the corresponding operators in the momentum representation. (ii) The remaining eight operators factorize linear combinations of the Hamiltonian and the dimension operator. In linearized, differential form four of these operators are ladder operators for energy and angular momentum in the radial part of the coordinate-space wave functions, while the other four are the corresponding operators in the momentum representation.
A completely algebraic and representation-independent solution is presented of the simultaneous eigenvalue problem for H, L2, and L3, where H is the Hamiltonian operator for the three-dimensional, isotropic harmonic oscillator, and L is its angular momemtum vector. It is shown that H can be written in the form h/ω(2ν°ν+λ°⋅λ+3/2), where ν° and ν are raising and lowering (boson) operators for ν°ν, which has nonnegative integer eigenvalues k; and λ° and λ are raising and lowering operators for λ°⋅λ, which has nonnegative integer eigenvalues l, the total angular momentum quantum number. Thus the eigenvalues of H appear in the familiar form h/ω(2k+l+3/2), previously obtained only by working in the coordinating the operators ν° and λ° to a ’’vacuum’’ vector on which ν and λ vanish. The Lie algebra so(2,1) ⊕ so(3,2) is shown to be a spectrum-generating algebra for this problem. It is suggested that coherent angular momentum states can be defined for the oscillator, as the eigenvectors of the lowering operators ν and λ. A brief discussion is given of the classical counterparts of ν,ν°, λ, and λ°, in order to clarify their physical interpretation.
The earlier treatments of the Lorentz covariant harmonic oscillator have brought to light various difficulties, such as reconciling Lorentz symmetry with the full Fock space, and divergence issues with their functional representations. We present here a full solution avoiding those problems. The complete set of Fock states is obtained, together with the corresponding explicit wavefunctions and their inner product integrals free from any divergence problem and with Lorentz symmetry fully maintained without additional constraints imposed. By a simple choice of the pseudo-unitary representation of the underlying symmetry group, motivated from the perspective of the Minkowski spacetime as a representation for the Lorentz group, we obtain the natural non-unitary Fock space picture commonly considered, although not formulated and presented in the careful details given here. From a direct derivation of the appropriate basis state wavefunctions of the finite-dimensional irreducible representations of the Lorentz symmetry, the relation between the latter and the Fock state wavefunctions is also explicitly shown. Moreover, the full picture, including the states with a non-positive norm, may give a consistent physics picture as a version of Lorentz covariant quantum mechanics. The probability interpretation for the usual von Neumann measurements is not a problem, as all wavefunctions restricted to a definite value for the `time’ variable are just like those of the usual time independent quantum mechanics. A further understanding from a perspective of the dynamics from the symplectic geometry of the phase space is shortly discussed.