Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

European Journal of Physics

Large quantum probability backflow and the azimuthal angle–angular momentum uncertainty relation for an electron in a constant magnetic field

P. Strange

Published Jul 2, 2012• 29 citations
Publisher

Abstract

In this paper we demonstrate a surprising aspect of quantum mechanics that is accessible to an undergraduate student. We discuss probability backflow for an electron in a constant magnetic field. It is shown that even for a wavepacket composed entirely of states with negative angular momentum the effective angular momentum can take on positive values in some regions of space. This is also a demonstration of the azimuthal angle–angular momentum uncertainty relation. This example is chosen because the backflow motion persists indefinitely. However this work can easily be extended to other systems where the motion is notionally circular, such as the hydrogen atom.

DOI
10.1088/0143-0807/33/5/1147

Related papers

On the uncertainty relations for an electron in a constant magnetic field

Francisco Marcelo Fernández

We discuss the uncertainty relation for the azimuthal angle $ϕ$ and the $z$-component of the angular momentum $L_z$. To this end we derive the uncertainty relation for an arbitrary pair of observables and discuss the conditions for its validity. By means of a simple parameter-dependent state we illustrate the well known fact that the standard uncertainty relation for the coordinate and its conjugate momentum does not apply the pair of observables $ϕ-L_z$. This analysis is motivated by a discussion of the motion of an electron in a constant magnetic field appeared recently in this journal (Eur. J. Phys. \textbf{33} (2012) 1147) where the author assumed the validity of the standard uncertainty relation for the pair $ϕ-L_z$.

arXiv:1207.7069•Jul 30, 2012•0 citations

Quantum backflow for a free-particle hermite wavepacket

P. Strange

Abstract Quantum backflow is the unexpected effect that wavepackets consisting of only positive momentum components can apparently move in the negative direction. This is usually described in terms of the backflow constant, which is a dimensionless quantity describing least upper bound on the amount of probability that can flow backwards during a given time interval. Backflow is usually calculated for wavepackets that can be written as a sum of positive momentum plane waves. Here we present a calculation of the backflow constant using the localised free particle hermite wavefunctions where equal weights of positive and negative momentum eigenfunctions occur. The resulting backflow constant is substantially smaller than the accepted value. The reasons for this are discussed and finally we draw conclusions about the calculation of backflow more generally.

Physica Scripta•Jan 4, 2024•5 citations

The Vector-Model Wavefunction: spatial description and wavepacket formation of quantum-mechanical angular momenta

Theodore Peter Rakitzis, Michail E. Koutrakis, George E. Katsoprinakis

In quantum mechanics, spatial wavefunctions describe distributions of a particle's position or momentum, but not of angular momentum $j$. In contrast, here we show that a spatial wavefunction, $j_m (ϕ,θ,χ)=~e^{i m ϕ} δ(θ- θ_m) ~e^{i(j+1/2)χ}$, which treats $j$ in the $|jm>$ state as a three-dimensional entity, is an asymptotic eigenfunction of angular-momentum operators; $ϕ$, $θ$, $χ$ are the Euler angles, and $cos θ_m=(m/|j|)$ is the Vector-Model polar angle. The $j_m (ϕ,θ,χ)$ gives a computationally simple description of particle and orbital-angular-momentum wavepackets (constructed from Gaussian distributions in $j$ and $m$) which predicts the effective wavepacket angular uncertainty relations for $Δm Δϕ$, $Δj Δχ$, and $ΔϕΔθ$, and the position of the particle-wavepacket angular motion on the orbital plane. The particle-wavepacket rotation can be experimentally probed through continuous and non-destructive $j$-rotation measurements. We also use the $j_m (ϕ,θ,χ)$ to determine well-known asymptotic expressions for Clebsch-Gordan coefficients, Wigner d-functions, the gyromagnetic ratio of elementary particles, $g=2$, and the m-state-correlation matrix elements, $$. Interestingly, for low j, even down to $j=1/2$, these expressions are either exact (the last two) or excellent approximations (the first two), showing that $j_m (ϕ,θ,χ)$ gives a useful spatial description of quantum-mechanical angular momentum, and provides a smooth connection with classical angular momentum.

arXiv:2305.11456•May 19, 2023•0 citations

Understanding quantum behaviors of an electron in a uniform magnetic field alternatively

Jin-Ming Wang, Yuan-Zao Gao, Dai-Lin Cun +1 more

Quantum mechanically, an electron moving in a uniform magnetic field forms Landau levels. A curious feature is that for states with a negative angular quantum number, the total probability current vanishes, which appears to contradict the classical picture of cyclotron motion. While a geometric interpretation based on classical orbits exists, alternative interpretations remain of interest. In this paper, we examine the probability current density and identify a critical radius that naturally partitions the plane into an inner clockwise-flow region and an outer counterclockwise-flow region. We show that the vanishing total current results from an exact cancellation between these two regions. Furthermore, by defining a partitioned kinetic angular momentum with respect to the critical radius, we reveal an intrinsic competitive structure: the electron simultaneously carries two opposing rotational components. The negative quantum number manifests in the strength of the inner counter-rotation, while the net kinetic angular momentum remains positive. This bidirectional flow picture also provides a dynamical interpretation of the infinite degeneracy of Landau levels.

cond-mat.mes-hallCross-listedarXiv:2606.13290•International Journal of Theoretical Physics•Jun 12, 2026•0 citations

Uncertainty relation between angle and orbital angular momentum: interference effect in electron vortex beams

Sh. Tanimura

The uncertainty relation between angle and orbital angular momentum had not been formulated in a similar form as the uncertainty relation between position and linear momentum because the angle variable is not represented by a quantum mechanical self-adjoint operator.Instead of the angle variable operator, we introduce the complex position operator Ẑ = x + iŷ and interpret the order parameter µ = Ẑ / Ẑ † Ẑ as a measure of certainty of the angle distribution.We prove the relation between the uncertainty of angular momentum and the angle order parameter.We also prove its generalizations and discuss experimental methods for testing these relations.

arXiv:1411.0823•Nanosystems Physics Chemistry Mathematics•Apr 16, 2015•3 citations

Analytical examples, measurement models, and classical limit of quantum backflow

James M. Yearsley, J. J. Halliwell, R. Hartshorn +1 more

We investigate the backflow effect in elementary quantum mechanics---the phenomenon in which a state consisting entirely of positive momenta may have negative current and the probability flows in the opposite direction to the momentum. We compute the current and flux for states consisting of superpositions of Gaussian wave packets. These are experimentally realizable but the amount of backflow is small. Inspired by the numerical results of Penz et al. [Penz, Gr\"ubl, Kreidl, and Wagner, J. Phys. A 39, 423 (2006)], we find two nontrivial wave functions whose current at any time may be computed analytically and which have periods of significant backflow, in one case with a backward flux equal to about 70$%$ of the maximum possible backflow, a dimensionless number ${c}_{bm}\ensuremath{\approx}0.04$, discovered by Bracken and Melloy [Bracken and Melloy, J. Phys. A 27, 2197 (1994)]. This number has the unusual property of being independent of $\ensuremath{\hbar}$ (and also of all other parameters of the model), despite corresponding to an obviously quantum-mechanical effect, and we shed some light on this surprising property by considering the classical limit of backflow. We discuss some specific measurement models in which backflow may be identified in certain measurable probabilities.

arXiv:1202.1783•Physical Review A•Oct 15, 2012•42 citations
In this paper we demonstrate a surprising aspect of quantum mechanics that is accessible to an undergraduate student. We discuss probability backflow for an electron in a constant magnetic field. It is shown that even for a wavepacket composed entirely of states with negative angular momentum the effective angular momentum can take on positive values in some regions of space. This is also a demonstration of the azimuthal angle–angular momentum uncertainty relation. This example is chosen because the backflow motion persists indefinitely. However this work can easily be extended to other systems where the motion is notionally circular, such as the hydrogen atom.
We discuss the uncertainty relation for the azimuthal angle ϕϕϕ and the zzz-component of the angular momentum LzL_zLz​. To this end we derive the uncertainty relation for an arbitrary pair of observables and discuss the conditions for its validity. By means of a simple parameter-dependent state we illustrate the well known fact that the standard uncertainty relation for the coordinate and its conjugate momentum does not apply the pair of observables ϕ−Lzϕ-L_zϕ−Lz​. This analysis is motivated by a discussion of the motion of an electron in a constant magnetic field appeared recently in this journal (Eur. J. Phys. \textbf{33} (2012) 1147) where the author assumed the validity of the standard uncertainty relation for the pair ϕ−Lzϕ-L_zϕ−Lz​.
Abstract Quantum backflow is the unexpected effect that wavepackets consisting of only positive momentum components can apparently move in the negative direction. This is usually described in terms of the backflow constant, which is a dimensionless quantity describing least upper bound on the amount of probability that can flow backwards during a given time interval. Backflow is usually calculated for wavepackets that can be written as a sum of positive momentum plane waves. Here we present a calculation of the backflow constant using the localised free particle hermite wavefunctions where equal weights of positive and negative momentum eigenfunctions occur. The resulting backflow constant is substantially smaller than the accepted value. The reasons for this are discussed and finally we draw conclusions about the calculation of backflow more generally.
In quantum mechanics, spatial wavefunctions describe distributions of a particle's position or momentum, but not of angular momentum jjj. In contrast, here we show that a spatial wavefunction, jm(ϕ,θ,χ)= eimϕδ(θ−θm) ei(j+1/2)χj_m (ϕ,θ,χ)=~e^{i m ϕ} δ(θ- θ_m) ~e^{i(j+1/2)χ}jm​(ϕ,θ,χ)= eimϕδ(θ−θm​) ei(j+1/2)χ, which treats jjj in the ∣jm>|jm>∣jm> state as a three-dimensional entity, is an asymptotic eigenfunction of angular-momentum operators; ϕϕϕ, θθθ, χχχ are the Euler angles, and cosθm=(m/∣j∣)cos θ_m=(m/|j|)cosθm​=(m/∣j∣) is the Vector-Model polar angle. The jm(ϕ,θ,χ)j_m (ϕ,θ,χ)jm​(ϕ,θ,χ) gives a computationally simple description of particle and orbital-angular-momentum wavepackets (constructed from Gaussian distributions in jjj and mmm) which predicts the effective wavepacket angular uncertainty relations for ΔmΔϕΔm ΔϕΔmΔϕ, ΔjΔχΔj ΔχΔjΔχ, and ΔϕΔθΔϕΔθΔϕΔθ, and the position of the particle-wavepacket angular motion on the orbital plane. The particle-wavepacket rotation can be experimentally probed through continuous and non-destructive jjj-rotation measurements. We also use the jm(ϕ,θ,χ)j_m (ϕ,θ,χ)jm​(ϕ,θ,χ) to determine well-known asymptotic expressions for Clebsch-Gordan coefficients, Wigner d-functions, the gyromagnetic ratio of elementary particles, g=2g=2g=2, and the m-state-correlation matrix elements, $$. Interestingly, for low j, even down to j=1/2j=1/2j=1/2, these expressions are either exact (the last two) or excellent approximations (the first two), showing that jm(ϕ,θ,χ)j_m (ϕ,θ,χ)jm​(ϕ,θ,χ) gives a useful spatial description of quantum-mechanical angular momentum, and provides a smooth connection with classical angular momentum.
Quantum mechanically, an electron moving in a uniform magnetic field forms Landau levels. A curious feature is that for states with a negative angular quantum number, the total probability current vanishes, which appears to contradict the classical picture of cyclotron motion. While a geometric interpretation based on classical orbits exists, alternative interpretations remain of interest. In this paper, we examine the probability current density and identify a critical radius that naturally partitions the plane into an inner clockwise-flow region and an outer counterclockwise-flow region. We show that the vanishing total current results from an exact cancellation between these two regions. Furthermore, by defining a partitioned kinetic angular momentum with respect to the critical radius, we reveal an intrinsic competitive structure: the electron simultaneously carries two opposing rotational components. The negative quantum number manifests in the strength of the inner counter-rotation, while the net kinetic angular momentum remains positive. This bidirectional flow picture also provides a dynamical interpretation of the infinite degeneracy of Landau levels.
The uncertainty relation between angle and orbital angular momentum had not been formulated in a similar form as the uncertainty relation between position and linear momentum because the angle variable is not represented by a quantum mechanical self-adjoint operator.Instead of the angle variable operator, we introduce the complex position operator Ẑ = x + iŷ and interpret the order parameter µ = Ẑ / Ẑ † Ẑ as a measure of certainty of the angle distribution.We prove the relation between the uncertainty of angular momentum and the angle order parameter.We also prove its generalizations and discuss experimental methods for testing these relations.
We investigate the backflow effect in elementary quantum mechanics---the phenomenon in which a state consisting entirely of positive momenta may have negative current and the probability flows in the opposite direction to the momentum. We compute the current and flux for states consisting of superpositions of Gaussian wave packets. These are experimentally realizable but the amount of backflow is small. Inspired by the numerical results of Penz et al. [Penz, Gr\"ubl, Kreidl, and Wagner, J. Phys. A 39, 423 (2006)], we find two nontrivial wave functions whose current at any time may be computed analytically and which have periods of significant backflow, in one case with a backward flux equal to about 70% of the maximum possible backflow, a dimensionless number ${c}_{bm}\ensuremath{\approx}0.04$, discovered by Bracken and Melloy [Bracken and Melloy, J. Phys. A 27, 2197 (1994)]. This number has the unusual property of being independent of $\ensuremath{\hbar}$ (and also of all other parameters of the model), despite corresponding to an obviously quantum-mechanical effect, and we shed some light on this surprising property by considering the classical limit of backflow. We discuss some specific measurement models in which backflow may be identified in certain measurable probabilities.